Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband said I can’t do something .. is he unreasonable or am I ?

254 replies

TeePee22 · 17/03/2023 09:43

Namechanged as I’m fairly sure he knows my old username ( shared iPad )
4 years ago I was overweight and had been since I had my first child also had some health problems . I joined a gym and fell in love with training . Got a PT and have really developed in bodybuilding … if I may say so myself I have built a pretty good body which has taken hundreds of hours of work and commitment . It’s not been quick and it’s certainly not been easy but I have done the grind day in day out dragged myself in the gym at 5 am etc .
Im hurtling towards menopause and at the end of last year had a great idea of oh I want to do a bodybuilding show .
I know it’s not everyone’s cup of tea but it takes huge dedication and balls to stand on a stage in a sparkly bikini and be judged on your physique . I just want a day where I’m glam and have some amazing photos to show when I’m really old .. look that was me kind of thing .
This has set off world war 3 in my household , I started comp prep beginning of the month with my coach and he has now flat out said I’m not doing it or we are getting divorced and no wife of his is and I quote “prancing around on a stage” and what if anyone finds out he would be the laughing stock ?
he has always hated everything to do with my gym time ( and yes it’s a daily commitment but I don’t feel it encroaches on life I manage to parent 3 children one who is still quite young and a stressful job ) FYI he is overweight despite me trying to do everything to encourage him he does zero exercise which worries me daily . I have tried to involve him so many times but he won’t come along and train with me .
i know it’s probably not a normal thing to decide to do at my advanced age …but Im going to be so bloody angry if I don’t and frankly let someone tell me what to do
Its not dangerous ,so it’s not like he is worried about me ( unless your in the realms of the men’s open classes ) it’s just a strange sport to those that don’t really get it

What I expected from him was Oh ok .. well I don’t really get what it why you’re doing it but crack on if you want to .
I don’t think IBU and frankly I think he is being a massive controlling dickhead but I’m willing to listen and take on board of people
think actually yeah it’s me I have lost my mind 👀

OP posts:
Naunet · 17/03/2023 16:46

Naunet · 17/03/2023 16:45

Ok, but this comes from a man who is over weight to the point OP is worried for his health, yet he’s still off down the pub drinking all the time. It’s a double standard.

Actually, a correction, has he even said he finds it unattractive? I think that’s just been the opinion of some people on this thread, as if it’s relevant and OP should care about looking conventionally ‘pretty’.

Naunet · 17/03/2023 16:45

CocaineBear · 17/03/2023 16:39

This is it. Some people really don't like certain looks.

I see lots of threads from people saying they hate tattoos, think they're vile, and would hate their husband to have them. Some women hate beards on men.

I'm heavily tattooed, so is DH. We both like tattoos. DH has always had a beard. I'm sure women who hate beards wouldn't like him.

I really really dislike heavy muscles/the bodybuilding look, it makes me shudder. I'm not sure how I'd feel if DH started to look like that. I didn't date large muscular men because I hate the look.

If OP is becoming something that her husband finds unattractive then that's a tough one.

Ok, but this comes from a man who is over weight to the point OP is worried for his health, yet he’s still off down the pub drinking all the time. It’s a double standard.

Naunet · 17/03/2023 16:43

CrotchetyCrocheting · 17/03/2023 16:08

Secondly, I’m not sure why so many posters are going to great lengths to point out how unattractive competing body builders look. Yes, it’s not the most attractive look in the world, but so what? Why must everything revolve around being sexually pleasing? Who gives a fuck if you’ll be ‘less conventionally attractive’ for a few hours whilst pumped up and wearing a dark tan?? I really can’t understand why that’s even an issue.

It's just one of those things that grosses people out I think. It's not even about it being sexually pleasing. It's the mindset behind wanting to do it, imagine wanting to stand there like a prize pig all eager while someone judges you on your body? I'd feel the same if dh wanted to wear a suit and enter a beauty pagent. He wouldn't be the man I married if he wanted to do that. It's juvenile and is kind of 1950s tbh.

Oh I totally agree with you re the having your body judged part, I would never do that personally, but I’m talking specifically about the comments around the aesthetic being unattractive, like that should really matter.

