Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

DH and I going part time to deliberately reduce wages

890 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 13:35

Just working out the free childcare hours and actually DH and I will be muxh better off if we both dropped to 3- 4 day week to deliberately reduce our incomes. Would obviously be nice way to live too! Anyone else doing same? Seems mental but we've looked at it 100 times over and it's true!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Lostinalibrary · 19/03/2023 17:43

Ejkmama · 19/03/2023 17:42

Thanks the rest of us with kids will just keep picking up the bill and missing out on seeing our kids! But yeah You go for it 🥺

Wow - have you actually read the thread. If not I suggest you do.

Ejkmama · 19/03/2023 17:42

Thanks the rest of us with kids will just keep picking up the bill and missing out on seeing our kids! But yeah You go for it 🥺

Fossie · 19/03/2023 17:42

Owlatnight · 18/03/2023 13:59

That's great news that you will both be able to spend more time with your children when they are little. Good for your relationship too if everyone is less stressed

Yes

HistoryFanatic · 19/03/2023 17:26

I wouldn't wish for the welfare system to collapse. What if you were to need it?

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 17:26

Thanks @PipMumsnet I appreciate it. But as I've explained, the only thing that will help us is if this penalisation through the tax system of single parents - almost all women - is removed. Then I'd have plenty of money to provide my children with a decent life, as other households with the same income but two parents do, because they are not penalised like this through tax. The best thing you could do for me and the many other single mothers in my situation is to campaign for change to these tax rules so that they are levied on a household basis. Then we could be on a level playing field at least financially - even though we are still trying to do in 24 hours what other people do in 48 - and provide decent lives for our children. Not be pushed to such extreme choices where there is no other way out.

Will you read the thread and the evidence posted? Will Mumsnet do something about it and campaign to get the same thresholds for tax, childcare etc applied to single parent households that are applied to other households? Instead of us doing two jobs in 24 hours not 48 and then being taxed MORE on what we earn, as well?

If not, your apparent concern for me is of no value. If you cared whatsoever about women or children or me or my children you'd be launching a campaign to get this fixed.

PipMumsnet · 19/03/2023 17:16

Hello @ScruffyGiraffes, we are really sorry to hear you are feeling this way.

We hope you don't mind, but when these posts are flagged up to us we usually add a link to our Mental Health resources. You can also go to the Samaritans website, or email them on [email protected].

Support from other Mumsnetters is great and we really hope you will be able to take some comfort from your fellow posters, but as other MNers will tell you, it's really a good idea to seek RL help and support as well.

We also like to remind everyone that, although we're awed daily by the astonishing support our members give each other through life's trickier twists and turns, we'd always caution anyone never to give more of themselves to another poster, emotionally or financially, than they can afford to spare.

Wishing you the very best,
MNHQ💐

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 17:13

School shoes

Their

Its

So much poorly written stuff from me today, I think because I'm so upset, but I hope it is still understandable.

I just wish people gave a damn and pressed for change, before it's too late for us. We'd still be funding lots of other families, and that's fine, but I can't keep doing that if I can't also house and feed and provide a decent living standard for my own children. I really have tried my very best but there is no more I can do.

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 17:02

If the tac bands were applied equally to my household in the way they are applied to two parent households - who have 48 hours per day to split between work and childcare so can choose to have zero childcare costs at all if they wish, or both work and pay far less tax than me while still having much lower childcare costs - then here is the maths:

2x £50k incomes: net pay £6,290
1x £100k income: net pay £5564.

So my household receives £726 per month less net pay on the same income. Bear in mind that we are currently trying to pay for all food, clothes, birthdays, activities, transport etc from £200 per month, so removing this discrimination in the tax system would increase our money for this by nearly 500%, just to equalise our tax situation with those who already have the advantage of having twice as many hours per day to earn money to support their children/ spend time with them, split as they see fit. Some will of course mot max out the tax allowances and one parent will stay at home, but then they save the £2k per month childcare hill so are also far better off and have lots of spare money.

Add on top that the other household would receive child benefit etc...

