Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ofsted needs to be abolished (Trigger warning)

387 replies

MrsMurphyIWish · 17/03/2023 09:29

Watched this heartbreaking story today:

www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m001k4r9

A headteacher took her own life as her school was rated inadequate. The pressures Ofsted creates are immense. Last week Ofsted were on strike Wednesday so decided to break protocol and rang schools Friday to conduct inspections on Monday - some schools were off for snow but that wasn’t a good enough reasons and even if the messages were picked up, that meant school staff would have worries over the weekend - some even going into school. Then there were schools who complained as these schools were given “extra notice”. Ofsted has created such a toxic work environment.

How has it come to this? A teacher who dedicated their life to education feels that a one word judgement meant life wasn’t worth living?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
saraclara · 25/03/2023 16:46

Maybe it would have helped if the governors had come clean to the school community immediately. They must have known this finding and their inadequacy would ensure the school was inadequate. The head knew too. So management of the situation should have been better.

@TizerorFizz they weren't allowed to. That's part of the problem, and it's been referred to many times in these OFSTED threads. The head wasn't even allowed to tell her family. The governor's couldn't tell anyone until the report was published last week

cantkeepawayforever · 25/03/2023 16:44

I think anyone who has had a DC in school has observed the service. We buy British food so we consume that service

I started off by thinking this was a REALLY odd analogy. Then I decided there were in fact some similarities. Buying a single pack of chicken with a ‘British’ label on it gives me an extremely limited view of the process that led to that point for that bird and how it extrapolated to that for all British meat (from breeding to hatching; to housing, feeding and exercise; to cleanliness at every stage; to transportation, slaughter and butchery; to packaging lines and cold chain). Equally, being a parent of a child in a particular school gives me very little genuine insight into the reality of their day 9-3, let alone that of every other member of their school (adult and child) or any information at all about education elsewhere in the town, region or country.

So yes, your observation of your single child is analogous to my purchase if a single pack of chicken. What us it telling you about education in this country as a whole, any more than my purchase of chicken is telling me about farming?

LolaSmiles · 25/03/2023 16:12

All opinions are valid, unless they're serving teachers, school support staff, and school leaders, in which case they have to stop complaining about things.

TizerorFizz
Of course schools do that with banners. It's a problem with the culture that Ofsted in its current form has created.

I don't trust the Oftsed gradings of at least half the schools in my area. Some have outstanding that's obviously for political agendas, and other great schools have been downgraded because they're not sufficiently doing whatever was in fashion.
As a parent and a teacher, one of the last things I would use to choose a school is an Ofsted grade because I know that they're often not worth the paper they're written on.

noblegiraffe · 25/03/2023 14:53

I think anyone who has had a DC in school has observed the service.

🤦‍♀️

All opinions are of value in this debate.

🤦‍♀️ 🤦‍♀️

TizerorFizz · 25/03/2023 14:17

I think anyone who has had a DC in school has observed the service. We buy British food so we consume that service. I live in the countryside, so I know something about farming. I’m the DD of a farmer. I’m a former school governor. I worked in education for decades. I also don’t believe these forums are a cross section of teachers either. Neither do I believe forums are expert only territory. It’s not a an echo chamber and neither should free speech be closed down. All opinions are of value in this debate.

I think we all know there are some issues with ofsted but some are grossly overstated. I heard a load of guff on the radio yesterday from about 30 years ago. It’s meaningless. I do think 2 grades below good is ok but only two above is too few. All need descriptors such as “Good with outstanding features” for example.

Around here, outstanding schools have big banners printed to advertise the fact. Plenty of celebration. It’s also fairly rare for a good school to not meet its legal obligation on safeguarding and the governors not to know. Maybe it would have helped if the governors had come clean to the school community immediately. They must have known this finding and their inadequacy would ensure the school was inadequate. The head knew too. So management of the situation should have been better.

babybythesea · 25/03/2023 13:51

TizerorFizz · 25/03/2023 10:38

@Puzzledandpissedoff I agree. Her death has unleashed all this fury. For whatever reason, the school failed safeguarding. A few years ago, MN would have been appalled at this. So perhaps a look into why this happened would be appropriate because for an experienced head, it’s an alarming oversight. With all
the training at all levels in schools, it seems reckless.

@RedToothBrush I agree. I think, when talking about pressurised jobs and health issues, it is important to consider other professions. Head Teachers are well paid when compared to the average farmer who is self employed. Farming is very tied to government policy and sadly stupid voters with Brexit. Teaching has its own issues but doesn’t seem to recognise that others have a tough time too. I also make no apology for mentioning farmer suicides. Let’s have a debate about stress at work overall. Blaming ofsted seems a stretch too far when the issue was safeguarding.