CocaineBear · 17/03/2023 16:39

CrotchetyCrocheting · 17/03/2023 16:08

Secondly, I’m not sure why so many posters are going to great lengths to point out how unattractive competing body builders look. Yes, it’s not the most attractive look in the world, but so what? Why must everything revolve around being sexually pleasing? Who gives a fuck if you’ll be ‘less conventionally attractive’ for a few hours whilst pumped up and wearing a dark tan?? I really can’t understand why that’s even an issue.

It's just one of those things that grosses people out I think. It's not even about it being sexually pleasing. It's the mindset behind wanting to do it, imagine wanting to stand there like a prize pig all eager while someone judges you on your body? I'd feel the same if dh wanted to wear a suit and enter a beauty pagent. He wouldn't be the man I married if he wanted to do that. It's juvenile and is kind of 1950s tbh.

This is it. Some people really don't like certain looks.

I see lots of threads from people saying they hate tattoos, think they're vile, and would hate their husband to have them. Some women hate beards on men.

I'm heavily tattooed, so is DH. We both like tattoos. DH has always had a beard. I'm sure women who hate beards wouldn't like him.

I really really dislike heavy muscles/the bodybuilding look, it makes me shudder. I'm not sure how I'd feel if DH started to look like that. I didn't date large muscular men because I hate the look.

If OP is becoming something that her husband finds unattractive then that's a tough one.

CrotchetyCrocheting · 17/03/2023 16:08

Secondly, I’m not sure why so many posters are going to great lengths to point out how unattractive competing body builders look. Yes, it’s not the most attractive look in the world, but so what? Why must everything revolve around being sexually pleasing? Who gives a fuck if you’ll be ‘less conventionally attractive’ for a few hours whilst pumped up and wearing a dark tan?? I really can’t understand why that’s even an issue.

It's just one of those things that grosses people out I think. It's not even about it being sexually pleasing. It's the mindset behind wanting to do it, imagine wanting to stand there like a prize pig all eager while someone judges you on your body? I'd feel the same if dh wanted to wear a suit and enter a beauty pagent. He wouldn't be the man I married if he wanted to do that. It's juvenile and is kind of 1950s tbh.

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 17/03/2023 16:00

BeachBlondey · 17/03/2023 15:02

I honestly couldn't cope with this. Me and DH are a bit overweight, but blimey we have FUN. We have regular weekends away and all inclusive holidays, we eat lovely food and drink far too much wine. I'd be bored stiff if he suddenly became a gum bunny and ditched all the fun stuff we do together. Yes we'd be healthier but at what cost to fun? Like Ricky Jervais says, if you're super healthy and add 2 years to your life, it's 2 years at the wrong end! You get an extra 2 years in your 90's, not your 30's.

Same here! Could both get a stone off but hey 🤷🏻‍♀️ we like a wee lunch date and a Saturday night wine and a decent holiday! I swim and he goes to gym couple nights a week but it’s not all encompassing, could never deal with that!

SoTiredNeedHoliday · 17/03/2023 15:08

Exactly @Naunet ! Why is no one mentioning the pub trips! @BeachBlondey seriously? is she sure she's not neglecting her marriage when DH spends more time at the pub than she does on her physical fitness and health (i.e. her hobby)

@BeachBlondey "Do you date? Do you go out for dinner? Do you find time for him? Do you spend the evenings together? Do you have sex? Do you have weekends and holidays away together? Do you switch off and let yourself drink wine and have treats, or have you become boring (to him)? Do you talk about training incessantly? Do you ask about his life? Do you come across as smug because you've got fit, and he hasn't? My hunch, is that he feels completely left behind and forgotten, and this is the straw that broke the camels back?" Its not the 1950's !!! 😣

He doesn't want her to do a competition ... he hasn't said he wants to start a hobby with her.

Gosh come on women we need to support women all she wants to do is 1 competition OP hasn't said she wants to do the circuit and spend the next year or two at competitions. OP has clearly said she is not neglecting her family or letting it impact their family life.

