Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ofsted needs to be abolished (Trigger warning)

387 replies

MrsMurphyIWish · 17/03/2023 09:29

Watched this heartbreaking story today:

www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m001k4r9

A headteacher took her own life as her school was rated inadequate. The pressures Ofsted creates are immense. Last week Ofsted were on strike Wednesday so decided to break protocol and rang schools Friday to conduct inspections on Monday - some schools were off for snow but that wasn’t a good enough reasons and even if the messages were picked up, that meant school staff would have worries over the weekend - some even going into school. Then there were schools who complained as these schools were given “extra notice”. Ofsted has created such a toxic work environment.

How has it come to this? A teacher who dedicated their life to education feels that a one word judgement meant life wasn’t worth living?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
JemimaTiggywinkles · 17/03/2023 15:54

Why did they have to prep for an inspection? Why weren’t all those things routinely done!?

I haven't done a written lesson plan in over 5 years. I do it all in my head now, because I'm experienced and capable. But I'd have to do written ones for an inspection.

The lessons I normally teach are great for long term learning, but not for Ofsted snapshot judgements, so I'd have to completely re-do all of my lesson plans and resources for all of the lessons if my school were being inspected.

My classroom is clean and usually tidy, but I don't have displays up because I usually spend spare time doing something useful for children's learning. So I'd have to get that sorted if I were being inspected. Plus the other minor maintenance jobs that need doing (eg new batteries in the clock, new lightbulb etc).

the80sweregreat · 17/03/2023 15:34

I feel so sorry for the head mistress that died . It was such a sad story.
No job is worth losing your life over.
Ofsted sound awful.

Nimbostratus100 · 17/03/2023 15:18

here are some ways Ofsted disadvantages students-

children can't be taught out of their year group, for example, a refugee child arriving in year 11 with no English, would clearly benefit from being taught in year 10, however, they would still be a year 11 child, so their GCSE results would count, and would be zero, so for ofsted reasons, forced into year 11, fails everything except maths, and counts as getting a grade. So better outcome for ofsted, worse for child

Children in care, children with cancer, children with applications in to other places which might not be successful for a few months down the line - less likely to be accepted into sixth form, as they might damage retention percentages, so turning them away looks better for ofsted, but worse for the children

Time wasted on harassing parents with children out of school for reasonable reasons that dont quite fit the school absence policy - for example, forces children away to see their Dad on the only week he will be in the UK this year. We have to prove we have threatened them with further action, waste of time for us, stress for the parent, but looks better for ofsted.

EBacc - restricting children's choices at GCSE, forcing a modern langauge and a humanity on everyone, whether suitable or not, because it is a measure ofsted looks at, but it s benefit the child.

Target grades, invented by some silly goverment formula, don't take individual circumstances into consideration, so children chosen for interventions based on how close they are to their target grade - why? Because ofsted want to see everyone meet their target grade - so children who would RERALLY benefit from intervention, becasue they have so much more potential than their target grade suggests, or because they are so much underachieving, don't get the time and resources allocated. Again, it is all about how it looks to ofsted, not what individual children need. I have had a preverbal child functioning at around age 18 months with a minimum target grade of 5 at GCSE. I have had children with degenerative brain diseases with target grades from before the disease happened. I have had genius children with target grades based on how they were doing when they couldn't speak any English, 4 years earlier.

I have had an ofsted inspector mark me down because I didn't have the homosexual students in my class marked on my register, and I wasn't teaching percentages in a way inclusive to homosexuals

We have had an inspector base a "Deep dive" on a randomly chosen ethnic origin, of which we had exactly one representative in the school.

I could go on and on and on

All you need to know though, is ofsted inspection results have been shown to be very little more than random.

It is utterly meaningless, schools jump through the most ridiculous hoops based on what ofsted currently favours, and doesn't want to see.