One of the issues with teaching vs other professions is that far more people think they know about teaching. I’m in Education. I know about it, so I comment on those threads. I don’t comment in detail on farming threads because I don’t know anything about it. I am not qualified to hold an opinion worth listening to.
However, in general, people have been to school so they think they know all
about it. People send children into school so they think they know all about it. They then put those opinions out there.

Teachers leave at 3.30.
Teachers say no we don’t. We leave at this time.
People jump on it and say “teachers are always moaning. Other people work long hours too you know.

What I tend to see is teachers trying to put people right who then accuse them of whining. Would you rather teachers didn’t correct anyone? Because it’s the children who will suffer in the end, and no one wants that.

noblegiraffe · 25/03/2023 10:41

Literally no end to the whataboutery though.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/03/2023 10:41

Teachers and headteachers don't need to wait for an inquest to know that Ofsted is a huge problem

I agree, and there's nothing wrong with a conversation about improving Ofsted - which even they acknowledged in their statement yesterday

So it just seems a shame that so many posts are be larded with "A Headteacher's died" and similar, as if weaponising this will help anything

TizerorFizz · 25/03/2023 10:38

@Puzzledandpissedoff I agree. Her death has unleashed all this fury. For whatever reason, the school failed safeguarding. A few years ago, MN would have been appalled at this. So perhaps a look into why this happened would be appropriate because for an experienced head, it’s an alarming oversight. With all
the training at all levels in schools, it seems reckless.

@RedToothBrush I agree. I think, when talking about pressurised jobs and health issues, it is important to consider other professions. Head Teachers are well paid when compared to the average farmer who is self employed. Farming is very tied to government policy and sadly stupid voters with Brexit. Teaching has its own issues but doesn’t seem to recognise that others have a tough time too. I also make no apology for mentioning farmer suicides. Let’s have a debate about stress at work overall. Blaming ofsted seems a stretch too far when the issue was safeguarding.

cantkeepawayforever · 25/03/2023 10:30

Ofsted grades, if they are to have so much impact, should be both reproducible and backed up by a robust quality assurance / review system.

Reproducible - a different team of inspectors seeing the same school should give the same grade (like eg SATs writing moderators have to be trained and assessed to check that they give the same grade to the same portfolio of work and there are then some random standardisation checks). How often do Ofsted do such ‘double’ checks, where inspectors view the same evidence and the grade they would give is checked?

Reproducibility is improved if the number of grades is reduced. A simpler system of ‘meeting standards / not meeting standards’ would be much better, and there could even be a ‘second level check’ by senior inspectors for marginal cases before the result was published.

Quality assurance and review - Ofsted themselves have agreed that their complaints procedure is not fit for purpose. ‘Second level checks’, scrutiny of evidence, reviews after complaints / feedback that actually change grades, robust code of conduct for inspectors that schools can hold them to - all of these could actually improve public confidence in Ofsted, not undermine it.

noblegiraffe · 25/03/2023 10:29

The death of the headteacher sparked this outpouring, but it should be pretty clear to anyone reading that it isn't just about that.

Teachers and headteachers don't need to wait for an inquest to know that Ofsted is a huge problem.

If you think they should, you're really not listening.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/03/2023 10:23

Has there been an inquest yet?

No there hasn't - they often take 3-6 months, though some can be quicker - which is why some of us prefer to wait for the results rather than leap to weaponising the HT's sad death

noblegiraffe · 25/03/2023 10:22

Education was the last labour governments big policy. 'Education, education, education'. Politicians know control of education is about shaping the next generation and future political support.

Are you suggesting that education is somehow a political priority? Or a media priority?

RedToothBrush · 25/03/2023 10:15

Florenz · 25/03/2023 09:41

Farmers aren't constantly in the media, including public forums like Mumsnet, moaning about how hard they work and how hard done by they are. Probably because they are too busy actually working.

There needs to be rigourous audits and inspections of schools to ensure educational standards are being met and to weed out teachers who can't hack it. No they should not be confidential. The public pays BILLIONS for education, you can't take our money and refuse to let us know what is being done with it, and how well what is being done is being done. No, the audits cannot be "consistent", the world changes, teachers have to be prepared to change to. Otherwise we're kicking kids out into the working world of 10 or 20 years ago instead of the world of today.

