Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To refuse to hold down toddler to force in medicine

239 replies

Calmondeck · 16/03/2023 20:47

DH & I are at loggerheads - our DS is refusing to take required oral syrup medication (daily). DH believes the most respectful thing to do is explain to DS why it’s necessary he swallow the syrup, and then both hold him down while we force the liquid inside/him to swallow. I think this is too traumatising (the medication is required for the next 10 months at least) and we should try disguising it in foods (this has been mostly unsuccessful to date). DH says it’s deceitful to do this. DS is 22 months old.

So far, forcing him down has result in vomiting and/or him spitting it out.

AIBU to refuse to participate in holding our son down?

OP posts:
Stickytreacle · 16/03/2023 23:56

I see some comments are saying that it is okay to hold them down for a one off, but not everyday for months, but it doesn't work like that as the child soon realises that taking their meds is the only alternative and they usually take their meds after a fairly short period of time without issues.
Certainly on the oncology ward my daughter was on I saw plenty of children objecting to their meds initially, but they really do adapt and see it as normal to just take them.
The fact is that they have to take them one way or another and you don't have the luxury of time to get them used to it.

TwoHedgehogs · 16/03/2023 23:56

My child is the same age, I wouldn't do it. I'd have to find some other way, hiding in food etc. Our son thankfully has never needed anything, but he won't even swallow calpol, we'd have an ordeal if he ever had to take medicine.

Mariposista · 16/03/2023 23:53

There is a time and a place for being cuddly and nicey nicey and medicine isn’t one of these times. He needs it and you get it into him via any means possible or he will potentially become very unwell.

Sugrny · 16/03/2023 23:47

Is it the medicine he doesn't like ...or having it administered?
My very independent grand daughter was persuaded to take liquid meds when she was very young (not sure if as young as 22months though) by being allowed to hold the syringe and suck/push herself.
It might work..? He could practice with something else so as not to waste the meds. A bit of 'big boy' psychology/deception! could help.

anothernamechange2244679 · 16/03/2023 23:47

OP has the hospital offered your son an NG tube? That's why my son had when he was having chemo and refused medicine. Made life so much easier

Nanny0gg · 16/03/2023 23:44

Calmondeck · 16/03/2023 21:37

Thank you all for the varied tips. We haven’t tried bribery - poor kid doesn’t know what chocolate is yet(!) but I think it’s time to get out the Nutella. We’ll try this tomorrow and see if we have any better luck.

For those telling me to become a parent and not a friend - I am his sole entertainer and comforter in a hospital isolation room for 4 days every 2 weeks. I am holding him every 4 weeks as he undergoes a general anaesthesia and chemotherapy. I am hugging him every 2 days while a home nurse draws blood. I am forcing him to do another treatment for 2 hours every day. This daily medication is for an extremely rare side effect of his other cancer treatments - I’m trying to find the best way to do this, not “fanny about”.

The hospital must face this all the time.

What do they do/suggest?

(So sorry you're going through this)

kittensinthekitchen · 16/03/2023 23:42

@Calmondeck So sorry your family are going through this, and sorry there's some idiots arguing on your thread.

Is there a hospital play therapist you can access? They may have some suggestions for making it into a game for your son.

I hope things improve soon Flowers

YoBeaches · 16/03/2023 23:42

Holding is fine for a one off but not every day for ten months.

You can also try for him to give to himself, my daughter liked being grown up and doing it.

Role play with favourite teddy and a drs kit.

Disguise it.

Bribery.

Poppins2016 · 16/03/2023 23:35

I wonder whether a small amount of strong tasting juice (e.g. orange) in your DSs usual drinking cup would work to mask the taste (you mentioned hiding in food, but not drink).

Sorry you're going through such a tough time, I can't begin to imagine how much stress you must be under. Flowers

MudLady · 16/03/2023 23:34

Have you tried getting him to hold his nose (or you hold it) while he swallows it. Then quickly stick something nice tasting in - juice, a chocolate button, whatever, too disguise the residue of the medicine. Holding your nose significantly reduces the ability to taste.

