Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs and joggers

333 replies

TootsAtOwls · 17/03/2023 11:34

I'm prepared to be told IABU on this but interested to know what others think...

I have a rescue dog who is mostly fine, always friendly if he meets people in the house etc. However he does sometimes bark at people he doesn't like the look of when we pass them on the street (tall men, people wearing neon colours etc). I am actively working on this with positive reinforcement (I get the treats out before we pass people so he learns that other people are a good thing) and most days pass without incident.

However, I am having trouble with (male) runners. They come out of nowhere, running around corners and hurtling past at full speed. I often don't have time to get the treat into the dog's mouth or he's already too distracted by the runner to take it. So he barks, and lunges (I know he means it in a playful way, but they don't!) They always seem to look back and give me a dirty look as i call out "Sorry!"

But I can't help thinking, if I was running past a dog, I'd either cross the road to avoid them or if that's impossible (say on a canal path) I would bloody well slow down! I get that they don't want to keep interrupting their run with bouts of walking. Bit am I so unreasonable to think that you don't run right past a dog who's looking intently at you (as opposed to a dog showing no interest)? Surely they must see it's going to get them barked at?

OP posts:
Reh123 · 18/03/2023 10:33

I was out with my medium size rescue and a male jogger caught up with us as he rounded the corner, my dog started barking at him not aggressive but letting him know that you don't chase my human, I apologized and the jogger was really good and said my dog was doing his job protecting me if somebody comes running up to you the dog doesn't know if it's a friend or foe.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 18/03/2023 10:27

concertgoer · 18/03/2023 10:05

I hate runners coming up behind or in front of me without much warning.
tall men, often wearing headphones and doing more heavy breathing than they are aware of.
it’s intimidating!
I am not very tall, but at 5ft I’m talking than a dog!!

Yes but the men are only being playful. Panting is a natural response from a man with an elevated heart rate. Even if they do look intimidating they’re usually just big softies and great with kids.

moviesanddonuts · 18/03/2023 10:24

When we were training our dog as a puppy we had issues with people coming up to her (she's very tiny and cute!) and trying to interact with her without asking while we were trying to teach her that she didn't need to say hello to everyone / jump up... it was really frustrating but improved a lot when we got a bright yellow 'warning sign' that attached to the leash saying 'Dog in Training' with a hand with a cross through it. Something similar might help in this situation? I think we got it from Etsy. I know your situation is a bit different but the sign did help hugely as it made people more aware that we were training the dog, not to approach her (especially without asking!) etc. – so could be useful for you too? I think you can also get signs and dog vests that say 'reactive dog'.

concertgoer · 18/03/2023 10:05

I hate runners coming up behind or in front of me without much warning.
tall men, often wearing headphones and doing more heavy breathing than they are aware of.
it’s intimidating!
I am not very tall, but at 5ft I’m talking than a dog!!

DrivingAllDay · 18/03/2023 08:35

I think YABU . And I do not hate dogs!!! I just think you are being unreasonable in this case. Can you walk him in places with more space?

Keepupandout · 18/03/2023 08:24

thisplaceisweird · 17/03/2023 12:26

I actually don't mind when my dog does this. It's really natural for a dog to feel intimidated when someone is running at them, particularly tall men. Barking is a natural instinct.

Same when my dog barks at a creepy looking man - I usually just keep walking and say "good girl".

Ultimately, I care far more about my dog than some random runners feelings for 2 seconds of their day. Not an issue.

This. If your dog is on a lead and poses zero risk to the runner, don't overthink the barking or lunge. It's a natural reaction to a fright. I don't think your job as a dog owner is to make sure the dog never reacts in public, but to make sure everyone is safe.

WonderingWanda · 18/03/2023 08:08

Just ignore their dirty looks op. Your dog is on a lead and not doing any harm.

SherbertDabs · 18/03/2023 07:52

PoseyFlump · 18/03/2023 07:09

You sound exactly the sort of runner who doesn't give a shit about cars and people. I've seen lots of near misses caused by selfish joggers.

I did care before this thread taught me I was under no obligation to. Always tried to make sure I wasn’t inconveniencing people whatever I was doing. Now it’s every man for themselves. Dogs, kids, buggies, people, belongings - I’ll stop for nothing.

LolaSmiles · 18/03/2023 07:50

can’t speak for others but I’ve found helping a dog who is the way he is having been beaten and starved by previous owners really rewarding. I can definitely forgive him for being a bit jumpy around strangers that are too close
I'm sure it is rewarding, but it doesn't mean the general public should have to change their activities to suit a random dog.
Too close is a vague concept.

If it's a little jumpy when someone is up in their face, I'd get it and agree with you.

If sharing a path with people doing perfectly normal things is too close then a reactive dog shouldn't be on a pavement in a public area.

If someone gets great satisfaction out of taking a reactive dog and investing the time and energy to train them effectively then that's brilliant. It's a special interest and skills.

However it's not the job of society to stop doing totally normal activities because some humans choose to take their reactive dogs out in public places and then moan that life is going on.

