Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Think That Oxfam Should Cancel Themselves

84 replies

MrsJamesofSutton · 17/03/2023 08:45

Oxfam have published a New Language Guide (if you google that phrase, there are various news sites and indeed Oxfam's own site) pouring approbation on terms such as 'Mother' , 'biological sex', 'field trip' and even apologising for the fact that the guide is written in English-a colonial language.

There are many more examples-some laughable and some quite frightening.

As Oxfam exists , primarily. to help other nations-many of them non-white-couldn't this be see as a patronising, 'Great White Saviour Organisation' and the next logical step, therefore, is to cancel itself.

OP posts:
Whattodonut · 17/03/2023 14:53

@MrsJamesofSutton I apologise for not tagging @LaviniasBigBloomers in my post. Who referred to herself as a cunty kind of woman and mother.

I also would refer to myself as a cunty kind of woman and mother so...

and I strongly agree with @EverybodysALebowski . I believe there is a place for calm rational conversation. Rather than pearl clutching. The first thing I did was read the document. And before I replied I read the whole thing.the name guardian isn't referred to. It's like book burning. Don't assume something is as bad as the view of one reviewer. Try reading the book itself.

Whattodonut · 17/03/2023 14:47

Oh my god. I was replying to @LaviniasBigBloomers ! Calm your pants my dear!

MrsJamesofSutton · 17/03/2023 14:31

EverybodysALebowski · 17/03/2023 14:27

I have been here a long time. Long enough in fact to remember when most people who posted in AIBU were at least willing to consider that they might be wrong, or were interested in hearing the perspectives of those they disagreed with, even if there was no chance whatsoever of changing their opinion.

Having a robust argument backed with information, facts, and spirit is great.

Telling someone who disagrees in their interpretation "Go back and have a proper read with your reading glasses on because everyone else has seen it" does not qualify as a a robust argumentative strategy. It's just name-calling and aggressiveness and suggests you're not interested in persuading others or having your ideas challenged.

What do you think about the fact I have been called a cunt?

This is all a smoke screen to take the light of Oxfam and their dangerous nonsensical document.

OP posts:
MrsJamesofSutton · 17/03/2023 14:29

The CEO of Oxfam, was asked by Kate Garroway why they had announced they were dropping, 'mother' and 'father' and @Whattodonut , unlike you, he acknowledged this and I guess as CEO, he must know what this document says, as he said they were dropping it but a lot of places used guardian now-yes, that was his weasel defence for that one.

Maybe you should get on to him and give him the wonderful news that he hasn't dropped 'mother' after all..

He will be pleased!

I'm a mother, not a guardian and I think more than 50% of mothers will feel the same.

Happy Guardians' day to you!

The rest of his document is laughable to and before you try to defend it, I accept your apology in advance for writing in English-a colonial language used to oppress-according to Oxfam.

OP posts:
EverybodysALebowski · 17/03/2023 14:27

I have been here a long time. Long enough in fact to remember when most people who posted in AIBU were at least willing to consider that they might be wrong, or were interested in hearing the perspectives of those they disagreed with, even if there was no chance whatsoever of changing their opinion.

Having a robust argument backed with information, facts, and spirit is great.

Telling someone who disagrees in their interpretation "Go back and have a proper read with your reading glasses on because everyone else has seen it" does not qualify as a a robust argumentative strategy. It's just name-calling and aggressiveness and suggests you're not interested in persuading others or having your ideas challenged.

MrsJamesofSutton · 17/03/2023 14:15

Whattodonut · 17/03/2023 12:06

Where does it say they don't use mother? They do. Explicitly. They use parents first because that includes both parents- That's what most organisations that support parents do. (E.g. NHS, SW, almost all charities except the hyper religious etc) And explicitly say "if individual parents have a preference for a role name, to respect their choices". So they'd be happy to refer to you as a mother.

Or woman? They do. All over! That's the whole 1st section.

I think they'd probably rather not call you a cunt out loud though.

Go back and have a proper read with your reading glasses on because everyone else has seen it.

Do you work for Oxfam?

Why so angry that you call me a cunt. Most odd. You sound as if you're angry that it is over every news outlet, even Breakfast TV and you've overheated.

Perhaps you would rather it was kept quiet.

OP posts:
MrsJamesofSutton · 17/03/2023 14:12

EverybodysALebowski · 17/03/2023 10:39

"Well, thank you for stating the obvious. Do you normally just ignore everything shit in this world as long as it doesn't directly affect you?"

"Some hard of thinking will agree with them."

"Do you think?"

YABU, regardless of any argument you're making, because you're being rude AF and insulting to people who respond with views different from yours.

What an odd remark.

So, if I say all cats and dogs should be down immediately but say it nicely with a smiley face and flowers, then, that makes it ok does it?

And if I say free healthcare for all but say it rudely, that is not ok.

As long as I understand that it is not what I say but how I say it. That is ridiculous. Vote for me, I've got a big smile and don't vote for Johnny because he is sarcastic! Is that really how you go through life deciding what is right and wrong? dear Oh dear! No wonder so many get away with so much.

Also, if you think I've been rude, well then-maybe you're new to AIBU.

OP posts:
MrsJamesofSutton · 17/03/2023 14:05

kikedog · 17/03/2023 10:13

They also say English is a language of oppression, I might start sending them a lot of correspondance in welsh so they can spend translation fees...

