Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU: I am so annoyed by my kids' unwarranted detention?

216 replies

SueDomym · 17/03/2023 22:26

Hi people, I hope this message finds you well.
I have moved for one new year to rural France and I are taking one year of school here. They are 11+12yr old boys who have not hit puberty in any way yet. One still sleeps with a giant teddy... to say they are lovely kids - context I think, is relevant here.
My eldest was given detention on the first week of school for the 'destruction of property'. Apparently, someone had ripped some sellotape around a broken ping-pong table. So DS was given a detention. I asked my son, but he said he had done nothing. I spoke with the principal and he said that there was at least one person who had seen him doing this, a student. It was a detention and there was no more talking about it. I accepted but explained that I felt it was unfair in my son's first week of school in a place where he doesn't speak the language. I also said I believed my son.
5 months later I innocently asked two kids at the school if they knew what happened - they both told me it was the boy who did rip the selotape who blamed my kid to not get into trouble and that the principal had punished him once he found out. I had not been told this and my son was not apologised to which I felt would have been fair.

Fast forward to 2 days ago, a note was sent home with a stamped signature from the school principal. It said: Your sons were climbing a school fence and will receive one hour's detention.
So, I asked my boys about it and they said that during the long 1.5-hour break they were hanging off a grill-fence. A 'surveillante' was watching them, she said nothing and walked away.
The day after that I get an official letter with the artices of the law this punishment was under: one hour's detention for climbing on the school fence. And that the youngest son can remember to be better behaved towards his community in future. I ask my boys again, politely to see ifthey will tell the truth. They know I better with the truth than not, getting caught out for lying is worse in my opinion. Also they other boy who was with them also has his parents writing back saying they did no harm to any school equipment and would have got down had they simply been asked.
I believe my boys and want to know how to contest this decision when the boys had not been given a verbal warning first.
So, I call the school and I happen to get one of the people who watched the boys climb the wall. I asked why they didn't simply ask them to get down. She replied that there were two adults watching them. I asked if the other person had asked the boys to get down, and she replied "well they should just know". Basically, I argued with her asking why they couldn't have spoken to the boys.

She asked if I wanted to speak to her boss and I said no. I said I would like to speak to a parent-teacher representative. She told me she couldn't give out their phone numbers. She also told me if I wasn't happy with the school to take them out of this one. She finished with "I wish you a very good day" and I replied " I don't believe you.". It felt like a nasty argument.

I had some time this morning so I looked up the school rules: they have to start with a verbal warning. Detention is once parents have been spoken with.

I also spoke to two other people about this and they said that this isn't worth fighting because this is the way it is and I will not get them to back down.

I spoke with an official mediator and she said not to bother with this. If I kick up a fuss over this small punishment I will bring down the whole establishment on the boys heads - my complaints will make them suffer. Can you imagine?

Am I unreasonable in thinking that this is unfair behaviour by the school? It's a little, rural school. Everyone knows each other. I have a mobile phone. They could easily speak with me.
AIBU for expecting better communication first for such a minor offence?

Or am I just being unrealistic about the world today? (Be kind if you think so - but honest!).

I just wish I had a way of feeling less alone. I showed the letter from the school to 2 friends and they both said they have never seen a letter with a paragraph of law articles on it explaining how this detention was official. I mean.. really.

I wrote to their class teacher and the HR manager - I had no reply today.

Thanks for listening if you got this far.

Personal detail redacted by MNHQ

OP posts:
ClaireStandishsLipstick · 18/03/2023 06:35

SueDomym · 17/03/2023 22:57

Maybe I am just not seeing hanging onto a fence as a terrible and obviously punishable offence. I had genuinely never considered that. I mean have you never hung on a fence before as a kid? I mean that as an actual question...if you would be so kind as to reply.

Hanging from a fence isn’t terrible but it all depends whose fence you’re hanging from. My son got into trouble for climbing one of the trees at school. We supported the school’s punishment because he broke the rules even though ordinarily we would encourage him climbing trees.

Do the crime, do the time. Move on. You’re making it worse than it is.

Zonder · 18/03/2023 06:34

SueDomym · 17/03/2023 23:07

I know I didn't learn anything from punishment at school. I learned from teachers that could talk with kids not just bully them into conformity.

I'm not a fan of punishment but I think you are attempting to change the entire school system here! My experience of French schools is that they are hot on punishment. I wouldn't put my kids in a French school.

