Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to walk for an hour?

208 replies

Summering23 · 16/03/2023 21:44

This is a question regarding travel to work during public transport strikes. One of my in office days fell on a tube strike day but my boss insisted that I still go in via bus.
As expected I couldn’t get on a bus for ages due to overcrowding and then the actual bus itself took three times longer than it should have. This meant I was over an hour late in.

I wasn’t in trouble but a comment was made that I should’ve just walked. The walk would have been around an hour according to Google and I don’t know the route at all. Plus to be perfectly honest I’m not up for an hour long walk after getting kids up and fed, walking to the station and a train commute.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Natsku · 17/03/2023 09:06

As a one off/occasional thing its fine. Different if you had to do it every day (for instance DS's nursery run is over an hour walk, hour and a half at his pace, each way and I do not want to do that every day so only do it when can't get someone to drive him. Especially as it'd be double for me doing back home inbetween)

Nimbostratus100 · 17/03/2023 08:57

Hartlebury · 17/03/2023 08:31

I would not be walking an hour to work, what nonsense 😂

this worries me hugely.

When did it become considered "nonsense" and laughable to walk 3 miles? We are built for walking and running it is what our bodies do. It isn't at all healthy not to

Even as a one off?

FluffMagnet · 17/03/2023 08:39

Honestly. All commuting threads are full of posters declaring anything over 30 mins is impossible. Here, OP is being lambasted for being cross at being forced into the office on a strike day, turning her usual 1 hr or so commute (walk, train, tube) into over 2 hrs each way. OP, im with you - why you could WFH is beyond me.

Hartlebury · 17/03/2023 08:31

I would not be walking an hour to work, what nonsense 😂

Calmdown14 · 17/03/2023 08:08

I love walking but agree there is a big difference between an hour from your house to work and an hour once you've already spent ages on public transport.

It is also different when you can work from home. I've been having car troubles (it needs a part and there's a two week delay so not for lack of trying). To get to work via public transport means leaving at 6.20 to get there for 9. I work from home most of the time. It is ridiculous to add 5.5 hours to my day for this. I'd happily work longer and be useful for that time.

Of course you could have done it but I can also see why it was a pain. The people who see themselves as more useful for going into the office arrive late, spend half an hour telling colleagues how long it took them, go and get a coffee then leave early to make sure they can get on a train (but somehow that is better)

SleekMamma · 17/03/2023 08:06

Your boss is shit. On a selfish power trip.

ImAvingOops · 17/03/2023 08:04

I think your boss was being a twat. Particularly given your update that he's wfh himself now due to the strikes!
I wouldn't fancy walking either and it's not always possible to leave earlier if you have childcare to sort.

As for cycling, unless a person is already a cyclist, that's not a viable suggestion.

Nimbostratus100 · 17/03/2023 08:01

lobeliasb · 17/03/2023 00:11

Did you walk ten miles through the snow each way to school back in your day as well?

no, I walked 3 miles to school and back through snow "back in my day"

When there was no snow, I had a lifet half way and walked 1 and a half miles there, and 3 miles back, every day for 7 years.

When I was at primary school I walked 2 miles to school and 2 miles back every day

During lock down I walked 6 miles to school and 6 miles back every day.

You are trying to mock me by exaggerating and pretending I am extreme

I am not

what has actually happened to some people, is that a completely normal, healthy, natural amount of physical exercise has become culturally and physically unacceptable. Not to all people, I teach in a school, and many students walk 2-3 miles in every day, with their school bags.

Walking to and from school is social and physically healthy. We chatted with friends all the way, and we exercised.

It makes no sense at all to rush around by car, polluting the environment, to hurry home to do social activities and go to an exercise class!

But yes, since you ask, during a rail strike a few years ago, when I was teaching at a different school, I walked 11 miles in and 11 miles back again, as a one off- it took me 3 hours each way( I ran part of it) I did go prepared though, trainers, and left my bag at work for that day, with a change of clothes in it. There were hundreds of people walking and it was a sociable experience

bigbluebus · 17/03/2023 08:00

I absolutely would have walked the 3 miles and not even bothered trying to catch the bus. I walked that distance to school as a child if the bus didn't turn up.
On a recent city break we walked 9 miles just sight seeing without even batting an eyelid.

sweetcornfeta · 17/03/2023 07:56

Ive walked through London on strike days. Its just what we do

You sound a bit lazy

Your excuses are lame: protests/didn't know way (even tho you have google maps)

Get a dead leg?

lazycats · 17/03/2023 07:51

If you have no mobility issues then for one day yes, it’s just laziness. And no, walking through London even in a strike day isn’t that bad, it’s hardly the last days of Rome.

Maybe you could WFH instead, but that’s a different issue. If you can then why cone in even on the non strike days?

limitedperiodonly · 17/03/2023 07:50

You didn't want to do it which is fair enough, but seeing as your boss wants you in, you're going to have to put up with it. It doesn't matter if she worked from home, she's your boss and she says you have to be there.

I regularly walk to and from work for a bit more than an hour but with certain conditions. For a start, it's a lovely walk through Central London with or without thousands of protesters (really?) waylaying me.

I won't do it in bad weather but cold or a bit of light rain is fine. A heatwave is manageable too. In fact, it's better than being on the tube as long as you wear sunscreen and go a bit slower.

