Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

DH and I going part time to deliberately reduce wages

890 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 13:35

Just working out the free childcare hours and actually DH and I will be muxh better off if we both dropped to 3- 4 day week to deliberately reduce our incomes. Would obviously be nice way to live too! Anyone else doing same? Seems mental but we've looked at it 100 times over and it's true!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 20/03/2023 11:05

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 10:57

The point is that for a lot of people going part time or reducing hours would impact careers, and that's why they would choose not to do it. That's not to say that applies to everyone. Just maybe not a significant enough amount of people for it to be an issue to the UK in general.

And yes petty is in the eye of the beholder, but if you're earning 50k a year / take home £3150 per month, being miffed about losing £35 a week in child benefit I think is on the petty end of the spectrum..

We're agreed that for some people it will make sense to reduce hours at bottleneck points and for some it won't. That's a given and not what I'm asking.

My question is how exactly people who think differently to you about the importance of these bottlenecks and the likely increase in the number of people who'll be facing them over the next few years can set out their concerns without being dismissed as whining?

Because ultimately, nobody other than you and maybe a few people you know gives a shit whether you think a particular action is petty or not. That isn't specific to you either, the same is true for everyone else on this thread too. People's personal moral opinions are not what this is about. It's at the very least an issue that is likely to grow simply because more people will be affected. Even if the percentages of people making the decision to work less stays at exactly the same as it is now, because of inflation and fiscal drag the numbers involved are going to increase.

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 11:00

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 20/03/2023 10:56

The fact that some people will always be on the border of thresholds and the fact that our system includes a number of bottlenecks are two different points. You don't address the second by pointing out the inevitability of the first.

On the subject of complaints, whining etc, how exactly would you like people to make the point that these disincentives exist, that fiscal drag combined with inflation is likely to increase the numbers potentially into both the 100k and 50-60k bottleneck territory and that this is going to have some impact? It sounds like your main issue is that you dispute how common it's going to be. But how can people who are more concerned about this than you are make that case without being accused of whining? Because the poster you replied to wasn't doing that.

It's fine if you think it's a risk that's being overexaggerated, although speaking as someone whose household are going to be taking action to ensure continued receipt of child benefit quite soon I feel less certain than you do, but we do actually need to have a way to discuss this. And why the fuck shouldn't people say that they think our tax system is awful? Bottlenecks and perverse incentives are a bad thing, and we do have them scattered throughout the income levels, particularly where children are involved. They're a feature of UC claimants just as much as they are of high earners. What's the problem with people complaining about bad policy?

Complain about bad policy yes, but don't use it as an excuse or a blame it as a reason as to why you're working less / going part time, when actually you are benefitting from being able to spend more time with your kids.. and it's a privilege to be able to do so.

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 10:57

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 10:35

There's always going to be some people who are on the border line of thresholds. And for those people yes maybe limiting hours to a certain degree might make sense. And yes for some maybe it won't impact their careers in anyway. But the idea that the amount of these people is so great that it's going to negatively impact the UKs economy I think is questionable.

Reduce your hours if you want. Enjoy the time with your kids. Just don't complain about being forced to do it because the of the awful tax system, and then also try and make out that the government is totally fucking themselves over as all these important people are reducing their hours which will clearly be disastrous for the UK economy..

The point is that for a lot of people going part time or reducing hours would impact careers, and that's why they would choose not to do it. That's not to say that applies to everyone. Just maybe not a significant enough amount of people for it to be an issue to the UK in general.

And yes petty is in the eye of the beholder, but if you're earning 50k a year / take home £3150 per month, being miffed about losing £35 a week in child benefit I think is on the petty end of the spectrum..

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 20/03/2023 10:56

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 10:35

There's always going to be some people who are on the border line of thresholds. And for those people yes maybe limiting hours to a certain degree might make sense. And yes for some maybe it won't impact their careers in anyway. But the idea that the amount of these people is so great that it's going to negatively impact the UKs economy I think is questionable.

Reduce your hours if you want. Enjoy the time with your kids. Just don't complain about being forced to do it because the of the awful tax system, and then also try and make out that the government is totally fucking themselves over as all these important people are reducing their hours which will clearly be disastrous for the UK economy..

The fact that some people will always be on the border of thresholds and the fact that our system includes a number of bottlenecks are two different points. You don't address the second by pointing out the inevitability of the first.