What is their French like? I'm guessing good since you're French / British. If it isn't good it could be that there are lots of misunderstandings happening and this was the last straw.

Whenwilliberich · 18/03/2023 06:25

How do you know they weren’t told not to do that??

of course they were told to get down!!!

LockEmUp · 18/03/2023 06:16

I also think tell them to get down. If they don't - consequence. If they get up again - consequence.

You're missing the point though and looking at it through UK system eyes. They shouldn't be on the fence therefore the teachers shouldn't have to tell them to get down. It is expected that they know and follow the rules. No discussion. It is the child's responsibility to behave, not the supervisors to enforce.

icypompoms · 18/03/2023 06:13

Maybe you should home school your children?

PoseyFlump · 18/03/2023 06:12

One still sleeps with a giant teddy

Is that your child by any chance?

donttellmehesalive · 18/03/2023 06:12

I'm a teacher and now think France must be a wonderful place to teach.

In the U.K., parents question any detention. They didn't do it. Oh you have witnesses and cctv? Well then it was your fault because they were bored, felt sad, didn't know it was wrong, were told to do it by someone else. And even if it was their fault, they can't do detention because they'll have to walk home alone, or they'll miss an important after school activity, or I'll have to finish work early, or you'll impair their mental health. Parents might feel like they've won if a detention is overturned but really standards are falling and behaviour is getting worse everywhere because kids increasingly know that there are no effective sanctions.

I'm glad the school stood up to you and you are being ridiculous.

KeHuyWinner · 18/03/2023 06:03

Your DS got a detention and 5 months later you're quizzing pupils about what happened? And now getting into a fight about another detention?

Think you need to let these things go.

itsgettingweird · 18/03/2023 06:02

SueDomym · 17/03/2023 22:39

But is punishment the only way to learn? Can the teacher not simply have asked them to get down? I mean, it seems disproportionate. Why all the official letters and messages? For something so small... Did you climb stuff as a kid sometimes on break, outside? I know my friends and I did. If we were asked to get down we did. End of story, no problem.
You know?
I will have to get over it I think...
Thanks for answering.

I agree with you over this.

Whilst I wouldn't be bothering to complain about this there has definitely been a shift too far the other way in consequences for pupils in schools lately.

We need a fine balance.

I also think tell them to get down. If they don't - consequence. If they get up again - consequence.

But we are teaching our young people to punish without effective communication nowadays IMO. They are learning of someone does something they don't like then punish them for it - rather than talk. It's having a massive effect on relationships between young people.

(I work in education bye the way and have for decades so I've seen the massive shift from one extreme to the other)

And I hate zero tolerance policies.

LockEmUp · 18/03/2023 06:01

We are not in the UK and when my DC started school there was one official school rule written in the info pack. And that was "children must not climb the fences". There are now three school rules, covering fences, phones and weapons. As for the rest, children are expected to behave and take responsibility for their actions. Our school only give detention if something has been damaged and that detention is to help the groundsman for two hours or until the task has been finished.

You are, I suspect, making your children's lives awkward.

SinisterIslandRoundabout · 18/03/2023 05:56

5 months later I innocently asked two kids at the school if they knew what happened - they both told me it was the boy who did rip the sellotape who blamed my kid to not get into trouble and that the principal had punished him once he found out. I had not been told this and my son was not apologised to which I felt would have been fair.

5 months later? 5 months later you were asking kids about the original incident? You really need to learn to let things go!

ScentOfAMemory · 18/03/2023 05:53

Oblomov23 · 18/03/2023 05:38

You will look back on this in years to come and cringe.

Sadly, as the kids are already 11 and 12 and she still thinks they can do nothing wrong, I think that's unlikely.

@SueDomym you're in a country where the school has a rule for inappropriate behaviour. BOTH of your children have been caught breaking that rule. Whether you like the rule or not is irrelevant.

Try the UK next time. As you'll see from Mumsnet alone, you'd find yourself in excellent company both for thinking your children can never do anything wrong, and for thinking parents should get to dictate how a school disciplines those who do. In the meantime suck it up and get them to behave.

PS have you discovered yet that in many countries kids can fail, have to repeat years etc? That one's going to hurt when it comes round. Use

Oblomov23 · 18/03/2023 05:38

You will look back on this in years to come and cringe.

endofthelinefinally · 18/03/2023 05:35

French schools are very strict. I think sometimes you just have to accept that if you are visiting or living in another country you have to accept the differences.
When I visit my DH's family I am careful to respect their culture and customs. It isn't my place to make a fuss or complain about the way things are done.
It is a learning experience for DC.

