Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs and joggers

333 replies

TootsAtOwls · 17/03/2023 11:34

I'm prepared to be told IABU on this but interested to know what others think...

I have a rescue dog who is mostly fine, always friendly if he meets people in the house etc. However he does sometimes bark at people he doesn't like the look of when we pass them on the street (tall men, people wearing neon colours etc). I am actively working on this with positive reinforcement (I get the treats out before we pass people so he learns that other people are a good thing) and most days pass without incident.

However, I am having trouble with (male) runners. They come out of nowhere, running around corners and hurtling past at full speed. I often don't have time to get the treat into the dog's mouth or he's already too distracted by the runner to take it. So he barks, and lunges (I know he means it in a playful way, but they don't!) They always seem to look back and give me a dirty look as i call out "Sorry!"

But I can't help thinking, if I was running past a dog, I'd either cross the road to avoid them or if that's impossible (say on a canal path) I would bloody well slow down! I get that they don't want to keep interrupting their run with bouts of walking. Bit am I so unreasonable to think that you don't run right past a dog who's looking intently at you (as opposed to a dog showing no interest)? Surely they must see it's going to get them barked at?

OP posts:
lljkk · 18/03/2023 13:08

This thread is funny. I really thought it would nicely put the dog-haters against the man-haters in terms of who to blame most. Interesting that the dog-haters seemed to win out. I would have bet on the man-haters for sure.

bonus points next time, OP, if the offending exerciser is a cyclist. Then you could get a 3 way competition between the dog/cyclist/man haters.

Even better (more popcorn) if you can drop in that you drive a stonking huge SUV, or if you docked your dog's tail.

maranella · 18/03/2023 13:04

YABU! Runners have every right to run on the pavement and if your dog can't handle it I suggest you muzzle the damn thing. The runners aren't doing anything wrong, you are.

TootsAtOwls · 18/03/2023 13:04

longtompot · 17/03/2023 18:51

At these pressure points where you have encountered joggers and or men in high vis, or even places where it might be a possibility, have your treats ready and have your dogs focus on you even before the event happens, if it does.

This is what I do, and 99 times out of 100 it's fine.

The issue is when people emerge out of nowhere and run past at close range, which is what I'm working on.

And for those asking, I do avoid enclosed paths whenever possible but unfortunately I have to walk on a canal path for a couple of minutes to get out of my home.

OP posts:
TootsAtOwls · 18/03/2023 13:01

WiddlinDiddlin · 17/03/2023 18:26

Dog owners cannot expect others to understand the details and intricacies of training a dog, dog behaviour etc etc.

I do think it reasonable that they understand human behaviour and have the common courtesy NOT to run up behind or pass people with only a foot or two to spare though.

However, that isn't the case, and we can't force people to behave politely or thoughtfully to others, so we have to train and handle dogs on the understanding that everyone else out there, is a twat.

Don't walk your dog where runners will pass close by, run up behind silently, where you can't get lots of space.

Avoiding your dog 'practicing' this behaviour or, being repeatedly startled or feeling threatened by runners/cyclists etc, is the first step to addressing the issue.

Spend some time teaching your dog that all the distracting noises and movements they see outside are markers or predictors for reward. In the same way that a clicker or a verbal marker like 'yes!' can be paired with a reinforcer to become a conditioned stimuli, so can all these sounds and movements you experience outdoors.

This means spending some time in a safe environment (door way, gate way, sitting in the back of the car, sitting on a bench somewhere) observing and classically conditioning to those events.

Once you have a dog who is automatically looking at you when they experience these conditioned markers, you're ready to think about walking where people may be jogging - but not every day, not every walk - start out simple and very minimal, and again strongly reinforcing seeing runners, hearing them, etc.

Be aware of 'trigger stacking' - dog has coped with jogger 1, juuuuuust about coped with jogger 2... but the next day, its jogger 3 that causes the reaction. This happens because stress hormones do not drop within minutes or hours, they can take days to come back down. So factoring this in and ensuring easy stress free walks or avoiding walks in favour of training sessions, trips to secure fields etc helps training be more efficient, and trigger stacking less likely to occur.

