Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ofsted needs to be abolished - further details

256 replies

MrsMurphyIWish · 18/03/2023 07:53

Have started a new thread as think it’s important this doesn’t just get lost on my previous thread

The Ofsted report for the school where the head teacher died has been published …

They are toxic and need reform immediately.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4765105-ofsted-needs-to-be-abolished-trigger-warning?page=1

Ofsted needs to be abolished - further details
OP posts:
Icedlatteplease · 22/03/2023 17:44

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 17:39

That the grades are useless is certainly an argument for losing them.

That they can have a devastating impact on a school is another.

That headteachers are expressing intolerable stress levels caused by the grading system is another.

That the grades are subjective bobbins is another.

That they correlate with local deprivation levels is another.

That they have a huge impact on house prices even when years out of date is another.

That chasing Ofsted grades takes time away from actually improving education is another.

But none of that was relevant to Caversham.

Caversham didn't fail for educational reasons.

It failed for safeguarding. Basic safeguarding was inadequate.

Ofsted shouldn't be preventing from labelling inadequate safeguarding as inadequate because a head is upset or stressed.

Adequate safeguarding is as important in deprived areas as privileged areas.

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 17:39

That the grades are useless is certainly an argument for losing them.

That they can have a devastating impact on a school is another.

That headteachers are expressing intolerable stress levels caused by the grading system is another.

That the grades are subjective bobbins is another.

That they correlate with local deprivation levels is another.

That they have a huge impact on house prices even when years out of date is another.

That chasing Ofsted grades takes time away from actually improving education is another.

Icedlatteplease · 22/03/2023 17:33

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 17:20

And yet that grade isn’t a good description of the school. It has probably fixed its paperwork and duty rota.

Is that grade helpful to a parent looking at a school for September for their child? I wouldn’t have thought so.

If you hear a school is outstanding and your first question is ‘how long ago?’ then that grade is pointless.

If an Ofsted grade puts you off applying for a school without hesitation because it means you think the school will be either jumping through stupid hoops to maintain its rating, or to get out of a category, then that’s a problem with the rating system.

It isnt an argument for removing the grading though

It's an argument for more thorough frequent grading

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 17:21

Not having a grade isn’t going to make much difference assuming we use words to communicate.

Lots of headteachers seem to disagree with you, from listening to discussions around this.

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 17:20

And yet that grade isn’t a good description of the school. It has probably fixed its paperwork and duty rota.

Is that grade helpful to a parent looking at a school for September for their child? I wouldn’t have thought so.

If you hear a school is outstanding and your first question is ‘how long ago?’ then that grade is pointless.

If an Ofsted grade puts you off applying for a school without hesitation because it means you think the school will be either jumping through stupid hoops to maintain its rating, or to get out of a category, then that’s a problem with the rating system.

Treaclehair · 22/03/2023 17:17

It doesn’t matter if there isn’t a grade.

They can say safeguarding is inadequate, or they can say safeguarding doesn’t meet the necessary standards, or they can say safeguarding is poor. The meaning is pretty much the same even if the wording changes.

Not having a grade isn’t going to make much difference assuming we use words to communicate.

Icedlatteplease · 22/03/2023 17:12

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 17:02

You’ve basically said you can’t trust the grade, that more info is needed.

Nobody has said that, certainly not in relation to the Caversham report.

Safeguarding concerns absolutely should be graded as inadequate.

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 17:02

You’ve basically said you can’t trust the grade, that more info is needed.

Icedlatteplease · 22/03/2023 16:50

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 16:49

What you’re acknowledging is that the grade can’t actually tell you very much on its own, you need more info and up-to-date experience to distinguish between schools.

Given how damaging the grading system is, there’s therefore no reason to keep it.

I'm not sure anyone is saying that. It's a bit of a stretch in terms of interpretation to try and support your own pov.

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 16:49

What you’re acknowledging is that the grade can’t actually tell you very much on its own, you need more info and up-to-date experience to distinguish between schools.

Given how damaging the grading system is, there’s therefore no reason to keep it.

fairydust11 · 22/03/2023 15:58

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 15:28

In my opinion grades and accountability are important.

Why is the grade important?