He gets a reward for taking it & it’s less disgusting. And maybe he’ll feel less stressed by it.

Train007 · 16/03/2023 23:32

Think all toddlers medicine should be provided as a suppository.

Onnabugeisha · 16/03/2023 23:26

Fluckinghell · 16/03/2023 22:29

What a horrible horrible person you are.

Nothing I see on this site shocks me anymore 😔

I’m the horrible one for ensuring my autistic medicine refusers were never held down and force fed essential medicine in a traumatising fashion. 🙄

Onnabugeisha · 16/03/2023 23:24

Rosula · 16/03/2023 23:18

Actually no, it isn't in the OP - it doesn't say they have tried squirting with a syringe. Your central premise is mistaken.

Doesn’t matter how the medicine gets to the back of the throat, he will still gag and vomit it back up. My central premise is based on actually knowing a bit of biology rather than your thinking that using a syringe instead of a spoon to convey the medicine to the back of the throat magically cancels out a strong gag reflex. Makes no difference.

KeepLosingThings · 16/03/2023 23:21

Tiny tiny bit of medicine, then a big bite of his favourite treat. Another tiny bit of medicine then a big bite of his favourite treat. Repeat until all the full dose is gone. This was the only thing that worked on dd with antibiotics around that age.

Rosula · 16/03/2023 23:18

Onnabugeisha · 16/03/2023 21:58

definitely don't discount the holding him and squirting method as it does work.

It’s in the OP they’ve already tried the holding him down and force feeding him and he vomits it back up. Can’t believe people are continuing to push a method that not only is traumatising but has literally not worked with this child despite multiple attempts. It’s like you don’t get that vomiting the medicine = no medicine in his system.

Actually no, it isn't in the OP - it doesn't say they have tried squirting with a syringe. Your central premise is mistaken.

Thatsnotevenmyusername · 16/03/2023 23:18

I’m sorry to hear of your DC’s health concerns OP. My DD is 16 months and has been diagnosed with severe asthma - this is more serious than it sounds resulting in 6 serious hospital admissions since October and a life-threatening attack last month which almost landed her in picu. I’ve found with her daily inhalers and medication it really is easiest to just pin her down and administer them. It is awful and at the start she used to scream blue murder and I never thought she would accept them but now the majority of the time she is happy to accept her inhalers and medications. It has taken months though and isn’t always successful, sometimes she decides not to cooperate but
on the whole she has learnt to accept and hopefully your DS will too. Now is the time to introduce chocolate buttons/Milky Way magic stars and give a couple after each time they get their medicine! Honestly it works so well and is forgotten about instantly. Good luck to you all x

MrsMiddleMother · 16/03/2023 23:12

My eldest (now 4) has literally always refused medicine, from calpol to antibiotics and hiding it in food was unsuccessful as was pinning him down as the results were same as you. We made him a small cup of juice or milkshake to disguise it and small enough for him to finish the whole thing relatively straight away

Psmith83 · 16/03/2023 23:09

Calmondeck · 16/03/2023 22:18

Thanks so much for this link @Psmith83

Pleasure, and good luck with all of it.

Stickytreacle · 16/03/2023 23:05

Hi Calmondeck, and my sympathies to you all going through this. I also had to give my two year old dd lots of oral meds for years as part of her leukaemia treatment.
Some tasted foul and were also quite big, we used yoghurt or jam to help the tablets slip down, which worked initially but then she refused and we had the whole battle ongoing, just as you are now.
We had no option but to force them down, which was traumatic for all involved, but once she realised that it was non negotiable she took her tablets with no issues, in fact she was very good about taking them! She would choose which to take first, and was always relieved when the big horrible one went down!
You need to do what has to be done, if you can manage with other methods then that's great, but we found it just prolonged the avoidance and made a bigger issue of it all. If you do need to be firm then remember that you are doing it for the right reasons and you are doing everything to the best you can; parenting is hard enough without serious illnesses to deal with, I'm sure he'll be taking his meds with a lot less bother soon enough, good luck with it all!

tolerable · 16/03/2023 22:58

my heart is with you-this is so hard.
i didnt try this-but popped into my head.i always call the medicine skoosher the syringe. but my head thinks-its a needle.
what bout-easy/quick grow seeds-on blotting paper?...lil one squeezes-puts under the light etc..rapid response buds..
slow it down as required/nurture/even on the bad days?
i wish you all the love in the world....

