Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ofsted needs to be abolished (Trigger warning)

387 replies

MrsMurphyIWish · 17/03/2023 09:29

Watched this heartbreaking story today:

www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m001k4r9

A headteacher took her own life as her school was rated inadequate. The pressures Ofsted creates are immense. Last week Ofsted were on strike Wednesday so decided to break protocol and rang schools Friday to conduct inspections on Monday - some schools were off for snow but that wasn’t a good enough reasons and even if the messages were picked up, that meant school staff would have worries over the weekend - some even going into school. Then there were schools who complained as these schools were given “extra notice”. Ofsted has created such a toxic work environment.

How has it come to this? A teacher who dedicated their life to education feels that a one word judgement meant life wasn’t worth living?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
begoneday · 18/03/2023 08:08

2022again · 17/03/2023 19:45

You can hardly blame parents ,if we are told that’s how schools are rated how are parents to know any different?we only know different because we’ve had 2 kids go through 3 different schools so know not to only assess a school by its ofsted (and to realise that outstanding schools in middle class areas can end up resting on their laurels because they’ve not been inspected in a decade).

In my area, parents plan their two house moves years ahead to get close enough to their desired primary and then secondary school. They know exactly what they want and so I do partially blame parents for driving this obsession with ratings.

MrsMurphyIWish · 18/03/2023 06:13

Unless you work in education, I don’t think anyone realised the toxicity of Ofsted. As I’ve said, I’ve been through 5 in my career - and like a PP - a HMI when the first school I taught at was graded inadequate. The HMI were great! Really supportive. I was a NQT at the time (23 years ago!) and I remember an inspector saying to me at the end of a lesson, “you were a pleasure to watch, don’t ever lose that enthusiasm”. Ofsted inspectors on the other hand, are rude and abrupt, and in my opinion, have made a judgement about the school before they inspect and are looking for evidence to confirm that judgement. At my last school the deputy head was an Ofsted inspector too - awful woman.

OP posts:
Overthebloodymoon · 17/03/2023 22:50

Agree with @Nightlystroll It is beyond tragic that the HT felt suicide was the only way out but you can’t mess around with safeguarding. The expectations are
clear and the whole school should have known exactly what to do with any given incident. It was always going to be an automatic inadequate if safeguarding measures were not up to scratch. It’s not just a bit of paperwork, it’s the safety of adults within the school, safer recruitment, you name it, there is so much training available. Whether there is a better method of assessing safeguarding is another issue but the inspector will have had no choice but to award that rating given the current criteria. All that said, utterly utterly tragic and such a loss. Incredibly sad.

TortolaParadise · 17/03/2023 22:27

I also hate the management’s joy when we go from Requires Improvement to Good. If we don’t accept the crap result we should not celebrate the good ones.

This

Shinyandnew1 · 17/03/2023 21:29

It didn't escape my notice that normally on a certain day the teacher has a few hours out of the classroom but the week of the inspection she was firmly in the class

Our PPA is always postponed to later in the week when we have Ofsted.

RedToothBrush · 17/03/2023 21:27

DS'S school has just been inspected. I'm terrified as to how it's going to come out.

Over the last few weeks we've had to complain about a few issues but it's been the child and their parents causing the issues. The school has historically, even by national standards, been exceptionally poorly funded. My son's class needs a one to one for this kid but because the parents are being arsed over it, the school hasn't the funding. The kid probably shouldn't be in the school with the level of behaviour he's been displaying.

But I do feel the school has largely done their best under the circumstances.

It's apparently like this in several other classes - it never was precovid.

I know a number of people who work there. The majority of the dinner ladies (who now double as TAs post COVID) are on the verge of quitting by all accounts. I know several of the dedicated full time tas are on the verge of leaving.

My son's class apparently wasn't inspected. Tbh I don't know how I feel about this. His teacher is amazing and is fire fighting with this kid. She's told me frankly that this class is the most challenging she's ever had. She previously worked in an inner city school which is about as far removed from DSs school as it's possible to be. I don't know if this is a relief and a bullet dodged or whether the inspected missed crucial things. It didn't escape my notice that normally on a certain day the teacher has a few hours out of the classroom but the week of the inspection she was firmly in the class.