I wear trainer-type shoes and keep them on all day because they go with my outfit. You do plan your clothes for work a bit, don't you? If I want to wear heels I carry them in a shoulder bag. Shoes, like laptops, are not heavy.

If I'm running late in the morning or tired in the evening or have plans I get the tube instead.

I do it because I want to. You don't. But a one-off like a tube strike is not unreasonable. You didn't even get told off for being late.

Member869894 · 17/03/2023 07:49

Honestly somw if these posts are ridiculous. Who would want to walk 3-4 miles( and presumably back) through crowded streets especially after everything else you have to do in the morning. As for the poster who appreared to happily walk for three hours to get to work I just don't believe it

Devoutspoken · 17/03/2023 07:44

Megletthesecond, put laptop in a backpack and see it as weights to keep you fit

bedtimestories · 17/03/2023 07:44

No way would I walk an hour to get to work after I've got the kids ready in the morning. I just don't have that kind of energy anymore, I'm not unfit, it's my age

moveoverye · 17/03/2023 07:38

Wether I was up for this would depend entirely on what shoes I was wearing at the time! My feet blister sooo easily.

SwedishEdith · 17/03/2023 07:38

Is it an hour door to door? That's possible occasionally with the right shoes etc but laptops and chargers are heavier than you think. But an hour's walk after a train commute is a big no. Essentially, 3.5 hours total commuting time. Not reasonable especially for a job that can be done from home.

londonrach · 17/03/2023 07:38

An hour walk really isn't that far. Three miles so very easy to do.

PanettoneMoly · 17/03/2023 07:36

Nah, I’m with you OP, especially as you say you can easily WFH.

Someone suggested I walk to Canary Wharf, about 1hr 15mins. Not a chance. I can happily WFH (indeed I often do), and I’m not fannying round the unknown streets of the docklands, most likely in the rain, waving my Google Maps round, trying to get into the office late, because the nursery still opens at the same time so I can’t simply ‘leave earlier’, when I can do my job at home, and more of it too with no commute.

For those suggesting you could not get paid for that hour, a lot of people in London will be salaried employees - the amount of admin to run a reduced paycycle for one hour for person for one month is very rarely worth the saving to the business.

Naddd · 17/03/2023 07:34

Summering23 · 16/03/2023 21:44

This is a question regarding travel to work during public transport strikes. One of my in office days fell on a tube strike day but my boss insisted that I still go in via bus.
As expected I couldn’t get on a bus for ages due to overcrowding and then the actual bus itself took three times longer than it should have. This meant I was over an hour late in.

I wasn’t in trouble but a comment was made that I should’ve just walked. The walk would have been around an hour according to Google and I don’t know the route at all. Plus to be perfectly honest I’m not up for an hour long walk after getting kids up and fed, walking to the station and a train commute.

AIBU?

Why didn't your boss change your days so strike days were wfh?

To answer your question no i would not fancy walking an hour to work n back. You mention a commute aswell as the walk, nah wouldn't happen.

My boss was happy for me to take off days during the strike to avoid the hour bus journey there and then work them back.

To walk would be three hours there according to google maps!

Im now cleared for wfh on strike days so it's not problem.

Perhaps i am lazy i don't walk back from the station it's a nearly 40 min walk ALL uphill!

Whataretheodds · 17/03/2023 07:34

Who made the comment? If someone other than your boss then ignore it.

I hadn't registered that it was an hour's walk on top of a 45 min train ride.

I think if your boss insisted that you come in despite the strike, using the bus, and you came in on the bus, then your boss can hardly complain that you were late. The buses were rammed. It probably didn't take much longer than walking, and it was raining.

If it was your boss who made the comment I'd suggest that next time there's a strike you wfh (and come into the office on a different day) to minimise wasted time on a longer journey. You don't need to get into walking v bussing.

DrHousecuredme · 17/03/2023 07:28

SkyandSurf · 16/03/2023 21:56

Do you have any mobility issues that would make it hard for you?

Most people would find an hours walk to be fine.

No, some people would love it, some people would tolerate it, some people would hate it but manage and some people would avoid it at all costs. It's ridiculous really to make a sweeping statement.
OP yanbu to not want to do it. I'm in the "hate but would do it" category (with my music on.
Ultimately though, how you get to work is up to you and not open to public vote...as long as you get there on time next time.

NeverTrustAPoliceman · 17/03/2023 07:22

I would seriously question myself if I thought walking for an hour was in any way a problem. When I'm walking to work I wear trainers and change when I get there.

OP what other exercise do you do to keep yourself fit?

Yerroblemom1923 · 17/03/2023 07:18

It's your responsibility to get yourself to work. If you have to walk you have to walk. It's only an hour and you can find the route on Google maps. YABU to moan about it.
Many people walk to work in all weathers. It's a one off and then you can resume sitting down all day every day at your laptop in the comfort of your own home 🙄

Tinybrother · 17/03/2023 07:10

follyfoot37 · 17/03/2023 06:47

leave earlier
Pure laziness

hahaha
i take it you offered wraparound care to parents on strike days, to make sure they could get to work on time regardless of when childcare opened?

Swipe left for the next trending thread