I'd also teach your dog a 'close' cue (when I walked it would be the dog targeting my leg with their shoulder, now its them targeting my arm rest with nose or leg rest with nose depending on height of dog) so you can ask for that behaviour before the runner passes and then reward for it after. A close cue or a 'behind' (dog walks behind you) can be really useful for going round blind corners or tight sections where there isn't much passing room.

Unfortunately it is VERY easy for a single event learning experience to set everything back again, so just one twat runs up behind and startles both dog and handler, and you can be back to the beginning. So I would really avoid popular jogging areas, narrow paths, surfaces where you can't hear runners approaching. Even after you've improved the response to seeing runners with plenty of warning.

This is really great advice, thank you

OP posts:
Thesharkradar · 18/03/2023 12:45

Get a muzzle for the dog, at least then runners know it can’t bite them
But the fur baby doesn't like that, the fur baby just wants to enjoy itself and do its own thing
it's not fair to restrict the furbaby it just wants to have fun
it needs to express it's personality by doing fur baby things, lunging at people barking and biting, that's just its way of saying hello and being fwendly!

OneTC · 18/03/2023 12:45

LuvSmallDogs · 18/03/2023 12:23

@Thesharkradar , depends what you mean by capable. Many breeds not generally associated with attacks are capable in the same way that you or I are capable of pushing someone into a busy road - we sure could, but we don't want to. Same with some individual members of breeds that are associated with attacks.

All I know is that as someone who likes dogs, I am amazed by some people's lack of self preservation around them. My own dog is tiny and adult strangers have picked her up and held her to their faces - are they fucking nuts?!

I was riding down a dark road one night, there were 2 people walking in the same direction ahead of me. I didn't want to startle them so I moved over, slowed right down, told them I was passing and did so, only to suddenly see their black collie type dog come darting across the road and sink it's teeth into my thigh. It happened in an instant. I wasn't hurt too badly, it didn't bite anything off, but there was quite a bit of blood and puncture marks. I love dogs, but they're idiots and decisions on attacking people shouldn't be left up to them

Divorcedalongtime · 18/03/2023 12:42

QuertyGirl · 17/03/2023 16:41

It's insane.

I have both a cat and a child.

I can tell them apart unlike some dog owners

Best answer ever

Divorcedalongtime · 18/03/2023 12:35

YABU totally 100%, your dog should NOT lunge at people. I hate dogs coming towards me and as a runner I will come up in people from behind and around circlets all the time often making them jump, that’s the nature of running. Get a muzzle for the dog, at least then runners know it can’t bite them..

LuvSmallDogs · 18/03/2023 12:35

@Thesharkradar are wants (or drives, or urges, if you prefer) always based on moral decisions? Do you not want to push people under cars because you know it would be immoral, or do you just...not want to?

Albiboba · 18/03/2023 12:32

am I so unreasonable to think that you don't run right past a dog who's looking intently at you

YABU

I don’t care enough about other peoples dogs to know where it’s looking. It’s your job to control your own dog.
If you can’t you need to take it somewhere even quieter.

Thesharkradar · 18/03/2023 12:29

Many breeds not generally associated with attacks are capable in the same way that you or I are capable of pushing someone into a busy road - we sure could, but we don't want to. Same with some individual members of breeds that are associated with attacks
@LuvSmallDogs
You seem to be implying that the animal is capable of making a moral choice?

LuvSmallDogs · 18/03/2023 12:23

Thesharkradar · 18/03/2023 12:09

Having a dangerous dog destroyed and the owners prosecuted can't replace calf muscle, restore full hand function, or remove facial scarring
I agree but on the other hand is it right that creatures capable of inflicting such damage are casually walking around the streets?
Answer= no it ducking🦆 well isn't🤬

@Thesharkradar , depends what you mean by capable. Many breeds not generally associated with attacks are capable in the same way that you or I are capable of pushing someone into a busy road - we sure could, but we don't want to. Same with some individual members of breeds that are associated with attacks.

