Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To refuse to hold down toddler to force in medicine

239 replies

Calmondeck · 16/03/2023 20:47

DH & I are at loggerheads - our DS is refusing to take required oral syrup medication (daily). DH believes the most respectful thing to do is explain to DS why it’s necessary he swallow the syrup, and then both hold him down while we force the liquid inside/him to swallow. I think this is too traumatising (the medication is required for the next 10 months at least) and we should try disguising it in foods (this has been mostly unsuccessful to date). DH says it’s deceitful to do this. DS is 22 months old.

So far, forcing him down has result in vomiting and/or him spitting it out.

AIBU to refuse to participate in holding our son down?

OP posts:
Nimbostratus100 · 16/03/2023 21:50

get three syringes. fill two with water and one with medicine. Show him mummy giving daddy the syringe, then he can give mummy the second syringe, then ask him who will give him his? The big party and celebration when everyone has had their syringe.

if that doesn't work, hold him down

R0ckets · 16/03/2023 21:48

Of course if you do it, you are going to rationalise it because that keeps you comfortable. Of course my comment is going to upset a parent who has rationalised restraining and force feeding as acceptable. I’d rather be considered rude than be the sort of parent who does that to any of my children. Fucking raise your bar.

Get off your high and mighty horse another poster has just told you her child would be dead without their medication... Im sure you'd change your tune about it being abusive and unacceptable if that was the alternative.

OP it sounds like you're understandably struggling right now. Definitely try the chocolate, I'm surprised you haven't already with everything he's been through poor kid but if that doesn't work definitely don't discount the holding him and squirting method as it does work.

pizzaHeart · 16/03/2023 21:47

I’m with you. Disguising with food is always the first step, only when you’ve tried different food and unsuccessful, only then you try holding down as a last resort. Your DH had very funny ideas about what to tell 22 months old child.

I’m really sorry that your DS and going through this. Hope he will be better soon and the illness won’t ever come back

ChristmasSirens · 16/03/2023 21:45

So much love and unmumsnetty hugs for you. That sounds horrendous and I hope things improve for you all. 💐

AnnaTortoiseshell · 16/03/2023 21:45

@Calmondeck I’m sorry you’re going through this. Sending strength and love to you and your boy. You sound like an amazing mum.

Flossiemoss · 16/03/2023 21:44

That must be very stressful for you both so it explains the desperation to get the medicine down.

clearly you can’t mess around but have you tried taking the emotion out of it to get ds to take medicine. Seriously - a taste of chocolate is the least of your worries . If the chocolate buttons come out and the medicine goes down then it’s a win.

my ds went into hospital for surgery healthily weaned eating a variety of veg and came out on a diet of quavers and rusks thanks to vancomycin. He got back on track eventually.

TriangleSquareCircle · 16/03/2023 21:44

What's the medication OP? Knowing might help posters give advice. I'd second advice to ask GP about alternatives.

ConsuelaHammock · 16/03/2023 21:42

Hold him down and give him the medicine.Its not poison.

RandomMess · 16/03/2023 21:42

Have you tried syringe when he is asleep?

Bunnycat101 · 16/03/2023 21:42

@Calmondeck it’s sounds like you’re having a torrid time of it- you must be so worried and stressed. A further battle with meds is the last thing you need so please do speak to your team and ask if there are any alternatives or tips. Your little one has clearly been very poorly indeed and you don’t really need to hear from people who have forced down the odd dose of calpol. This is obviously quite a different situation.

itsgettingweird · 16/03/2023 21:42

Calmondeck · 16/03/2023 21:37

Thank you all for the varied tips. We haven’t tried bribery - poor kid doesn’t know what chocolate is yet(!) but I think it’s time to get out the Nutella. We’ll try this tomorrow and see if we have any better luck.

For those telling me to become a parent and not a friend - I am his sole entertainer and comforter in a hospital isolation room for 4 days every 2 weeks. I am holding him every 4 weeks as he undergoes a general anaesthesia and chemotherapy. I am hugging him every 2 days while a home nurse draws blood. I am forcing him to do another treatment for 2 hours every day. This daily medication is for an extremely rare side effect of his other cancer treatments - I’m trying to find the best way to do this, not “fanny about”.

