Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ofsted needs to be abolished - further details

256 replies

MrsMurphyIWish · 18/03/2023 07:53

Have started a new thread as think it’s important this doesn’t just get lost on my previous thread

The Ofsted report for the school where the head teacher died has been published …

They are toxic and need reform immediately.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4765105-ofsted-needs-to-be-abolished-trigger-warning?page=1

Ofsted needs to be abolished - further details
OP posts:
Icedlatteplease · 22/03/2023 11:36

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 11:19

Scrapping the gradings would totally have changed this school’s outcome. It wouldn’t have been branded an inadequate school. That label is a key point. The impact of it is devastating to a school.

The argument that this report is fine or that the grading is fine implies that it does its job.

An inadequate rating, however, actually harms a school. It struggles to get pupils (affecting funding). It struggles to get staff (affecting quality of education). It is counterproductive.

The DfE is arguing that grades need to be kept ‘for parents’. Yet many parents say they ignore the rating.

And if you think it helps you decide between two schools - if you had to make a decision tonight on school applications would you pick this Inadequate school who in all likelihood has fixed its paperwork and duty rota since September, or the Outstanding school which hasn’t been inspected in a decade and could have unfixed paperwork issues because no one has looked?

No child should be at a school that can't safeguard adequately.

As a teacher I do not want to teach at a school that cannot adequately safeguard its children. If I report a safeguarding concerns I want to know it will be dealt with appropriately.

If safeguarding is inadequate, a school is completely inadequate

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 11:19

Treaclehair · 22/03/2023 10:39

But like what, then? Yes, sure, we can scrap the deep dives and the gradings and other things, but this wouldn’t have changed this schools outcome anyway.

Scrapping the gradings would totally have changed this school’s outcome. It wouldn’t have been branded an inadequate school. That label is a key point. The impact of it is devastating to a school.

The argument that this report is fine or that the grading is fine implies that it does its job.

An inadequate rating, however, actually harms a school. It struggles to get pupils (affecting funding). It struggles to get staff (affecting quality of education). It is counterproductive.

The DfE is arguing that grades need to be kept ‘for parents’. Yet many parents say they ignore the rating.

And if you think it helps you decide between two schools - if you had to make a decision tonight on school applications would you pick this Inadequate school who in all likelihood has fixed its paperwork and duty rota since September, or the Outstanding school which hasn’t been inspected in a decade and could have unfixed paperwork issues because no one has looked?

Cassiehopes · 22/03/2023 11:17

Ummm… am I missing something? I can’t see anything even close to a problem with this?

thevery · 22/03/2023 11:08

But the one thing ofsted should be doing is monitoring Safeguarding and no school should fail on that.

But the issue is, they aren't monitoring it! There are schools I know of who have not been inspected for 14 years! So ofsted are failing in their own safeguarding!

Treaclehair · 22/03/2023 10:39

But like what, then? Yes, sure, we can scrap the deep dives and the gradings and other things, but this wouldn’t have changed this schools outcome anyway.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/03/2023 10:36

A failure on Safeguarding - nobody should be arguing that that is ok

In fairness nobody is; the position of most seems to be that of course schools have to be inspected "but not like this", which up to a point I agree with

That said, with the determination to weaponise the HT's tragic death and the seizing on smaller points to be offended it's hard not to wonder if any replacement system would be welcomed either

Icedlatteplease · 22/03/2023 10:11

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 20/03/2023 19:13

There's a new Ofsted framework of "deep dives" which many, many primary teachers say is not fit for purpose.

You effectively have to have a "lead" for each NC subject. If you are a small primary, even single form entry, that cam mean teachers leading multiple subjects, and the burden becomes quite high very quickly. It's a lot of pressure on classroom teachers, and people above ECT level don't really get to opt out in smaller schools.

I think it's something that needs looking at urgently.

But yes things like this are the stuff that does need reform.

But to be fair if I saw anything like this in a report I wouldn’t think much of it anyway

Treaclehair · 22/03/2023 10:10

I agree with you @Icedlatteplease . It’s all fine until it isn’t fine, and we can’t say it isn’t fine as it’s too stressful for those concerned - really not a good argument.