My fear is that a school that has already lost a number of experienced staff in the last three years is about to lose more. Last year DS had a newly qualified teacher. And which she was lovely, she was fecking useless on SEN stuff and she pretty much set up the bullying and crappy stuff that's ensued this year because she expected various kids to manage the behavioural issues of this other kid.

I am aware of two parents complaining over their child being expected to manage this child even though he was routinely physically assaulting them.

But the schools hands are also tied because there's no where for this kid to go and they can't kick him out at this stage until there is a major incident (which school are deseparately trying to avoid).

It feels like a rock and a hard place. If the school are marked down then it only gets worse, but if the school retain outstanding I'm not sure it will get better either cos they've got away with stuff they probably shouldn't.

I rate the school. The teachers do all genuinely care. But there's just so much bullshit going on too. The whole system from top to bottom isn't set up to help the child to be safe and maximise all their potential. There's no money for the kids that need support, if parents play the system there's no teeth to address it for the benefit of the other kids, there's no consequences for outrageous behaviour.

Everyone is just being failed.

My suspicion is that things are going to go from bad to worse with moral in the school. Even if it retains outstanding.

I fail to see what the inspection will actually achieve tbh. Apart from more problems.

Notjustamum10 · 17/03/2023 20:35

I lost faith in Ofsted when they downgraded my kids’ nursery after an un-announced inspection. They came in a day or two before Xmas - most nurseries were already closed for the holiday but this one made a real effort to keep closures to a minimum - and so had a lot of temporary staff. It was central London and had very multi-cultural staff and children.
One comment in the inspection was around staff not being familiar with the Prevent programme and children were therefore not kept safe from religious radicalisation. This was 1-4 year olds!
I bet that Ofsted wouldn’t have criticised a mainly white / less diverse nursery in the same way. It smacked of racism and it felt that the nursery was punished for trying to stay open during the Christmas holidays, and bringing in temporary staff to do so, in response to demand from working parents.

BakedBear · 17/03/2023 20:15

Ofsted are harmful and disgusting.

User8646382 · 17/03/2023 19:55

HoranTheHawk · 17/03/2023 19:24

I wouldn’t have agreed with this myself until my youngest child’s pre school became victim to OFSTED the other month.

The inspectors were rude and disinterested when I spoke to them. They said the pre school (running and serving the village for 75 years) was inadequate because children could potentially gain access to a fire door and open it. The fire door couldn’t be blocked because that would be a fire risk… The pre school put in a new fire door but because of how long it would take for OFSTED to reinspect they lost their funding for the council and had to close leaving 35 children with nowhere to go. The care of the children and everything else was outstanding…. Just heartbreaking.

You can adapt fire doors to make them childproof at very little cost so I suspect your preschool was looking for an excuse to close.

That said, Ofsted has way too much power, and the inspectors, in my experience, are bitter, angry people who derive pleasure from making others squirm. I have yet to meet a normal one.

2022again · 17/03/2023 19:45

begoneday · 17/03/2023 19:34

They only have their power and influence because parents want outstanding rated schools for their DC. If parents were less obsessed with ratings , schools and teachers could dismiss Ofsted ratings and focus on more important things.

You can hardly blame parents ,if we are told that’s how schools are rated how are parents to know any different?we only know different because we’ve had 2 kids go through 3 different schools so know not to only assess a school by its ofsted (and to realise that outstanding schools in middle class areas can end up resting on their laurels because they’ve not been inspected in a decade).

Eskarina1 · 17/03/2023 19:42

I used to work for a regulator in healthcare (not the cqc) that got overhauled for being really aggressive just as I joined. The new approach was much more of a partnership where if services were getting it wrong we worked with them to improve - sometimes with mentorship and support, sometimes with making it clear to other agencies what they needed. We also worked with them to build clear action plans and support them to achieve it.