On the subject of complaints, whining etc, how exactly would you like people to make the point that these disincentives exist, that fiscal drag combined with inflation is likely to increase the numbers potentially into both the 100k and 50-60k bottleneck territory and that this is going to have some impact? It sounds like your main issue is that you dispute how common it's going to be. But how can people who are more concerned about this than you are make that case without being accused of whining? Because the poster you replied to wasn't doing that.

It's fine if you think it's a risk that's being overexaggerated, although speaking as someone whose household are going to be taking action to ensure continued receipt of child benefit quite soon I feel less certain than you do, but we do actually need to have a way to discuss this. And why the fuck shouldn't people say that they think our tax system is awful? Bottlenecks and perverse incentives are a bad thing, and we do have them scattered throughout the income levels, particularly where children are involved. They're a feature of UC claimants just as much as they are of high earners. What's the problem with people complaining about bad policy?

Xenia · 20/03/2023 10:40

Well said ladykale.

My preference would be a capped say 20% or 33% flat tax/NI combined and once you pay say £250k tax a year then no m atter who much you earn you have done your bit and keep what is over that or something ilke the Gibraltar tax system (5% on the highest income). en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxation_in_Gibraltar and none of the various allowances or childcare help - just allowing people to keep more of their own money and choose how to spend it i.e. freedom.

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 10:35

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 20/03/2023 10:24

You are assuming other people make the same value judgement and have the same circumstances or budgets as you.

'Petty' is in the eye of the beholder, particularly as there are some circumstances where a person might need to work harder or more and possibly increase work expenses such as childcare. Child benefit demonstrably isn't supposed to be there for people struggling, given that it was a universal benefit when invented and is now still available to households towards the top of the income distribution if the earnings are split between two partners.

And lastly, people who don't like the idea of others doing this often are very keen on the idea that it's a bad idea to limit one's career but again, this is a generalisation and a value judgement. Some people won't be limiting their careers by doing it. Others might and won't be bothered. Not everyone has the sort of job where they work up the ladder for promotions and need to put the time in to do it. Some of the people you're talking about here will be say tradespeople deciding if it's worth their while to take the extra job or not. You cannot just universalise your opinion and circumstances.

There's always going to be some people who are on the border line of thresholds. And for those people yes maybe limiting hours to a certain degree might make sense. And yes for some maybe it won't impact their careers in anyway. But the idea that the amount of these people is so great that it's going to negatively impact the UKs economy I think is questionable.

Reduce your hours if you want. Enjoy the time with your kids. Just don't complain about being forced to do it because the of the awful tax system, and then also try and make out that the government is totally fucking themselves over as all these important people are reducing their hours which will clearly be disastrous for the UK economy..

Dibblydoodahdah · 20/03/2023 10:30

@usernamealreadytaken what are your thoughts on childcare in the UK being the most expensive in the developed World?

Dibblydoodahdah · 20/03/2023 10:27

@usernamealreadytaken is it morally reprehensible to have your NI credit paid whilst being a SAHM parent?

ladykale · 20/03/2023 10:27

Blossomtoes · 20/03/2023 08:49

Many of the children as DS2’s private school are born to highly skilled first generation immigrants. They decided to move here, they can decide to move elsewhere. The local hospital would be fucked without them.

What an excellent argument for allowing more immigrants to settle here.

Me and my OH fall into this category. We currently pay about 200-250k in income tax each year.

We are tired of the anti-immigrant rhetoric in the U.K and have very little tying us to the U.K.

Fingers crossed that all goes to plan we'll be moving at the end of 2024 to a lower tax jurisdiction and will no longer by tax resident in the U.K. within 6 months of that. Public services there are slightly worse or similar, but like the U.K. we pay for private everything so it will be the same.

U.K. income tax system is very anti-inspiration.

I don't mind working 60 - 70 hour weeks for 10 years of my life if it means a better future for my future children, but certainly not to fund entitled people int he U.K. who think they can sit on their backside and be funded by everyone else.

OP SHOULD scale back her hours to get one of the few benefits that a high earner can get in the U.K after all the tax she pays in!

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 20/03/2023 10:24

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 09:15

Yes child benefit is tapered over 50k-60k. But essentially if you are earning that much you are not going to miss it and it is petty feeling hard done by missing out on the benefits. And generally quite stupid to limit your career purely to qualify for benefits that are meant to be there for people struggling. If people want to reduce their hours to enjoy spending time with family absolutely do that, but own the decision rather than claiming it's based on saving petty amounts here and there.

You are assuming other people make the same value judgement and have the same circumstances or budgets as you.