@BeachBlondey I've got to go now, I'd better get dinner on and dressed properly for when DH comes home 😂

BeachBlondey · 17/03/2023 15:02

2PintsOfCidernaBagofCrisps · 17/03/2023 13:34

That's definitely something that is overlooked...how BORING it is. It becomes all encompassing. All my DH talks about is the gym and food. Not just the miserable food that he has to eat just now but all this fantasy food that he's going to eat in 6 weeks. Yawnnnn.

I honestly couldn't cope with this. Me and DH are a bit overweight, but blimey we have FUN. We have regular weekends away and all inclusive holidays, we eat lovely food and drink far too much wine. I'd be bored stiff if he suddenly became a gum bunny and ditched all the fun stuff we do together. Yes we'd be healthier but at what cost to fun? Like Ricky Jervais says, if you're super healthy and add 2 years to your life, it's 2 years at the wrong end! You get an extra 2 years in your 90's, not your 30's.

Siameasy · 17/03/2023 14:55

I think if his concerns were based on how this pursuit will affect the family that’s one thing but they seem to come from a place of insecurity. That would annoy me. I love working out too. I’ve contemplated going all out and doing the bikini thing but decided I’m not up for it. It defo IS full on. So have a proper talk with him about his concerns. But I think it’s jealousy and “misery loves company”. Fat people generally don’t want other fat people to not be fat any more.

meatyryvita · 17/03/2023 14:34

I struggle with this one. Whilst you have every right to pursue your hobbies, competing will take up so much time and energy and you might not be able to participate in family life as normal. A friend of mine did this and she had to be so controlled (almost obsessed to an outsider) in her eating and exercise schedule, that she somewhat checked out of family life.

That said, you are NOT property and as long as you factor in your family obligations, whatever they may be, go for it!

BeachBlondey · 17/03/2023 14:33

OK, well done firstly, because it sounds like you have done so well.

BUT......Are you sure you haven't been neglecting your marriage, whilst pursuing this? I mean, it's not something you are doing together, and you sound as though you had a busy life before this.

Do you date? Do you go out for dinner? Do you find time for him? Do you spend the evenings together? Do you have sex? Do you have weekends and holidays away together? Do you switch off and let yourself drink wine and have treats, or have you become boring (to him)? Do you talk about training incessantly? Do you ask about his life? Do you come across as smug because you've got fit, and he hasn't? My hunch, is that he feels completely left behind and forgotten, and this is the straw that broke the camels back?

It depends how important this marriage is to you, but I think if you cherish it, just take a day or two, to really think about this. How would you feel, for eg. if he had a hobby that took up the same amount of time, and you were in his shoes.

Personally, if my DH took up training to this level, I think I'd get really bored by it, and would probably resent the time it took up, and I would miss the old version of him, especially if it meant that we suddenly could have take-out or drink or do any of the "unhealthy" things we used to do. If he then was going to rank it up another few notches to competitions, I can see how I might snap.

Arniesleftleg · 17/03/2023 14:28

It sounds like he's not able to handle your new physique. He may have preferred you being overweight and what he deems was invisible to other men, and now you're going to be more than visible. This is his problem, not yours.

Do what makes you happy, sounds like you've nailed it.

Naunet · 17/03/2023 14:19

Rosula · 17/03/2023 14:03

Exactly this. Nobody on here or any other forum or in real life would have any problem with a man pursuing a hobby and spending potentially 60-70%. of his waking hours (outside work) doing it.

You can't have been on MN long, @DannyZukosSmile, if you really believe this. We get at least one thread a week where someone is bemoaning the amount of time their husband/male partner is spending on their hobby.

So why is his hobby of going to the pub, (which takes up more time than OP’s) not being mentioned as a problem? All the focus seems to be on OP and her less time consuming hobby.

Rosula · 17/03/2023 14:03

Exactly this. Nobody on here or any other forum or in real life would have any problem with a man pursuing a hobby and spending potentially 60-70%. of his waking hours (outside work) doing it.

You can't have been on MN long, @DannyZukosSmile, if you really believe this. We get at least one thread a week where someone is bemoaning the amount of time their husband/male partner is spending on their hobby.

Rosula · 17/03/2023 13:58

On what grounds is he going to divorce you? Disobedience?

Presumably on the grounds that the relationship has permanently broken down, which is the only ground he needs to demonstrate.

