Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ofsted needs to be abolished (Trigger warning)

387 replies

MrsMurphyIWish · 17/03/2023 09:29

Watched this heartbreaking story today:

www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m001k4r9

A headteacher took her own life as her school was rated inadequate. The pressures Ofsted creates are immense. Last week Ofsted were on strike Wednesday so decided to break protocol and rang schools Friday to conduct inspections on Monday - some schools were off for snow but that wasn’t a good enough reasons and even if the messages were picked up, that meant school staff would have worries over the weekend - some even going into school. Then there were schools who complained as these schools were given “extra notice”. Ofsted has created such a toxic work environment.

How has it come to this? A teacher who dedicated their life to education feels that a one word judgement meant life wasn’t worth living?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
larkstar · 24/03/2023 13:35

I very much doubt it will be abolished but drastic reform is required on the level of a paradigm shift. I don't know who schools aren't following following Flora Cooper's courageous lead and refusing to comply with OFSTED's request for an inspection - simply refuse them entry until a reformed system had been put in place.

Callmenat · 24/03/2023 13:28

It's right that schools and teachers are measured.

lieselotte · 19/03/2023 17:52

noblegiraffe · 17/03/2023 18:29

But that doesn't mean ofsted weren't in the wrong to point out the failings.

I don't think anyone disagrees with inspectors telling a school that their safeguarding paperwork is incomplete.

It's the form of the telling that's the issue.

According to the article in the Times, it was to do with a member of staff from overseas, so a full safeguarding check wasn't possible. There should have been evidence of a risk assessment. Really not enough for someone to take their life over!

Shinyandnew1 · 19/03/2023 10:13

I don't want a return to the days where each school just does its own thing

No, I don’t think that will ever happen.

JussathoB · 19/03/2023 10:07

Untitledsquatboulder · 19/03/2023 09:59

@JussathoB and that's exactly the problem. Some people got a good education years ago, and some people wasted years in years in classrooms being taught badly, incompletely or just plain wrongly and there was no comeback at all. Speaking as one of the latter I don't want a return to the days where each school just does its own thing, where the art teacher teaches her own special version of science, where the history is "taught" by copying out text books word for word.

I am all for reform of OFSTED, I have no problem at all with schools and teachers having to work to some quality assured standards.

I agree. Of course there should be a process for ensuring safety, high quality teaching, consistency.
what some of us are saying is that the current system of Ofsted is problematic and a lot of effort, time and resources are devoted to doing certain things which are not actually that helpful to the children

Untitledsquatboulder · 19/03/2023 09:59

@JussathoB and that's exactly the problem. Some people got a good education years ago, and some people wasted years in years in classrooms being taught badly, incompletely or just plain wrongly and there was no comeback at all. Speaking as one of the latter I don't want a return to the days where each school just does its own thing, where the art teacher teaches her own special version of science, where the history is "taught" by copying out text books word for word.

I am all for reform of OFSTED, I have no problem at all with schools and teachers having to work to some quality assured standards.

Shinyandnew1 · 19/03/2023 09:57

Trying to figure out exactly what Ofsted want to see is a huge industry.

Absolutely-I get countless emails about (eye-wateringly expensive) courses I could sign up to telling me how to get ‘Ofsted’ ready in my subject. Schools and academy trusts pay large sums of money for ‘mock’ inspections to try to keep their Good grading. There are lots of people out there making huge amounts of money out of the fear of Ofsted. The system is very broken.

I hope what happened at Caversham is the catalyst for real reform here.

JussathoB · 19/03/2023 09:46

noblegiraffe · 19/03/2023 09:41

Ofsted, a few years ago when Sean Harford was director, published their Ofsted Myths document which told teachers they didn't need to do detailed lesson plans, triple marking, all the stuff that teachers at the time were doing because they thought Ofsted wanted to see it. I think that genuinely helped.

Then the framework review changed to have the new focus on curriculum with the deep dives, and it's all gone utterly mad again.

Trying to figure out exactly what Ofsted want to see is a huge industry.