'Petty' is in the eye of the beholder, particularly as there are some circumstances where a person might need to work harder or more and possibly increase work expenses such as childcare. Child benefit demonstrably isn't supposed to be there for people struggling, given that it was a universal benefit when invented and is now still available to households towards the top of the income distribution if the earnings are split between two partners.

And lastly, people who don't like the idea of others doing this often are very keen on the idea that it's a bad idea to limit one's career but again, this is a generalisation and a value judgement. Some people won't be limiting their careers by doing it. Others might and won't be bothered. Not everyone has the sort of job where they work up the ladder for promotions and need to put the time in to do it. Some of the people you're talking about here will be say tradespeople deciding if it's worth their while to take the extra job or not. You cannot just universalise your opinion and circumstances.

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 10:19

Mycatsgoldtooth · 20/03/2023 08:54

The gist here seems to be ok for the op to work for no personal gain for herself and to support other people who are unable to earn as well as she does. And she should be happy about it and not try to reap any benefits from the tax she pays or have ‘a day off’.
Is it ok for a lower earning mother to work part time while she’s getting 15 hours of childcare, even if she could work more. Is that also depriving the tax system of money?

I think the point is so do it and enjoy the day off, rather than make out you're being forced to do it due to the awful tax system, and complaining about it. And recognise you are privileged to be able to take the day off in the first place.

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 10:16

StatisticallyChallenged · 20/03/2023 09:32

I meant that CB is better - because it's gradual so you are never in a position where you earn more and have less because of it. You might not have much more, but you do have more.

If it was a hard limit and you were a single parent earning near the threshold you'd be very careful about not doing the odd hour of overtime. CB for two kids is about £35 a week, I think a single earner just tipping over the threshold might well notice that loss.

Carer's allowance where you lose it as soon as you earn an extra £1 is another one. And that hits very low earners.

Yes I know you were saying it's better as it's tapered.

On the single parent example, you mean if it was a hard threshold of 50k? And they were on the edge of earning just over £50k?

That would be take home of around £3200 per month, so yeh losing £140 of CB (for 2 kids) isn't nothing, but probably not worth limiting your career over by going part time. (And if we're talking about not doing hour or so here of overtime rather than part-time- that isn't exactly going to take away from UKs economy in any meanful way).

Also they are likely to either receiving child support for ex, or if not potentially some UC.

Anyway my point that there needs to be a threshold somewhere stands, whether it's tapered or not! Wingeing that you're not entitled to benefits as you earn too much, benefits that are meant to be there for people who are struggling, and that would be a small amount relative to what you earn is petty imo.

usernamealreadytaken · 20/03/2023 10:15

StatisticallyChallenged · 20/03/2023 10:11

They're going to be earning just under 100k each. So they won't be net receivers.

So you think it's okay for a couple earning over £100k EACH to have their childcare paid for them? Unfeckingbelievable.

StatisticallyChallenged · 20/03/2023 10:11

usernamealreadytaken · 20/03/2023 10:01

Very few of us are net contributors. You have to earn over about £40k before you become a net contributor, and deliberately going below that makes you, by default, a net receiver which means other people are paying to support you. Making a choice to do that is morally reprehensible, in the same way as any other minimisation of income in order to receive income related support benefits.

They're going to be earning just under 100k each. So they won't be net receivers.

usernamealreadytaken · 20/03/2023 10:01

StatisticallyChallenged · 20/03/2023 08:39

They'll still be net contributors even after they reduce their hours and qualify for childcare.

Very few of us are net contributors. You have to earn over about £40k before you become a net contributor, and deliberately going below that makes you, by default, a net receiver which means other people are paying to support you. Making a choice to do that is morally reprehensible, in the same way as any other minimisation of income in order to receive income related support benefits.

YukoandHiro · 20/03/2023 09:52

@messybutfun that's inaccurate - you're not entitled to the 30 free hours if either parent earns £100k (not both)

StatisticallyChallenged · 20/03/2023 09:49

MustWeDoThis · 20/03/2023 09:09

Do you mean because anything over 30hrs, you'll obviously have to pay when you could look after them yourselves and still get the same amount of income? Because otherwise you're only working those extra hours to pay a childminder and you're not really losing out?

It's something my husband and I have done. I work compressed full-time hours over 3 days and the other 4 are for kids and studying.

If it's benefit wise- I work for the DWP. UC doesn't work like that. It's not worth the hassle from them.

Genuinely interested though. :)

They're currently over the 100k threshold for the 30 free hours.

By dropping hours (and dropping income under 100k) they'll

  1. need fewer hours overall - from 5 days to probably 2 if op does 3 and her dh 4
  2. the hours they do need will be basically covered by the 30 hours (aware of top ups etc...keeping it simple)
Dibblydoodahdah · 20/03/2023 09:49

@Ilikepinacoladass £60k after tax is £3575, less if you make pension contributions. On the basis that average rent where I live is £1500 per month and a nursery place is £1400 per month, I think single parents on £60k would miss the child benefit.

StatisticallyChallenged · 20/03/2023 09:32

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 09:15

Yes child benefit is tapered over 50k-60k. But essentially if you are earning that much you are not going to miss it and it is petty feeling hard done by missing out on the benefits. And generally quite stupid to limit your career purely to qualify for benefits that are meant to be there for people struggling. If people want to reduce their hours to enjoy spending time with family absolutely do that, but own the decision rather than claiming it's based on saving petty amounts here and there.

I meant that CB is better - because it's gradual so you are never in a position where you earn more and have less because of it. You might not have much more, but you do have more.

If it was a hard limit and you were a single parent earning near the threshold you'd be very careful about not doing the odd hour of overtime. CB for two kids is about £35 a week, I think a single earner just tipping over the threshold might well notice that loss.

Carer's allowance where you lose it as soon as you earn an extra £1 is another one. And that hits very low earners.

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 09:25

MustWeDoThis · 20/03/2023 09:09

Do you mean because anything over 30hrs, you'll obviously have to pay when you could look after them yourselves and still get the same amount of income? Because otherwise you're only working those extra hours to pay a childminder and you're not really losing out?

It's something my husband and I have done. I work compressed full-time hours over 3 days and the other 4 are for kids and studying.

If it's benefit wise- I work for the DWP. UC doesn't work like that. It's not worth the hassle from them.

Genuinely interested though. :)

No, on the amount they are earning they will be making a lot more by working and paying a childminder to look after the children.

They are saying if they reduce their hours / wages they will then qualify for the free hours, where as earning over £100k each means they don't get the free 30 hours.

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 09:19

*Petty amounts relative to their earnings

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 09:15

StatisticallyChallenged · 20/03/2023 08:52

All or nothing thresholds aren't essential, no. While the withdrawal rate is probably too steep IMO, we don't have that situation with child benefit - it's tapered. Likewise for many benefits.

As soon as they introduce hard income thresholds in the system then they create bottlenecks where people are incentivised to remain below the thresholds until they can clear them by a significant margin.

And often the decision to do so is career limiting - and that's why it matters, because these issues are very heavily skewed towards having a negative impact on people with caring responsibilities - the hard threshold for Carer's Allowance is similarly shit. And the reality is that most of the people taking these career limiting decisions are women.

It's poor system design really.

Yes child benefit is tapered over 50k-60k. But essentially if you are earning that much you are not going to miss it and it is petty feeling hard done by missing out on the benefits. And generally quite stupid to limit your career purely to qualify for benefits that are meant to be there for people struggling. If people want to reduce their hours to enjoy spending time with family absolutely do that, but own the decision rather than claiming it's based on saving petty amounts here and there.

Blossomtoes · 20/03/2023 09:10

On a scale accross the UK it must be an insane amount that's moving out.

Given that only 2% of the population earns £100k+ and most of those live in
London, that seems unlikely.

MustWeDoThis · 20/03/2023 09:09

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 13:35

Just working out the free childcare hours and actually DH and I will be muxh better off if we both dropped to 3- 4 day week to deliberately reduce our incomes. Would obviously be nice way to live too! Anyone else doing same? Seems mental but we've looked at it 100 times over and it's true!

Do you mean because anything over 30hrs, you'll obviously have to pay when you could look after them yourselves and still get the same amount of income? Because otherwise you're only working those extra hours to pay a childminder and you're not really losing out?

It's something my husband and I have done. I work compressed full-time hours over 3 days and the other 4 are for kids and studying.

If it's benefit wise- I work for the DWP. UC doesn't work like that. It's not worth the hassle from them.

Genuinely interested though. :)

messybutfun · 20/03/2023 09:05

I am not really going to read through 26 pages of responses but this seems nonsense for several reasons.

  1. This will only come in in two and half years time.
  2. You will both need to earn more than £100, 000 before you lose your entitlement.
  3. This £100,000 is after pension contributions, which will have a new limit of £60,000. So really you can each earn £160,000 before you lose the childcare.
  4. If you both only work 3/4 days a week, you do not need this much childcare.
  5. There will not be enough places to accommodate all the extra children.