Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ofsted needs to be abolished (Trigger warning)

387 replies

MrsMurphyIWish · 17/03/2023 09:29

Watched this heartbreaking story today:

www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m001k4r9

A headteacher took her own life as her school was rated inadequate. The pressures Ofsted creates are immense. Last week Ofsted were on strike Wednesday so decided to break protocol and rang schools Friday to conduct inspections on Monday - some schools were off for snow but that wasn’t a good enough reasons and even if the messages were picked up, that meant school staff would have worries over the weekend - some even going into school. Then there were schools who complained as these schools were given “extra notice”. Ofsted has created such a toxic work environment.

How has it come to this? A teacher who dedicated their life to education feels that a one word judgement meant life wasn’t worth living?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Shanksponyorbust · 17/03/2023 12:43

It’s important to have some scrutiny though there needs to be a review of how and when that happens.

On the when, I know of a secondary school still dining off their outstanding ofsted from 2009. 14 years ago! There will be others in similar situation and no wonder some of these schools go from outstanding to inadequate when they haven’t been looked at by ofsted for all that time.

HubertTheGoat · 17/03/2023 12:42

Yitus · 17/03/2023 11:05

Our school was inspected in March 2020, the week before lockdown, when everyone was really stressed and lots of people were already staying at home. It was downgraded from good to requires improvement, and hasn’t been inspected again since, so has been stuck with that label and become the school that parents avoid locally based on it, even although other schools seem to have more problems.

Exactly, or you could be inspected in the week before the summer holidays or the two days before Christmas. You are expected to drop your Christmas parties or whatever and make up some lessons to teach so they can be observed. My 7 year olds were expected to talk in detail, to a man they'd never met, about history lessons they'd had before the summer holidays, even though it was October. One of the children hadn't even been there for them as he'd been off himself on a term-time holiday! Their not being able to talk about it was part of the reason we went down to RI. Ofsted also wouldn't accept seeing physical evidence that something was in place (e.g. look in the children's books and see), they wanted to see a bit of paper that talked checks that had been undertaken. The whole process is bonkers.

Bunnycat101 · 17/03/2023 12:36

There is clearly something not quite right with the fear ofsted generates in schools. I don’t know the sector but have enough friends who are teachers to see the worry in them. But, I also think the concept of inspections and a degree of scrutiny is probably important. I don’t understand how some schools have gone over a decade without any form of inspection. That just seems to raise the stakes massively as a good chance there will be a downgrade for previously outstanding schools. So much must depend on the individual inspector/team. Our nursery manager was telling me about their last inspection and she said it was genuinely helpful and the inspector was lovely with their conversations focused on best practice in a supportive way. So, clearly some inspectors can do an inspection in a more light-touch, developmental way without creating the fear. Sadly, there seem to be lots of teachers who have experienced the opposite.

LolaSmiles · 17/03/2023 12:31

A basic check of ‘is this school, in the context of its community, providing a decent standard of education and care?’ with a brief of ‘carry on if you are’ and ‘instant access to all necessary support and development if you aren’t’ should be sufficient
Agree with this
Is this school doing the right thing for the children in its care? If that's making sure they have an amazing set of vocational options and improving literacy Vs forcing children to sit an MFL GCSE when they're struggling with English then great. If you've got a high prior attaining cohort and you're letting them twiddle their thumbs then that's not good enough.

I think Ofsted should be two grades: satisfactory and unsatisfactory. Then within unsatisfactory there'd be two judgements: one where the inspectors feel the school can improve with some lighter touch support and one like special measures where there's concerns about SLT's capacity to improve the school.

wantmorenow · 17/03/2023 12:30

I posted this yesterday in staffroom - but it hasn't had the traffic. Thank you for also posting.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/the_staffroom/4764916-head-took-her-own-life-shared?reply=124704683

Another reason I am so glad to out of teaching, only been 12 weeks or so but my physical and mental health so much better already.

lieselotte · 17/03/2023 12:30

Some very thoughtful comments on here. I agree an overall less than perfect rating makes a school the one to avoid in the area even though it might be doing a generally decent job so maybe ratings for individual areas rather than overall would help.

In my experience some of the comments made by Ofsted are nit-picking and totally unnecessary.

The key questions should be:

Is the school educating to a decent standard - do the kids achieve well compared with their abilities at entry
Is it following the law (eg safeguarding)
Is it following its own policies and procedures properly (eg anti-bullying, given so many schools seem not to be able to deal with bullying)

and as a pp said, I'd also add a category for staff wellbeing to stop some awful SMTs bullying their staff.