UdoU · 18/03/2023 05:30

SueDomym · 17/03/2023 22:39

But is punishment the only way to learn? Can the teacher not simply have asked them to get down? I mean, it seems disproportionate. Why all the official letters and messages? For something so small... Did you climb stuff as a kid sometimes on break, outside? I know my friends and I did. If we were asked to get down we did. End of story, no problem.
You know?
I will have to get over it I think...
Thanks for answering.

No, I didn’t climb fences and I agree with the surveillante, your kids should know not to climb fences. You are minimising this but if all the kids did this, the fence would break over time.

MrsOrange · 18/03/2023 05:29

One of the most valuable lessons I learned growing up in the French school system is that Life Is Not Fair. Thé sooner you learn to accept that, the happier you’ll be.

This...

The French system is infamously strict, they take no shit from pupils or parents. It might be over the top, and likely handled differently in different countries or school systems. That's irrelevant- you're in rural France, their rules, their decision.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 18/03/2023 05:21

SueDomym · 17/03/2023 22:57

Maybe I am just not seeing hanging onto a fence as a terrible and obviously punishable offence. I had genuinely never considered that. I mean have you never hung on a fence before as a kid? I mean that as an actual question...if you would be so kind as to reply.

Hanging on a fence at school is not acceptable behaviour and I would expect your children to know that. I agree they should have been asked to get down first but you need to stop thinking that they have done nothing wrong, they have.

aloris · 18/03/2023 04:59

The thing with the fence may be reasonable but coming on the heels of your child having received detention for something he didn't do, in his first week at a new school, and the principal then failing to disclose that he knew the other child lied and that your child didn't do it, it starts to feel like, not only are they incredibly unkind and unwelcoming people, but they are also picking on your children.

I think it's interesting the mediator said that raising this issue with the principal will result in bringing down the whole establishment on your children's heads. A principal who reacts like that to a parent addressing a small behavior problem (in which the principal was partially at fault) is a vindictive person. Maybe you are now in a culture where people in power are allowed to be vindictive and it's accepted. Or maybe the mediator just knows this particular principal. I don't know. You should probably follow the mediator's advice as they know the culture. But you don't have to like it or convince yourself it's reasonable.

PeanutButterCheesecake · 18/03/2023 04:59

Teachers are busy enough without having idiots ringing up AND writing to them every ten minutes to argue with them and undermine their decisions.

You need to accept that your pwecious ickle hunny bunny aaaaaangels are capable of misbehaving, the same as any other child.

im not surprised they haven’t written back yet. The harder work the parent is, the longer it takes to put together a response.

Emanresu9 · 18/03/2023 04:25

God I wish uk schools still had this level of discipline.

Glitteratitar · 18/03/2023 04:25

Agree, it is odd the teacher walked away without saying anything, but they should have still got the attention.

What difference does it make that the teacher didn’t say anything? If your children were attacking other children, do you think the teacher telling them to stop would have excused the punishment? Of course not. At that age they should know what is right and wrong and they have been dealt with accordingly.

JennyJenny8675309 · 18/03/2023 04:22

I think you need to suck it up and realise that you’re not running the school. You send your kids there and they make the rules.

Mummyoflittledragon · 18/03/2023 04:03

You know the school is far more strict than your dcs are used to. Just let it go. It’s only an hour’s detention. The only other option is to return home early. My dh is French and that would be his take. In the UK, children are given detentions all the time. For being late by only a few seconds, girls for rolling their skirts up, for forgetting your PE kit etc.

Marchitectmummy · 18/03/2023 03:11

Your kids surely know not to climb on things don't they, surely they dont need someone to tell them that? My children are younger but they certainly do.

I think your reaction to a detention is OTT, you sound very delusional about your children's behaviour.

SammyScrounge · 18/03/2023 02:48

SueDomym · 17/03/2023 22:57

Maybe I am just not seeing hanging onto a fence as a terrible and obviously punishable offence. I had genuinely never considered that. I mean have you never hung on a fence before as a kid? I mean that as an actual question...if you would be so kind as to reply.

I bet if one of your boys.fell off the fence and.broke his arm you'd be banging on the head teacher's door complaining about sloppy staff who didn't supervise children properly, lack of adequate discipline measures, failure to provide sufficient medical care etc etc
The most effective way to deal with this is to tell your boy to stay off the wall.