Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

DH and I going part time to deliberately reduce wages

890 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 13:35

Just working out the free childcare hours and actually DH and I will be muxh better off if we both dropped to 3- 4 day week to deliberately reduce our incomes. Would obviously be nice way to live too! Anyone else doing same? Seems mental but we've looked at it 100 times over and it's true!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 13:33

Bearing in mind of course - as I pointed out earlier - that every one of those 200,000 is paying exponentially more tax than someone earning national minimum wage and receiving UC is, given that those people have a negative tax rate, often -50%+. People literally would not have UC or NHS or state education if it wasn't for these people. Likewise there even more numerous counterparts earning these salaries but without children, who with student loans etc are paying over 70% tax and even they are thinking "what is the point?".

If you want state services funded then it needs changing. PPs have posted lots of evidence and research proving this. If you choose to consider penalising these people who provide all of the public goods out of spite, then you'll have to own the consequences of that: these things will be continually downgraded because the money to pay for them will not exist. So make the choice, continue supporting taxing people to death and lose the services and welfare, or support a more sensible system that will actually raise more tax and raise living standards for everyone. It comes down to whether you have sufficient rationality and intelligence to override your jealousy. So I won't hold my breath.

Like I said previously, the UK is a mess largely because it's population is so ignorant and unable to assess facts and data. Seems like they "hate experts", who have done the research on this. People who are, you know, qualified in economics. Went so well last time these people were maligned and ignored. I guess some people never learn...

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 13:19

So, as a result, watch over 200,000 people in this tax bracket who have children make similar choices to the OP. And watch tax revenues decrease further, and don't moan when there are further cuts to services and benefits because there is less money available to fund them.

If you want higher living standards for everyone, campaign to remove these huge disincentives for the people who are paying for the NHS, education, universal credit, the funded childcare, etc. If you would rather they continue to be penalised at over 100% tax just because you - inexpicably - hate them for paying for these things for everyone else, then you only have yourself to blame as these things become increasingly poorly funded.

Unless you plan to work towards one of these high paying careers yourself and continue to increase your earnings when you hit the 100%+ tax rates because you are soooooo altruistic you've happy to pay to work extra hours?

Thought not.

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 13:14

BringItOn2023 · 19/03/2023 12:45

If you're earning £100k you can easily put more into your pension for a couple of years. It's hardly rocket science.

Not exactly helpful if you need more net pay to cover huge mortgage, food, commuting, nursery and utility price increases though, is it? And are literally banned by tax policy from earning ANY increase in net pay until you get a payrise of £50k in one go. Which will just about get you back to the same net pay you had without that 50% pay increase.

One would think designing a more sensible tax system would not be "rocket science" for someone who is meant to be the Chancellor of the Exchequer and has had his job done for him through copious research telling him what needs to be done. All he had to do was announce it and sit back to watch productivity and tax revenues rocket over the next 12 months. But apparently that was too much to ask. 🙄

Bucketheadbucketbum · 19/03/2023 13:02

Dyslexicwonder · 19/03/2023 12:51

Actually I can't, not without incurring a huge tax penalty there as well.

Same for us.

OP posts:
Dyslexicwonder · 19/03/2023 12:51

BringItOn2023 · 19/03/2023 12:45

If you're earning £100k you can easily put more into your pension for a couple of years. It's hardly rocket science.

Actually I can't, not without incurring a huge tax penalty there as well.

BringItOn2023 · 19/03/2023 12:45

If you're earning £100k you can easily put more into your pension for a couple of years. It's hardly rocket science.

Dibblydoodahdah · 19/03/2023 12:41

@YukoandHiro presumably you think that NI insurance credits should be banned for stay at home parents too?

Dibblydoodahdah · 19/03/2023 12:36

@YukoandHiro no she isn’t bang on. People who claim universal credit are not net contributors. The OP and her DH are. They will still be putting far more in then they will be taking out.

Lostinalibrary · 19/03/2023 12:34

YukoandHiro · 19/03/2023 12:06

"Surprised at the responses. I wonder if it’s because it’s child care. If someone posted me and my husband are going to go part time so we can claim universal credit id suspect the responses would be different"

@Fragrantandfoolish is absolutely bang on here!

Childcare is a benefit like any other, but people consider it differently.

That higher rate tax payers pay for alongside everything else as net contributors.