😂😂

OP posts:
Whattodonut · 17/03/2023 12:06

Where does it say they don't use mother? They do. Explicitly. They use parents first because that includes both parents- That's what most organisations that support parents do. (E.g. NHS, SW, almost all charities except the hyper religious etc) And explicitly say "if individual parents have a preference for a role name, to respect their choices". So they'd be happy to refer to you as a mother.

Or woman? They do. All over! That's the whole 1st section.

I think they'd probably rather not call you a cunt out loud though.

LaviniasBigBloomers · 17/03/2023 11:57

Whattodonut · 17/03/2023 11:42

It even says "when working with groups that have experienced discrimination, we should always be advised by them on how they wish to be referred to"

Brilliant.

In that case I'll have woman (the cunty kind) for my societal and sexual discrimination and mother (also the cunty kind) for my economic discrimination.

Anything to do with Oxfam just makes me think 'they need their hard drives checking'. Horrendous organisation.

Whattodonut · 17/03/2023 11:42

It even says "when working with groups that have experienced discrimination, we should always be advised by them on how they wish to be referred to"

Whattodonut · 17/03/2023 11:27

I think the principles are sound and were created with the people who experience the discrimination. So " sex worker" is what people who are usually called prostitutes prefer to be called. I can't see a problem with that. But I can't say I've read 92 pages of it!

furryfrontbottom · 17/03/2023 11:17

OXFAM have written this because this is how they want language to be used going forward. They want it it to be accepted. Anyone who buys as much as a tatty old overpriced paperback from them or who donates Grandmothers' curtains to them, is agreeing with them.

I don't think so. Most people engaging in the transactions you describe will not have read the book and will not have an opinion about it.

Precipice · 17/03/2023 11:00

OP, approbation is positive! Not sure what you were aiming for - perhaps opprobium?

EverybodysALebowski · 17/03/2023 10:39

"Well, thank you for stating the obvious. Do you normally just ignore everything shit in this world as long as it doesn't directly affect you?"

"Some hard of thinking will agree with them."

"Do you think?"

YABU, regardless of any argument you're making, because you're being rude AF and insulting to people who respond with views different from yours.

TidyDancer · 17/03/2023 10:15

This is genuinely one of the worst examples of this shit I've seen in quite a while. They are so out of touch it's unreal.

Do we know much about the joker(s) who actually put this crap together? I'd be taking a very close look at them.

kikedog · 17/03/2023 10:13

They also say English is a language of oppression, I might start sending them a lot of correspondance in welsh so they can spend translation fees...

Cleargreysky · 17/03/2023 10:11

Their definition of sex worker makes it clear that they do not view men purchasing women's bodies as an exploitative or harmful practice. Which rather helps us to understand their appalling behaviour when their own workers were exploiting women in this way. From their organistion's political position, nothing bad was actually happening.

I also note that in 92 pages of definitions (92!) they deliberately avoid defining 'woman' or 'man'. Which marks them out as rather cowardly.

This document is not about avoiding offence. It is deeply offensive to many people, as they will well know. Its offensive to many women based on their understanding of the human rights of women. Its offensive to many gay and lesbian people based on their understanding of their humans rights as lesbians and gay men.

This document is a deeply political statement on Oxfam's stance on a deeply divisive human rights issues, with people on both sides viewing their positions as rights based groups. They could at least have been honest about what this document is.

BossBerk · 17/03/2023 10:10

Ew. The youth (teenagers and early 20s) are suspicious of Oxfam and their sexual exploitation and bullying issues.

I don't think oxfam will be around for much longer! The local secondary kids refused to do work experience with the 😂 their views and opinions were eye opening!

fairislecable · 17/03/2023 10:05

I know someone who worked there after Uni, she ended up on successive temporary contracts until they told her no money for 3 months until the next project. Could she work for free?

Sadly she wasn’t the only young person they did this to..

I only ever support local charities now.

SweetMeadow · 17/03/2023 09:54

Completely agree OP. I get such bad vibes from Oxfam and refuse to donate my stuff there (even though it’s the most convenient option with their superstore in our city) and won’t buy any of their eye watering, overpriced stuff.

I still feel disgusted about the sex worker revelations and constantly hear about the toxic environment and culture which drives them to make money.

I once had to deal with the head of another big charity (on a personal matter to him) and he was the worst bully I’ve ever come across and used to leave screaming voicemails for me with threats. I was 21 and it gave me an insight into what kind of people have these top jobs in the charity sector.

Cleargreysky · 17/03/2023 09:47

They are a classic example of a charity that has lost its focus on its core aims.

The time and money spent on developing that guide should have been spent on their core mission.

Justmeandthedog1 · 17/03/2023 09:46

So if a person donates to Oxfam their money might contribute to developing, writing, publishing & distributing this dross rather than help the people Oxfam purports to help?
Yes, they’re past their sell by date.

Mummyoflittledragon · 17/03/2023 09:46

This is just so funny. Yes, logical conclusion.

MrsJamesofSutton · 17/03/2023 09:43

ThreeFeetTall · 17/03/2023 09:37

What do the people that the charity exists to support think of the language used? This is probably more important than what some (UK based?) person on Mumsnet thinks.

Do you think?

OP posts: