Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

DH and I going part time to deliberately reduce wages

890 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 13:35

Just working out the free childcare hours and actually DH and I will be muxh better off if we both dropped to 3- 4 day week to deliberately reduce our incomes. Would obviously be nice way to live too! Anyone else doing same? Seems mental but we've looked at it 100 times over and it's true!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Jonei · 19/03/2023 19:49

Crikey. I am very tempted to drop my work hours and spend more time with my kids. I actually think I will be significantly better off.

StatisticallyChallenged · 19/03/2023 19:49

AngryBirdsNoMore · 19/03/2023 19:39

Ok this has made me look up salaries around the £50k-£70k mark as people have mentioned this a few times.

£50k = take home pay of £3168
£60k = take home pay of £3654 and no child benefit

that’s a bit mad.

(Not checked the salary numbers) - but this means that with two kids the first number is effectively £3325 - so for an extra 10k you actually walk away with a benefit of £3948 per year

Ignoring the childcare issue, £100k is £5370 and £110k is £5661, so you walk away with an extra £3492 per year (Scottish numbers).

Clymene · 19/03/2023 19:47

Gosh what a lot of very unpleasant people this thread has spawned. Many of whom can't spell despite their high paying jobs.

Absolute mystery

Mandyjack · 19/03/2023 19:45

A lot of companies will let you reduce your hours if you ask. I dropped from 37 to 30 a few years back so do 4.5 days

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 19:44

AngryBirdsNoMore · 19/03/2023 19:39

Ok this has made me look up salaries around the £50k-£70k mark as people have mentioned this a few times.

£50k = take home pay of £3168
£60k = take home pay of £3654 and no child benefit

that’s a bit mad.

Have a look at net take home pay that is less at £135k than at £99k. If people can't accept that is absurd and will mean the very people we need to earn more to pay for everyone else will stop doing so, then UK welfare/ services are doomed to collapse entirely before much longer. Why would anybody bother?

bigbabycooker · 19/03/2023 19:42

@MaidOfSteel

No, not moaning about people on benefits at all. Moaning about the fact that government policy on taxation means that you basically don't keep any of your money if you earn between £100k and £150k, which disincentivises working hard to pay for others who may not be so fortunate. Most people do work for money, after all

Mycatsgoldtooth · 19/03/2023 19:41

Do it op. So many people on this thread that have no idea how the tax system effects higher earners. Why should op work extra hours just for that money to go to the government and not her family. Why should she pay for someone on 30k to have a child care for free, child benefit that she’s not entitled to and then be told she’s an awful person. If she’s earning over 100k and so is her husband they will be paying massive amounts of tax. But on mumsnet those paying high taxes are evil, those claiming benefits are saints.

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 19:40

Even after this thread, with links and facts and graphs and research and then also personal stories spelling out the very real and effects of all of this, still all of these stupid and facile comments talking about "privilege". Just what the actual fuck is wrong with people?!

AngryBirdsNoMore · 19/03/2023 19:39

Ok this has made me look up salaries around the £50k-£70k mark as people have mentioned this a few times.

£50k = take home pay of £3168
£60k = take home pay of £3654 and no child benefit

that’s a bit mad.

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 19:38

not so much if you're lower down the scale and struggle to survive instead. Then you're a lazy scrounger who doesn't have aspirations.

Explain to me why I should work my arse off and have hardly any time with my children to pay for those people "lower down the income scale" to have far more disposable income than I do because so much of what I earn is taken from me and given to them? So mucj that I can't feed my children properly or pay to heat their home properly despite earning £100k per year, and apparently should pay even more of the money that I earn to people who did not earn it, so that their children can have a better standard of living than mine? Would love to hear how you think this is "fair".