My son's childminder had an excellent rating. She was good, but it was quite tedious how worried she was about maintaining her rating and how she would have a go at parents if she thought we were doing anything that would affect her rating.

Spendonsend · 17/03/2023 12:29

I think it inspects too many things in one go.

Safeguarding is really important and best practice changes frequently so a different safeguarding thing should be in place annually as thats when kcsie changes and it should be supportive.

I'm not sure what the rest should look like.

TortolaParadise · 17/03/2023 12:27

Thehop · 17/03/2023 12:23

My dealings this month with OFSTED have left me so stressed I couldn't sleep and crying in the middle of the night to my husband that they'd all be better off with my life insurance.

It's been the worst month of my life. I hate them.

Breath it out!

Thehop · 17/03/2023 12:23

My dealings this month with OFSTED have left me so stressed I couldn't sleep and crying in the middle of the night to my husband that they'd all be better off with my life insurance.

It's been the worst month of my life. I hate them.

TortolaParadise · 17/03/2023 12:22

The flip side to this tragic event however is when the Ofsted report is 'Good'/'Outstanding' out rolls the bunting and banners and even more common is that families move homes to benefit from this calibre of school. There are many contributors to the whole culture of Ofsted hating/worshiping.

LadyHaHaHeeHaw · 17/03/2023 12:20

@cantkeepawayforever , so pleased that the inspector took that into consideration, where I am getting some pupils into school is an achievement in itself , not through health issues but because of family priorities
I wish parents would look beyond their report
The worst school I worked in couldn't give a shit about the children, the head ran it like a business, staff and pupils left in droves
It got outstanding, horrible, toxic and a very unhappy environment to be

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 17/03/2023 12:19

My children’s school dropped to inadequate following an ofsted inspection last year. At the time, immediately post pandemic, the head had just resigned, having previously been off sick for 6 months or so with stress. The school, still reeling from the pandemic, had been being run by the deputy head, who was part time, and also supposed to be teaching a class. The reason for the ofsted inadequate was also leadership and safeguarding - lack of paperwork. Which wasn’t a surprise since there wasn’t really any leadership. What we needed was a head. But then the ofsted inadequate rating happened, and the school was told to become an academy. Which took about 9 months, during which time they couldn’t recruit for a head because it was in the interim phase. Now we are an academy, and we finally have a permanent head, and honestly? I don’t see much difference. Because there wasn’t really much wrong to start with except the paperwork. But the school has been through a year of turmoil, and has been slapped with an ‘inadequate’ rating - all in the name of improving….the paperwork.

Lorrymum · 17/03/2023 12:17

OFSTED is not fit for purpose. The whole inspection process is deeply flawed. My previous head was constantly worried about the next Ofsted and everything was geared to the possibility of the next inspection.
I worked as a TA with a teacher who would put on a wonderful performance for Ofsted. She was, warm, approachable and kind, walking around the classroom being encouraging and helpful. The reality was totally different, lots of shouting and she never left her chair!

Roste · 17/03/2023 12:10

Yes, totally agree needs to be abolished. Same for CQC in primary care- we don’t need to jump through meaningless hoops to satisfy quangos who disregard our professionalism, we simply need the resources and time to do the jobs we trained for.

TortolaParadise · 17/03/2023 12:08

I may be viewing this from a different lens but where is the support network for headteachers and senior leaders? The whole system is wrong! Blame culture causes this distress.

Lulu1919 · 17/03/2023 12:02

emmylousings · 17/03/2023 10:10

I know of a head who killed themselves in similar circumstances.
OFSTED is a toxic organisation, which seriously distorts educational priorities and drives good teachers away.
Scrap it and start again. I dread to think what it costs; but lots of tax payers money is spent on pointless bullying of people who are working hard and trying their best.

Me too

berksandbeyond · 17/03/2023 11:59

My daughters school is so new that it hasn’t had an Ofsted visit yet (although they’re expecting it will be soon!) and I was very impressed that in a new parents evening the head said when they do come they won’t be aiming for outstanding, because they don’t think that all the metrics that equate outstanding are the correct ways to run a school. He’s confident they run a good school, and so am I. We’ll see if ofsted agree I guess!

modgepodge · 17/03/2023 11:58

It’s such an awful story. I live near to that school, not in catchment and no point applying cos it’s so popular. I knew the teacher had died and heard rumour it was suicide at the time but to see it confirmed today is very sad indeed.