StatisticallyChallenged · 19/03/2023 12:19

YukoandHiro · 19/03/2023 12:06

"Surprised at the responses. I wonder if it’s because it’s child care. If someone posted me and my husband are going to go part time so we can claim universal credit id suspect the responses would be different"

@Fragrantandfoolish is absolutely bang on here!

Childcare is a benefit like any other, but people consider it differently.

For me it's not about whether it's a benefit. It's the fact that people will be worse off by earning more. Not "only a tiny bit better off and it's not really worth it" but "thousands of pounds less every year"

SleeplessWB · 19/03/2023 12:06

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 19:02

The personal allowance withdrawal and child benefit withdrawal need scrapping entirely. Both cost the state more to administer than they save AND create these disincentives to work more. It is a no brainer. This costs money and reduces tax revenue. There is no point in it.

Early years childcare/ education is a universal good that pays for itself and should be available to everyone just like pensions and healthcare and education for older children (and adults for that matter). The vast majority of higher tax payers are fine with paying this for everyone else, but it must be available to all, including them.

Penalising single adult households charging them double the tax on the same income is not acceptable, and has only been tolerated because over 90% of single parents are women. What is hugely disappointing is that other women do not campaign for this to change and stand side by side with those affected by it. Depressing.

Ultimately if you want well-funded welfare and services you need the people who pay the vast majority of that cost to be incentivised to work. If they face effective tax rates of 65% at £50k (as soon as they become net contributors) and 100% at £100k they won't. So there won't be the money to pay for it all, as we are now seeing.

Anybody who wants a functioning welfare state and services should want this fixed. But as we can see here, they do not. So it won't be.

This is absolutely true. I work 4 days, earning just under £50k. If I worked full time I would lose my child benefit and need to pay an extra day of childcare, therefore basically earning nothing for that extra day.

YukoandHiro · 19/03/2023 12:06

"Surprised at the responses. I wonder if it’s because it’s child care. If someone posted me and my husband are going to go part time so we can claim universal credit id suspect the responses would be different"

@Fragrantandfoolish is absolutely bang on here!

Childcare is a benefit like any other, but people consider it differently.

YukoandHiro · 19/03/2023 12:05

"We paid in tax far more than anything we could ever possibly use (over a million easlily in our careers to date) and actually our net income is less more than it would be if we earn a lot less!!!"

A) you have literally no idea what you'll "use". If tomorrow you need emergency brain surgery and associated rehabilitation care then you'll use more then you've ever paid in.

B) This is how tax works. You are highly privileged even if you don't recognise it. You pay this tax in return for living in a state that (just about) functions. If you don't like it, go and live in a low tax state where you will be fine but you'll be surrounded by extreme street homelessness (to take one example)

I understand your frustration but the years you're talking about are very short. Of course you can both choose to go part time. It may be the best decision for you as a family. But make sure your long term lifestyle is planned for (if you're ok with a drop in lifestyle for better balance, go for it)

AntarcticGiraffe · 19/03/2023 12:05

EmmaDilemma5 · 19/03/2023 07:24

It's unethical and it's paid for by the rest of us.

But yeah, if you're the kind of people who think about yourselves before anyone else, and play systems to get all you can, then, do it.

But don't boast about it on a public forum and don't call yourself the squeezed middle. You're the tight higher earners; you always want more.

What?

It's paid for by the OP! She's paid for it many times over. She's paying for YOU.

Tight? "Always want more"? To want to keep more than 0% of a payrise?! In fact not to LOSE tens of thousands of pounds of net pay by taking a payrise?

Do you realise how absurd your comments are?

🤯🤯🤯

MarshaBradyo · 19/03/2023 11:59

I’m not even sure the cc changes are a mistake overall. If more women stay in work because it’s easier to get reduced hours and have better balance then that’s good surely.

Hardbackwriter · 19/03/2023 11:55

What's the point in life? We could be dead tomorrow and if we are net net net worse off financially working more, why wpuld we choose to spend less time with each other? And to have a more stressful existence? Our lives will be monumentally more enjoyable if we both cut our hours, and we will be better off financially!

Completely agree with this! For me I ended up sort of glad that the tax system works as it does as it made our decisions to go part-time easier and much more financially possible than we first assumed (I assumed that I'd be considerably down by dropping a day but with the reduced tax and the cost of that extra day of childcare it worked out even), but I appreciate that we're at a different place on the tax scale - and we're not on a cliff edge - and for us it was a very active and welcome choice.