Sometimes senior leadership in schools are driving the myths. They look in a few exercise books as part of monitoring teaching and learning. It’s probably not their own subject and notes are partial because kids in school don’t spend the whole lesson writing. So senior leadership can’t tell what’s going on from the few exercise books, therefore devise all these systems of writing out complicated targets/improvements etc which might be good in theory but are a nightmare to actually carry out

LolaSmiles · 19/03/2023 09:41

And funny how, years ago, some of us managed to get a great education without the teachers writing all this nonsense down.
This ^^
I do think some closer scrutiny than there used to be is good. I think progress 8 is better than 5A*-C as plenty of children didn't reach their potential because schools were obsessed with the C/D borderline.
I'm also happy for the bar to be raised where schools can't get away with writing off children from disadvantaged areas or students with SEN. Thinking to my own school days, there were definitely some groups of students who weren't expected to achieve very much.

The current system is awful though and is leading to a culture of bloated management in schools all trying to justify their inflated salary.

noblegiraffe · 19/03/2023 09:41

Ofsted, a few years ago when Sean Harford was director, published their Ofsted Myths document which told teachers they didn't need to do detailed lesson plans, triple marking, all the stuff that teachers at the time were doing because they thought Ofsted wanted to see it. I think that genuinely helped.

Then the framework review changed to have the new focus on curriculum with the deep dives, and it's all gone utterly mad again.

Trying to figure out exactly what Ofsted want to see is a huge industry.

JussathoB · 19/03/2023 09:37

LolaSmiles · 19/03/2023 09:17

wehavenotomatoes
I think I agree in principle with some of your ideas, but there's some issues in taking the approach you outline.

Unfortunately it isn't the case that learning can be easily observed, which means schools spend a lot of time trying to make things obvious just in case a stranger shows up.

Some real examples I've seen expected as general expectations:

  1. Lesson objectives printed and glued in or on a sticker. The teacher must tick off what level every child has hit the objective for every lesson. (30 children x 4 or 5 lessons a day)
  1. Books marked daily for core subjects
  1. Tracking sheets or stickers on the front/in the cover of books whet teachers and students have to copy out of duplicate record assessment information.
  1. A piece of work has to be marked in detail, the pupil has to be given a personalised task after the piece of work, the pupil completes the personalised task, and that needs marking. Some also have a full redraft of the original piece of work.
  1. Written feedback for reception and year 1 children who cannot read yet.
  1. Assorted initiatives from SLT or aspiring SLT to prove that they've done something with the expensive Ofsted wants course that they attended. These must be printed and stuck in the books to show it's been done. The language is more for showing Ofsted you have used their buzz word than the children.

A lot of that is done daily, not because it's good for children, but because there's less than 24 hours notice for Ofsted and so everything has to be Ofsted ready at all times.

Ofsted ready does not mean providing a high quality education for children. Ofsted ready means having largely meaningless stuff in place on top of being a decent teacher.

We don't have to have special lesson plans on the day, but people will often have them because Ofsted have shown that they make it up as they go along and will conclude that if they didn't see A/B/C in the 10 minutes they're in then the teacher mustn't do it.

This is it. A massive bureaucratic exercise which teachers can’t say no to, for fear of not seeming to be hard working or conscientious enough or worse being considered unsatisfactory and losing their self esteem or their job. It’s ridiculous.
And funny how, years ago, some of us managed to get a great education without the teachers writing all this nonsense down.

Shinyandnew1 · 19/03/2023 09:21

Colourfingers2 · 19/03/2023 00:56

No it didn’t.

Where on earth did you get this idea from, @Colourfingers2?! A link would be great.

LolaSmiles · 19/03/2023 09:17

wehavenotomatoes
I think I agree in principle with some of your ideas, but there's some issues in taking the approach you outline.

Unfortunately it isn't the case that learning can be easily observed, which means schools spend a lot of time trying to make things obvious just in case a stranger shows up.