As a parent, as well as a teacher I believe a report with a grade (in addition to visiting the schools with my children & speaking to current parents) - helps to aid the decision process when choosing where to apply…

Also if applying for a teaching role, I want to know what are (if any) the issues in the school and if the leadership is strong... I want to know what grade a school is if I am considering applying to that school…

To me a grade helps with the overall picture of a school.

Icedlatteplease · 22/03/2023 15:55

jcyclops · 22/03/2023 15:48

I am far from being anti-Ofsted or anti-inspection, but something in Private Eye recently worried me, and should worry others.

Inspections are being carried out by current senior employees of multi-academy trusts (MATs) including HTs and directors. If they rate the school being inspected as inadequate then the school can be forced to be taken over by a MAT and this can be the MAT for which the inspector works! This is an obvious conflict of interest and should never happen.

There is also the case of an academy that received a "good" rating, to which the academy's Chief Executive complained, and Ofsted agreed to re-inspect and the rating was upgraded to "outstanding". You might think this quick re-inspection of a "good" school is highly unusual, but perhaps not considering the academy's Chief Executive also sits on the board of Ofsted!

Yes that is worrying. But I don't think anyone us suggesting that's what is happening at Caversham.

jcyclops · 22/03/2023 15:48

I am far from being anti-Ofsted or anti-inspection, but something in Private Eye recently worried me, and should worry others.

Inspections are being carried out by current senior employees of multi-academy trusts (MATs) including HTs and directors. If they rate the school being inspected as inadequate then the school can be forced to be taken over by a MAT and this can be the MAT for which the inspector works! This is an obvious conflict of interest and should never happen.

There is also the case of an academy that received a "good" rating, to which the academy's Chief Executive complained, and Ofsted agreed to re-inspect and the rating was upgraded to "outstanding". You might think this quick re-inspection of a "good" school is highly unusual, but perhaps not considering the academy's Chief Executive also sits on the board of Ofsted!

Icedlatteplease · 22/03/2023 15:37

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 15:28

In my opinion grades and accountability are important.

Why is the grade important?

Because if something is inadequate, you should be able to say its inadequate

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 15:28

In my opinion grades and accountability are important.

Why is the grade important?

fairydust11 · 22/03/2023 15:23

Icedlatteplease · 22/03/2023 09:44

Then this report really shouldn't be a rallying cry. Nor should this woman's death.

This report is everything an ofsted report should be. This report still needs to be published. The failures in this school still need to be bought to light.

To put it bluntly Ofsted should not be afraid to publish reports detailing failures in safeguarding in case heads kill themselves.

There is the political point regarding the rest of what ofsted does.

But safeguarding should never be comprised to make political point.

I completely agree.

What has happened is horrendous, but if the school is failing on safeguarding and is deemed inadequate then Ofsted needs to report it as such.

I have been teaching for many years and there is no way I would want to be a headteacher - the stress and accountability is immense.

At the end of the day the school was graded inadequate. In my opinion grades and accountability are important.

Being graded inadequate has happened to other schools and other headteachers over the years who know that once you accept the role of headteacher, you are where the buck stops.
In similar situations most headteachers have either resigned or stayed and fought hard to turn the school around and get a better grading.

It’s just so very sad it turned out like this, and such a shame that Ruth Perry felt was no other option than the route she took. 💐

Icedlatteplease · 22/03/2023 14:45

MrsMurphyIWish · 22/03/2023 14:02

Inspections are unfair.

I have worked at my school for 6 years now and I have witnessed several huge safeguarding issues that eventually were dealt with but would have resulted in an inadequate judgement. As it happens, my school is outstanding and hasn’t had an inspection for nearly 14 years.

This is why Ofsted needs reform. Inspectors will come into my school and see it as picture perfect but it is far from it.

I'm wondering what happened with the major safeguarding failures? Did anyone report them?

Icedlatteplease · 22/03/2023 14:03

queenofthewild · 22/03/2023 12:36

The full breakdown of the safeguarding failures is on the school website along with a plan to resolve things.

All the failures have been rectified already, and were indeed rectified some time ago, but the inadequate rating will remain in place for years.

Absolutely safeguarding is paramount and parents have a right to ensure safeguarding is in place at their child's school. However, what one ofsted inspector considers to be good safeguarding isn't always what another inspector considers good practice.

