Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

are we all just wank material?

215 replies

piqueen · 17/03/2023 00:30

I've been speaking to a few different people online in a group for my hobby.
The women are all normal, the men have mostly been normal. (age from 20-50)
I've been speaking to 3 men, very polite. Everything on topic. As soon as the sun goes down, all 3 become rude, sexual innuendos and asking if I'm alone in bed.
Why?!
It is so boring and predictable and now I feel like leaving the group because its so fucking insulting.

This is a group where people can message privately only, and I get mostly messages from men, there are maybe 10x the amount of men on here than women. Now I'm wondering if they all come on just to talk dirty to women.

OP posts:
Burgoo · 18/03/2023 18:39

@piqueen No you are being ludicrous and TBH a bit egocentric. Not every man is interested in you, no matter how attractive you think you are (not YOU I mean generally). Get over yourselves.

Some men (just like some women) are sexualised and some aren't.

Imagine if I asked "why do women do X?" as though women are one homogenous group. PEOPLE are arseholes, regardless of gender.

Sealwright · 18/03/2023 18:34

Sometimes it does feel like that. It's heartbreaking that we have no spaces to go to, not even online, that men won't turn wierd. Do we all have to go incognito just to stay safe?

Hence · 18/03/2023 18:27

Not all men are like this... but it is such a large amount of men that it may as well be. The very few men that aren't like this also seem not to be good at calling the shit majority out. My DH is not like this, but he would never call it out, which to me is almost as bad.

Cantbebothered90 · 18/03/2023 18:07

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

emptythelitterbox · 18/03/2023 17:59

Mark19735 · 18/03/2023 16:45

I'm sometimes convinced that most MN threads are populated by men pretending to be women. Or AI chatbots pretending to be human. Some of the opinions stated are so dogmatic, hate-filled, inflexible and frankly discriminatory that they can only be intended as parody.

Quite a few are men pretending to be women. Far too many have issues with women congregating and speaking so they bully, harrass, and try to chase off women.

Onnabugeisha · 18/03/2023 17:58

piqueen · 17/03/2023 00:30

I've been speaking to a few different people online in a group for my hobby.
The women are all normal, the men have mostly been normal. (age from 20-50)
I've been speaking to 3 men, very polite. Everything on topic. As soon as the sun goes down, all 3 become rude, sexual innuendos and asking if I'm alone in bed.
Why?!
It is so boring and predictable and now I feel like leaving the group because its so fucking insulting.

This is a group where people can message privately only, and I get mostly messages from men, there are maybe 10x the amount of men on here than women. Now I'm wondering if they all come on just to talk dirty to women.

Well, apparently 3 men do. But that’s hardly an adequate sample size from which to conclude all men do.

emptythelitterbox · 18/03/2023 17:57

TheMatriarchy · 18/03/2023 16:17

Online men and men in real life seem to be a different species. Online men behave like this routinely, IRL men do not. Are they the same men, I don't know.

What I have noticed however, is that threads like this are magnets to the men of mumsnet. You dont get mark12345 or cantbebothered getting their 2p in on the 'whats this rash on my baby', or 'this happened at work today', but put wank or porn in the title and the site suddenly becomes a lot more mixed sex.
Says it all really.

Men in RL also seem to not know any other men who do these things. Amazing isn't it!

I'm not sure I've ever seen a man on here ever giving that type of advice. Should I go to A&E, having problems with toddler for x, suggestions for cleaning x, woman being abused, All crickets from men.

Anything sex, dick, porn, problems with their hurt feels, they're on those threads with bells on and NAMALT thrown in for good measure.

Mark19735 · 18/03/2023 16:45

I'm sometimes convinced that most MN threads are populated by men pretending to be women. Or AI chatbots pretending to be human. Some of the opinions stated are so dogmatic, hate-filled, inflexible and frankly discriminatory that they can only be intended as parody.

TheMatriarchy · 18/03/2023 16:17

Online men and men in real life seem to be a different species. Online men behave like this routinely, IRL men do not. Are they the same men, I don't know.

What I have noticed however, is that threads like this are magnets to the men of mumsnet. You dont get mark12345 or cantbebothered getting their 2p in on the 'whats this rash on my baby', or 'this happened at work today', but put wank or porn in the title and the site suddenly becomes a lot more mixed sex.
Says it all really.

Shitfather · 18/03/2023 15:36

Ponderoveryonder · 17/03/2023 23:04

@Shitfather
why would you entertain your married friend sending you messages like that?
why would you want a friend who thought that was ok?

I cut off the conversation as soon as there is a hint of any of this. I don’t entertain them and I certainly do not respond. There’s invariably a decent conversation beforehand. He’s like the other men described, but he has a lot of redeeming qualities too.

