Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Think That Oxfam Should Cancel Themselves

84 replies

MrsJamesofSutton · 17/03/2023 08:45

Oxfam have published a New Language Guide (if you google that phrase, there are various news sites and indeed Oxfam's own site) pouring approbation on terms such as 'Mother' , 'biological sex', 'field trip' and even apologising for the fact that the guide is written in English-a colonial language.

There are many more examples-some laughable and some quite frightening.

As Oxfam exists , primarily. to help other nations-many of them non-white-couldn't this be see as a patronising, 'Great White Saviour Organisation' and the next logical step, therefore, is to cancel itself.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ArabellaScott · 18/03/2023 18:31

YANBU, OP. Oxfam seems to me to be rotten.

This bit in the language guide in particular made me raise my eyebrow:

'we avoid

prostitute, prostitution, use of prostitutes, use of sex workers'

^^

To Think That Oxfam Should Cancel Themselves
Sloth66 · 18/03/2023 11:06

BBC
Oxfam: UK halts funding over new sexual exploitation claims
7 April 2021

new allegations of sexual abuse led to staff being suspended

Sloth66 · 18/03/2023 10:14

I stopped donating to them after the disgusting Haiti revelations . I don’t know how they felt able to use the phrase Empowering Women above their shop fronts after that.

A friend spent some time at their Oxford headquarters and told me she was shocked at the culture of excess and profligacy there. This booklet just continues to endorse my opinion of them.

Bamboux · 18/03/2023 09:59

RudsyFarmer · 17/03/2023 21:28

These huge charities waste so much time and resources on this nonsense. Amnesty International is no better.

Amnesty has become an appalling cesspit of antisemitism and misogyny in recent years. It's really sad
In its early years it was a true force for good.

RudsyFarmer · 17/03/2023 21:28

These huge charities waste so much time and resources on this nonsense. Amnesty International is no better.

Bamboux · 17/03/2023 21:24

110APiccadilly · 17/03/2023 20:56

Syniad gwych!

Bendigedig x

FKATondelayo · 17/03/2023 21:22

flaffydaffy · 17/03/2023 20:51

That's a bit jumbled. Is being a mother about being female or about giving birth?

If you're confused ask an adult.

ClareBlue · 17/03/2023 21:17

Cleargreysky · 17/03/2023 09:47

They are a classic example of a charity that has lost its focus on its core aims.

The time and money spent on developing that guide should have been spent on their core mission.

They made a deliberate policy decision a number of years ago to change their core mission from only practical projects helping those in need to incorporating advocating politically for those in need through political lobbying. Whilst there might be a role for this in large charitable organisations Oxfam are an absolute classic example where it can go wrong. There culture is now full of its own self importance, self interest, power and hierarchical bullying and abuse wrapped up with entitlement and financial greed and mismanagement. Unfortunately they still live on a past repretation of actually doing some good and people still support them. They have millions in public funding.
Amensty International aren't far behind them and going the same way.

JudgeJ · 17/03/2023 21:03

Lockheart · 17/03/2023 09:10

Have you tried not using this "New Language Guide"? I'd just ignore it myself.

Sounds like the source of many a laugh at the idiocy!

110APiccadilly · 17/03/2023 20:56

kikedog · 17/03/2023 10:13

They also say English is a language of oppression, I might start sending them a lot of correspondance in welsh so they can spend translation fees...

Syniad gwych!

flaffydaffy · 17/03/2023 20:51

FKATondelayo · 17/03/2023 19:37

Lesbian parents are both mothers, just like I said. The mother is the female parent. Someone who gives birth is a mother. Both females, one of whom gives birth.

But agree with you about gender - unnecessary ever to reference it. Sex is the relevant category.

That's a bit jumbled. Is being a mother about being female or about giving birth?

Whattodonut · 17/03/2023 20:43

ColdHandsHotHead · 17/03/2023 17:35

Exactly. All organisations have this sort of style guide. If you don't work for them, why are you worried about it? Just get on with your life.

They really do. Its the equivalent of a linguistical style guide. Any publisher would have that.
I'm very shrug about this outrage. You can hate Oxfam but this document is so inoffensive that those trying to critique it here are tying themselves in knots

FKATondelayo · 17/03/2023 19:37

Crancod · 17/03/2023 17:34

“A mother is a female parent, a father is a male parent. If my husband decided to transition he wouldn't be our kids mother. A person who gives birth is a mother, regardless of whether they have a wispy beard.”
So if the parents are a lesbian couple, the ‘person who gives birth’ is the mother? What’s the other person?

Defaulting to ‘parent’ where gender references are not necessary makes sense to me.

I also note that, in the context of pregnancy, Oxfam’s preferred language is ‘pregnant women’, so we’re not exactly in the realms of ‘uterus-havers’.

Lesbian parents are both mothers, just like I said. The mother is the female parent. Someone who gives birth is a mother. Both females, one of whom gives birth.

But agree with you about gender - unnecessary ever to reference it. Sex is the relevant category.

DevilinaCardigan · 17/03/2023 17:45

I’m so confused. I’m not a cunning linguist but I’m pretty sure most , if not all, languages have words for mother and father.
Also, I’m guessing people who are in need of help from oxfam have much larger concerns than being called mother or father.

Transgenderism seems to be a western phenomena. other countries have various third genders but no one believes that they are actually literally women.

ColdHandsHotHead · 17/03/2023 17:35

Lockheart · 17/03/2023 09:10

Have you tried not using this "New Language Guide"? I'd just ignore it myself.

Exactly. All organisations have this sort of style guide. If you don't work for them, why are you worried about it? Just get on with your life.