Schoolkids are tested and examined, graded and ranked all the time. Is it stressful? Yes. But it's absolutely necessary. Because they and we need some way to quantify and measure how well they are learning. Just as we need some way to quantify and measure how well teachers are teaching.

Farmers aren't in the media, because the media has for years deemed it uninteresting and of low political interest/power. It's been deemed 'minor interest'.

Then comes Jeremy Clarkson on his tractor to give Amazon their highest viewing figures. Ever.

Which kinda shows that the media is misreading this.

Why don't farmers spend all day on the internet moaning? Possibly because they work even longer hours than teachers, for even less return.

Plus living in rural areas, internet reception and provision is second rate (a hidden political issue in itself that we have broadband poverty). And where provision is poor, there's less awareness of how to use social media to your advantage...

Education was the last labour governments big policy. 'Education, education, education'. Politicians know control of education is about shaping the next generation and future political support.

Also, theres is nothing like a cute kid to sell newspapers / drive click bait. It's all about the money...

Whip things up into a frenzy and everyone will have an opinion on the subject (Jezza is proving this, with farming as it goes).

Farming needs to show cute animals being cuddled by children more and needs to recruit its own brand of NIMBY to fight on the media fronts. It will never compete with education though for one other very simple reason: there are a lot less farmers in this country compared to children and their parents. MN is bigger, has more journalists and politicians on it than FarmersWeekly Forum (or whatever the equivalent is). I suspect if you go on that forum you WOULD find a whole bunch of farmers 'whinging'. We just aren't aware of it on MN because the social circle isn't overlapping with media luvvies and ad sellers.

I wish people understood how media worked some days... and how politics is linked to the media.

RedToothBrush · 25/03/2023 10:02

LolaSmiles · 25/03/2023 07:15

TizerorFizz
The thing is that if a group of farmers had a thread about the challenges of farmers, I highly doubt you'd get the same sort of posts that Ofsted threads get. People would get on with talking about the problems, discussing what need sto change, not saying 'but other people have to get up early and work long days for little pay, don't get what you're complaining about "

If someone from another industry created a thread saying their audit or inspection system isn't fit for purpose and it needs scrapping so it can be replaced by something that is appropriate and transparent, the thread wouldn't get filled with people saying "so what, other jobs have bad systems, why are you moaning about it, what have you got to hide".

Hidden injustice, economic and social pressures of farming just highlight how farming isn't regarded as a vote winner nor is on the immediate radar of the public.

I actually think this is changing with awareness of climate change, the cost of food and one badly dressed middle aged man with a reputation for having a big gob has seen fit to make it his personal mission on Amazon.

Awful industry conditions across sectors being pitted against each other as 'which is more important and stressful' isn't useful. It doesn't stop the stress, it doesn't improve lives and it doesn't make taxes and costs go down.

Shinyandnew1 · 25/03/2023 09:59

No, the audits cannot be "consistent"

I don’t mean that Ofsted in 1998 should be the same as ofsted in 2023. I mean that Ofsted at my school and Ofsted at the very similar school down the road the week before shouldn’t be the absolute polar opposite of each other.

Ofsted inspections should be consistent.

noblegiraffe · 25/03/2023 09:51

Poster "I want to know what's going on in schools"

Teachers "Here's what's going on in schools"

Poster "God, teachers are always moaning"

Hmm
Florenz · 25/03/2023 09:41

Farmers aren't constantly in the media, including public forums like Mumsnet, moaning about how hard they work and how hard done by they are. Probably because they are too busy actually working.

There needs to be rigourous audits and inspections of schools to ensure educational standards are being met and to weed out teachers who can't hack it. No they should not be confidential. The public pays BILLIONS for education, you can't take our money and refuse to let us know what is being done with it, and how well what is being done is being done. No, the audits cannot be "consistent", the world changes, teachers have to be prepared to change to. Otherwise we're kicking kids out into the working world of 10 or 20 years ago instead of the world of today.

Schoolkids are tested and examined, graded and ranked all the time. Is it stressful? Yes. But it's absolutely necessary. Because they and we need some way to quantify and measure how well they are learning. Just as we need some way to quantify and measure how well teachers are teaching.

LolaSmiles · 25/03/2023 09:26

I think so noblegiraffe.

There's something about education where people would rather get into irrelevant whataboutery than engage with discussions for change that could change the system for the better.

noblegiraffe · 25/03/2023 09:23

Did a poster really just look up farmer suicides so that they could one-up teachers? Shock

The depths that some people will fall to to try to minimise any discussions of issues facing teacher is incredible.

