Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU: I am so annoyed by my kids' unwarranted detention?

216 replies

SueDomym · 17/03/2023 22:26

Hi people, I hope this message finds you well.
I have moved for one new year to rural France and I are taking one year of school here. They are 11+12yr old boys who have not hit puberty in any way yet. One still sleeps with a giant teddy... to say they are lovely kids - context I think, is relevant here.
My eldest was given detention on the first week of school for the 'destruction of property'. Apparently, someone had ripped some sellotape around a broken ping-pong table. So DS was given a detention. I asked my son, but he said he had done nothing. I spoke with the principal and he said that there was at least one person who had seen him doing this, a student. It was a detention and there was no more talking about it. I accepted but explained that I felt it was unfair in my son's first week of school in a place where he doesn't speak the language. I also said I believed my son.
5 months later I innocently asked two kids at the school if they knew what happened - they both told me it was the boy who did rip the selotape who blamed my kid to not get into trouble and that the principal had punished him once he found out. I had not been told this and my son was not apologised to which I felt would have been fair.

Fast forward to 2 days ago, a note was sent home with a stamped signature from the school principal. It said: Your sons were climbing a school fence and will receive one hour's detention.
So, I asked my boys about it and they said that during the long 1.5-hour break they were hanging off a grill-fence. A 'surveillante' was watching them, she said nothing and walked away.
The day after that I get an official letter with the artices of the law this punishment was under: one hour's detention for climbing on the school fence. And that the youngest son can remember to be better behaved towards his community in future. I ask my boys again, politely to see ifthey will tell the truth. They know I better with the truth than not, getting caught out for lying is worse in my opinion. Also they other boy who was with them also has his parents writing back saying they did no harm to any school equipment and would have got down had they simply been asked.
I believe my boys and want to know how to contest this decision when the boys had not been given a verbal warning first.
So, I call the school and I happen to get one of the people who watched the boys climb the wall. I asked why they didn't simply ask them to get down. She replied that there were two adults watching them. I asked if the other person had asked the boys to get down, and she replied "well they should just know". Basically, I argued with her asking why they couldn't have spoken to the boys.

She asked if I wanted to speak to her boss and I said no. I said I would like to speak to a parent-teacher representative. She told me she couldn't give out their phone numbers. She also told me if I wasn't happy with the school to take them out of this one. She finished with "I wish you a very good day" and I replied " I don't believe you.". It felt like a nasty argument.

I had some time this morning so I looked up the school rules: they have to start with a verbal warning. Detention is once parents have been spoken with.

I also spoke to two other people about this and they said that this isn't worth fighting because this is the way it is and I will not get them to back down.

I spoke with an official mediator and she said not to bother with this. If I kick up a fuss over this small punishment I will bring down the whole establishment on the boys heads - my complaints will make them suffer. Can you imagine?

Am I unreasonable in thinking that this is unfair behaviour by the school? It's a little, rural school. Everyone knows each other. I have a mobile phone. They could easily speak with me.
AIBU for expecting better communication first for such a minor offence?

Or am I just being unrealistic about the world today? (Be kind if you think so - but honest!).

I just wish I had a way of feeling less alone. I showed the letter from the school to 2 friends and they both said they have never seen a letter with a paragraph of law articles on it explaining how this detention was official. I mean.. really.

I wrote to their class teacher and the HR manager - I had no reply today.

Thanks for listening if you got this far.

Personal detail redacted by MNHQ

OP posts:
JMSA · 18/03/2023 02:46

I wish Britain would go down this route! I work in a high school and it's unbelievable what goes on.

snitzelvoncrumb · 18/03/2023 02:43

It does sound a bit like they aren’t the principal’s favourites. There is no point arguing about the rules with the principal. I would look at how good you think the school is in general (not counting these incidents) and how much longer they will be there, and consider moving them. If they are moving to a new senior school soon I wouldn’t bother, but if they are already in the school they stay in until they complete high school I would think about the possibility of changing schools. You don’t want them to miss any opportunities due to not being selected in teams etc. and this sort of thing does happen. If the school has been great outside these incidents, I would just let it go.

