Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ofsted needs to be abolished (Trigger warning)

387 replies

MrsMurphyIWish · 17/03/2023 09:29

Watched this heartbreaking story today:

www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m001k4r9

A headteacher took her own life as her school was rated inadequate. The pressures Ofsted creates are immense. Last week Ofsted were on strike Wednesday so decided to break protocol and rang schools Friday to conduct inspections on Monday - some schools were off for snow but that wasn’t a good enough reasons and even if the messages were picked up, that meant school staff would have worries over the weekend - some even going into school. Then there were schools who complained as these schools were given “extra notice”. Ofsted has created such a toxic work environment.

How has it come to this? A teacher who dedicated their life to education feels that a one word judgement meant life wasn’t worth living?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Spamalam · 17/03/2023 11:37

I’m a childminder and OFSTED causes me so much stress that I’ve considered giving up for that sole reason. Many childminders already have. Our inspection is a little different but an awful lot of pressure. They’re with me for around 5/6 hours and I’m a lone worker so all the scrutiny is on me. We are inspected in the same way a pre-school is but obviously a pre-school has more staff and children.

When you have an inspection you are at the mercy of someone making a judgment on a snapshot. That person could be in the foulest of moods which flows over whilst they are making that judgment. There is no consistency between inspectors. OFSTED gives no advice and if someone makes a complaint about an inspector they close ranks and nothing happens. Some inspectors are lovely however some are just intent on tripping you up all the time.

settings and schools are losing valued people because of the way OFSTED operates.

Politicalnamechange · 17/03/2023 11:34

Thay poor woman

What I don't understand with schools and Ofsted though is why schools need "hours and days of stressful preparation" for an inspection? To me that implies you know you're doing things wrong and will be picked up on them. Is it not the case that all the things you're frantically putting into place should be routine daily stuff that is done as part of your working day? If someone went and audited my work you'd know exactly what was going on and where it was going to on any given day. Isn't that the case for everyone? Maybe I just don't understand teaching.

cantkeepawayforever · 17/03/2023 11:31

As a trivial example, a school I worked in had a very high % of Traveller pupils. Our attendance statistics were, as a result of the cultural norms of that community, less good than a school that catered only to a settled community would be, despite us putting an enormous amount of time, money and support into improving them.

Luckily, we had an Ofsted inspector who judged the school in its context. He noted that despite having attendance below the ‘theoretical’ threshold for failing on that aspect of the framework, we had much higher Traveller attendance and engagement than average for that group nationally, and that we were going above and beyond in what we were doing to improve it.

That’s what I mean by ‘in context’.

MrsMurphyIWish · 17/03/2023 11:30

I’ve been teaching for 23 years and have been though 5 inspections in that time. The last eight years I have been subjected to annual mock-steds. It’s not just the inspection itself, it’s the toxicity Ofsted generates which is the issue.

OP posts:
cantkeepawayforever · 17/03/2023 11:23

Untitledsquatboulder · 17/03/2023 11:07

@cantkeepawayforever "in the context of its community" was used for very many years for providing a substandard education for the masses. So no.

So you are saying that a selective school with 2% PP and 2% SEN should be looked at in exactly the same way by inspectors as a school with 40% PP and 45% SEN?

Under the previous Ofsted framework (the one used for many of the inspections in the database), there was an exceptionally tight relationship between ‘low PP’ and ‘High Ofsted’ - which is obviously wrong, because if Ofsted is of any use at all, it should be based on ‘the educational and care work being done’, not the nature of the intake.

Yes, schools should have high expectations of all pupils. Yes, obviously, funding should and must flow to the schools (and the support services that they refer in to) with most challenging intakes to reflect the much harder work they need to do in SEN support, pastoral support, meeting the physical and mental health needs if their pupils and tge families they come from. But proposing that inspections should turn a blind eye to the nature of a school’s intake is wrong.

Butteryflakycrust83 · 17/03/2023 11:19

I do not pay any attention to Ofted anymore, after the nursery I withdrew DD from for serious safeguarding received a GOOD, and her current nursery so are just on top of its shit, caring, wonderful setting received inadequate on what was basically an admin nitpick.

ChestnutGrove · 17/03/2023 11:19

ENTnightmare · 17/03/2023 11:17

Don't you think though that results and achievements tell how well a school is performing? Of course a safeguarding inspection is one thing but in my experience those inspecting have no clue how a classroom works.

Not necessarily. That can be down to parental support and tutoring. I'm glad they look at bullying, racism, homophobia and not just results

Rowthe · 17/03/2023 11:19

StaySpicy · 17/03/2023 10:12

A friend who's support staff had her school rung last Friday for a Monday/ Tuesday inspection. She said the teachers were in school for 10 hours on Saturday to get things ready!! Plus more time on the Sunday making books and planning lessons.