It really is INSANE that anybody thinks this is fair. They can't possibly think that in reality, so the fact they refuse to press for change on our behalf shows that nobody gives a crap about single mothers or their children. We should be penalised, tough. Let your children suffer.

And so here we are with my only real option being making myself disappear, so that my children can have a decent life. If we were taxed in the same way as other families on the same households income I'd be able to provide for them just fine, take them on a camping trip, buy them new schools and uniform, look after them properly. But nobody wants to campaign to change it. Hunt doesn't care. Rachel Reeves laughed when asked about it. So instead I have only very extreme options left to look at.

Dente · 19/03/2023 16:35

But the Government can always change the goal posts and do u-turns.

Are you guaranteed to go back full time if you needed to ?

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 16:26

Moraxella · 19/03/2023 16:06

@ScruffyGiraffes as someone who lost their mum I can assure you that they would 1000% rather have you. 💐

I know that emotionally that is true. They have lost their father, I am all they have. It would absolutely traumatise them. But being traumatised is maybe better than being homeless as a child. This is the choice I will soon have to make for them.

Lostinalibrary · 19/03/2023 16:23

I used to be that person who would scoff at higher earners and say “you deserve to pay more.” Until you actually see the eye watering amounts of tax - especially at 100k you just can’t comprehend how much is deducted at source. It’s much higher than the headline rate. Combine that with all the losses you are indeed worse off for working. It really doesn’t pay to do well in this country. Hence the state of the economy. People cannot even fathom how you don’t have “loadsa money” because they don’t see all the direct/stealth taxes.

All of the heavy lifting in this economy is done by people on about 100k. Professionals who have done well. They are paying for everyone including their richer peers who don’t contribute. All to be left with less disposable income than most. It’s ok though - they are rich and it must be a budgeting issue.

Labour’s plan will collapse the economy and welfare state even more. I actually think it’s what the country needs to be honest. Then people will realise that everyone should be paying their share not just the tiny percentage on PAYE at 6 figures.

Moraxella · 19/03/2023 16:06

@ScruffyGiraffes as someone who lost their mum I can assure you that they would 1000% rather have you. 💐

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 16:05

They will need this childcare all through primary at least and perhaps longer. I think I have to accept that even with £100k salary on paper I can't provide adequately for them. I have tried every avenue to get help: SS, DLA, etc. All say "no". I can't do any more because me working more would make them worse off. So the options left are: 1) put them into care (no); or 2) get rid of mummy so you get the payout and can live a decent life.

mishmased · 19/03/2023 16:04

@ScruffyGiraffes no amount of money, love and care they get from anyone can replace you. Hang in there .

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 16:00

If I die there will be enough money for 1:1 nannies full time while my friend who I've appointed as their guardian raises them (she has a big enough house to house them) and also enough insurance money to cover all her costs and leave a fair bit left over for when they are adults. With my rational head on, increasingly this seems like by far the better life for them, than anything I can provide because no matter what I do now I cannot make things any better. We get poorer every year. We'll have no car soon. We have a colder house and less food. I can't replace their shoes and uniform. If Labour come on and impose more taxes at £80k they'll lose their home, the only bit of stability that these traumatised kids have had. I can't help thinking they'd be better off with my friend, in a nice warm home with enough food a shoes that fit and family holidays and bikes and activities that I just cannot give to them, but the insurance money would.

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 15:50

This sounds really tough-
With a special needs child- can you get PIPs?
Hope it will get easier once you don’t have to pay wrap around care.

I applied for DLA for them. The answer was no. Even though both have diagnosed conditions, had reports sent from psychologists, paediatricians, OTs, nannies, them really struggling with school etc. They can't be unsupervised for a minute, they can't sleep. They are in immense emotional distress. But apparently do not meet the criteria for support. I have challenged this. Still no.