ZestFest · 18/03/2023 02:18

I think it was heavy-handed of the school, but pick your battles. They shouldn't have been doing it and there's a consequence. Hold them accountable and move on.

Cassiehopes · 18/03/2023 01:57

I’m a teacher abroad (not France) and honestly, things are just done differently than in the UK in most countries! More traditional strictness, respect for teachers and the school (by parents and children), punishments for bad behaviour which parents support and which lead to children with excellent behaviour. My country is very strict with punishments but as a result the children are exceptionally well behaved. I think strictness can have positive effects on a child - never thought this when I lived in the UK but now I have seen what it’s like here, I sort of admire it. It works, anyway.

Eyerollcentral · 18/03/2023 01:52

Kamia · 18/03/2023 01:08

You are not being unreasonable. They seem quite punitive. The fact they just blamed your child for something and did not try and understand what had happened. It may be the language is a barrier but I think I would do what the school says and find another better school. Maybe it is a cultural clash but they need to be more understanding that they just moved to the country and do not understand the rules.

Ach come off it, no 11 and 12 year old children at a school think they are allowed to hang off a wire fence, there’s no language barrier involved!!! There is no culture clash, there is no school culture in the world that thinks it ok to let children hang off a fence.

fUNNYfACE36 · 18/03/2023 01:33

How many kids in the school? How a long would rhe fence last? If they all hang off it?

QueenCamilla · 18/03/2023 01:22

I climbed every fence and tree going as a kid. Never at school.

At school I remember it being banned to sit on window sills or lean against radiators. Seemed stupid at the time but now I'm all grown up and I get it.

UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 18/03/2023 01:21

One of the most valuable lessons I learned growing up in the French school system is that Life Is Not Fair. Thé sooner you learn to accept that, the happier you’ll be.

Lesvacances · 18/03/2023 01:18

If you've been to a french school OP then you know how strict they are. They're not supposed to hit the kids but it happens and if the parents complain you get a shrug.
If your dc are OK then I'd let it go.

daretodenim · 18/03/2023 01:14

You do know, I assume, that French schools are, in general, more top down authoritarian than in the U.K., and that children are simply expected to behave, full stop? They don't, generally, in comparison to the U.K., look at mitigating factors of the individual child, because they're supposed to conform. I know this because I have family in France and chose not to put my kids in the French school where I live. My DH is French.

You chose to put your children in a foreign school system for a year. It's not only the language and the curriculum that's different in this different culture, but the educational culture. This school being "rural" doesn't change that.

Yes they could have been told not to hang on the fence. But they weren't. You're only there for a year, with about 16 weeks of school left. Tell your boys this is how it is in France and to follow rules. If they don't, they'll get detentions. Hopefully you'll be happier with their next school.

And leave it be. You'll never win against this system, whether you're 100% right or not. Your kids will be out of there soon so just enjoy your last weeks rather than make it a nightmare for you all.

chocolatemademefat · 18/03/2023 01:09

Don’t be so ridiculous. Suck it up and tell your sons to do the same. And tell them to stay off fences.

Kamia · 18/03/2023 01:08

You are not being unreasonable. They seem quite punitive. The fact they just blamed your child for something and did not try and understand what had happened. It may be the language is a barrier but I think I would do what the school says and find another better school. Maybe it is a cultural clash but they need to be more understanding that they just moved to the country and do not understand the rules.

Jeschara · 18/03/2023 01:02

Move on, accept it has happened,and stop being so tiresome.
Why is it such a big Deal? You are making too much of it. You have already been told if you don't like what the School does to take them elsewhere. You are clearly annoying alot of people.

NeverApologiseNeverExplain · 18/03/2023 00:54

An hour's detention? It's not life without parole!

It's you who is getting things out of proportion, not the school.

What does the children's father think?