Support staff were told they could go in if they wanted but there was no money for overtime. My friend didn't go in. But she felt a bit guilty. Imagine feeling guilty because you don't want to go to work for free!

The whole thing just sounds ridiculous. I have no knowledge of how public sector are observed and judged. Does a GP have inspectors observing them in a patient appointment? Do police officers have someone following them around for an hour in order to make a judgement about the police station? I know teachers have this, but do other people?

Theres the CQC for GP surgeries same crap.
Stress all round and people dread the inspections and spend hours preparing etc

Chickenly · 17/03/2023 11:18

As a former teacher, the biggest problem with Ofsted is that their metrics make no sense. What schools are judged on is almost entirely irrelevant to whether or not the school is actually any damn good. For example, Ofsted like schools to have a computer drive with every lesson on it uploaded with PowerPoint and worksheets etc. Schools have to have decided why they’re teaching it in that order and why they teach physics in term one and chemistry in term three etc. BUT Ofsted also need you to show that teachers aren’t even fucking using the exact fucking PowerPoint and worksheets from the bloody computer drive because each class is unique so you need to show that staff spent time creating lesson resources and uploading them to the drive for them to download and edit for each class and explain why they edited them in that way.

I taught science. I didn’t need a power point because I could teach it off the top of my head, draw diagrams, use movement or mini-whiteboards etc - but I had to have a PowerPoint so that Ofsted could look at it. My PowerPoint had to say things like “mini-whiteboard exercise” so that Ofsted knew I was doing something… the whole thing is just a rimming exercise.

Every school and every teacher up and down the country are having to personally make the exact same lesson because Ofsted will fail any school who hasn’t made bespoke lessons. It’s a complete and total waste of everyone’s time. They completely ignore the fact that schools are actually there to educate children - teachers know full well that when asked “why are you teaching them X?” then the absolute worst answer is “because they’ll fail their GCSE otherwise” because Ofsted are actively against teachings students how to get qualifications.

Ofsted are worse than useless - they’re actively detrimental. Ofsted had no issue with a school locking a child outside naked as punishment but have an issue with teachers using worksheets made by a different teacher who’s teaching exactly the same lesson. That’s how ridiculous their metrics are.

ENTnightmare · 17/03/2023 11:17

AnneElliott · 17/03/2023 10:45

I agrée with @Untitledsquatboulder reform may well be what is needed but abolishing an inspection programme will not raise standards.

Certainly the state of some fire authorities was pretty dire when inspection was brought back.

Also agree that maybe an overall rating isn't helpful. Police and fire have 'pillars' where they are assessed against different outcomes such as effectiveness, efficiency and people. Certainly from what I read on here and hear in RL some schools should certainly be marked down on how some SLT and Heads treat the staff.

Don't you think though that results and achievements tell how well a school is performing? Of course a safeguarding inspection is one thing but in my experience those inspecting have no clue how a classroom works.

ChestnutGrove · 17/03/2023 11:16

Ive not listened to the recording in the link posted. I think they should listen to teachers about how ofsted could be improved.

I do think it's good that they now ask kids about bullying, racism, homophobia etc. Sometimes outstanding selective schools like the Bacup grammar are downgraded because of entrenched problems with the school community that have been ignored.

spanieleyes · 17/03/2023 11:14

In my authority, the locality lead comes into schools each term with a different focus, so SEND, attendance, maths, safeguarding etc. They spend the day going through everything relevant, provide items for improvement and positives. The following term, they check up on the areas identified for improvement and the new focus areas. Supportive, helpful and not life threatening.
OFSTED, alternatively had us all in tears, even though we came out with a Good.

Emerald237 · 17/03/2023 11:14

Untitledsquatboulder · 17/03/2023 10:35

I'm not against reforming OFSTED but I would not support the return to a lack of scrutiny about what happens in schools and no accountability over year after year of children being failed.

In NI we have been taking part in action short of strike for years, I can't remember how many exactly but it it is six or more years anyway. As part of this we have not been taking part in inspections by ETI (our version of OFSTED), we refuse the inspectors at the door.

We have to take part in safeguarding inspections and the inspectors can only look around the school, receive the safeguarding folder and speak to some P6 pupils.

Funnily enough, grades and attainment have never been better. I have worked under a couple of principals who are ETI inspections and I can honestly say they were the worst schools I taught in, every box was ticked but the schools and and the kids had no warmth or personality.

noblegiraffe · 17/03/2023 11:09

Our school was inspected in March 2020, the week before lockdown

Utterly ridiculous. What could they have possibly learned from that, schools were in chaos.