ThreeFeetTall · 19/03/2023 19:35

Haven't read the whole thread but did working part time not occur to you before? Kind of odd you are doing this purely because you will be better off and not because you want to spend more time with your kids or have better work life balance (when you were clearly rich enough to have these choices before)

bigbabycooker · 19/03/2023 19:34

@Ilikepinacoladass

I agree, definitely that dropping out of the workforce and not earning entirely is very risky ( I think pp was a nurse and did occasional bank shifts, so at least in theory she might be able to scale up in the event if a split) because not everyone can rely on their partner which is why government policy is madness - good quality childcare should be available to all.

Noname77 · 19/03/2023 19:27

HospitalitySux · 18/03/2023 14:42

Exactly.

It's ok to do what you need to do to have a decent life if you consider yourself the 'Squeezed middle' - not so much if you're lower down the scale and struggle to survive instead. Then you're a lazy scrounger who doesn't have aspirations.

Agree

ScruffyGiraffe · 19/03/2023 19:17

You can't of had it that hard "starting from the bottom" if you have "NEVER claimed a penny from the state"

Sounds like you have come from a pretty privileged place..

What utter crap. I've supported myself since I was a teenager and never, ever had any benefits etc. Many peoole do not. It's not "priviledge" to work full time through A levels and a degree to support yourself. It's not "priviledge" to work crazy hours all through your 20s and early 30s the build a career. This assumption that people owe you something or must have had it easier than you because they've achieved more is not just distasteful but in many cases completely false.

Dibblydoodahdah · 19/03/2023 19:16

@Ejkmama are you a net contributor? The OP is so no one is picking up her bill even if she works a bit less. Why are you economically illiterate?

Lostinalibrary · 19/03/2023 19:15

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 19:05

If you look at Denmark, Sweden etc the tax rates on higher earners are quite similar to the UK. Actually lower mostly. And not with these perverse bottlenecks, with the tax rate escalating to 89% then dropping down then up to over 100% then down to 47%. But importantly the difference is not that higher earners are taxed more - they can't actually be taxed more than they are in the UK - it's that the tax base is wider: it's accepted that everyone should contribute to public services and there is then enough money for everyone to receive decent services.

In the UK services are failing because an ever smaller group of people are the only ones funding them. And they are then being told that a) they shouldn't also use the services they are funding for themselves and everyone else; and b) that it's selfish to refuse to work more when you'd be taxed over 100% on that income.

Totally mind boggling. And the result of it all is that I can no longer provide for my children because I am paying so much to support other people's children. But if you have the audacity to complain about it you are told it's "disgusting" and just keep giving them the money, how dare you access the public services you pay for, how dare you expect any time with your child, who cares if you cannot afford their home or uniform or food or the people you are funding have way more spare money than you? Just shut up, cash cow, and carry on working more and give money to us, money money money and who gives a shit if you can't heat your house properly for your disabled kids? We'll think of you while we're on holiday this year and raise a glass while you're busy moving your children out of their home because we've bled you so dry you can't afford the mortgage anymore of feed them properly. Because we need your money that you earned MUCH more than you do, so we don't give a fuck if you can't afford to live. Just give us more!!

Good luck to them. They will end up with the country they deserve. Destitute with no public services and no welfare. Only 50% ish adults pay any form of income tax. Out of that a minute amount are net contributors. The will end up with nothing too. Forcing a country into stagnation is not a bright idea for a country which relies on taxes to fund the bloated welfare state.

AviMav · 19/03/2023 19:13

Buildingthefuture · 19/03/2023 19:06

I can absolutely see why you would do that. The system allows it and it benefits you. But, do it in the full knowledge that other people (I.e me!) are paying for your choices.
I have made different choices..those choices have ended with me being a higher rate tax payer. I have never been gifted anything, I’ve never inherited anything (other than a massively strong work ethic - thank you mother!) and I have never received a penny from the state. Despite what MN says, some of us have worked our way up from the bottom. And yes, we do wonder why we have to pay for you and your choices. But, it is what it is and we keep plugging away. I’ve no choice but to keep paying my taxes, you apparently have an easier choice. More power to your elbow, but me and people like me are paying for it.