User135644 · 18/03/2023 14:55

PearCrumbleCustard · 18/03/2023 12:46

I really think generalisations are never helpful, most men aren’t awful. There are cultural factors at play which I think helps more men than women feel entitled, but I think a lot of women feed into this also. Like see how many women stick up on mumsnet forums for these:

If we’re going to go down the feminism route though, today’s accepted feminism tells us a few things:

men can be women if they want, with access all areas
Sex work is work, and a valid choice for young women to choose
porn is empowering and all men and plenty of women watch it.

I am against all of the above.

Women are so key often to social cultural norms, we have a lot of power to change them, and often we don’t. Not sure why!

There's more women than men in the country. More women than men vote. An increasing percentage of women MPs each parliament, two female PMs in tge last 5 years. Women have plenty of power to change things.

PearCrumbleCustard · 18/03/2023 12:46

I really think generalisations are never helpful, most men aren’t awful. There are cultural factors at play which I think helps more men than women feel entitled, but I think a lot of women feed into this also. Like see how many women stick up on mumsnet forums for these:

If we’re going to go down the feminism route though, today’s accepted feminism tells us a few things:

men can be women if they want, with access all areas
Sex work is work, and a valid choice for young women to choose
porn is empowering and all men and plenty of women watch it.

I am against all of the above.

Women are so key often to social cultural norms, we have a lot of power to change them, and often we don’t. Not sure why!

TobeLeRone · 18/03/2023 12:35

Mark19735 · 18/03/2023 08:12

If you want to talk about cultures and poison - try dance classes. The standard ballet and tap. Thousands of them up and down the country. Kids as young as 4 being taught hyper-sexualised moves, then performing them at a gala show at the end of the year to an approving audience. The older ones are usually encouraged to choreograph their own routines - I must have seen five successive variations on the Flashdance shower dance with sixteen year olds in fishnets sitting on a chair in the Christine Keeler pose. The participants are 99% girls. The 1% boys are usually too young to have come out yet but it's patently only a matter of time until they do. The teachers are all women. The assistants who demonstrate the moves are all older girls. The audience in 75% mums and grans. There is no way - no way at all - that it can be said that this segment of society is populated by, run for the benefit of, or directly influenced in any way by men. These girls are being groomed - by women - to have a body shape, mannerisms and posture that is pleasing to the male gaze. (And also the female gaze, no doubt). See also FGM. A crime perpetrated by women, against girls ... but blamed on men. Why is that? There are other root causes than just "AMALT"

Yes, you’re right, but the structure behind this goes back to times when it was openly accepted that women were the property of men, were inferior, only had any social standing once married, and only married well if they complied to societal expectations (or had family money backing them). Even in poor families a woman’s worth was in her marriage and her ability to produce sons. For a long time women have had to keep up with harmful beauty standards or being available for their men, disregarding their own needs. Even now it’s known that when a wife gets seriously ill many husbands run for the hills. If a woman wants to be with a man there are compromises. Many of us have realised that the compromises we make are too high a price to pay. Life is better without them.

These things are so deeply ingrained into women, even now. Maybe less so now, as more women reject mediocre men, and some countries have whole feminist movements that reject all men.

It’s going to take time, and men will continue to accept systems that keep women down, but I think eventually (assuming we don’t have some devastating handmaid’s tale scenario forced upon us) there will be a trickle down effect where men actually do better, and start treating women like they are equal humans and stepping up against woman-hating movements (like liberal feminism).

ssd · 18/03/2023 11:24

Jedsnewstar · 18/03/2023 08:32

idiot

Pathetic response

Cantbebothered90 · 18/03/2023 10:39

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

WayToMemphis · 18/03/2023 09:34

@piqueen I've experienced similar situations. Maybe it is worse online? I've had less problems with in-person social/hobby groups (I'm part of a cycling group, and also participate in hiking group).

You may or may not be wank material, who knows? But that's very different from the pushy, aggressive, suggestive interactions that are pushed on us by many men.

Jedsnewstar · 18/03/2023 08:32

CallieQ · 17/03/2023 00:56

NAMALT

idiot

User135644 · 18/03/2023 08:30

Mark19735 · 18/03/2023 08:12

If you want to talk about cultures and poison - try dance classes. The standard ballet and tap. Thousands of them up and down the country. Kids as young as 4 being taught hyper-sexualised moves, then performing them at a gala show at the end of the year to an approving audience. The older ones are usually encouraged to choreograph their own routines - I must have seen five successive variations on the Flashdance shower dance with sixteen year olds in fishnets sitting on a chair in the Christine Keeler pose. The participants are 99% girls. The 1% boys are usually too young to have come out yet but it's patently only a matter of time until they do. The teachers are all women. The assistants who demonstrate the moves are all older girls. The audience in 75% mums and grans. There is no way - no way at all - that it can be said that this segment of society is populated by, run for the benefit of, or directly influenced in any way by men. These girls are being groomed - by women - to have a body shape, mannerisms and posture that is pleasing to the male gaze. (And also the female gaze, no doubt). See also FGM. A crime perpetrated by women, against girls ... but blamed on men. Why is that? There are other root causes than just "AMALT"

It's like all the Cosmopolitan type magazines and articles and celebrity nonsense with damaging messages for women. It's all written for women by women.

