Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

DH and I going part time to deliberately reduce wages

890 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 13:35

Just working out the free childcare hours and actually DH and I will be muxh better off if we both dropped to 3- 4 day week to deliberately reduce our incomes. Would obviously be nice way to live too! Anyone else doing same? Seems mental but we've looked at it 100 times over and it's true!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
messybutfun · 20/03/2023 12:34

Dibblydoodahdah · 20/03/2023 09:49

@Ilikepinacoladass £60k after tax is £3575, less if you make pension contributions. On the basis that average rent where I live is £1500 per month and a nursery place is £1400 per month, I think single parents on £60k would miss the child benefit.

It’s not after tax, it’s taxable income (net adjusted income).

StatisticallyChallenged · 20/03/2023 12:31

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 20/03/2023 12:19

I do hope nobody is daft enough to think it's only higher earners who ever make this kind of calculation. As I said upthread, my parents were applying the same principle to tax credit awards 20 years ago.

We run a small business and have part time staff who do exactly this calculation. We have someone being promoted and simultaneously asking to reduce hours slightly to stay under a threshold.

These are systematic issues. Blaming individuals doesn't solve anything (unless you're blaming politicians of course!)

StatisticallyChallenged · 20/03/2023 12:27

Part of the reason the system is broken is because of these perverse disincentives to earn more.

I don't think you can reasonably expect people to work more hours in order to be worse off. Most humans are not that altruistic that they will choose to work an extra day every week in order to have less.

messybutfun · 20/03/2023 12:21

YukoandHiro · 20/03/2023 09:52

@messybutfun that's inaccurate - you're not entitled to the 30 free hours if either parent earns £100k (not both)

This was in response to OP saying they both were over the threshold and both would have to work less - if only one of them is above, then the other doesn’t need to reduce their hours.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 20/03/2023 12:19

I do hope nobody is daft enough to think it's only higher earners who ever make this kind of calculation. As I said upthread, my parents were applying the same principle to tax credit awards 20 years ago.

ScruffyGiraffes · 20/03/2023 12:18

usernamealreadytaken · 20/03/2023 12:12

I'm absolutely aghast at the sheer number of people who think it's okay and even right and proper for one of the wealthiest earning families which falls in the 1% of top earners in the UK (apparently two earners on over £100k each) to minimise their income so they can claim free stuff from the government. I though we were against rich people dodging taxes, or is that only if they are overt Conservative voters? Bloody unreal.

They're not "claiming free stuff". They are using the services that they fund for themselves and everyone else.

usernamealreadytaken · 20/03/2023 12:17

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 14:28

This is exactly our situation

In the current tax set up We will have a MUCH nicer family life and general existence by both working and earning less

This is exactly why we will never have higher funded public services, because the ultra high earners and wealthiest in society don't want to pay for them, want more free stuff and then complain that services aren't good enough. You're right, the system is broken but that doesn't mean you have to use it to your advantage.

ScruffyGiraffes · 20/03/2023 12:15

Blossomtoes · 20/03/2023 09:10

On a scale accross the UK it must be an insane amount that's moving out.

Given that only 2% of the population earns £100k+ and most of those live in
London, that seems unlikely.

You might want to consider what proportion of the total tax take those people are funding for everyone else.

Talk about biting the hand that feeds you.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 20/03/2023 12:13

You've phrased that better than me @StatisticallyChallenged

I just don't get some of the responses to this. What we know and presumably all agree on is that bottlenecks exist across a wide income spectrum, some people will feel their circumstances are better if they take action to stay under them and that because of inflation and fiscal drag the number of people for whom this is a relevant decision will increase. These things are all completely uncontroversial and not affected by anyone's feelings. You don't have to be concerned about any of them to understand that.

I'm not even saying that people have to agree this is a problem. One take is that it's better in the long run if more people increase pension contributions, so incentives to do that are a good thing. That's not my view but it would at least show that some thought had gone into it. But airy dismissal of the issue because you don't have any sympathy with some of the people concerned is plain silly.

usernamealreadytaken · 20/03/2023 12:12

I'm absolutely aghast at the sheer number of people who think it's okay and even right and proper for one of the wealthiest earning families which falls in the 1% of top earners in the UK (apparently two earners on over £100k each) to minimise their income so they can claim free stuff from the government. I though we were against rich people dodging taxes, or is that only if they are overt Conservative voters? Bloody unreal.

ScruffyGiraffes · 20/03/2023 12:12

A system based on household income would be impossible to administer.

That's funny. I wonder how France, Denmark and a large number of other developed countries have managed the impossible. Perhaps we should ask them.

ScruffyGiraffes · 20/03/2023 12:09

Obviously don't disagree that the govt should help out single parents at the lower end of the pay spectrum. But if you're earning enough to care for yourself and your kids, then living on your own without sharing the house is a lifestyle choice imo!

What? I should just move a random person into my two traumatised, autistic children's come to save money? I haven't asked for any "support" from the Government. Just for them to stop penalising me by taxing me MORE than other households with the same income.

usernamealreadytaken · 20/03/2023 12:03

Mycatsgoldtooth · 20/03/2023 11:16

@usernamealreadytaken how much should a woman’s husband be allowed to earn before she forgoes her pension contributions? 100k is ok with you. What happens to her if he leaves her when it comes to pension time, or should she have been working instead of being a sahm in your opinion?

Wrong end of the stick there @Mycatsgoldtooth. I think it's wrong for a SAHP to have their NI contributions met if THEY are earning £100k. Any SAHP with no earnings should have their min conts met so they retain state pension entitlement. Nobody should have their conts met (or receive CB, or UC, or free childcare) if THEY are earning £100k. HTH.

usernamealreadytaken · 20/03/2023 12:01

Jonei · 20/03/2023 11:34

Crazy isn't it. The outrage.