You can't of had it that hard "starting from the bottom" if you have "NEVER claimed a penny from the state"

Sounds like you have come from a pretty privileged place..

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 19:13

Buildingthefuture · 19/03/2023 19:06

I can absolutely see why you would do that. The system allows it and it benefits you. But, do it in the full knowledge that other people (I.e me!) are paying for your choices.
I have made different choices..those choices have ended with me being a higher rate tax payer. I have never been gifted anything, I’ve never inherited anything (other than a massively strong work ethic - thank you mother!) and I have never received a penny from the state. Despite what MN says, some of us have worked our way up from the bottom. And yes, we do wonder why we have to pay for you and your choices. But, it is what it is and we keep plugging away. I’ve no choice but to keep paying my taxes, you apparently have an easier choice. More power to your elbow, but me and people like me are paying for it.

You are NOT paying for the OP. She and her HD are paying for the services they are using several times over. Even with the cut in hours, they will still be funding themselves and many other families. If you're a higher rate taxpayer, you are now just about covering your own cost. If you're further into higher rate, you're now covering yourself and contributing a bit to others. OP and DH have been supporting themselves and many other families for many years. Them deciding to cut their hours slightly and still pay in way more than they get out, still covering themselves AND supporting others, but also spend some time with their own kids costs you nothing. Zero. They have never cost taxpayers anything and still won't, they'll still be paying for things for everyone else. So maybe rein in the sanctimonious bullshit and say "thank you OP for helping us all so much".

Ungrateful idiots.

Lostinalibrary · 19/03/2023 19:12

Buildingthefuture · 19/03/2023 19:06

I can absolutely see why you would do that. The system allows it and it benefits you. But, do it in the full knowledge that other people (I.e me!) are paying for your choices.
I have made different choices..those choices have ended with me being a higher rate tax payer. I have never been gifted anything, I’ve never inherited anything (other than a massively strong work ethic - thank you mother!) and I have never received a penny from the state. Despite what MN says, some of us have worked our way up from the bottom. And yes, we do wonder why we have to pay for you and your choices. But, it is what it is and we keep plugging away. I’ve no choice but to keep paying my taxes, you apparently have an easier choice. More power to your elbow, but me and people like me are paying for it.

No - you’re not.

StatisticallyChallenged · 19/03/2023 19:08

Buildingthefuture · 19/03/2023 19:06

I can absolutely see why you would do that. The system allows it and it benefits you. But, do it in the full knowledge that other people (I.e me!) are paying for your choices.
I have made different choices..those choices have ended with me being a higher rate tax payer. I have never been gifted anything, I’ve never inherited anything (other than a massively strong work ethic - thank you mother!) and I have never received a penny from the state. Despite what MN says, some of us have worked our way up from the bottom. And yes, we do wonder why we have to pay for you and your choices. But, it is what it is and we keep plugging away. I’ve no choice but to keep paying my taxes, you apparently have an easier choice. More power to your elbow, but me and people like me are paying for it.

The OP will be reducing her wage to just under £100k, as will her DH. Don't think you are paying for it in their case.

saltwater1985 · 19/03/2023 19:08

You do what's best for your family.
The govt fuck ups are not our responsibility.
Take the money and run, it's not a race to the bottom and you don't get a medial for working your arse off if you don't have to.

Buildingthefuture · 19/03/2023 19:06

I can absolutely see why you would do that. The system allows it and it benefits you. But, do it in the full knowledge that other people (I.e me!) are paying for your choices.
I have made different choices..those choices have ended with me being a higher rate tax payer. I have never been gifted anything, I’ve never inherited anything (other than a massively strong work ethic - thank you mother!) and I have never received a penny from the state. Despite what MN says, some of us have worked our way up from the bottom. And yes, we do wonder why we have to pay for you and your choices. But, it is what it is and we keep plugging away. I’ve no choice but to keep paying my taxes, you apparently have an easier choice. More power to your elbow, but me and people like me are paying for it.