It's not just wrap around care. They need 1:1 care so can't do clubs before school/ after school or in holidays. I have 5 weeks per year of AL so 7 weeks to cover, plus inset days, illness, strikes. That is with me getting zero time on my own, ever, that is not at work or caring for them. I also have to go away for business trips. In bad months with school holidays and work commitments the childcare cost (even with "tax free" childcare that isn't tax free, just 20% discount which will also vanish if I earn £1 more per year) the childcare cost can be over £3.5k per month. Apparently I shouldn't be using this discount though anyway and should pay it myself according to many posters on this thread! My children are not eligible for SS support etc apparently because of my income. The irony, when we have £200 per month left for food and any other things like clothes, birthdays, etc.

There is no help for us. We are just a cash cow to fund everyone else's help even if it leaves my children in poverty. And hardly seeing their mother, so that they have a roof over their heads. As I said upthread, I have seen the calculations and if I'd never worked, never got a degree or professional qualifications or worked all those hours or bought a house we'd have everything funded by people like the OP (and me!) and twice the disposable income that we do now, with me not working at all and here to support them 24/7.

It makes no sense to me.

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 15:34

Again, for those confused, please read the evidence posted on the thread: many graphs and articles with the research demonstrating the issue.

https://www.taxpolicy.org.uk/2022/10/04/marginal/

^^ This is a good visual representation, although obviously the latest budget makes it even worse. Per the other articles also available in the thread.

If you cannot be bothered to understand the basic maths or read the evidence, then please refrain from commenting, because it's just pointless to voice opinions when they have no relationship to reality.

Happyvalleyfan · 19/03/2023 15:27

www.gov.uk/disability-living-allowance-children/eligibility

sorry if you already know about this

Happyvalleyfan · 19/03/2023 15:21

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 14:22

And machine gun in the face is absolutely right. I'm embarrassed that I'm struggling to buy my children new school uniform that fits them. I'm selling the car: it's ancient so won't raise much but will help cover some of the childcare cost in the summer holidays. Not sure how we'll pay the fuel bills next winter. My children have disabilities so can't have the house cold but to heat it to the temperature they need would take 30% of my net pay after tax and mortgage and childcare. That would leave us with only £700 for my commuting, food and Council tax. Commuting even with cutting my hours is another £350. Council tax is £150 with single person discount. So we now have £200 for our food and household stuff each month, and their clothes etc plus birthday presents or activites. They are meant to take a bike or scooter into school for an activity on Monday but I can't afford to buy those for them even second hand. School suggested I get them a private OT and SALT. I can't. They are asking what we can do for their birthday parties and where we're going on holiday because they were all talking about it as a topic at school. They won't have any of those things.

Yet people say we are rich. It makes me want to cry tbh. I have had some really dark thoughts recently about how to die without it being obvious I did it on purpose so they'd still get the life insurance as then they'd be able to have a much better life than I can give to them. I have appointed guardians and they'd be well cared for and have the money from the insurance to live a proper life that I can't give to them.

This sounds really tough-
With a special needs child- can you get PIPs?
Hope it will get easier once you don’t have to pay wrap around care.

NorthernDrizzle · 19/03/2023 15:14

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 18/03/2023 18:59

Well the free hours are removed at 100k now so even a non-gradual tapering would offer more incentive than now, but broadly I agree. It's like with the 50-60k in England being both the 40% tax rate and CB withdrawal territory. They do it that way for administrative reasons afaik, but the flipside is the creation of more and steeper bottlenecks. To which people respond.

No they are not
Everyone gets 15 hours over 38 weeks so 570 hours a year
The additional 15 are removed, worth less than £6k a year - even at the new higher rate proposed.

Lostinalibrary · 19/03/2023 14:35

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 14:22

And machine gun in the face is absolutely right. I'm embarrassed that I'm struggling to buy my children new school uniform that fits them. I'm selling the car: it's ancient so won't raise much but will help cover some of the childcare cost in the summer holidays. Not sure how we'll pay the fuel bills next winter. My children have disabilities so can't have the house cold but to heat it to the temperature they need would take 30% of my net pay after tax and mortgage and childcare. That would leave us with only £700 for my commuting, food and Council tax. Commuting even with cutting my hours is another £350. Council tax is £150 with single person discount. So we now have £200 for our food and household stuff each month, and their clothes etc plus birthday presents or activites. They are meant to take a bike or scooter into school for an activity on Monday but I can't afford to buy those for them even second hand. School suggested I get them a private OT and SALT. I can't. They are asking what we can do for their birthday parties and where we're going on holiday because they were all talking about it as a topic at school. They won't have any of those things.

Yet people say we are rich. It makes me want to cry tbh. I have had some really dark thoughts recently about how to die without it being obvious I did it on purpose so they'd still get the life insurance as then they'd be able to have a much better life than I can give to them. I have appointed guardians and they'd be well cared for and have the money from the insurance to live a proper life that I can't give to them.

I am so sorry to read this. People should be absolutely ashamed of themselves on here. I don’t know if it’s ignorance, jealousy or just lack of education. People see 6 figures and think “rich.” Happy for you to work yourself into a grave to pay for their UC, pension, school places and NHS access.

The actual real rich - the real 1% pay nothing. Many people on six figures don’t have savings. People can’t comprehend that. What they also can’t comprehend is 70% of their income going in deductions. With no top-ups, no support and more tax. It should not be the case that you can get a 50k pay rise and only be a few hundred better off a month if you don’t have children.

Personally, the collapse of the welfare system can’t come fast enough. Only 50% of adults or thereabouts pay any income tax. Of those - most are still net recipients through low tax, UC and state services. It’s not sustainable. It’s people like you who are supporting everyone - not the rich.

It’s absolutely perverse and real that a single parent on 6 figures can be living in hardship.

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 14:22

And machine gun in the face is absolutely right. I'm embarrassed that I'm struggling to buy my children new school uniform that fits them. I'm selling the car: it's ancient so won't raise much but will help cover some of the childcare cost in the summer holidays. Not sure how we'll pay the fuel bills next winter. My children have disabilities so can't have the house cold but to heat it to the temperature they need would take 30% of my net pay after tax and mortgage and childcare. That would leave us with only £700 for my commuting, food and Council tax. Commuting even with cutting my hours is another £350. Council tax is £150 with single person discount. So we now have £200 for our food and household stuff each month, and their clothes etc plus birthday presents or activites. They are meant to take a bike or scooter into school for an activity on Monday but I can't afford to buy those for them even second hand. School suggested I get them a private OT and SALT. I can't. They are asking what we can do for their birthday parties and where we're going on holiday because they were all talking about it as a topic at school. They won't have any of those things.

Yet people say we are rich. It makes me want to cry tbh. I have had some really dark thoughts recently about how to die without it being obvious I did it on purpose so they'd still get the life insurance as then they'd be able to have a much better life than I can give to them. I have appointed guardians and they'd be well cared for and have the money from the insurance to live a proper life that I can't give to them.

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 14:04

Same here. Always worked what most people considered an insane amount. Never begrudged the taxes to help others. Despite supporting myself since I was a teenager with no help from the state whatsoever! Would never, ever have dreamed of turning doen a promotion until recently, when I realised I had no choice but to do so to not lose our home. There is a limit, and nobody is going to work more to receive a far lower net income. 🤣 It's great that in your situation you can make the only real choice available and spend more time with your children. I wish I could enjoy doing the same and not be worrying about is losing the house or how to pay the utility bill because of the single parent double tax. But you absolutely shouldn't feel guilty, when you're still going to be the ones funding everyone else's services and benefits anyway. I hope you really enjoy the better balance. Another silly thing about the system: after people have got used to being forced to work lower hours and enjoyed it, they're less likely to be keen to go back to full time!

Bucketheadbucketbum · 19/03/2023 13:57

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 13:48

OP it's a complete no-brainer. Nobody would do anything differently and work more for less money. Nobody.

People on UC all the time make decisions on working hours because working more would make them only marginally better off. And this is when they are weighing up earning more money themselves versus claiming more money from other taxpayers like you, if they choose to work less. I understand the withdrawal can be up to 67% for them.