Remember when ofsted suddenly turned against text books, and they all got dumped, now schools are crying out for them

IJustHadToLookHavingReadTheBook · 17/03/2023 15:08

OFSTED are a proper evil organisation. I remember being rated "satisfactory" by then back in the day (back when that was a rating) and beating myself up for months after because I'd previously been rated good and outstanding in a previous inspection. I remember unloading all of this on my HODs lap after months of ruminating on it and she just laughed and said "they pull it out of their arses!" And then reminded me that I had been observed with bottom set year eight on a Friday period five when I got this rating so it was actually a miracle that no one had died. Since then I've tried to always remember it's nonsense.

fUNNYfACE36 · 17/03/2023 15:08

Fruitfriend · 17/03/2023 13:47

Not to be a dick, but I sent DD to a lovely school with lovely people and lovely ethos. Cheerfully ignored that it had been dinged by OFSTED for safeguarding because 'its just box ticking' and lovelyschool is so lovely and kind.
...
THEY LOST HER!!!!!
Was no harm done in the end, but another mum had been given the OK to grab her DC from the playground during break for an appointment. My DD followed along like a little duckling and got through the gate, playground supervisor let it go because she knew the kids were friends(!!!), other mum didn't notice and drove off. My DD went for a lovely walk around and wasn't missed for nearly an hour.

Lovely teachers and lovely playground supervisors are great. Heads and safeguarding leads need to support lovely staff by keeping procedures tight and covering everyone's arses.

You know when i was a kid,schools weren't prisons. They weren't locked, they werent gated. Some kids went home for lunch and then walked back again. All the kids knew it was not allowed to leave school otherwise without permission
Very very occasionally a child did run away, but you know what, the blame was very squarely laid at the kids school, thwere was no question that the school were to blame for a kid who is old enoughto know better (5+) absonding.

Jazz12 · 17/03/2023 15:06

StaySpicy · 17/03/2023 10:12

A friend who's support staff had her school rung last Friday for a Monday/ Tuesday inspection. She said the teachers were in school for 10 hours on Saturday to get things ready!! Plus more time on the Sunday making books and planning lessons.

Support staff were told they could go in if they wanted but there was no money for overtime. My friend didn't go in. But she felt a bit guilty. Imagine feeling guilty because you don't want to go to work for free!

The whole thing just sounds ridiculous. I have no knowledge of how public sector are observed and judged. Does a GP have inspectors observing them in a patient appointment? Do police officers have someone following them around for an hour in order to make a judgement about the police station? I know teachers have this, but do other people?

Why did they have to prep for an inspection? Why weren’t all those things routinely done!?

SirenSays · 17/03/2023 15:00

Whatalife88 · 17/03/2023 14:45

What I hate about ofsted is nothing to do with how the staff feel but more that it's all so fake. Everyone works extra hard and covers up safeguarding concerns to impress ofstead and so a real rating doesn't always happen. Ours is rated good because in reality half of what ofsted said was bs and the school is much worse because the school went out of their way for that inspection.

This! It can be so fake. My primary school was awful for faking it. Hiding away the badly behaved kids, warning us about things not to mention...
I remember a teacher coming up with a plan to make himself look good for ofsted. He would ask the class a question and if we didn't know the answer we'd raise our left hand, if we did know we'd raise our right. If we all raised left hand the teacher would say wow you're all so brilliant of course the answer is

ApplePippa · 17/03/2023 15:00

This school is very local to me. It is absolutely heart breaking.

It's one of those schools that is put on a pedestal by local people - The Best School - outstanding, oversubscribed with an expensive catchment, lots of high achievers.

I do wonder if the fact it has such a reputation played into the head teacher's tragic decision. It can't be easy to be the person seen as taking a school from such perceived heights to such perceived failure.

Its all senseless, as the Ofsted report contains so many positives and areas with Good ratings, yet the overall headline is Inadequate. It's a good school!! Yet the head teacher is driven to this....

Something is very wrong in the way schools are being judged.

BananaBerks · 17/03/2023 15:00

Also live locally and the school has always been in high regard and people even moved area to get their kids in.
The thing that stood out to me was when Ruth Perrys sister was speaking on the news, saying that Ruth was told that she wasn't allowed to even discuss the situation with her family. The irony is that she obviously really cared about the school, its staff and pupils and that passion caused her that much distress that lead to her actions. The reasons given for the poor Ofsted report including flossing as sexual abuse and a fight in the playground as child on child as abuse are beyond me. Exactly how qualified that these inspectors??!!!
RIP Ruth Perry.