I don't think focusing on individuals- either as super stars transforming schools or framing them as the problem - is the right way. Its about making the system work. Noone should feel like this about an inspection

begoneday · 17/03/2023 19:34

They only have their power and influence because parents want outstanding rated schools for their DC. If parents were less obsessed with ratings , schools and teachers could dismiss Ofsted ratings and focus on more important things.

HoranTheHawk · 17/03/2023 19:24

I wouldn’t have agreed with this myself until my youngest child’s pre school became victim to OFSTED the other month.

The inspectors were rude and disinterested when I spoke to them. They said the pre school (running and serving the village for 75 years) was inadequate because children could potentially gain access to a fire door and open it. The fire door couldn’t be blocked because that would be a fire risk… The pre school put in a new fire door but because of how long it would take for OFSTED to reinspect they lost their funding for the council and had to close leaving 35 children with nowhere to go. The care of the children and everything else was outstanding…. Just heartbreaking.

avocadotofu · 17/03/2023 19:16

I totally agree. Schools could still be held accountable by a collaborative inspection process that focused on working together and truly improving schools. Rather than the current just coming and judging them.

cansu · 17/03/2023 19:15

Ofsted is not about every child matters. It is about ticking boxes and putting on a show. It is about training staff and children to answer questions using buzz words. It is a real shame that we don't have a service focused on school improvement.

HubertTheGoat · 17/03/2023 19:09

Puzzledandpissedoff · 17/03/2023 16:42

It's awful that anyone lives under so much stress that they think suicide is the answer and there's so much pressure on a couple of days visit, but ofsted isn't in the wrong to point out risks to children and say the present set up is inadequate

Sounds a pretty balanced response to this tragedy to me, and as so often I expect there's more to this than we know

Of course it's harsh to award an almost automatic "inadequate" over a bit of record keeping, but it's not as if this is an unknown thing so why not make damned sure something you know they're going to prioritise is watertight?

Also, as you say, the report suggests there was rather more to it than just a bit of paperwork

I don't know specifically about safeguarding records, but what I do know is that Ofsted are anything but clear about what paperwork schools should have in place. It is literally a guessing game. Where I am, headteachers often have two or three schools (rural) and are asked to produce completely different documents when their respective schools are inspected, which shows how inconsistent the process is. I've told teacher friends in at least half a dozen schools about the paperwork we were asked for and not one keeps the records we were asked to produce. If Ofsted were more transparent, we might all stand a chance. We were told time and again by LA advisors we were Good. Inspectors said otherwise. The process is broken.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 17/03/2023 19:07

Nightlystroll · 17/03/2023 18:02

Gaps in record keeping? Maybe the school couldn’t employ a permanent safeguarding team due to cuts?

But the gaps ofsted were talking about were things like gaps in employment records where anything could have happened. It's just a basic requirement that you have a full and complete employment background on all your employees who will be around vulnerable people. I've been looking for care homes for my mum. I've come across a couple that got rated inadequate for both management and safety categories because of gaps like these. If a member of staff assaulted a child and that could have been discovered from a full employment record, how many poster on here would be supporting you over your claim you were too busy to check or lacked sufficient staff?

The gaps in record keeping at our school weren’t gaps. They were just files that for reasons I won’t go into weren’t accessible. Not great, yes, but not actual gaps. Our report said that no children had been put at risk, as did Caversham’s. But still, inadequate.

WhereIsMyRefund · 17/03/2023 18:58

Ugh it’s shit. We have CQC inspections on our wards and it’s equally mindless. Auditing crap and not focussing on the important stuff. We actually set up teams to manage the inspection weeks in advance. Leaflets sent round staff. Endless prep meetings. All costing time
and money and keeping us from patient care.

I wish there was some way we could boycott it.

I also hate the management’s joy when we go from Requires Improvement to Good. If we don’t accept the crap result we should not celebrate the good ones.

I wish there could be some national action of boycotting CQC and Ofsted inspections. Downing tools and refusing to engage. If everyone did it, that might give a message.

Shinyandnew1 · 17/03/2023 18:44

schoolsweek.co.uk/labours-ofsted-plans-logical-evolution-says-spielman/

The head of Ofsted even seems to think removing their own grading labels (as Labour have already proposed) is probably a good idea. Shame she didn’t suggest it during the years she was in charge really.