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 19:05

Lostinalibrary · 19/03/2023 16:23

I used to be that person who would scoff at higher earners and say “you deserve to pay more.” Until you actually see the eye watering amounts of tax - especially at 100k you just can’t comprehend how much is deducted at source. It’s much higher than the headline rate. Combine that with all the losses you are indeed worse off for working. It really doesn’t pay to do well in this country. Hence the state of the economy. People cannot even fathom how you don’t have “loadsa money” because they don’t see all the direct/stealth taxes.

All of the heavy lifting in this economy is done by people on about 100k. Professionals who have done well. They are paying for everyone including their richer peers who don’t contribute. All to be left with less disposable income than most. It’s ok though - they are rich and it must be a budgeting issue.

Labour’s plan will collapse the economy and welfare state even more. I actually think it’s what the country needs to be honest. Then people will realise that everyone should be paying their share not just the tiny percentage on PAYE at 6 figures.

If you look at Denmark, Sweden etc the tax rates on higher earners are quite similar to the UK. Actually lower mostly. And not with these perverse bottlenecks, with the tax rate escalating to 89% then dropping down then up to over 100% then down to 47%. But importantly the difference is not that higher earners are taxed more - they can't actually be taxed more than they are in the UK - it's that the tax base is wider: it's accepted that everyone should contribute to public services and there is then enough money for everyone to receive decent services.

In the UK services are failing because an ever smaller group of people are the only ones funding them. And they are then being told that a) they shouldn't also use the services they are funding for themselves and everyone else; and b) that it's selfish to refuse to work more when you'd be taxed over 100% on that income.

Totally mind boggling. And the result of it all is that I can no longer provide for my children because I am paying so much to support other people's children. But if you have the audacity to complain about it you are told it's "disgusting" and just keep giving them the money, how dare you access the public services you pay for, how dare you expect any time with your child, who cares if you cannot afford their home or uniform or food or the people you are funding have way more spare money than you? Just shut up, cash cow, and carry on working more and give money to us, money money money and who gives a shit if you can't heat your house properly for your disabled kids? We'll think of you while we're on holiday this year and raise a glass while you're busy moving your children out of their home because we've bled you so dry you can't afford the mortgage anymore of feed them properly. Because we need your money that you earned MUCH more than you do, so we don't give a fuck if you can't afford to live. Just give us more!!

mandlerparr · 19/03/2023 18:55

I think it is more of a math problem. If daycare costs more than what you are making during those hours, what is the incentive to work? Most of the time, in these situations, the woman is made to take the hit by leaving the workforce or only working 1-2 days a week. This way, both are still working.

Ilikepinacoladass · 19/03/2023 18:51

bigbabycooker · 18/03/2023 20:18

@Ilikepinacoladass

I'm not in this situation (I work 3 days, to earn £100k, rather than £150k, which would barely pay be any more at all net of childcare, so I am basically the OP and have chosen more leisure with my kids), so I can't speak for that poster, but...

I think you are being extremely disingenuous to claim that all the things that a SAHM might do if her partner just goes to work and doesn't have much capacity to help out in the week are replaced by a cleaner. If you have to do all the drop offs, all the picks ups, make and attend all the appointments, book all clubs, buy all shopping and clothes (or else give up your weekend family time so that you can both share it) and you are still basically paying to work net of childcare, I can totally see how you might feel that you have a much higher quality of life with your kids than working, whether or not you like your job. In this country, nursing shifts are also very family unfriendly - in France, you can do an 8 hour shift, allowing you to not work nights and see your kids at one or both ends of the day, whereas in the U.K., most NHS shifts are 12 hours, so you can't. It's a very rational decision to decide that this is a bit crappy and one that you can't really get too sniffy about (which is what your post sounded like) if you can leave at 5pm in an office job.

That's true. Although think you would be putting yourself in a risky situation to do all those things to facilitate your partner earning money, not having a job yourself and giving up career. Especially if you split up.

Swipe left for the next trending thread