What really needs to change with inspections is the way inspectors question school staff about safeguarding. Inspectors should ask staff how they would handle a real life incident giving the staff member an example situation and asking them what steps they would take.

Instead, often they ask much more theoretical questions and jargon that some part time staff simply don't understand despite having done the training.

Asking a playground assistant what they know about the Prevent strategy, you'll get a very different answer than if you give a real life example of a child who has been exposed to radicalisation and what steps you would take to record this and alert the safeguarding lead.

The school local to me also listed their "failures" in a letter to parents after being rated inadequate.

What they don't publish is they waited 8 months to make a major safeguarding report to social services and had no record that the child was already under SS despite having attended multiple meetings with SS and made regular "safeguarding checks" on the child.

It's absolutely right that OFSTED don't publish precise failings. But don't necessarily take schools explanations at face value either.

MrsMurphyIWish · 22/03/2023 14:02

Inspections are unfair.

I have worked at my school for 6 years now and I have witnessed several huge safeguarding issues that eventually were dealt with but would have resulted in an inadequate judgement. As it happens, my school is outstanding and hasn’t had an inspection for nearly 14 years.

This is why Ofsted needs reform. Inspectors will come into my school and see it as picture perfect but it is far from it.

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 13:56

For the zillionth time, no one is arguing for no inspection.

People are, however, arguing for no grade.

Icedlatteplease · 22/03/2023 13:51

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 13:33

As a teacher I do not want to teach at a school that cannot adequately safeguard its children. If I report a safeguarding concerns I want to know it will be dealt with appropriately.

Of course. That goes without saying.

How can you tell the inadequate rated 6 months ago school isn’t safe now? How can you tell that the outstanding from 10 years ago school is safe?

And the answer is that you can’t. So what is the point of the grades?

It's a bit like saying DBS is only up to date at the time when you apply for so why have DBS?

But actually it isn't necessarily. Reporting safeguarding failures to ofsted can trigger a review. It's also an argument for more frequently grading and inspection not none

noblegiraffe · 22/03/2023 13:33

As a teacher I do not want to teach at a school that cannot adequately safeguard its children. If I report a safeguarding concerns I want to know it will be dealt with appropriately.

Of course. That goes without saying.

How can you tell the inadequate rated 6 months ago school isn’t safe now? How can you tell that the outstanding from 10 years ago school is safe?

And the answer is that you can’t. So what is the point of the grades?

saraclara · 22/03/2023 13:19

Treaclehair · 22/03/2023 12:12

But giraffe, they are still going to say safeguarding requirements aren’t being met. I really don’t think there is a way of saying this softly.

No-one's saying that the safeguardinng issue shouldn't have been dealt with firmly and straightforwardly, and that it has to be dealt with softly.

. But it wasn't that single fault that is likely to have tipped the head over the edge. It's the fact that her entire school was damned by coming under that single word. None of that good stuff in the report (so pretty much everything else) was going to matter. No-one was going to see anything other than 'inadequate'.

Again, I think safeguarding checks should happen annually, and not be left to infrequent OFSTED inspections. Let safeguarding stand alone BECAUSE of its importance, and the inspection be about teaching and learning.

queenofthewild · 22/03/2023 12:36

The full breakdown of the safeguarding failures is on the school website along with a plan to resolve things.

All the failures have been rectified already, and were indeed rectified some time ago, but the inadequate rating will remain in place for years.

Absolutely safeguarding is paramount and parents have a right to ensure safeguarding is in place at their child's school. However, what one ofsted inspector considers to be good safeguarding isn't always what another inspector considers good practice.

What really needs to change with inspections is the way inspectors question school staff about safeguarding. Inspectors should ask staff how they would handle a real life incident giving the staff member an example situation and asking them what steps they would take.

Instead, often they ask much more theoretical questions and jargon that some part time staff simply don't understand despite having done the training.

Asking a playground assistant what they know about the Prevent strategy, you'll get a very different answer than if you give a real life example of a child who has been exposed to radicalisation and what steps you would take to record this and alert the safeguarding lead.

Treaclehair · 22/03/2023 12:12

But giraffe, they are still going to say safeguarding requirements aren’t being met. I really don’t think there is a way of saying this softly.