Some real examples I've seen expected as general expectations:

  1. Lesson objectives printed and glued in or on a sticker. The teacher must tick off what level every child has hit the objective for every lesson. (30 children x 4 or 5 lessons a day)
  1. Books marked daily for core subjects
  1. Tracking sheets or stickers on the front/in the cover of books whet teachers and students have to copy out of duplicate record assessment information.
  1. A piece of work has to be marked in detail, the pupil has to be given a personalised task after the piece of work, the pupil completes the personalised task, and that needs marking. Some also have a full redraft of the original piece of work.
  1. Written feedback for reception and year 1 children who cannot read yet.
  1. Assorted initiatives from SLT or aspiring SLT to prove that they've done something with the expensive Ofsted wants course that they attended. These must be printed and stuck in the books to show it's been done. The language is more for showing Ofsted you have used their buzz word than the children.

A lot of that is done daily, not because it's good for children, but because there's less than 24 hours notice for Ofsted and so everything has to be Ofsted ready at all times.

Ofsted ready does not mean providing a high quality education for children. Ofsted ready means having largely meaningless stuff in place on top of being a decent teacher.

We don't have to have special lesson plans on the day, but people will often have them because Ofsted have shown that they make it up as they go along and will conclude that if they didn't see A/B/C in the 10 minutes they're in then the teacher mustn't do it.

MrsHamlet · 19/03/2023 09:03

Notice is less than 24 hours. And got multiple reasons, it cannot be less than that.

wehavenotomatoes · 19/03/2023 08:49

@LolaSmiles yes absolutely.

And I would take away the notice, whether two days or a weekend or whatever. Teachers shouldn't be going back and fake marking or making special lesson plans or anything else for them. They should be there to see what provision is there FOR THE ACTUAL CHILDREN.
If the marking is so poor, over an extended period that it's impacted outcomes, then it should impact judgement and no one should be allowed to fake that. If not, then judge based on what the children actually experience, verbal feedback, conversations, peer marking, not stupid stamps and stickers etc.
ditto lesson planning. Either a lesson is planned or it isn't, and that can be judged by watching a lesson and seeing the outcomes. It doesn't need power points or school pro formas - fine if that's what the teacher wants to use to help themselves day to day anyway and happens to hand them to the inspector, but if someone is an experienced professional with half the content in their head, that should only be judged negatively if it impacts children negatively.
Then within their 'satisfactory' reports they could put a lot more formative feedback about what they appreciated and what could be improved, not a pointless page of numbers.

pimplebum · 19/03/2023 06:48

My partner is on anti depressants due to ofsted pressure which stated to be put on two years before the inspection , now it's over they are physically really run down and sick - all the work done does not Benefit the kids one bit

OxanaVorontsova · 19/03/2023 03:42

I endured my first Ofsted inspection before labour won the election so it was definitely John Major.

Maximo2 · 19/03/2023 03:09

onefile.co.uk/explore/why-was-ofsted-introduced/

Labour, my arse.

Colourfingers2 · 19/03/2023 00:56

noblegiraffe · 18/03/2023 23:56

Ofsted came in under John Major. What a bizarre thing to try to blame this on Labour.

No it didn’t.

noblegiraffe · 18/03/2023 23:56

Ofsted came in under John Major. What a bizarre thing to try to blame this on Labour.

saraclara · 18/03/2023 23:22

Colourfingers2 · 18/03/2023 22:54

Ofstead was dreamt up by Tony Blair’s government. Did anything good ever come out of that shower?

There was nothing wrong with the idea when it was brought in thirty-odd years ago. My school was one of the first in the country to be inspected, and the procedure was massively different from what it is now.

It's more recent governments that have turned it into the cruel and punitive thing that it is now, and have used it as a tool to benefit their friends who run Academy trusts and to get one over on local authorities (especially those with Labour majorities)

Colourfingers2 · 18/03/2023 22:54

Ofstead was dreamt up by Tony Blair’s government. Did anything good ever come out of that shower?

Maximo2 · 18/03/2023 22:47

NAHT and NEU are writing an emergency motion.

Maximo2 · 18/03/2023 22:46

Screenshots of the above Facebook link

Ofsted needs to be abolished (Trigger warning)
Ofsted needs to be abolished (Trigger warning)