You think NI credit of a few hundred pounds, in order for a (usually mother) parent to be entitled to full state pension on retirement is equivalent to full time free childcare for someone on £100k who will have a massive pension regardless? No wonder the country's finances are on its knees.

Dibblydoodahdah · 20/03/2023 11:53

@Jonei it certainly is and none of them ever come back to confirm what they are paying in!

Jonei · 20/03/2023 11:34

Dibblydoodahdah · 20/03/2023 11:33

@usernamealreadytaken which shows how ridiculous you are. You are happy for people not putting anything into the system to still get a credit and be at home full time with their children but not for people who are already putting in far more than they take out to spend a little bit more time with their children and pay a little bit less.

How much are you putting in by the way?

Crazy isn't it. The outrage.

Jonei · 20/03/2023 11:33

Well if they drop their hours they won't be able to afford it will they. Arguably more people need to work more hours and pay into the system which benefits everyone. But they don't. With this in mind it's fine for the op should to drop her hours so she can spend time with her children to whom she has more of a moral obligation than anyone else. That's how the system is geared up. Until there's a radical overhaul for everyone, then I would definitely do this.

Dibblydoodahdah · 20/03/2023 11:33

@usernamealreadytaken which shows how ridiculous you are. You are happy for people not putting anything into the system to still get a credit and be at home full time with their children but not for people who are already putting in far more than they take out to spend a little bit more time with their children and pay a little bit less.

How much are you putting in by the way?

StatisticallyChallenged · 20/03/2023 11:29

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 20/03/2023 10:56

The fact that some people will always be on the border of thresholds and the fact that our system includes a number of bottlenecks are two different points. You don't address the second by pointing out the inevitability of the first.

On the subject of complaints, whining etc, how exactly would you like people to make the point that these disincentives exist, that fiscal drag combined with inflation is likely to increase the numbers potentially into both the 100k and 50-60k bottleneck territory and that this is going to have some impact? It sounds like your main issue is that you dispute how common it's going to be. But how can people who are more concerned about this than you are make that case without being accused of whining? Because the poster you replied to wasn't doing that.

It's fine if you think it's a risk that's being overexaggerated, although speaking as someone whose household are going to be taking action to ensure continued receipt of child benefit quite soon I feel less certain than you do, but we do actually need to have a way to discuss this. And why the fuck shouldn't people say that they think our tax system is awful? Bottlenecks and perverse incentives are a bad thing, and we do have them scattered throughout the income levels, particularly where children are involved. They're a feature of UC claimants just as much as they are of high earners. What's the problem with people complaining about bad policy?

Exactly. Different people will respond in different ways and at differently pinch points. If you're in a professional career where you know another promotion which will negate the loss of CB (for example) is not far away then you might decide to suck it up. If you're deciding whether to work 38 hours or 40 in a job with limited prospects then you might not.

I'm definitely not whining either. I'm not impacted by the childcare issue as I'm in Scotland so why would I be whining!

But if you were starting from first principles and designing a tax/benefit/social care/healthcare funding system then it would be blindingly obvious not to create these cliff edges. It would also seem obvious that you'd want to avoid having income bands where your effective marginal rate of tax is higher than the band above. It doesn't make sense to me to go from (including NI) 33% to 54% then down to 44% then up to 65% then back to 47%.

I'd personally rather things like CB, childcare, Carer's allowance etc were not income based at all and that personal allowance was not withdrawn, but instead that headline tax rates were a little higher to compensate. I suspect once the resulting reduction in admin costs was taken in to consideration it probably wouldn't even be that significant. But I think it would reduce some of the areas where working harder is effectively discouraged

kirinm · 20/03/2023 11:26

High rate tax payers - of which I am one - contribute more because they earn more and can afford to.

Morally the right thing to do is pay for your own childcare since you can afford it and the nursery need non funded kids to run.

kirinm · 20/03/2023 11:24

From a moral point of view, it's really shitty. It is the nurseries losing out.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 20/03/2023 11:16

@usernamealreadytaken how much should a woman’s husband be allowed to earn before she forgoes her pension contributions? 100k is ok with you. What happens to her if he leaves her when it comes to pension time, or should she have been working instead of being a sahm in your opinion?

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 20/03/2023 11:09

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 11:00

Complain about bad policy yes, but don't use it as an excuse or a blame it as a reason as to why you're working less / going part time, when actually you are benefitting from being able to spend more time with your kids.. and it's a privilege to be able to do so.

This is generalising again and not even true in some cases. You don't get to decide what counts as beneficial in someone's circumstances and what doesn't, and people have no obligation to couch their discussion of their choices in language and paradigms that you've chosen. Especially as there's no guarantee they'll be spending more time with their kids by making that choice. They may simply not be choosing to spend less time, so what you're saying here doesn't even necessarily apply.

Jonei · 20/03/2023 11:07

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 11:00

Complain about bad policy yes, but don't use it as an excuse or a blame it as a reason as to why you're working less / going part time, when actually you are benefitting from being able to spend more time with your kids.. and it's a privilege to be able to do so.

It is a reason why though. Even if it is nice to spend more time with the children.

usernamealreadytaken · 20/03/2023 11:06

Dibblydoodahdah · 20/03/2023 10:27

@usernamealreadytaken is it morally reprehensible to have your NI credit paid whilst being a SAHM parent?

Only if you're earning £100k while being a SAHP🙄