Over40Overdating · 18/03/2023 08:30

If it’s not all men, then why don’t the NAMALTS ever go police, patronise, hector and insult the men who make these good ones look bad?
Why is it more important to spend their time telling women they are wrong / not allowed to have an opinion than it is to stop the rot from the ‘minority’ making the rest look bad?

Misogyny really rots the brain.

StepHigh · 18/03/2023 08:21

TobeLeRone · 18/03/2023 07:24

With respect, I don’t think you can assert your opinion on someone else’s and claim it isn’t true or helpful.

Many of us reach an age where we realise we see through the outward charm, and we see the everyday misogyny.
It’s not fighting a feminist cause, it’s having our eyes opened to the fact that many men, even the “good” ones, see women as there for men’s purpose.
This starts young - what’s the average age when men start ogling girls - is it 10 or 11? I forget. And porn? When do boys start looking at porn? Iirc average age is about 12. Most girls are harassed or assaulted in some way at secondary school, and are largely expected to suck it up.
There have been many threads pointing out that men will often charm women into marrying them, bearing their children, then being mediocre husbands and fathers from that point. All the men in my life are outwardly lovely and charming, but under the surface there’s always a level of misogyny that crops up now and again, that isn’t really recognised by many women - and that’s what many of us start to recognise, and it makes you feel like you’ve been played to serve a man’s purpose.

If we’re going to go down the feminism route though, today’s accepted feminism tells us a few things:

  1. men can be women if they want, with access all areas
  2. Sex work is work, and a valid choice for young women to choose
  3. porn is empowering and all men and plenty of women watch it.
I’d argue that the fact that this abominable collection of male accepted views are evidence enough that MMALT. If men genuinely respected women then each of the above points would be shut down immediately, as each are obviously harmful to women. Each also prioritises the feelings and wants of men. Funny how most men fully accept this type of feminism? The feminism that fully centres men’s desire for control over women? Funny how real, woman centred feminism is typically rejected and attacked by most men, or simply not discussed. Women who truly centre women are typically insulted for it, by plenty of so-called nice guys. There are few men who will genuinely stand up for women in each of those 3 points, and of the ones that do, sadly, many will be doing so because they think they’ve tapped into an uncharted source of women to send unsolicited messages to, as evidenced in messages similar to the ones the op has had.

I stand by my previous post. This is not how all men behave. Claiming that it is (when it clearly isn’t) just legitimises the behaviour of the men who do behave like this.

I agree with your points about sex work and porn etc but they’re not really connected to my post.

Mark19735 · 18/03/2023 08:12

If you want to talk about cultures and poison - try dance classes. The standard ballet and tap. Thousands of them up and down the country. Kids as young as 4 being taught hyper-sexualised moves, then performing them at a gala show at the end of the year to an approving audience. The older ones are usually encouraged to choreograph their own routines - I must have seen five successive variations on the Flashdance shower dance with sixteen year olds in fishnets sitting on a chair in the Christine Keeler pose. The participants are 99% girls. The 1% boys are usually too young to have come out yet but it's patently only a matter of time until they do. The teachers are all women. The assistants who demonstrate the moves are all older girls. The audience in 75% mums and grans. There is no way - no way at all - that it can be said that this segment of society is populated by, run for the benefit of, or directly influenced in any way by men. These girls are being groomed - by women - to have a body shape, mannerisms and posture that is pleasing to the male gaze. (And also the female gaze, no doubt). See also FGM. A crime perpetrated by women, against girls ... but blamed on men. Why is that? There are other root causes than just "AMALT"

fairywhale · 18/03/2023 08:03

Knullrufs · 17/03/2023 19:59

I think a significant amount of men lack emotional maturation milestones in childhood. Crap dads/low-quality male role-models a lot of the time. I genuinely think football culture fucks up a lot of men too. So you end up with these id-driven, emotional toddler-tier adults who don’t know themselves at all, and spin out when life doesn’t go 100% perfectly.

This!

Football culture is poison. Boys get pushed into it from the baby age and then all that many do at school playtime and after school is play football with no chance of proper socialisation or gaining abilities to function in a civilised society. And the rest of what goes with football culture follows.

And limited exposure to nurturing play. Most baby and toddler boys like to push dolls pushchairs and play with babies in group settings and dress up in what's considered girls outfits but how many parents provide that at home for their sons. By age 3 or 4 stereotypes and expected behavior have been drilled into them directly or indirectly. And those typed patterns of behaviour they learnt from parents and society are not usually nurturing or respectful behaviour.