Untitledsquatboulder · 17/03/2023 11:07

@cantkeepawayforever "in the context of its community" was used for very many years for providing a substandard education for the masses. So no.

noblegiraffe · 17/03/2023 11:06

I don’t think anyone is suggesting that schools shouldn’t have some sort of monitoring regime, particularly as one of the problems in the school in the OP was that it had been allowed to go 13 years without inspection.

It’s the extremely high stakes and unsupportive nature of inspections that is the issue. Because it’s only every 4 years or so that’s also a problem as it distorts everything around it. Yearly light-touch inspections would be less stressful and more useful.

Yitus · 17/03/2023 11:05

Our school was inspected in March 2020, the week before lockdown, when everyone was really stressed and lots of people were already staying at home. It was downgraded from good to requires improvement, and hasn’t been inspected again since, so has been stuck with that label and become the school that parents avoid locally based on it, even although other schools seem to have more problems.

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 17/03/2023 11:03

I think that there should be some kind of regular inspection/quality check. I went to school in 70s and 80s and the standard of teaching was frankly shocking.
But I agree that it isn't great. I briefly went into teaching in an FE college, from a professional training background. I left within 18 months.

LakieLady · 17/03/2023 10:55

Ofsted was the reason a London borough lost a very committed, talented and hardworking primary head when my friend opted to take early retirement.

She said it had got to the point where the LEA cared more about the Ofsted report than anything that actually went on in the school.

It's shit, imo.

cantkeepawayforever · 17/03/2023 10:48

A basic check of ‘is this school, in the context of its community, providing a decent standard of education and care?’ with a brief of ‘carry on if you are’ and ‘instant access to all necessary support and development if you aren’t’ should be sufficient.

Particularly if the checks were undertaken by experienced education experts who were then responsible for co-ordinating / providing follow up support, not delivering a snap judgement then waltzing away.

I was at school pre-Ofsted and pre-National Curriculum and there was some seriously poor stuff going on. A light touch and supportive oversight regime, where the vast majority ‘pass’ and the few who don’t are then heavily supported, would perhaps avoid the worst extremes of both systems.

AnneElliott · 17/03/2023 10:45

I agrée with @Untitledsquatboulder reform may well be what is needed but abolishing an inspection programme will not raise standards.

Certainly the state of some fire authorities was pretty dire when inspection was brought back.

Also agree that maybe an overall rating isn't helpful. Police and fire have 'pillars' where they are assessed against different outcomes such as effectiveness, efficiency and people. Certainly from what I read on here and hear in RL some schools should certainly be marked down on how some SLT and Heads treat the staff.

IfYouDontAsk · 17/03/2023 10:35

It’s always struck me as unhelpful for schools to have overall ratings. I think it would be better for the reports to just rate the individual areas and not give an overall score. Frankly, if parents can’t be bothered to read the full report to find out how their child’s school is performing, that’s on them.

Though the more I hear about Ofsted inspections, the more I think they just shouldn’t exist full stop. The amount of stress they cause to already overworked school staff is awful. I’m not sure what the answer is but the current system isn't fair on teachers.

Untitledsquatboulder · 17/03/2023 10:35

I'm not against reforming OFSTED but I would not support the return to a lack of scrutiny about what happens in schools and no accountability over year after year of children being failed.

PolkaDotMankini · 17/03/2023 10:34

My DD's school lost an innovative and hardworking head to a mental breakdown after Ofsted rated the school inadequate with safeguarding concerns. He had totally transformed the school and I felt - and feel - incredibly sorry for him and all the staff. I was so cross I wrote a complaint to Ofsted and CC'ed the school but just got a generic response back.

Since then, staff turnover has been ridiculous. I can understand why - imagine working your butt off for years to turn a school around, have positive interim inspections, only for someone to come in for 8 hours and tell the world that your school is crap and dangerous for children. Appalling.

Ofsted should be there to support schools and help them improve, not put them under so much pressure that morale collapses and teachers kill themselves.

BogRollBOGOF · 17/03/2023 10:28

Evidence for OFSTED is a significant driver behind increases in workload that don't really make much practical difference to improving what goes in in the classroom.

Schools have turned into a dog eat dog world of political survival trickling from management down. The academies take-over policy rarely solves issues deep down and tends to shunt issues from one school to another in a cycle. The "zero tolerance" mentality that many academies adopt when taking on a new school is harmful to students and staff. Both benefit most from stability, but the politics imposed through the OFSTED system is the antithesis of that.

Schools need to be safe. They need to educate young people and there does need to be an accountability and feedback process, but OFSTED is not it and the stakes are too punitive.

Swipe left for the next trending thread