LuluBlakey1 · 18/03/2023 00:52

Get a grip! This is really trivial. They did something wrong and were given a detention. It's nothing.

Coyoacan · 18/03/2023 00:46

I do think, OP. that if you disagree so strongly with the school you are sending your childrren to, you should home school

Coyoacan · 18/03/2023 00:41

Did you climb stuff as a kid sometimes on break, outside? I know my friends and I did

Yes and we were punished for it.

Actually I'm old enough to remember being caned pretty much every day

thirdfiddle · 18/03/2023 00:13

I think you probably should have spoken to the boss when offered.

Certainly in the UK, and sounds like maybe also where you are too, parent-teacher representatives don't have anything to do with this sort of thing. Maybe they do in the Czech republic? Is there a first contact for you at the school? Again at ours in the UK, it would be DC's form tutor I'd talk to if I was concerned about something like this, or maybe head of year. Is there someone like that for you to contact about concerns?

It seems like they use detention a lot more lightly than I'm used to, and you're used to a school environment where it's not used at all. As such I think your natural reaction is that it's a huge punishment. You may find that where you are it's seen as no big deal, so your reaction will seem disproportionate to people.

As always when talking to schools, don't assume you know the whole story.

But seems to me you do have reasonable questions to ask. Were they doing something dangerous? If so, why were they not told to get down? If not, why straight to detention without any verbal warning?

Maybe they've fallen foul of history before they joined the school. There could be strict rules about the fence that were communicated before they joined and they genuinely didn't know, or were communicated when they'd recently joined and they didn't understand because of the language barrier. As a default, I wouldn't assume hanging on a fence was any sort of offence (sorry), we used to do it and our teachers didn't object.

WandaWonder · 17/03/2023 23:54

Ovidnaso · 17/03/2023 23:20

Exactly. Racism, possibly.

How is it racism?

Biggiee · 17/03/2023 23:37

So:

👉You've rang the school
👉You've looked up the school rules
👉You've spoken to two other people about this
👉You then spoke with an official mediator
👉You've written to class teacher
👉You've written to HR manager
👉You've posted an extremely large post on MN

Question 1, are your kids even arsed in the slightest that they have got detention?

Question 2, I bet your kids have served their sentence 10 times over by the time you've done all of the above?

Question 3, can you not see that you are being that parent?

Dancingdoggo · 17/03/2023 23:34

I agree with you OP about the fact it seems an odd way for them to deal with it.
I would absolutely expect them to call the kids off the fence first even if they did then get a detention.
But you perhaps have to assume school are fairly clear with the kids about the fence being a no-go area that they mention quite often perhaps even saying it’s an automatic detention if you are seen climbing it. Our school have a pond area that the kids are frequently told they will get detention if they go into.

I don’t agree with you about the way you are handling it sorry. I think you have to let it go and just say to the kids- well you know for sure about the fence rule now so get the detention done and don’t do it agin then move on.
Going into battle everytime school do something like this will not end well. For you or the kids! I know that can be tricky though when we feel hard done by but you honestly won’t win this and it does f set a good example to your boys.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 17/03/2023 23:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MeinKraft · 17/03/2023 23:28

SueDomym · 17/03/2023 23:11

I can't believe you don't see the issue with teachers not asking them to get down and just walking off saying nothing.
If it didn't warrant a telling off in person it doesn't warrant a detention.

Do you actually know the school didn't say something to them?

SueDomym · 17/03/2023 23:27

Chickenly · 17/03/2023 22:50

But is punishment the only way to learn?
No, of course not. Just like how they're learning from you right now that they can do whatever the fuck they like because mummy will tell the school off for thinking the rules apply to them. If you don't like your children being disciplined for breaking rules then home school them.

Your bad use of sarcasm doesn't help at all. Thanks for the bitterness.

OP posts:
ArmchairAnarchist2 · 17/03/2023 23:26

You do know you're 'that' parent, such hard work. The world doesn't revolve around you and DSs.