Having said that, far from all men are CREEPs. The ones drawn to online stuff often are.

Hence · 18/03/2023 07:50

I am a massive nerd and like to play things like Risk online. I have to play with a fake male profile now, as I would either get men hitting on me or when I won I would get men saying they were going to find me and rape me.

butterfliedtwo · 18/03/2023 07:28

TobeLeRone · 18/03/2023 07:24

With respect, I don’t think you can assert your opinion on someone else’s and claim it isn’t true or helpful.

Many of us reach an age where we realise we see through the outward charm, and we see the everyday misogyny.
It’s not fighting a feminist cause, it’s having our eyes opened to the fact that many men, even the “good” ones, see women as there for men’s purpose.
This starts young - what’s the average age when men start ogling girls - is it 10 or 11? I forget. And porn? When do boys start looking at porn? Iirc average age is about 12. Most girls are harassed or assaulted in some way at secondary school, and are largely expected to suck it up.
There have been many threads pointing out that men will often charm women into marrying them, bearing their children, then being mediocre husbands and fathers from that point. All the men in my life are outwardly lovely and charming, but under the surface there’s always a level of misogyny that crops up now and again, that isn’t really recognised by many women - and that’s what many of us start to recognise, and it makes you feel like you’ve been played to serve a man’s purpose.

If we’re going to go down the feminism route though, today’s accepted feminism tells us a few things:

  1. men can be women if they want, with access all areas
  2. Sex work is work, and a valid choice for young women to choose
  3. porn is empowering and all men and plenty of women watch it.
I’d argue that the fact that this abominable collection of male accepted views are evidence enough that MMALT. If men genuinely respected women then each of the above points would be shut down immediately, as each are obviously harmful to women. Each also prioritises the feelings and wants of men. Funny how most men fully accept this type of feminism? The feminism that fully centres men’s desire for control over women? Funny how real, woman centred feminism is typically rejected and attacked by most men, or simply not discussed. Women who truly centre women are typically insulted for it, by plenty of so-called nice guys. There are few men who will genuinely stand up for women in each of those 3 points, and of the ones that do, sadly, many will be doing so because they think they’ve tapped into an uncharted source of women to send unsolicited messages to, as evidenced in messages similar to the ones the op has had.

👏👏

TobeLeRone · 18/03/2023 07:24

StepHigh · 17/03/2023 22:22

This simply isn’t true and also isn’t helpful. The idea that all men would do this sort of thing just legitimises the men who do it. We’d do better to emphasise that this behaviour really isn’t normal or acceptable. Also just wtf? Harassing women in an online group isn’t living the dream or something all men want to to do- it’s proper basement-dwelling behaviour.

I know women saying that all men do this think they’re fighting the feminist cause but I think the opposite is the case. If you want the men who do this stuff to stop, they need to understand that they are outliers, not the norm.

With respect, I don’t think you can assert your opinion on someone else’s and claim it isn’t true or helpful.

Many of us reach an age where we realise we see through the outward charm, and we see the everyday misogyny.
It’s not fighting a feminist cause, it’s having our eyes opened to the fact that many men, even the “good” ones, see women as there for men’s purpose.
This starts young - what’s the average age when men start ogling girls - is it 10 or 11? I forget. And porn? When do boys start looking at porn? Iirc average age is about 12. Most girls are harassed or assaulted in some way at secondary school, and are largely expected to suck it up.
There have been many threads pointing out that men will often charm women into marrying them, bearing their children, then being mediocre husbands and fathers from that point. All the men in my life are outwardly lovely and charming, but under the surface there’s always a level of misogyny that crops up now and again, that isn’t really recognised by many women - and that’s what many of us start to recognise, and it makes you feel like you’ve been played to serve a man’s purpose.

If we’re going to go down the feminism route though, today’s accepted feminism tells us a few things:

  1. men can be women if they want, with access all areas
  2. Sex work is work, and a valid choice for young women to choose
  3. porn is empowering and all men and plenty of women watch it.
I’d argue that the fact that this abominable collection of male accepted views are evidence enough that MMALT. If men genuinely respected women then each of the above points would be shut down immediately, as each are obviously harmful to women. Each also prioritises the feelings and wants of men. Funny how most men fully accept this type of feminism? The feminism that fully centres men’s desire for control over women? Funny how real, woman centred feminism is typically rejected and attacked by most men, or simply not discussed. Women who truly centre women are typically insulted for it, by plenty of so-called nice guys. There are few men who will genuinely stand up for women in each of those 3 points, and of the ones that do, sadly, many will be doing so because they think they’ve tapped into an uncharted source of women to send unsolicited messages to, as evidenced in messages similar to the ones the op has had.
Swipe left for the next trending thread