Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ofsted needs to be abolished (Trigger warning)

387 replies

MrsMurphyIWish · 17/03/2023 09:29

Watched this heartbreaking story today:

www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m001k4r9

A headteacher took her own life as her school was rated inadequate. The pressures Ofsted creates are immense. Last week Ofsted were on strike Wednesday so decided to break protocol and rang schools Friday to conduct inspections on Monday - some schools were off for snow but that wasn’t a good enough reasons and even if the messages were picked up, that meant school staff would have worries over the weekend - some even going into school. Then there were schools who complained as these schools were given “extra notice”. Ofsted has created such a toxic work environment.

How has it come to this? A teacher who dedicated their life to education feels that a one word judgement meant life wasn’t worth living?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
PonkyPonky · 17/03/2023 18:20

Police forces definitely do. My local constabulary was recently rated ‘inadequate’ and put in special measures. I don’t see the need for the scary labels, just give school a list of positive points and things requiring improvement. It’s madness to hinge an entire school’s reputation on a single inspection. My DS’s nursery was rated inadequate while he was there and I genuinely couldn’t believe it. I felt they were the most warm, loving environment for children and every child was genuinely happy to go there every day. DS adored all the staff, they were well educated, well fed and cared for. But the day of the inspection, they had 2 room leaders off sick, they were struggling to replace a staff member who had to leave to move away because they had zero applications when they advertised. They didn’t deserve the inadequate rating based on one bad day.

modgepodge · 17/03/2023 18:09

Nightlystroll · 17/03/2023 16:21

There's so much to that story, though. She took over as headteacher just after the school was awarded outstanding. When inspected now, the staff didn't know about effective safe guarding, they didn't step in when children were at risk, they weren't even aware of their weaknesses, and their were gaps in employment records which could gave left children at risk.
This is all pretty basic stuff and she inherited an outstanding grade so the systems must have been in place at the start of her employment.

It's awful that anyone lives under so much stress that they think suicide is the answer and there's so much pressure on a couple of days visit, but ofsted isn't in the wrong to point out risks to children and say the present set up is inadequate.

Of course the paperwork should have been in order. But I think there should be a better way to check on this so it could be picked up earlier - perhaps yearly low stakes checks by the LA to check everything is in order, and if it’s not, support to sort it out, without publicly announcing to the world that it is a problem. Not 13 years of not knowing it’s wrong followed by a public branding of INADEQUATE which makes it seem like the whole school is crap, when the report clearly shows it is not and is good in every other area.

OddBoots · 17/03/2023 18:09

spanieleyes · 17/03/2023 11:14

In my authority, the locality lead comes into schools each term with a different focus, so SEND, attendance, maths, safeguarding etc. They spend the day going through everything relevant, provide items for improvement and positives. The following term, they check up on the areas identified for improvement and the new focus areas. Supportive, helpful and not life threatening.
OFSTED, alternatively had us all in tears, even though we came out with a Good.

Now that sounds exactly the kind of thing that would actually help schools be the best they can. I get that it would cost more to provide than the current Ofsted model but it looks like would bring such a positive change to schools that it would would save money in the context of staff retention.

saraclara · 17/03/2023 18:08

Shepandawing · 17/03/2023 18:02

What would the alternative be? I'm not a teacher so I don't have first hand experience but I do have regulatory bodies overseeing my work environment and I definitely think there is a place for them.
How would you assess schools without actual visits from something like ofsted?

No-one has a problem with schools being assessed and objective inspectors visiting. Of course that's necessary.

What's wrong with OFSTED isn't that it inspects schools at all, it's what it expects of them. It's entirely unrealistic and focuses on the things that are least important to most children and parents.

It's a punitive system and it way too much hangs on it.

queenofthewild · 17/03/2023 18:07

Nightlystroll · 17/03/2023 18:02

Gaps in record keeping? Maybe the school couldn’t employ a permanent safeguarding team due to cuts?

But the gaps ofsted were talking about were things like gaps in employment records where anything could have happened. It's just a basic requirement that you have a full and complete employment background on all your employees who will be around vulnerable people. I've been looking for care homes for my mum. I've come across a couple that got rated inadequate for both management and safety categories because of gaps like these. If a member of staff assaulted a child and that could have been discovered from a full employment record, how many poster on here would be supporting you over your claim you were too busy to check or lacked sufficient staff?

It's a local authority school. HR won't issue an employment contract until they have had evidence the appropriate checks have been made. It was almost certainly a filing error so the evidence of these checks couldn't be located immediately.

cansu · 17/03/2023 18:03

Ofsted needs to be overhauled. Schools do need external scrutiny but it should be less public and more about improvement. High stakes inspections every four or five years are not doing what they need to. The death of this lady is tragic and highlights everything that is wrong with the current system.

Nightlystroll · 17/03/2023 18:02

Gaps in record keeping? Maybe the school couldn’t employ a permanent safeguarding team due to cuts?

But the gaps ofsted were talking about were things like gaps in employment records where anything could have happened. It's just a basic requirement that you have a full and complete employment background on all your employees who will be around vulnerable people. I've been looking for care homes for my mum. I've come across a couple that got rated inadequate for both management and safety categories because of gaps like these. If a member of staff assaulted a child and that could have been discovered from a full employment record, how many poster on here would be supporting you over your claim you were too busy to check or lacked sufficient staff?

Shepandawing · 17/03/2023 18:02

What would the alternative be? I'm not a teacher so I don't have first hand experience but I do have regulatory bodies overseeing my work environment and I definitely think there is a place for them.
How would you assess schools without actual visits from something like ofsted?

queenofthewild · 17/03/2023 18:01

It's an absolute tragedy. Because of a snapshot judgment from ofsted a husband is now a widow, children are left without a mother and Julia has lost her sister.

This school is based in an area with falling birth rates and many primaries are struggling to fill spaces despite bulge classes only a few years back. This rating would have certainly also affected applications, funding and the long term viability of the school. No wonder poor Ruth was desperate.

Keeping on top of staff training and paperwork in a school office is a huge job, and one that many schools are struggling to stay on top of as falling budgets mean a fall in admin and support staff on site.

A local private school was in a similar situation not too long ago. They were written to by ofsted, told what to do to remedy the safeguarding issues and kept their Outstanding grade in the meantime. Why is the same grace period not given to state schools who already have fewer resources.

RIP Ruth. You didn't deserve this. Your family didn't deserve this. Your colleagues and the school community didn't deserve this.

MrsMurphyIWish · 17/03/2023 17:57

Ofsted is in opposition to “every child matters”.

OP posts:
babybythesea · 17/03/2023 17:55

We got nailed for the poor reading of one KS2 child. Pointing out he was non-verbal when he started school, getting out all the SLT paperwork (which they didn’t look at), all the paperwork from hours of interventions (they didn’t even glance at it), the fact that they couldn’t actually understand what he was saying when he was just talking, not reading (shows his speech was a major block in him being able to sound words out - he couldn’t say half the sounds, of course he couldn’t read them clearly. He just couldn’t pronounce them)… made next to no difference. They listened to three readers in the whole school and then homed in on this child and asked if we felt, as they did, that it was evidence of our inability to teach reading adequately.
We got a good rating but it was close. Three years ago this was a 5 yo who didn’t speak. The fact he is operating in a mainstream school at all is a small miracle, doing maths along with his year group, and accessing science and history and English too, with significant support to read everything. Not relevant - he doesn’t read as well as he should for his age…

MrsMurphyIWish · 17/03/2023 17:50

I’m just can’t believe this is not a national story. I only learned of it due to a podcast.

OP posts:
MrsMurphyIWish · 17/03/2023 17:47

Ofsted is so pernicious because of outside forces - many imposed on us because of the government’s own making.

Gaps in record keeping? Maybe the school couldn’t employ a permanent safeguarding team due to cuts?

At the moment I only feel in barely control of my own classes - I can’t be responsible for 2000 pupil’s progress in school - let alone what each of those are bringing into school every day.

OP posts:
Snowontheblow · 17/03/2023 17:36

Pupils are not at risk from playground dancing.

cantkeepawayforever · 17/03/2023 17:16

I think it is reasonable for someone trained in inspection and coaching, with a wide experience of education (of all types), to be involved in the monitoring of schools. That’s the HMI model, and IME they’re pretty good and balanced.

It’s not reasonable to involve ‘non education’ inspectors in the current inspection framework, though it would be worth including eg child protection professionals in annual light touch safeguarding-type monitoring / advisory visits.

Too many ‘additional inspectors’ are ‘not that great teachers/ leaders in schools’, who combine inspection with their own work. They are, ime, the most likely to pull up ‘different from my place’ as ‘wrong’, and impose a layer if ‘what I would expect’ on top of the framework OR over-interpret a single piece of evidence through inexperience or poor training in inspection.

AnneElliott · 17/03/2023 17:07

Absolutely @ENTnightmare - sometimes they don't. But other times it's actually helpful having someone from the outside come in and give their perspective. That's not something I think we should lose if/when Ofsted is reformed.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 17/03/2023 16:42

It's awful that anyone lives under so much stress that they think suicide is the answer and there's so much pressure on a couple of days visit, but ofsted isn't in the wrong to point out risks to children and say the present set up is inadequate

Sounds a pretty balanced response to this tragedy to me, and as so often I expect there's more to this than we know

Of course it's harsh to award an almost automatic "inadequate" over a bit of record keeping, but it's not as if this is an unknown thing so why not make damned sure something you know they're going to prioritise is watertight?

Also, as you say, the report suggests there was rather more to it than just a bit of paperwork

Nightlystroll · 17/03/2023 16:21

There's so much to that story, though. She took over as headteacher just after the school was awarded outstanding. When inspected now, the staff didn't know about effective safe guarding, they didn't step in when children were at risk, they weren't even aware of their weaknesses, and their were gaps in employment records which could gave left children at risk.
This is all pretty basic stuff and she inherited an outstanding grade so the systems must have been in place at the start of her employment.

It's awful that anyone lives under so much stress that they think suicide is the answer and there's so much pressure on a couple of days visit, but ofsted isn't in the wrong to point out risks to children and say the present set up is inadequate.

noblegiraffe · 17/03/2023 16:20

I have had an ofsted inspector mark me down because I didn't have the homosexual students in my class marked on my register, and I wasn't teaching percentages in a way inclusive to homosexuals

Er, what??

Mumsafan · 17/03/2023 16:12

SirenSays · 17/03/2023 15:00

This! It can be so fake. My primary school was awful for faking it. Hiding away the badly behaved kids, warning us about things not to mention...
I remember a teacher coming up with a plan to make himself look good for ofsted. He would ask the class a question and if we didn't know the answer we'd raise our left hand, if we did know we'd raise our right. If we all raised left hand the teacher would say wow you're all so brilliant of course the answer is

It is completely fake - our village school gave 5 disruptive pupils the week off when inspectors were in!

ENTnightmare · 17/03/2023 16:09

AnneElliott · 17/03/2023 14:02

I don't think results are everything @ENTnightmare so inspection still has its place in my view.

I'm also a bit wary when people comment that 'inspectors don't know how to teach/haven't taught in years etc'. While that's valid if they're commenting on a teaching methodology, this is what I hear a lot from fire and rescue (ie the inspectors don't know what they're talking about). However, in a lot of cases, fire authorities are in their own weird bubble with shocking treatment of their staff (see recent press reports) and they resent anyone pointing that out. All industries need to be exposed to wider societal scrutiny to improve the public service that they are delivering.

Also, we have had secondary teachers come in and observe nursery. They may as well be different professions, the pedagogy is completely different. So yes, at times the inspectors don't have a clue.

ENTnightmare · 17/03/2023 16:07

AnneElliott · 17/03/2023 14:02

I don't think results are everything @ENTnightmare so inspection still has its place in my view.

I'm also a bit wary when people comment that 'inspectors don't know how to teach/haven't taught in years etc'. While that's valid if they're commenting on a teaching methodology, this is what I hear a lot from fire and rescue (ie the inspectors don't know what they're talking about). However, in a lot of cases, fire authorities are in their own weird bubble with shocking treatment of their staff (see recent press reports) and they resent anyone pointing that out. All industries need to be exposed to wider societal scrutiny to improve the public service that they are delivering.

You're right results aren't everything, a lot of the time parents have the measure of a school. Parents know if they have happy children. In my experience the schools who are always 'inspection ready' are the worst ones for the children as nothing is child centred. Everything is geared towards the inspection, whenever it may be.

VickyEadieofThigh · 17/03/2023 16:07

Ofsted: a kid flossing is over-sexualisation, school is failing on safeguarding!

Also Ofsted: schools buying in SRE packages that teach kids about sexual practices such as anal sex - totally fine and nothing to do with us.

spanieleyes · 17/03/2023 16:07

At a recent inspection, the year 3 children were asked what they had learnt about protected characteristics. They had no idea what they were. Now, if the inspector had asked about treating everyone fairly or not discriminating against people, about not judging based on being a boy or a girl etc then the children could, and would have explained all they knew. But we were pulled up for not teaching 6 year olds about protected characteristics when the children couldn't even pronounce the words!

modgepodge · 17/03/2023 15:59

Jazz12 · 17/03/2023 15:06

Why did they have to prep for an inspection? Why weren’t all those things routinely done!?

Someone explained this above.

planning - I can plan a lot of maths lessons in a minute or two. I know I’ll model the method on the board, I know which misconceptions are likely and will highlight them. I’ll find a textbook page, job done. I’ve been teaching a long time so don’t need it scripted. If ofsted were coming in, my school would expect me to write this plan out to full 2 a4 pages, including identifying target students, saying what learning comes before/after, writing down the support I’ll offer to SEN and pupil premium and so and so on. I’d have to do that for each of my 4-6 lessons that day. All of which takes rather longer than ‘column addition? Lovely, I know what I’ll do.’

marking - in an ideal world, yes, every single question a child answers and every word they write would be marked. In reality, this is extremely time consuming and really only beneficial if it’s done within a couple of days of the work being done. Ideally you do it each evening after the kids have gone. However, if you don’t for any reason, the work is still in the book and ofsted will question why it isn’t marked. The answer ‘I didn’t have time as I had a migraine/my gran died/I went to the cinema that night, and marking it 3 weeks later is pointless’ won’t cut it, so you end up going back and catching up if you know ofsted are coming it (or parents evening is coming up!)

Swipe left for the next trending thread