Makingupfactstosuitmyagenda · 19/03/2023 11:52

@HalfWomanHalfChocolate it bemuses me when people resent high earners taking out from the very system they put into. It’s not a bad thing; it’s equality and with nhs, schools etc it can mean key opinion formers have a knowledge of what it’s like for the masses. Anyone remember the posts years ago criticising Katie Price for using council transport for her son Harvey who was at a special needs school? Comments like, she should pay for a private driver?!

anyone paying into a pension, criticising the OP and yet benefiting from the tax/ni break is clearly paying the difference back then, no?

anyone who is a SAHP or on reduced hours is depriving the nation of tax?! Crazy logic.

Dibblydoodahdah · 19/03/2023 11:46

OP I don’t know whether this in an option for you but if you can buy additional holiday via salary sacrifice that may reduce your income a bit. I can buy two additonal weeks in my role. I am expecting a pay rise that is likely to push me over the £100k cliff when taking into account my bonus so I am looking at options to keep it under.

Bucketheadbucketbum · 19/03/2023 11:43

To be honest it's not so much about the childcare now, although that was the final straw, it's more about the tax cliff edge .

We've reanalysed our situation and just can't get away from the fact we are working harder, for less.

What's the point in life? We could be dead tomorrow and if we are net net net worse off financially working more, why wpuld we choose to spend less time with each other? And to have a more stressful existence? Our lives will be monumentally more enjoyable if we both cut our hours, and we will be better off financially!

We will still be paying tens of thousands in tax so not sure what everyone's problem is- how much tax do you all pay? How many hours do you work a week? How much time do you get with your family? How much stress does your job cause you? How long and how costly is your commute?

Would you really do anything differently? Really. Honestly. No you would not.

OP posts:
Hardbackwriter · 19/03/2023 11:37

It just worries me a bit because I keep seeing woman, from right across the economic spectrum, talking about the decisions they're making in light of the childcare announcement and so many of them seem to be predicated on the idea that the 30 hours of free childcare is literally that, but unless there's a sea change in funding it won't be any more than it is now.

Hardbackwriter · 19/03/2023 11:31

RedemptiveThursday · 19/03/2023 10:24

My 3 year old's preschool (a local authority one) costs £11 a day, which is £8.80 after tax free childcare.

If I only had 15 free hours, and no TFC, because I earned over £100k, it would be £36.50 a day.

Monthly difference for March 2023 (23 days) would be £637.50. So not £1k, but not insubstantial (and that's the difference for just one of my children, and doesn't account for the loss of the personal allowance).

If I had no entitlement to free hours or TFC at all then it would cost me an extra £1,224 a month (£1,426 total, against a current total of £202) for my child to attend preschool.

These are the kind of figures that impact of decision-making!

I guess it's very individual - the (fantastic, a bit but not very above averagely priced for the SE commuter town we live in) nursery we use costs £386 a week for a full-time place with no funded hours (£77 a day - I'm guessing your preschool doesn't offer a full working day?), £262 a week if you have full 30 hours funding. It's a big difference of course but it's nothing close to £12k a year per child and I really don't know anyone who has ever saved that with it.

Bucketheadbucketbum · 19/03/2023 11:23

Dyslexicwonder · 19/03/2023 10:30

That is excellent advice. Luckily we always knew we could increase up to full-time later.

This is a really good idea, thank you I will see if its an option

OP posts:
Bucketheadbucketbum · 19/03/2023 11:21

*our net income is much less each month than it would be if our salaries were lower

OP posts:
Bucketheadbucketbum · 19/03/2023 11:20

Dyslexicwonder · 19/03/2023 09:23

This is a great visual that explains it brilliantly. Look at what happens at 50-60 and 100k

This is a great visual.

I don't think the moaners understand we pay tens and tens of thousands of pounds in tax every year, and have dome for decades.

We paid in tax far more than anything we could ever possibly use (over a million easlily in our careers to date) and actually our net income is less more than it would be if we earn a lot less!!! Now we have kids we are thinking- what's the point in this! Working 70h weeks for what?

It's the f you you're loaded we deserve it keep slaving you don't deserve anything attitude that makes one think you'll take yourself and our tax contributions abroad! Good luck to the moaners then!

OP posts:
LittleBearPad · 19/03/2023 11:15

I’d love to know how much tax is paid by all the people shouting about how ‘disgusting’ this plan is?

Go for it OP.

Swipe left for the next trending thread