If he's going through all this treatment could you ask the hospital about play therapists to support him?

Also does he have an ng tube or would they consider fitting one for meds?

It's not going to be as black and white as your OP suggested in light of the new information.

Onnabugeisha · 16/03/2023 21:41

R0ckets · 16/03/2023 21:33

It’s fucking traumatising to do it every day until you break them mentally.

You're not breaking them mentally for goodness sake, your showing them they have no choice because sometimes they don't have a bloody choice. Your comment is actually really fucking rude considering that several posters have said they had to use such methods on their own children whete no choice existed such as inhalers or injections.

Yes you fucking are breaking them mentally. Eventually they realise resistance is futile against a human that is 10x bigger and stronger and they break and comply. They are too young to understand why they need the medicine, they only know they are being held down so mum or dad can do something nasty that they have not consented to with all their power. It’s traumatising.

Of course if you do it, you are going to rationalise it because that keeps you comfortable. Of course my comment is going to upset a parent who has rationalised restraining and force feeding as acceptable. I’d rather be considered rude than be the sort of parent who does that to any of my children. Fucking raise your bar.

And trust me, with autistic children that were primo fussy eaters with overwhelming sensory, texture and taste issues, so I’ve faced this problem many times when it comes to medicine. No excuse.

Albiboba · 16/03/2023 21:41

Calmondeck · 16/03/2023 21:37

Thank you all for the varied tips. We haven’t tried bribery - poor kid doesn’t know what chocolate is yet(!) but I think it’s time to get out the Nutella. We’ll try this tomorrow and see if we have any better luck.

For those telling me to become a parent and not a friend - I am his sole entertainer and comforter in a hospital isolation room for 4 days every 2 weeks. I am holding him every 4 weeks as he undergoes a general anaesthesia and chemotherapy. I am hugging him every 2 days while a home nurse draws blood. I am forcing him to do another treatment for 2 hours every day. This daily medication is for an extremely rare side effect of his other cancer treatments - I’m trying to find the best way to do this, not “fanny about”.

No one’s saying it to be horrible to you, its just the reality.
Ask any nurse or dr who works with young daily and I guarantee they will suggest wrapping it them up, putting the medicine to the back of their cheeks, praising them and giving them a treat after. And there’s a reason they will all give the same advice, because it’s what works.
It’s awfully to do as a parent. I’ve also spent plenty of time with my DD in hospital holding her down for treatment. Is heart breaking but you know in your heart it’s best for them.
The more firm and consistent you can be with it the quicker he will adjust and after 2 weeks he will just take it no bother!
It will get better.

shakeitoffsis · 16/03/2023 21:40

I'd go with holding down

AltitudeCheck · 16/03/2023 21:39

@Calmondeck What's the medicine and how much / how often does he have to have it?

If he's getting it from a hospital pharmacy you could ask them if they have a medicines information department who can advise on any other options. For example, it may be possible to get it in a different flavour, in a more concentrated form so there's less volume of medicine to give or as a chewable tablet/ powder.

Depending on the medicine and it's flavour; try mixing it with a very small quantity of squash (blackcurrant is good if he likes that as it's quite a strong taste) and put it in a sippy cup so he can't see/ smell anything different about it.

FavouriteDogMug · 16/03/2023 21:39

I'm not against hiding it in food if he would eat it, that's the best way imo, but if not I think is fine to hold him. I still remember us holding dd down to put some eyedrops in, like Rachel on Friends. Dd thought it was funny when we saw the episode and I told her.

Albiboba · 16/03/2023 21:38

YANBU,
I never forced mine by holding them down, especially the DC with autism. It’s fucking traumatising to do it every day until you break them mentally

You don’t break them mentally for god sake, they learn that it’s not actually that bad and they learn not to be afraid of it. Similarly with teeth brushing, nappy changing, getting dressed etc.
You need to acknowledge that if you never had to force your child to have medication then they’ve never really need truly ill and you should couldn’t yourself lucky.
Yes it’s always difficult to upset your child but sometimes parents are better placed to know what’s best for them.
If I never forced my toddler to take medication she would be dead.
Better a minute or two or stress for a week or two than a dead child because giving them the medicine seems like too much hassle.

