Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To refuse to hold down toddler to force in medicine

239 replies

Calmondeck · 16/03/2023 20:47

DH & I are at loggerheads - our DS is refusing to take required oral syrup medication (daily). DH believes the most respectful thing to do is explain to DS why it’s necessary he swallow the syrup, and then both hold him down while we force the liquid inside/him to swallow. I think this is too traumatising (the medication is required for the next 10 months at least) and we should try disguising it in foods (this has been mostly unsuccessful to date). DH says it’s deceitful to do this. DS is 22 months old.

So far, forcing him down has result in vomiting and/or him spitting it out.

AIBU to refuse to participate in holding our son down?

OP posts:
Sirzy · 17/03/2023 09:24

Ds has been on a lot of medication since he was a baby. As hard as it is often the bear hug and get it done approach is the best.

I would avoid hiding things in food as unless every mouthful is eaten you don’t know they are getting the full dose and if it changes the taste of the food you may end up with issues with food.

aSofaNearYou · 17/03/2023 09:20

At that age I think it's a bit dramatic to say both that it's deceitful to sneak it in his food and that it's traumatising to hold him down, tbh.

Rosula · 17/03/2023 09:13

OP, I really don't understand why your husband thinks it's disrespectful to hide medicine in food but not disrespectful to hold him down. There is simply no logic there.

Rosula · 17/03/2023 09:09

Onnabugeisha · 16/03/2023 23:24

Doesn’t matter how the medicine gets to the back of the throat, he will still gag and vomit it back up. My central premise is based on actually knowing a bit of biology rather than your thinking that using a syringe instead of a spoon to convey the medicine to the back of the throat magically cancels out a strong gag reflex. Makes no difference.

My knowledge comes from dealing with a child with a strong gag reflex when he didn't want to take medicine. The syringe method worked like a charm and didn't provoke gagging.

BossBerk · 17/03/2023 08:59

Use your brain and common sense and hide it in food like most other parents do

Strawberry nesquik is a good one for hiding disgusting tastes...

caffelattetogo · 17/03/2023 08:58

It sounds like you're doing amazingly with all his treatment. Bribery and/or hiding it in food/drink sounds like a good option. What 'flavour' is it?

Babyimyours · 17/03/2023 05:20

I’m so sorry about your little one. It sounds very, very hard. I’m sorry too that some people are so unempathic.

This may sound obvious, but have you tried a spoon?

I hadn’t even considered a spoon and was having the same issues with the syringe and not wanting him to choke/breathe it in while we tried to hold him down.

So I tried a spoon and it worked. I couldn’t believe that I hadn’t thought of it. I had simply assumed it wouldn’t work as they always give you a syringe. Now he takes oral medicine fine, and doing in front of the TV helps, or as part of “pudding” (if it’s a sweet medicine). I used a teaspoon as those silicone baby spoons aren’t very effective.

He gets lots of clapping and effusive praise after taking it, and a big cuddle. I have also had success with syringe by giving a kiss before each “pump” and turning it into a game. My husband finds it easier to give a syringe in the bath, as part of routine.

I hope that you find a solution. Good luck x

carriedout · 17/03/2023 04:51

The only ridiculous thing here is posters recommending the most traumatic option that has already been shown to not work with her child.

Yes this is my feeling. If holding the child down was working it'd be a different matter, but holding them down every day for 10 months is going to be horrific - and if the medicine comes back up what is the benefit?

carriedout · 17/03/2023 04:47

TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 17/03/2023 02:40

Can't you read? The OP says disguising it is mostly unsuccessful.

So is holding the child down, if both are unsuccessful why do you favour the one over the other?

NumberTheory · 17/03/2023 04:46

I think your DH is a bit batshit to be worrying that disguising it in food is deceitful, but at the same time, if it’s mostly unsuccessful, it’s unreasonable to do it that way. Equally, if holding him down is unsuccessful, that’s unreasonable too (and even if it’s successful, holding him down should be a last resort not number 2 on the list, especially if this is going to have to happen daily for 10 months).

We had success with a syringe when ours were that sort of age. And then tablets when they were a little older.

I had to hold one of my DC down once when they were about 7 for sedation for an MRI it did need to happen, but I found it really traumatic to do.

emptythelitterbox · 17/03/2023 03:23

Tell him that's exactly what they do in hospital.

How do you think they're able to start ivs and other procedures?

TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 17/03/2023 02:40

carriedout · 16/03/2023 20:49

Can't you read? The op wants to disguise it in food.

Can't you read? The OP says disguising it is mostly unsuccessful.

snitzelvoncrumb · 17/03/2023 02:11

If you hold him down it will take two of you. One has hold the child’s face, pour the medicine in, and keep holding until he has to breathe so he will swallow. Then you have to hope the child doesn’t throw up from hysterical screaming. You can simply refuse to hold the child down. Then do it your own way.

TheOriginalEmu · 17/03/2023 01:33

Onnabugeisha · 17/03/2023 00:24

There are always other options to try.

Forcing isn’t even a universal solution, as with the Ops child, forcing has resulted in her DC vomiting the medicine straight back up. So obviously she has to find an option other than forcing to get the medicine into her DC.

You'd have been forced to find a different option too if the medicine didn’t stay down for your child. On that basis, I do cannot agree that force feeding is ever the only option that will work. It’s just the can’t be arsed to work with my child option imho.

The only ridiculous thing here is posters recommending the most traumatic option that has already been shown to not work with her child.

She doesnt have time to repeat the force feed and vomit cycle over and over. She is being perfectly reasonable to refuse to continue it and want to try other options.