LuckySantangelo35 · 18/03/2023 07:44

bibbybox · 18/03/2023 07:36

I just think if I was running I wouldn't DREAM of running right next to a dog and expecting zero reaction!

where should people run then?

They shouldn’t

running should be banned

just in case they scare some poor dog and it lunges at them

according to some posters on here anyway!!

bibbybox · 18/03/2023 07:41

Surely good manners means you neither hog the pavement as a dog walker, or expect a totally clear run as a runner.

don't bring common sense into it! 😆

journeyofsanity · 18/03/2023 07:39

thisplaceisweird · 17/03/2023 12:26

I actually don't mind when my dog does this. It's really natural for a dog to feel intimidated when someone is running at them, particularly tall men. Barking is a natural instinct.

Same when my dog barks at a creepy looking man - I usually just keep walking and say "good girl".

Ultimately, I care far more about my dog than some random runners feelings for 2 seconds of their day. Not an issue.

You are encouraging your dog to be nervous. You also appear to be nervous of men and are unconsciously communicating this to your dog. This is terrible and cruel dog ownership. I have no idea why you seem so pleased with yourself and smug about your poor dog skills and poorly trained dog. Your dog would be better off with someone who actually cares about them

bibbybox · 18/03/2023 07:36

I just think if I was running I wouldn't DREAM of running right next to a dog and expecting zero reaction!

where should people run then?

IfYouDontAsk · 18/03/2023 07:34

You ought to have your dog on a very short lead so it can’t lunge at people. It’s annoying when people run close to you but I think that’s a separate issue to you having close enough physical control of your dog so that it can’t lunge towards people.

LuckySantangelo35 · 18/03/2023 07:32

People come before dogs

it really is that simple

YABU

PoseyFlump · 18/03/2023 07:09

SherbertDabs · 18/03/2023 05:38

I’m going to adopt a similar attitude I think. None of your shit is my problem. I’m under no obligation to be a decent human whilst running. Keep your belongings close, people. I’m running wherever the fuck I want. Hope I don’t scare you although if I do, you should just train yourself to not be startled.

You sound exactly the sort of runner who doesn't give a shit about cars and people. I've seen lots of near misses caused by selfish joggers.

PoseyFlump · 18/03/2023 07:06

@TootsAtOwls I wouldn't give it too much thought if your dog is on lead. I agree with a pp who said you can't train dogs nor people out of a 'startle' reaction and we shouldn't want to either. We're not robots.

Most joggers we encounter are considerate but some lone men runners can be a pain. Like the ones that hate stopping and don't like waiting for traffic because they want to beat their personal best. Nothing else matters to them.

MrsMurphyIWish · 18/03/2023 06:21

I’m a runner but female so guess I’m less “intimidating”.

Why do I need to cross the road - which would constantly for me in my area - because owners choose to have a dog? I run as I have a disability which means I have to keep my bones strong. Running isn’t a choice for me - it’s staving off me prematurely being in a wheelchair. Dog owners choose to have a dog so I think OP, you need to stop blaming others for your dog’s reaction.

SherbertDabs · 18/03/2023 05:38

I’m going to adopt a similar attitude I think. None of your shit is my problem. I’m under no obligation to be a decent human whilst running. Keep your belongings close, people. I’m running wherever the fuck I want. Hope I don’t scare you although if I do, you should just train yourself to not be startled.

Zooeyzebra · 18/03/2023 02:53

With your dogs particular problems obviously.

A reactive dog is not the publics problem. Sort your dogs training away from the public until it is safe around others. A dog that lunges is a danger to you, himself and everyone else

Zooeyzebra · 18/03/2023 00:56

Most people using the pavement expect dog to be trained and under control. If yours is not and you expect others to change their behaviour for you perhaps you need to let them know by getting your dog something like this, so people know to give you space

Dogs and joggers
Dogs and joggers
kitsuneghost · 18/03/2023 00:41

The trouble is you want them to slow down for YOUR dog. Does that mean they need to slow down for every dog. If so they wouldn't get very far with the number of dogs in public spaces nowadays

ElonsMusky · 18/03/2023 00:02

pretty sure men have the right to jog without being obligated to cross the road or worry about your dog. Jesus Christ, the world doesn't revolve around you.

Frogdoglog · 17/03/2023 23:55

OP I have dogs and am a runner too and also work as a dog walker, and I would slow down to pass any dogs when I’m running, if they bark or lunge I would usually stop and walk past them. From the other side if I think a dog I’m walking might react to something I try and warn the person before hand, just call out something like “sorry he might bark a bit when you pass, he’s very nervous” that way the person won’t get a fright and if they are understanding they might slow down. I use this approach when ever I meet a runner, horse, cyclist etc with my walked dogs as It’s not always easy to know how they will react if I’ve not seen them in that situation before and I find people are generally very nice about it. I do live in a ‘friendly’ area though so attitudes might be different here!

Doveyouknow · 17/03/2023 23:17

I always give dogs a wide berth and will stop and stand to one side if the path is narrow. However, some dog owners do get offended by this as they think I am implying their dog is untrained / unfriendly. As a jogger and a cyclist, I have long since learnt I can't win...