All I know is that as someone who likes dogs, I am amazed by some people's lack of self preservation around them. My own dog is tiny and adult strangers have picked her up and held her to their faces - are they fucking nuts?!

Scottsy200 · 18/03/2023 12:19

Sorry this just makes it sound like no one is allowed to live their lives because you have a nervous dog, if your dog is that bad maybe you should only take it for walks in remote areas where the chances of it being spooked and reacting are a lot less, otherwise then I’m afraid you will just have to steel yourself for runners and skateboarders and cyclists as that’s life 🤷🏼‍♀️

Thesharkradar · 18/03/2023 12:19

Zooeyzebra · 18/03/2023 00:56

Most people using the pavement expect dog to be trained and under control. If yours is not and you expect others to change their behaviour for you perhaps you need to let them know by getting your dog something like this, so people know to give you space

Or maybe runners cyclists and walkers should wear 'KEEP YOUR DOG AWAY FROM ME' signs?

Grrrrdarling · 18/03/2023 12:11

TootsAtOwls · 17/03/2023 11:34

I'm prepared to be told IABU on this but interested to know what others think...

I have a rescue dog who is mostly fine, always friendly if he meets people in the house etc. However he does sometimes bark at people he doesn't like the look of when we pass them on the street (tall men, people wearing neon colours etc). I am actively working on this with positive reinforcement (I get the treats out before we pass people so he learns that other people are a good thing) and most days pass without incident.

However, I am having trouble with (male) runners. They come out of nowhere, running around corners and hurtling past at full speed. I often don't have time to get the treat into the dog's mouth or he's already too distracted by the runner to take it. So he barks, and lunges (I know he means it in a playful way, but they don't!) They always seem to look back and give me a dirty look as i call out "Sorry!"

But I can't help thinking, if I was running past a dog, I'd either cross the road to avoid them or if that's impossible (say on a canal path) I would bloody well slow down! I get that they don't want to keep interrupting their run with bouts of walking. Bit am I so unreasonable to think that you don't run right past a dog who's looking intently at you (as opposed to a dog showing no interest)? Surely they must see it's going to get them barked at?

Ignore the runners & do your thing.
Their reaction is valid as their stride is being interrupted but so is your feeling bad for disturbing their run. Your dog is on a lead, under control & no one got hurt. Runners should really slow down, give a wide berth to others on the pathway & even walk when passing dogs/kids/prams etc like people in cars do when passing cyclists/horses/big puddles of water.
If these incidents are happening at similar points on your dog walks consider placing a little pile of treat bits down on the ground to entice your dog to look away from the big scary man/bright thing running towards him/her.

Thesharkradar · 18/03/2023 12:09

Having a dangerous dog destroyed and the owners prosecuted can't replace calf muscle, restore full hand function, or remove facial scarring
I agree but on the other hand is it right that creatures capable of inflicting such damage are casually walking around the streets?
Answer= no it ducking🦆 well isn't🤬

LuvSmallDogs · 18/03/2023 12:05

Honestly, I thought it was common sense not to run up close to a dog you don't know.

Having a dangerous dog destroyed and the owners prosecuted can't replace calf muscle, restore full hand function, or remove facial scarring.

It's a bit like the old gag about road users saying "But I had right of way" with their dying breath.

Widoweddad · 18/03/2023 12:01

Oh fgs the amount of posters saying they're scared of "the big scary running man" .
99% of them are just exercising without any other motive. If you're that scared of others exercising then it sounds like a you problem and should probably look into counselling.