Yellowdays · 22/03/2023 10:09

@Postapocalypticcowgirl Yes, I can see that would be crazy. Cuts then more cuts, especially in smaller schools.

Icedlatteplease · 22/03/2023 10:08

Why should a school that can't safeguard its pupils not be graded anything other than inadequate?

It is inadequate.

Why should we not label a school inadequate if it is inadequate.

But yes a do agree ofsted should be visiting far more frequently. I actually think every school should be ofstedded 12-18 months after a change of head.

I think the report has done a good job at highlighting the schools strengths and personally I haven't found it at all muddled. Sometimes I don't think a report has to be highly detailed to do what it needs to do. In fact if I walked into the school today I'd have a pretty good idea of what I'd find. A delightful school were the kids are happy and generally well educated.

They might however have accidentally employed an Ian Huntly or forgotten to put in that safeguarding query or have a couple of SEN kids that they have no clue what to do with....

saraclara · 22/03/2023 09:53

XelaM · 22/03/2023 09:35

But ANY audit is stressful. I'm in a different regulated profession and have been audited by our regular and it's always very stressful. I don't see how impromptu audits can be stress-free

No-one is suggesting that a school inspection can or should be stress free.

Most of my friend are in professions that require audits or outside independent competency tests. But they are appalled by my accounts of what an OFSTED is like, and don't consider their own inspections/audits to be at all comparable. Stressful, yes, but they're predictable and the goalposts don't change every five minutes. Nor are their results and personal failings announced to the world and specifically to all their clients and colleagues.

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 09:51

This report is everything an ofsted report should be.

No, it’s not. There is no reason for it to have a single grade on it, It’s light on detail and very muddled. It doesn’t describe steps needed to be taken. Safeguarding is lumped in with other stuff.

And this report was issued after 13 years of no inspections. If you care about safeguarding, that’s pretty concerning.

If you think this report is everything an Ofsted report should be, you have pretty low expectations. It’s a pile of shit.

Icedlatteplease · 22/03/2023 09:44

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 09:32

🤦‍♀️

Do you think it appropriate that inspections are conducted in such a manner that they are actively detrimental to the mental health of the workforce and distort educational practices in entirely unhelpful ways?

That’s what this is about. Not about whether schools should be inspected or whether safeguarding is important.

Then this report really shouldn't be a rallying cry. Nor should this woman's death.

This report is everything an ofsted report should be. This report still needs to be published. The failures in this school still need to be bought to light.

To put it bluntly Ofsted should not be afraid to publish reports detailing failures in safeguarding in case heads kill themselves.

There is the political point regarding the rest of what ofsted does.

But safeguarding should never be comprised to make political point.

XelaM · 22/03/2023 09:35

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 09:32

🤦‍♀️

Do you think it appropriate that inspections are conducted in such a manner that they are actively detrimental to the mental health of the workforce and distort educational practices in entirely unhelpful ways?

That’s what this is about. Not about whether schools should be inspected or whether safeguarding is important.

But ANY audit is stressful. I'm in a different regulated profession and have been audited by our regular and it's always very stressful. I don't see how impromptu audits can be stress-free

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 09:32

🤦‍♀️

Do you think it appropriate that inspections are conducted in such a manner that they are actively detrimental to the mental health of the workforce and distort educational practices in entirely unhelpful ways?

That’s what this is about. Not about whether schools should be inspected or whether safeguarding is important.

Icedlatteplease · 22/03/2023 09:30

XelaM · 22/03/2023 09:17

I completely agree and I find it scary that this Headteacher who refused an inspection could start a trend of schools having no accountability.

I totally agree.

There is no way on earth I'd want my child attending a school that wouldn't let ofsted in at all.

Icedlatteplease · 22/03/2023 09:28

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 09:17

No one is arguing that schools shouldn’t be inspected for safeguarding and if you agree that Ofsted should be reformed then you agree with what everyone is saying about it.