I don’t dispute that the OP has other options to try. My point is should those options be exhausted, then sometimes it’s necessary to do. Your ‘no excuse’ is nonsense. Sometimes you don’t have any other choice.

PearCrumbleCustard · 17/03/2023 01:20

I’ve posted suggestions on things like playing doctor with a soft toy. Definately try not a traumatic route.

But also with my DS with significant SEN, I often ‘have’ the treatment also - obviously not injections - try seeing if your child would like to give you ‘fake’ medicine - and make it funny and even screw up your face ‘ewww’ if it tastes funny.

Another thing I do is I save a certain video that he LOVES to watch, only for medical or emergency purposes, and he gets to watch it then and for 20 minutes afterwards.

CrotchetyQuaver · 17/03/2023 01:12

I would see if it's possible for the GP to give the medicine in capsules or tablets. My DD absolutely hated taking one antibiotic (IIRC) syrup. She was older and absolutely adamant. Bribery didn't work. She happily swallowed the capsules much to the doctors surprise.

Or with a capsule you could open it and have a special medicine snack they have to eat, if necessary followed by an uncontaminated one.

They have to take the medicine, there should be no negotiation on that.

wingingit1987 · 17/03/2023 01:00

I have no issue being deceitful with my children over medication. But then I am the sort of mother who has told her kids they can’t go to the park because it’s closed. If hiding it isn’t working- can your wee one be bribed? I’ve found there isn’t much my kids won’t do for haribo.

LadyJ2023 · 17/03/2023 00:44

Eh each of my 4 kids were held down by nurses for immunisations its for there benefit. One of them she ain't keen on medicine but we hold her and soon as she swallows she gets a treat. The others now voluntarily take it a under 3 if they need it and still get a treat after it

BlackeyedSusan · 17/03/2023 00:26

Mine had that nasty tasting antibiotics in a small amount of neat ribena with added sugar. Plus little bits of chocolate for each bit taken.

Also had to hold them down whilst putting eye drops in... Which is a lot less traumatising than going blind.

Onnabugeisha · 17/03/2023 00:24

TheOriginalEmu · 17/03/2023 00:09

I have autistic kids, one of home has diabetes and another had leukemia. It’s not rationalising when you have no other option but to force it or that child dies. Don’t be so ridiculous.

There are always other options to try.

Forcing isn’t even a universal solution, as with the Ops child, forcing has resulted in her DC vomiting the medicine straight back up. So obviously she has to find an option other than forcing to get the medicine into her DC.

You'd have been forced to find a different option too if the medicine didn’t stay down for your child. On that basis, I do cannot agree that force feeding is ever the only option that will work. It’s just the can’t be arsed to work with my child option imho.

The only ridiculous thing here is posters recommending the most traumatic option that has already been shown to not work with her child.

She doesnt have time to repeat the force feed and vomit cycle over and over. She is being perfectly reasonable to refuse to continue it and want to try other options.

Phoebo · 17/03/2023 00:18

I'd do whatever it takes if he needed the medication, including by by force if necessary

oakleaffy · 17/03/2023 00:15

@Calmondeck Oral syringe, very gently squirted into the back of his mouth.
Give a sweet if you must to take the taste away.

Far better never to battle a child, or animal.
( I knew a horse who would rear violently at the sight of an oral syringe for wormers as he’d been put in an ear /mouth twitch to take it.

Disguising it in his feed was needed.

Disguising it in his food may make him refuse the food.
There will be a way, but avoid battles at all costs.

TheOriginalEmu · 17/03/2023 00:09

Onnabugeisha · 16/03/2023 21:41

Yes you fucking are breaking them mentally. Eventually they realise resistance is futile against a human that is 10x bigger and stronger and they break and comply. They are too young to understand why they need the medicine, they only know they are being held down so mum or dad can do something nasty that they have not consented to with all their power. It’s traumatising.

Of course if you do it, you are going to rationalise it because that keeps you comfortable. Of course my comment is going to upset a parent who has rationalised restraining and force feeding as acceptable. I’d rather be considered rude than be the sort of parent who does that to any of my children. Fucking raise your bar.

And trust me, with autistic children that were primo fussy eaters with overwhelming sensory, texture and taste issues, so I’ve faced this problem many times when it comes to medicine. No excuse.

I have autistic kids, one of home has diabetes and another had leukemia. It’s not rationalising when you have no other option but to force it or that child dies. Don’t be so ridiculous.

Mulhollandmagoo · 16/03/2023 23:59

Calmondeck · 16/03/2023 21:37

Thank you all for the varied tips. We haven’t tried bribery - poor kid doesn’t know what chocolate is yet(!) but I think it’s time to get out the Nutella. We’ll try this tomorrow and see if we have any better luck.

For those telling me to become a parent and not a friend - I am his sole entertainer and comforter in a hospital isolation room for 4 days every 2 weeks. I am holding him every 4 weeks as he undergoes a general anaesthesia and chemotherapy. I am hugging him every 2 days while a home nurse draws blood. I am forcing him to do another treatment for 2 hours every day. This daily medication is for an extremely rare side effect of his other cancer treatments - I’m trying to find the best way to do this, not “fanny about”.

Bribe bribe bribe!!! That's my motto with long term meds, anything you think may work - may I suggest stickers, toddlers go absolutely spare for stickers (and obviously chocolate)

I wouldn't hold my child down either, because like yours she would spit it out everywhere! She's a bit older then your son and can operate a syringe herself, which has made it so much easier, could he do that maybe? Practise with some juice or something?

toucaninjapan · 16/03/2023 23:58

Can you get a powder type medicine instead of liquid?
I disguise it in ice-cream, and it works well (DD has just turned 2).
I wouldn't force medicine down the child's throat tbh.

Swipe left for the next trending thread