Dee1224 · 17/03/2023 14:57

This is an awful thing to have happened, It’s not the first time and probably won’t be the last. Decent HTs are understandably devastated by bad inspections and ‘safeguarding issues’ are always a useful stick with which to beat schools. Of course safeguarding is important, but a school can fail an inspection for very minor paperwork issues, best resolved by support and advice, not with public humiliation.

OFSTED is a pernicious, fault-finding organisation full of people who haven’t taught for years. Unless you are a UK teacher, you really can’t understand the horror, (especially if, like at our school, you have a HT who is obsessed with OFSTED and who likes to use the threat of their imminent appearance to torment staff!)

I have been through many inspections and they were all awful. There surely has to be a better way!

Whatalife88 · 17/03/2023 14:45

What I hate about ofsted is nothing to do with how the staff feel but more that it's all so fake. Everyone works extra hard and covers up safeguarding concerns to impress ofstead and so a real rating doesn't always happen. Ours is rated good because in reality half of what ofsted said was bs and the school is much worse because the school went out of their way for that inspection.

NorthernWanker · 17/03/2023 14:37

We had a local nursery make a formal complaint and the MP was involved after they marked them inadequate but the report completely contradicted its self. Anyway they were reinspected a few months later and are now good with some outstanding. It's all personal opinion on what good is (I know paperwork is something different and mandatory) but this inspector seems to want them to fail and had a personal connection to some of the management.

What's awful is a bet the inspector never lost sleep over it. The staff were devastated and work bloody hard.

Ballbagisnotmyname · 17/03/2023 14:36

My daughters first school went from excellent to special measures with 1 ofsted report. They sacked an amazing head teacher for an awful business driven one. Turned out the school didn’t want to become an academy but if they went into special measures they had to - ofsted and local council had forced their hand☹️
at the parent meeting to discuss what was happening the council and ofsted representatives walked out when the parents revealed this info!

Cathpot · 17/03/2023 14:33

Been teaching for over 20 years and actually I much prefer the short notice OFSTED system as the schools used to go bonkers with longer notice. Plus it is a more realistic snapshot of what is going on as there was all sorts of performative nonsense with a lead up. There is also a much lighter touch for classroom teachers than in the inspections at the start of my career where you were personally graded . What I have issue with is the nature of the feedback which is never a discussion and only a lecture style delivery and brooks no discussion at all - unlike the old HMIs with whom you could usually have a useful, professional supportive conversation . 3 OFSTEDs ago feedback was delivered at me in person, in such a hectoring way that I thought I had failed until he finally told me my grade - and he then did the same to my colleague- we were both completely bemused, walking away with good grades after a very odd experience. This time feedback on our dept was delivered as a lecture to my HOD (who hadn’t been in those lessons) by the inspector who wasn’t a science teacher- it was not useful in any way. The SLT in our school who moonlights as an inspector is a poor teacher themselves, and often you meet inspectors who you absolutely know would be a shower in the classroom. I presume there are decent ones out there but I don’t know how they are selected.

That said I do not blame OFSTED for awful awful management in some schools. A friend who is a completely fantastic HOD at a failing school has just been broken by her own SLT, and that is on them. Poor decisions, poor communication, no regard for wellbeing. They are apparently trying to establish a ‘resilience culture’ where the ridiculous unmanageable workload she was given due to staff shortages was part of a ‘if you can’t hack it you shouldn’t be a teacher’ attitude. Now they are in a flap as she is leaving but they have done that to her, not OFSTED.

My own school with a sympathetic and reasonable SLT is able to ride through OFSTEDs with their staff morale intact.

Lots of the decisions that have negatively impacted staff over the years- like marking in 3 colours of pen etc are driven by what school management think OFSTED want, rather than what they actually want to see. I also find it telling that the 5 OFSTEDs I have been through all wanted different things- this time is was all about curriculum for instance- and part of the problem with teaching is the constant chasing a new paradigm.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 17/03/2023 14:31

It's unfit for purpose.

There should be an audit of paperwork, training and governance, then instead of Ofsted reviewing classes, senior teachers and Heads should be pooled into a working group who visit and observe other schools in their area. This working group then shares best practices etc and records critique (weighted to positive / good news stories etc). Ofsted should then ensure this is carried out / include recording in the paperwork audit.