LolaSmiles · 25/03/2023 07:38

Has it occurred to you that there's a reason why recruitment and retention are an issue though?
The system badly needs change in several ways because it's not working and children are the ones who lose out.

I've never understood it when school staff point out problems in their sector, they're always met with:
But this other sector also has an ineffective audit system
But other jobs work long hours
But other jobs have paperwork
But other jobs are stressful
But why are you complaining

There's something about education that means some people are incapable of saying:
"This is affecting/going to affect my children, maybe we do need to make sure that there's appropriate funding and assessments for children with SEN"
"This is affecting/going to affect my children, maybe we should have an audit regime that allows my children's teachers to focus on teaching and not making stickers to duplicate information on exercise books"
"Now you've highlighted how schools are picking up the pieces from cuts to other services, I've realised we need better funding for CAMHS, more EdPsyc sessions, better support around families who need it so that children can thrive in school. That way schools can focus on educating instead of trying to be all things".
"Children deserve to be taught be qualified teachers and qualified subject specialists at secondary. Let's start to look at what would be needed to ensure that happens".

Rarely any of that, just stop complaining. I don't understand why anyone wouldn't want a better system for their children.

Callmenat · 25/03/2023 07:30

LolaSmiles · 25/03/2023 07:15

TizerorFizz
The thing is that if a group of farmers had a thread about the challenges of farmers, I highly doubt you'd get the same sort of posts that Ofsted threads get. People would get on with talking about the problems, discussing what need sto change, not saying 'but other people have to get up early and work long days for little pay, don't get what you're complaining about "

If someone from another industry created a thread saying their audit or inspection system isn't fit for purpose and it needs scrapping so it can be replaced by something that is appropriate and transparent, the thread wouldn't get filled with people saying "so what, other jobs have bad systems, why are you moaning about it, what have you got to hide".

It's the constant moaning about everything though.

LolaSmiles · 25/03/2023 07:15

TizerorFizz
The thing is that if a group of farmers had a thread about the challenges of farmers, I highly doubt you'd get the same sort of posts that Ofsted threads get. People would get on with talking about the problems, discussing what need sto change, not saying 'but other people have to get up early and work long days for little pay, don't get what you're complaining about "

If someone from another industry created a thread saying their audit or inspection system isn't fit for purpose and it needs scrapping so it can be replaced by something that is appropriate and transparent, the thread wouldn't get filled with people saying "so what, other jobs have bad systems, why are you moaning about it, what have you got to hide".

TizerorFizz · 24/03/2023 23:04

Has there been an inquest yet? We don’t actually know all the circumstances. Just reported thoughts. Plenty of people sadly die where work is a contributing factor. DH’s company had a similar tragedy but the inquest found it wasn’t the job. This is obviously a tragedy but it doesn’t mean the job of being a head is not doable. Or that inspection needs an overhaul. I have no doubt the governors wonder why they didn’t know about the safeguarding shortcomings . It’s their responsibility too.

Farmers’ suicides run at 44 a year just for comparison. So let’s be understanding of all who feel overwhelmed.

User8646382 · 24/03/2023 21:32

Florenz · 24/03/2023 18:27

I don't know what teachers are moaning about. They need to be monitored and audited to make sure standard are maintained. There isn't a job out there where that doesn't happen. What is it with teachers? Why are they constantly complaining about literally everything? Just go to job, do your work, come home, go to bed, get up the next day and do it all again. Get paid at the end of the month. If you hate your job quit and do something else. The same as everyone else does. They are not unique. They are not special. They do a hard job but so do many other people, and they are paid quite well, get plenty of time off and get a generous pension.

Look, no one should feel like they have to kill themselves because they are too afraid to face the public humiliation and shame of a less than perfect Ofsted report. Yes, children have to be safeguarded, but let’s keep things in perspective. People are human, mistakes happen. It’s not like the teachers were subjecting the kids at this school to satanic ritual abuse, it was one missing overseas police check. Why the need for all the drama with the emotive language and labelling? What does it achieve except to make Ofsted feel important and encourage the parents to get the pitchforks out? As if the gang mentality of the parents isn’t frightening enough in the best of circumstances.

Ofsted reports should be confidential. That way, no one would have to suffer public humiliation or be made to face a baying mob, but Ofsted would still retain their powers. It’s absolutely fair, and if they won’t consider it, the reason why is obvious: they’re not in it for the sake of improving schools, they’re in it to bully and intimidate. They’re in it for the power, and it’s twisted and wrong.

Swipe left for the next trending thread