Not about this report I don't.

I think this report sounds fairly balanced.

It sounds like a beautiful school until something goes wrong. Then it sounds like an absolute nightmare.

It's absolutely right that the ofsted report should be reporting on this.

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 09:20

No one is arguing that schools should have no accountability. That people keep bringing up this straw man is just bizarre.

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 09:19

Don’t be daft.

XelaM · 22/03/2023 09:17

Icedlatteplease · 22/03/2023 09:14

I'm trying to understand the outcry, but I just don't get it.

You can argue the rest of it being unnecessary (deep dives etc) but Safeguarding is basic.

The school failed on Safeguarding. I can read a report and go well ofsted are making a political point if they are prattling on about whatever, but Safeguarding? A failure on Safeguarding.

Nobody should be arguing that that is ok.

Whilst it is tragic the head took her life, I'm not sure we should be surprised that that is included on the report. It factually happened.

I know a school that has failed on Safeguarding. In fact I should imagine we as a family might have been one of the reasons for the failure. Yes in our case actually we weren't put at risk by the Safeguarding failure but that wasn't any thanks to the Safeguarding paperwork of the school and frankly if the Safeguarding was dependent on the school we would have been stuffed. It could well have been recorded the same as the ofsted report here. Thankfully the head has been removed thanks to a ofsted inspection. Damn good thing too as she had completely ruined the school.

Yes ofsted needs reform. What has happened is tragic and awful for the family of the woman. But the one thing ofsted should be doing is monitoring Safeguarding and no school should fail on that.

I completely agree and I find it scary that this Headteacher who refused an inspection could start a trend of schools having no accountability.

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 09:17

No one is arguing that schools shouldn’t be inspected for safeguarding and if you agree that Ofsted should be reformed then you agree with what everyone is saying about it.

Icedlatteplease · 22/03/2023 09:14

I'm trying to understand the outcry, but I just don't get it.

You can argue the rest of it being unnecessary (deep dives etc) but Safeguarding is basic.

The school failed on Safeguarding. I can read a report and go well ofsted are making a political point if they are prattling on about whatever, but Safeguarding? A failure on Safeguarding.

Nobody should be arguing that that is ok.

Whilst it is tragic the head took her life, I'm not sure we should be surprised that that is included on the report. It factually happened.

I know a school that has failed on Safeguarding. In fact I should imagine we as a family might have been one of the reasons for the failure. Yes in our case actually we weren't put at risk by the Safeguarding failure but that wasn't any thanks to the Safeguarding paperwork of the school and frankly if the Safeguarding was dependent on the school we would have been stuffed. It could well have been recorded the same as the ofsted report here. Thankfully the head has been removed thanks to a ofsted inspection. Damn good thing too as she had completely ruined the school.

Yes ofsted needs reform. What has happened is tragic and awful for the family of the woman. But the one thing ofsted should be doing is monitoring Safeguarding and no school should fail on that.

thevery · 22/03/2023 08:25

Yes and many have questioned the fairness of serving heads/slt being complicit and having insider knowledge of what is required.

JaneSelf · 22/03/2023 07:46

Thanks for the clarification. OIs sound like a good "realistic" perspective but stil requires adequate training.

thevery · 22/03/2023 06:15

JaneSelf · 22/03/2023 00:21

Successful, constructive auditing is a real skill.

I'm not sure I agree that Alan Derry the Lead Inspector has extensive experience according to his LinkedIn profile.
https://www.linkedin.com/in/alan-derry-a78299168

The other two inspectors named are not even listed on here, updated March 2023, are they trainees?
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/ofsted-pen-portraits-of-her-majestys-inspectors-hmis/ofsted-hmi-pen-portraits

That list only has HMIs on who are employed Ofsted and work for them full time.

The other two inspectors in this case are OIs. This means they are often serving SLT/heads elsewhere who do some work for Ofsted. Lots of HTs do it to get an insight into what is required to help their own schools.

Someone on Twitter made the point that if all of these OIs stopped doing it the system would collapse.