People earning £50k are faced with similar choices. Again, almost all (obviously) choose not to work more to earn less. The withdrawal can be up to 80% for them. So obviously also a perfectly rational decision.

People earning £100k are faced with an even more stark choice: work more and lose £27k of net pay for earning £1. The idea that anybody would say it's immoral to choose not to do that is beyond my comprehension. When in fact this decision, unlike the people on UC, involves you still funding everything yourself AND continuing to fund a great deal of the extra support for other families: their rent, living costs, healthcare, their children's education. But you're immoral apparently for not working EVEN MORE, to pay even more to them and make your own family poorer than you are now?!?

Either the respondents saying this are really unintelligent, or have some kind of disability with basic maths, or are completely delusional.

Whichever it is, it matters not. It's not your fault how the system is designed. Obviously you are making the right choice. The only choice really. How would you look your children in the eye and tell them you decided to have a lower income so that you could spend less time with them?

You will still be supporting a very large number of poorer families through the large taxes you'll still be paying, and a little more gratitude for that wouldn't go amiss.

In the meantime, as more and more of our most productive workers who pay for the services and welfare for everyone make the same choices as you, perhaps eventually the message will get through to politicians that they need to fix this, then in the future sometime it may be worth you working more again.

For now, enjoy the increased work/ life balance and time with your children. You've earned it many times over.

Thank you!

I just still cannot fathom this is the set up, its bonkers. Not only is there no carrot for working hard and earning more- it turns out the stick is a massive bloody machine gun!!

Never thought I'd be deliberately turning down work or pay rises but, if this is how the government want things to be time work less and to enjoy life for a change. :-)

OP posts:
ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 13:48

Bucketheadbucketbum · 19/03/2023 11:43

To be honest it's not so much about the childcare now, although that was the final straw, it's more about the tax cliff edge .

We've reanalysed our situation and just can't get away from the fact we are working harder, for less.

What's the point in life? We could be dead tomorrow and if we are net net net worse off financially working more, why wpuld we choose to spend less time with each other? And to have a more stressful existence? Our lives will be monumentally more enjoyable if we both cut our hours, and we will be better off financially!

We will still be paying tens of thousands in tax so not sure what everyone's problem is- how much tax do you all pay? How many hours do you work a week? How much time do you get with your family? How much stress does your job cause you? How long and how costly is your commute?

Would you really do anything differently? Really. Honestly. No you would not.

OP it's a complete no-brainer. Nobody would do anything differently and work more for less money. Nobody.

People on UC all the time make decisions on working hours because working more would make them only marginally better off. And this is when they are weighing up earning more money themselves versus claiming more money from other taxpayers like you, if they choose to work less. I understand the withdrawal can be up to 67% for them.

People earning £50k are faced with similar choices. Again, almost all (obviously) choose not to work more to earn less. The withdrawal can be up to 80% for them. So obviously also a perfectly rational decision.

People earning £100k are faced with an even more stark choice: work more and lose £27k of net pay for earning £1. The idea that anybody would say it's immoral to choose not to do that is beyond my comprehension. When in fact this decision, unlike the people on UC, involves you still funding everything yourself AND continuing to fund a great deal of the extra support for other families: their rent, living costs, healthcare, their children's education. But you're immoral apparently for not working EVEN MORE, to pay even more to them and make your own family poorer than you are now?!?

Either the respondents saying this are really unintelligent, or have some kind of disability with basic maths, or are completely delusional.

Whichever it is, it matters not. It's not your fault how the system is designed. Obviously you are making the right choice. The only choice really. How would you look your children in the eye and tell them you decided to have a lower income so that you could spend less time with them?

You will still be supporting a very large number of poorer families through the large taxes you'll still be paying, and a little more gratitude for that wouldn't go amiss.

In the meantime, as more and more of our most productive workers who pay for the services and welfare for everyone make the same choices as you, perhaps eventually the message will get through to politicians that they need to fix this, then in the future sometime it may be worth you working more again.

For now, enjoy the increased work/ life balance and time with your children. You've earned it many times over.