Crancod · 17/03/2023 17:34

FKATondelayo · 17/03/2023 17:20

A mother is a female parent, a father is a male parent. If my husband decided to transition he wouldn't be our kids mother. A person who gives birth is a mother, regardless of whether they have a wispy beard.

Language should be simple and describe facts. And that goes a hundred times over for any setting that Oxfam operates in where there are multiple languages being spoken by people who may not have fluent English, people who are under pressure who use words to quickly and accurately convey meaning.

“A mother is a female parent, a father is a male parent. If my husband decided to transition he wouldn't be our kids mother. A person who gives birth is a mother, regardless of whether they have a wispy beard.”
So if the parents are a lesbian couple, the ‘person who gives birth’ is the mother? What’s the other person?

Defaulting to ‘parent’ where gender references are not necessary makes sense to me.

I also note that, in the context of pregnancy, Oxfam’s preferred language is ‘pregnant women’, so we’re not exactly in the realms of ‘uterus-havers’.

FKATondelayo · 17/03/2023 17:20

Crancod · 17/03/2023 17:02

What part of that is objectionable?

A mother is a female parent, a father is a male parent. If my husband decided to transition he wouldn't be our kids mother. A person who gives birth is a mother, regardless of whether they have a wispy beard.

Language should be simple and describe facts. And that goes a hundred times over for any setting that Oxfam operates in where there are multiple languages being spoken by people who may not have fluent English, people who are under pressure who use words to quickly and accurately convey meaning.

Naunet · 17/03/2023 17:12

They’re a disgusting, misogynistic, rapey, hypocritical organisation. Should be closed down.

endofthelinefinally · 17/03/2023 17:12

I remember hearing about Oxfam's awful reputation over 30 years ago. How they are still going is beyond me.

Bamboux · 17/03/2023 17:10

14 June
Haiti announces it is withdrawing Oxfam GB’s right to operate in the country “for violation of Haitian law and serious violation of the principle of the dignity of the human beings”.

I mean that's fairly serious. That was in 2018, not 11 years ago.

Bamboux · 17/03/2023 17:09

Whattodonut · 17/03/2023 16:15

I am in no way defending them but that was in 2011. 12 years have passed and I'm pretty sure all charities have bad people in them who take advantage of the vunerable and the access being an air worker gives them. Does that mean all charities should close down? Or just those who are trying to be better now?

I don't know of any other examples of very large charities who have routinely carried out and then covered up such truly horrific acts of abuse using the charity's funds.

It wasn't just in Haiti and it wasn't a few bad apples. This was systematic rape, child abuse, and cover ups.

NurseCranesRolodex · 17/03/2023 17:05

thebellagio · 17/03/2023 09:11

Slightly OT but I've never been a fan of Oxfam. I worked on a project many moons ago where a client was making a substantial donation to Oxfam - think £20-25k and they couldn't have been less interested in us. Whenever we asked for feedback/support on this project, we were just constantly told we didn't reach the right "corporate partner" level so we weren't entitled to any support from them

It really opened my eyes to what national corporate charities are like.

Wow. That's shocking but I'm not completely surprised. Time to cancel Oxfam I think.

Crancod · 17/03/2023 17:02

FKATondelayo · 17/03/2023 16:49

That's not true at all. At no point in that section does it state they are talking about trans parents specifically.

The paragraph is called Parent, Parenthood

"To describe the role in raising children without directly ascribing
gendered roles. If trans parents have a preferred specified gender role,
such as ‘mother’ or ‘father’, this should be respected. If unsure, it is
more inclusive to use ‘parent’.

In patriarchal culture, social norms around gender result in designated roles for parents that reflect expectations of that gender. Some transgender and non-binarypeople may identify with these roles. However, some may prefer to use other names to designate parenthood. The important principle
here is to be inclusive in the broader sense by describing people as ‘parents’, but if individual parents have a preference for a role name, to respect their choice.

WE AVOID ‘mother’ or ‘father’ (avoid assuming the adoption of gendered roles by transgender parents)"

What part of that is objectionable?

FKATondelayo · 17/03/2023 16:49

Crancod · 17/03/2023 16:38

But it’s specifically in the context of transgender parents, unless they indicate a preference for ‘mother or father’.

“To describe the role in raising children without directly ascribing gendered roles. If trans parents have a preferred specified gender role, such as ‘mother’ or ‘father’, this should be respected. If unsure, it is more inclusive to use ‘parent’.”

“WE AVOID
‘mother’ or ‘father’ (avoid assuming the adoption of gendered roles by transgender parents)”

That's not true at all. At no point in that section does it state they are talking about trans parents specifically.

The paragraph is called Parent, Parenthood

"To describe the role in raising children without directly ascribing
gendered roles. If trans parents have a preferred specified gender role,
such as ‘mother’ or ‘father’, this should be respected. If unsure, it is
more inclusive to use ‘parent’.

In patriarchal culture, social norms around gender result in designated roles for parents that reflect expectations of that gender. Some transgender and non-binarypeople may identify with these roles. However, some may prefer to use other names to designate parenthood. The important principle
here is to be inclusive in the broader sense by describing people as ‘parents’, but if individual parents have a preference for a role name, to respect their choice.

WE AVOID ‘mother’ or ‘father’ (avoid assuming the adoption of gendered roles by transgender parents)"

EdithHowland · 17/03/2023 16:47

I am just boggling that someone was sitting piously writing this crap and getting paid for it. It might be a nice little fantasy to run up in your spare time if you believe that language should be amended to such an extent (eg like Esperanto).

Heaven knows how many other charities are haemorrhaging precious funds on this kind of drivel.

Swipe left for the next trending thread