Labour also suggest having specialists inspecting phases which should already be a must. My friend’s school was done recently. They are a small infant school and were inspected by an inspector who was the Assistant Head of a secondary and taught mainly A level geography. He didn’t know anything about child development, phonics or early reading-it was a bit of a joke really.

I don’t think anyone really thinks schools should never have any sort of audit, but this system is broken, destructive and doesn’t raise standards. I think Labour’s proposals here are good.

Nightlystroll · 17/03/2023 18:43

noblegiraffe · 17/03/2023 18:29

But that doesn't mean ofsted weren't in the wrong to point out the failings.

I don't think anyone disagrees with inspectors telling a school that their safeguarding paperwork is incomplete.

It's the form of the telling that's the issue.

But aren't parents entitled to know that there are failings in safeguarding? Amd it wasn't like the paperwork was just incomplete, the leadership team lacked knowledge to carry out adequate safeguarding. If the leadership didn't know, you know the staff are going to know even less

"Leaders do not have the required knowledge to keep pupils safe from harm. They have not taken prompt and proper actions when pupils are at risk. They have not ensured that safeguarding is effective throughout the school"...leaders have a "weak understanding of safeguarding requirements and procedures".

The lack of understanding is really quite serious. How much training do you go through in your school? Nothing is done on staff training days more than that.

Dippydinosaurus · 17/03/2023 18:36

I also know of a local head who committed suicide. As an ex teacher I'd do away with any advance notice as it creates panic no matter how well the school is prepared. Much better to just turn up on the day for a day inspection. I'm so glad I'm out of it now

noblegiraffe · 17/03/2023 18:29

But that doesn't mean ofsted weren't in the wrong to point out the failings.

I don't think anyone disagrees with inspectors telling a school that their safeguarding paperwork is incomplete.

It's the form of the telling that's the issue.

Nightlystroll · 17/03/2023 18:25

modgepodge · 17/03/2023 18:09

Of course the paperwork should have been in order. But I think there should be a better way to check on this so it could be picked up earlier - perhaps yearly low stakes checks by the LA to check everything is in order, and if it’s not, support to sort it out, without publicly announcing to the world that it is a problem. Not 13 years of not knowing it’s wrong followed by a public branding of INADEQUATE which makes it seem like the whole school is crap, when the report clearly shows it is not and is good in every other area.

I've been through ofsteds. It's a mad system and better ways to do it, in my opinion. The stress it causes throughout the school or college is massive. So much, too much, rests on this two days. And it's not an accurate snapshot of how the school operates day by day.

But. But this headteacher knew what was coming down the tracks. She'd have known they'd been due an inspection after so long. Everyone, but everyone, knows your paperwork needs to be in order. Even above the standard of teaching, the boxes must be ticked. You can't just say, oh we've lost this and that. And they clearly hadn't done safeguarding training properly. I can't count how much safe guarding training we had to go through. Like you say, the school reached good in other categories. But in this day and age, if you've not got your safeguarding properly sorted, getting inadequate seems inevitable.

Clearly the stress this woman felt must have been so excessive and I feel hugely for her and her family. But that doesn't mean ofsted weren't in the wrong to point out the failings.

PleaseJustText · 17/03/2023 18:24

noblegiraffe · 17/03/2023 16:20

I have had an ofsted inspector mark me down because I didn't have the homosexual students in my class marked on my register, and I wasn't teaching percentages in a way inclusive to homosexuals

Er, what??

This doesn't surprise me as much as you. I kid you not, in higher educations we have to report sexual orientation to the Higher Education Statistics Agency. The rest of the data is the usual stuff like start date, end date, course applied for, final award. It's all very standard except sexual orientation. I was surprised.

noblegiraffe · 17/03/2023 18:20

No one thinks that schools shouldn't be inspected and the fact that teachers are generally recommending inspections take place more often so that they are less high stakes shows this.

If this school did not have the correct safeguarding paperwork in place, even going four years without this being checked isn't good enough. A lot can happen in four years.