FuckNuggets · 17/03/2023 13:57

Tell him you'll give a few numbers of divorce lawyers. Any man that try's to tell you what can and can't do, should be divorced!

Minimummonday · 17/03/2023 13:55

It’s of course ultimately up to you what you do with you life. But he doesn’t have to come along for the ride. Personally, I find body building really repulsive and if my partner got into it as a lifestyle choice, then yes, I would leave. Neither of you are in the wrong you just sound incompatible now.

Naunet · 17/03/2023 13:54

First of all, well done OP on making such a massive change to your life, that’s seriously a huge achivement and if I was your partner I’d be so proud of you.

Secondly, I’m not sure why so many posters are going to great lengths to point out how unattractive competing body builders look. Yes, it’s not the most attractive look in the world, but so what? Why must everything revolve around being sexually pleasing? Who gives a fuck if you’ll be ‘less conventionally attractive’ for a few hours whilst pumped up and wearing a dark tan?? I really can’t understand why that’s even an issue.

As others are pointing out, if this was about you being away from family, obsessive etc, I’d understand, but you’ve said yourself you husband has more down time than you already, and he spends his at the pub drinking booze and making himself less conventionally attractive, but apparently that’s note worth of comment for some reason! However, as his issue is more down to being jealous and controling, he’s being a prick. You aren’t his property, you don’t exist for his pleasure. I’d go for it if I were you, if he wants to divorce you over something so petty, that you’ve really not lost much anyway.

Rollingaroundinmud · 17/03/2023 13:52

TheYearOfSmallThings · 17/03/2023 10:56

I am 99% thinking "Ooh, what a bastard - how dare he stand in the way of her goals?".

I am 1% thinking "Ooh, but if I had a DH who wanted to be sprayed orange and wear a sparkly speedo to use his extreme muscles to lift weights for an audience...I would die inside."

The question is would you hold your partner back if he wanted to be sprayed orange and walk around in sparkly speedos?

I can't hold people back I support my loved ones and vice versa. You live one life and then you're dead have fun and enjoy life. Can you imagine in your obituary what they would say about you I have to do one for my mum should I say she was controlled by my father because he didn't want to do it so she shouldn't? What a miserable existence.

StopStartStop · 17/03/2023 13:43

He's a dick. Do what you like.
I see it like this:
You've put in a lot of work on your body - admirable.
Time is passing. You'll never be this young again - do it now.
It's only reasonable to take/make the opportunities you want in life.

Maray1967 · 17/03/2023 13:43

Blobblobblob · 17/03/2023 09:55

If he's got valid concerns he needs to explain them properly and leave this 1950s shite in the past where it belongs.

Well said.

Jimboscott0115 · 17/03/2023 13:39

He sounds like a nob TBH.

There's a few reasons to not really like/want bodybuilding like the health issues that weight cutting can bring, the propensity of steroid use across the industry, the damage to the body it can cause but these are health concerns which I'd completely understand him wanting to talk through like normal adults, but his points? No, he's a combination of jealous and a bit of a sad sack by the sounds of it

discobrain · 17/03/2023 13:39

I'd tell him to fuck off.

Controlling arsehole.

2PintsOfCidernaBagofCrisps · 17/03/2023 13:34

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 17/03/2023 13:31

I wouldn’t like this. My friends husband competes and it impacts their whole life; all food is weighed, discussed, debated, no casual meals out or take aways, no spontaneous family days, family meals, sex life has suffered, availability to help with DC is next to nothing, money spent on this hobby is insane, he’s incapable of discussing anything but food or weights. It has a massive family impact.

That's definitely something that is overlooked...how BORING it is. It becomes all encompassing. All my DH talks about is the gym and food. Not just the miserable food that he has to eat just now but all this fantasy food that he's going to eat in 6 weeks. Yawnnnn.

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 17/03/2023 13:31

I wouldn’t like this. My friends husband competes and it impacts their whole life; all food is weighed, discussed, debated, no casual meals out or take aways, no spontaneous family days, family meals, sex life has suffered, availability to help with DC is next to nothing, money spent on this hobby is insane, he’s incapable of discussing anything but food or weights. It has a massive family impact.