Snowontheblow · 17/03/2023 14:27

I've just watched the video the OP links to and it's heartbreaking. Obviously you'd like to think we'd all say "fuck them" and not let it get under your skin to the point you can't carry on, but going through it yourself must be sheer hell. Her poor family, and the school community.

saraclara · 17/03/2023 14:26

I've been retired for several years, but simply reading this thread has brought it all back, and I feel anxious and agitated simply recalling it all. And I'm absolutely heartbroken for that head teacher and her family.

JussathoB · 17/03/2023 14:20

@flashria ‘no teacher exposition’ - if this means what I think it does, no wonder educational standards are dropping…. Ofsted prefers it if teachers remain silent and don’t teach !! Crazy

Snowontheblow · 17/03/2023 14:18

Who is going to want to be a headteacher?

RaraRachael · 17/03/2023 14:06

We were told that all our wall displays should be dated and have the Learning Intentions written on them as the inspectors had said it was a "Missed Opportunity". When we asked our HT what it was a missed opportunity for, she couldn't answer. The pupils knew what the learning intention for the task was, so goodness knows why it had to be plastered on the wall display.

saraclara · 17/03/2023 14:06

That school was graded Good in everything but the safeguarding issues, the reality of which seem to have been trivial.

The employment paperwork that potentially could cause a safeguarding issue and some apparently misinterpreted playground behaviour over-rode every single good thing about the school.

The OFSTED metric shouldn't work that way. Of course any potentila safeguarding issue should be prioritised, but it shouldn't result in a school that is good in every other metric, being denounced as inadequate.

AnneElliott · 17/03/2023 14:02

I don't think results are everything @ENTnightmare so inspection still has its place in my view.

I'm also a bit wary when people comment that 'inspectors don't know how to teach/haven't taught in years etc'. While that's valid if they're commenting on a teaching methodology, this is what I hear a lot from fire and rescue (ie the inspectors don't know what they're talking about). However, in a lot of cases, fire authorities are in their own weird bubble with shocking treatment of their staff (see recent press reports) and they resent anyone pointing that out. All industries need to be exposed to wider societal scrutiny to improve the public service that they are delivering.

clopper · 17/03/2023 14:01

It sounds like that poor HT must have had other issues.

I bet she didn’t.

Just recently had an ofsted . One man stalking round the school making snap judgements on very little evidence to be honest. Literally picking away to find fault. We came out as ‘good’ but honestly everyone felt so flat about it. Has it helped us in any way to move forward? No just nit picking criticisms.

Sick to death of it all. The whole thing turns into 4 years preparing for the next one. Each time ( have done 5) the priorities and buzz words change ( all about fluency in reading at the moment).

we are just given new things to focus on…what’s trending at the moment it seems to be. I look at these inspectors from nice little sage schools and wonder if they could hack my job working 25 years in an inner city environment with the flow of children that move in and out continually, so many different languages and so many safeguarding issues . We are judged on the same basis as schools with different demographics.

Glad this will be my last ofsted. Used to really like the HMI school improvement advisor who used to come in with a critical eye but some helpful solutions. He built a relationship with the school and staff over time and was highly regarded.

I think the problem is they have to find something to say. Before they enter the school they have an agenda in my opinion and then seek to prove it.

That poor, poor dedicated lady who gave so many years to the school and who was highly regarded. So sorry for her family and colleagues.

Fruitfriend · 17/03/2023 13:47

Not to be a dick, but I sent DD to a lovely school with lovely people and lovely ethos. Cheerfully ignored that it had been dinged by OFSTED for safeguarding because 'its just box ticking' and lovelyschool is so lovely and kind.
...
THEY LOST HER!!!!!
Was no harm done in the end, but another mum had been given the OK to grab her DC from the playground during break for an appointment. My DD followed along like a little duckling and got through the gate, playground supervisor let it go because she knew the kids were friends(!!!), other mum didn't notice and drove off. My DD went for a lovely walk around and wasn't missed for nearly an hour.

Lovely teachers and lovely playground supervisors are great. Heads and safeguarding leads need to support lovely staff by keeping procedures tight and covering everyone's arses.

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 17/03/2023 13:42

It sounds like that poor HT must have had other issues. OFSTED inspection is a bastard, I’ve been part of the Scottish equivalent twice, but really it’s not worth your life. Heartbreaking that they felt this was their only option.