Calmondeck · 16/03/2023 21:37

Thank you all for the varied tips. We haven’t tried bribery - poor kid doesn’t know what chocolate is yet(!) but I think it’s time to get out the Nutella. We’ll try this tomorrow and see if we have any better luck.

For those telling me to become a parent and not a friend - I am his sole entertainer and comforter in a hospital isolation room for 4 days every 2 weeks. I am holding him every 4 weeks as he undergoes a general anaesthesia and chemotherapy. I am hugging him every 2 days while a home nurse draws blood. I am forcing him to do another treatment for 2 hours every day. This daily medication is for an extremely rare side effect of his other cancer treatments - I’m trying to find the best way to do this, not “fanny about”.

OP posts:
JudgeRudy · 16/03/2023 21:36

JohnnyMcGrathSaysFuckOff · 16/03/2023 20:51

I would hold him down. Never mind respectful, he needs this medicine and your job is to make sure he gets it.

You can do it with a syringe towards back of mouth then blow in his face. This worked with mine when they needed medicine at this age.

The alternative is to see if it can be given in another form, but assuming not, you need to be practical.

I'd do same. I've done similar with my cat. Swaddled her ET style, tilted her back a bit then squint. I think it would be fair to say I've been quite forceful.
With a 2 year old I'd have a task to get on with straight away, so load the dishwasher, rearrange cushions, whatever....just make it seem no big deal.

First time he 'submits' I'd reward with praise and hugs. This isn't a short term thing so you can't have big celebrations and treats every night.

Of course if you can get away with disguising it all well and good but it's not really worked well has it.

I also think it's important you play your part. When my child was a baby/toddler he required physio that was uncomfortable. Me and OH did it together so no-one was the baddie. It worked. He got better.

ladygindiva · 16/03/2023 21:35

My DD ( awaiting ASD diagnosis ) has never willingly taken medicine and gets too distressed and I couldn't bring myself to force her so I syringe it into a slab of chocolate cake/ brownie. She knows it's there but can't resist consuming it 🤣 I'm with you op, forcing it would be an utter last resort.

Bunnycat101 · 16/03/2023 21:35

@DaveyJonesLocker to be fair your child sounds pretty compliant if they’ll just sit on your knee and take them with you holding their head (very similar to my first). It’s quite a different situation if the child is kicking off, absolutely locks their jaws and prone to vomming if forced and you have to do it 4/5 times a day.

I am very matter of fact with both of mine but my second has been significantly harder to get medicine in despite me being much better at it and having no problems with my other one.

Spamalam · 16/03/2023 21:34

Onnabugeisha · 16/03/2023 21:31

YANBU,
I never forced mine by holding them down, especially the DC with autism. It’s fucking traumatising to do it every day until you break them mentally.

And a 22mo old isn’t going to be making himself vomit it back up. That’s too young to be able to do that.

I agree with the poster that said call the GP and explain that the medicine is making him vomit and that it’s really distressing to force feed him something that makes him sick. They always have alternatives they can offer.

Unfortunately, in our case, the only alternative was being continuously admitted in order to have the medication via IV which was far more traumatic

R0ckets · 16/03/2023 21:34

It’s fucking traumatising to do it every day until you break them mentally.

You're not breaking them mentally for goodness sake, your showing them they have no choice because sometimes they don't have a bloody choice. Your comment is actually really fucking rude considering that several posters have said they had to use such methods on their own children whete no choice existed such as inhalers or injections.

Shopper727 · 16/03/2023 21:34

Using one spoonful is fine if it’s got food in it but in my experience meds need a fair bit of food to disguise the taste of some meds pen v in particular is bloody foul - after taste like mould really horrid and prednisalone is disgusting too, really bitter my son decided taking them as tablets was much nicer but little ones can’t do that and so many have spat it out at me, no idea why they can’t make things taste more palatable for kids, well money as we had bubblegum amoxicillin in America when my kids were unwell and they took that no problem.

R0ckets · 16/03/2023 21:33

It’s fucking traumatising to do it every day until you break them mentally.

You're not breaking them mentally for goodness sake, your showing them they have no choice because sometimes they don't have a bloody choice. Your comment is actually really fucking rude considering that several posters have said they had to use such methods on their own children whete no choice existed such as inhalers or injections.