I was a runner (quit due to knee issues) and in the end in order to get a good run ie not stopping for everyone who refused to move by pavement hogging etc I had to get up at 4 in the morning. Those saying they shouldn't have to look over their shoulders when walking... I do this when I'm walking to allow room for faster walkers or anyone else who needs to pass. What irritates me are those who walk their dog walking on one side of the pavement and have a long lead with the dog on the other side. Sorry but as you think your dog is your baby and more important than me,I'm trying to walk mine and think he's more important than your dog.

deveronvalley · 18/03/2023 11:53

Runner and a dog owner. I slow down for dogs or walk if the dog looks a bit ‘playful’. I’ve been bitten twice. I slow
down for kids learning bikes and scooters, elderly people or anyone really who hasn’t spotted me or isn’t themselves moving quickly. You often can’t win whatever you do. If you are running up behind someone, they’re just as startled if you overtake unannounced as if you call out from 20 metres behind - the latter ends up in a big song and dance while they dramatically decide which side of the path to pull into while getting tangled up in the dog or their friend. Sometimes it’s better just to sneak past! A short sharp shock is surely better than some of the absurdity I’ve been embroiled in - I’m a calm and considerate person, not a big huffing and puffing bloke trying to beat his Strava segment record and NOBODY WILL GET IN MY WAY! You absolutely do get those runners and they should probably chill a bit in public shared spaces. However, don’t always imagine a ‘look’ is a ‘dirty look’ as it’s often quite hard to look friendly when running - also, many runners will spend many hours a week running and will get into these situations regularly, in their mind, it might not warrant any sort of acknowledgment or pleasantries, just not an event at all.

greenacrylicpaint · 18/03/2023 11:23

Yes but the men are only being playful. Panting is a natural response from a man with an elevated heart rate. Even if they do look intimidating they’re usually just big softies and great with kids.

Grin love this
AliceDownTheRabbitHole · 18/03/2023 11:18

I'm a jogger (and a dog owner so may think differently) but I always slow down when approaching a dog (or a person or cyclist). For my own protection more than anything as dogs can be unpredictable and running up behind one and startling them is asking for trouble. I wouldn't necessarily cross the road but I appreciate the need to share the pavement. In the word ms of blur.. . 'Its not all about you joggers who go round and round' 😂😂

Welshmonster · 18/03/2023 11:11

I was running and bit by dog who was not on lead and had no recall. So I give dogs a wide berth. Blind corners are that. Blind so plan for these and cross over so you aren’t surprised.

TiddlySquats · 18/03/2023 11:09

I just think if I was running I wouldn't DREAM of running right next to a dog and expecting zero reaction!

You should be able to run next to a dog without it reacting. Dogs can be trained to ignore joggers, it's not hard.
There are always loads of runners and people walking dogs on our daily riverside walk. Runners have to overtake closely on the narrow trail and I've never once seen a dog react or take any notice.
Apart from mine when I first got him from the rescue!
So we avoided the area for a few months until he was trained not to react.

concertgoer · 18/03/2023 10:56

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 18/03/2023 10:27

Yes but the men are only being playful. Panting is a natural response from a man with an elevated heart rate. Even if they do look intimidating they’re usually just big softies and great with kids.

😂
they’re running past! They’re generally minding their own business. It’s still momentarily intimidating!!

I’d prefer to choose which man was heavy breathing playfully in close proximity to me …… & it wouldn’t be in the street !!

LolaSmiles · 18/03/2023 10:54

This. If your dog is on a lead and poses zero risk to the runner, don't overthink the barking or lunge. It's a natural reaction to a fright. I don't think your job as a dog owner is to make sure the dog never reacts in public, but to make sure everyone is safe.
No dog is never going to react because there might be occasional situations where a reaction is appropriate.

HOWEVER, if someone's dog is going to lunge and react at strangers in public who are getting on with their life then it IS a risk to the public. Owners who think it's acceptable to reinforce their dog lunging at runners and other path users are choosing to teach their dog that's acceptable behaviour.

I'm a dog owner and am fed up with the amount of times I see and hear people thinking that their bloody dog should be allowed to run up to people, lunge at people, and jump at people whilst making silly excuses for it.