Thing is, if you read the report it’s actually overwhelmingly positive. Everything was good except leadership and management, which was inadequate due to safeguarding concerns only. Whilst it is bad the school did not have the safeguarding stuff sorted, it makes you think - has no one been checking on safeguarding at that school for 13 years? No one deliberately does safeguarding badly or is lazy with it - someone should have been in checking their arrangements were adequate at some point surely? My school is independent but we have an advisor in a couple of times a year to check we are compliant. Do LAs not check this in state schools? Or does it literally come down to ofsted, which in this schools case had not checked on them for 13 years? I don’t think that’s ok. People make mistakes and should be supported to correct them; not just publicly branded inadequate when actually lots of the provision was clearly fine and the local community is very happy.

Unbelievably sad.

Politicalnamechange · 17/03/2023 11:57

Thank you both for taking my comment in the spirit it was meant and taking the time to explain without shouting me down.

Loupenny25 · 17/03/2023 11:55

Politicalnamechange · 17/03/2023 11:34

Thay poor woman

What I don't understand with schools and Ofsted though is why schools need "hours and days of stressful preparation" for an inspection? To me that implies you know you're doing things wrong and will be picked up on them. Is it not the case that all the things you're frantically putting into place should be routine daily stuff that is done as part of your working day? If someone went and audited my work you'd know exactly what was going on and where it was going to on any given day. Isn't that the case for everyone? Maybe I just don't understand teaching.

It's because the list of things you "should be" doing doesn't even fit in a 13 hour day. Teaching is a constant juggling act of sorting out the absolute most pressing tasks while shouldering the weight and guilt of all the things you should be doing but don't have time for.

So for example when I taught Year 1 in a particular school I had 120 books to mark every evening (English, Maths, RE and Topic). And not just a few ticks and a smiley stamp.... a multicoloured, 2 stars and a wish, next steps kind of marking! Now let's say one day you are feeling really ill so you leave without doing the marking that night. Well the next day you've got 120 to do again, you can't do 240 pieces of work so you skip that day. Then you can't catch up at the weekend as that's when you do your planning, catch up on your assessments and maybe look at your own children.

But OFSTED might ask why that day was never marked, so the night before the inspection you've got to go back and "fake" mark it. That's just one example I can think of, and yes, I only stayed at that school for a year and had a lovely breakdown mixed in too!

cantkeepawayforever · 17/03/2023 11:52

Politicalnamechange,

I think the difficulty with teaching (vs, for example, financial work) is that so much of the output is not ‘visible’ on paper in the same way.

So, for example, an experienced teacher could teach a lesson with the objective ‘To calculate unit fractions of an amount’ with very little more than that objective, their own personal knowledge of that class, a jar of counters, a whiteboard and a pen. Sone children may have almost no work in their books after the lesson, having used the counters throughout, but will emerge from the lesson with a secure understanding. Others may have a variety
of numbers written down in their books.

The teacher will have a good knowledge, as a result of the lesson, who understands, who doesn’t, and what tomorrow’s lesson should look like.

However, for inspection, everything must be documented (and obviously as inspection is short notice, this tends to mean that documentation becomes a routine burden even if not required). There needs to be a written plan. Specific adaptations must be detailed as evidence of meeting SEN needs. Marking books is done to evidence that the teacher knows what the child can do - and so on.

With such a high-stakes inspection system, so much is done ‘just in case’.

berksandbeyond · 17/03/2023 11:51

This is heartbreaking. I live locally and all I have heard from people is what an incredible person and headteacher Ruth was. What a sad loss of life, and for what?!

TortolaParadise · 17/03/2023 11:48

all that glitters is not gold @butterfly

IhearyouClemFandango · 17/03/2023 11:48

It's all shit tbh. My daughter goes to a Requires Improvement high school, and we cannot speak highly enough of their commitment to her well-being, which we tell them regularly. Yes, there are the odd behaviour issues, but you get those anywhere. Academics we can boost if needs be. We have chosen it for our son as well, over and above the 'Good' school, that is closer but by all reports shows very little care for the individual pupils bar their results and their skirt length.

TortolaParadise · 17/03/2023 11:47

Butteryflakycrust83 · 17/03/2023 11:19

I do not pay any attention to Ofted anymore, after the nursery I withdrew DD from for serious safeguarding received a GOOD, and her current nursery so are just on top of its shit, caring, wonderful setting received inadequate on what was basically an admin nitpick.

this

Swipe left for the next trending thread