Somuchgoo · 16/03/2023 22:57

I totally understand your quandary. My little one has a similar serious illness which had resulted in many hospital admissions, and holding her down for bloods and cannula more times than I can remember.

Knowing that it's going to be the same for many years, we are desperate to try to minimise the trauma.

My take on this is:

  • that medicine MUST go in. If truly the only way is brute force, then so be it.
  • age appropriate honesty is really important. I won't lie to my 3yo. I don't conceal medicines either. She has medicine in a drink, but we make it taste good, and she knows why she needs to drink it. It's more for comfort than lifesaving though. If i lie to get about something, she may not trust me, and I need her to feel safe with me.
  • talk to the hospital and play therapist, they may be able to help.
  • depending on your child, a NG tube may not be better. Mine was fine with her tube (and it was great for getting medicine in easily) but so many kids pull them out, and then you are back to holding them still whilst they put it back in etc, which is unpleasant. Replacing the sticker even, involved holding her in a blanket so she couldn't move and then holding her head still.
  • find out how small the tablet versions are, and whether training would work at this age. We are about to start this with my child, but she is older.

You are doing your best. It's an awful situation, and you aren't going to get everything perfect. There probably isn't a perfect way to deal with this. The this thing is that he is young enough that taking his medicines should end up being as much a part of his routine as brushing his teeth.

Best of luck

Blondeshavemorefun · 16/03/2023 22:54

Calmondeck · 16/03/2023 21:37

Thank you all for the varied tips. We haven’t tried bribery - poor kid doesn’t know what chocolate is yet(!) but I think it’s time to get out the Nutella. We’ll try this tomorrow and see if we have any better luck.

For those telling me to become a parent and not a friend - I am his sole entertainer and comforter in a hospital isolation room for 4 days every 2 weeks. I am holding him every 4 weeks as he undergoes a general anaesthesia and chemotherapy. I am hugging him every 2 days while a home nurse draws blood. I am forcing him to do another treatment for 2 hours every day. This daily medication is for an extremely rare side effect of his other cancer treatments - I’m trying to find the best way to do this, not “fanny about”.

((Hugs)). I know very un mn

Sorryto hear ds has cancer 💐💐

Life is cruel

I did wonder if was cancer as sounded similar to what my cousin had to go through with their child

hennaoj · 16/03/2023 22:50

Had same issue with my eldest when he was in hospital, years ago. He had to take Sytron. The nurse tried getting him to take it himself with the syringe. It eventually worked. He had to be the one in control.

SomeHorribleMamsnetter · 16/03/2023 22:50

When mine was little and had to take antibiotics I made him a chart of 'bugs'. Every time he took a dose, we crossed off a 'bug' that he'd just zapped, and he got a handful of sweets afterwards. I can't recall his exact age, could have been a little bit older, but it worked for us and I never thought it would - he would scream blue murder when we tried to give him it.

I can try and find the 'bug' chart for you if that might be helpful.

Calmondeck · 16/03/2023 22:43

Thank you 💛 you’re giving me confidence to trial different methods first. @LibrariansGiveUsPower you’ve hit the nail on the head for me - because this is such a long road ahead, I really want this little guy to feel like I am his advocate. I feel like I am achieving this with most of the other treatments, he may cry but he’s holding tight to my hand and I feel an element of trust.
But the oral medication is the only one I feel quite uncertain on because of such dramatic reactions from him. I’m going to go in with more confidence now - bribes, treats, play acting, patience. Thank you everyone for the alternatives.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread