Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rejected by two bariatric surgeons but approved by two others - what do I do?

94 replies

weightlosssurgeryprobs · 16/03/2023 17:23

In a bit of a dilemma and would appreciate some anonymous, impartial advice if possible.

I’m 28, and up until I gave birth to my son in 2020 I have always been a size 10 - 12. I developed really horrendous postnatal depression and stopped exercising and looked to food as a comfort.

I am finally better but in three years I have gained almost 10 stone. I am now 20 stone with a BMI of 44 and I feel awful. Not just because of how I look but I get out of breath walking up the stairs, my back hurts standing too long, I snore incredibly badly and likely have sleep apnea.

I am eating healthily and trying to move more currently because I am determined to get back to my healthy weight. I have never felt so awful and I want to be healthy for my son as I am terrified of the consequences (I know I only have myself to blame).

I am looking into a gastric sleeve currently because I feel I really need help. However I am high risk as in 2015 I had my appendix and my colon removed in a sub total colectomy, a stoma bag for a year in open surgery & then another open surgery for a reversal and to close the stoma hole.

i have no issues since then; and in July 2022 had my gallbladder removed with no issues other than more pain due to the scarring.

I have consulted four surgeons so far - two have refused saying I am too complicated for the private sector and too high risk, however two surgeons have said yes, are skilled in operating on patients with experiences like mine and are confident it would be fine.

I don’t want to do it on the NHS as I have had a multiple failing by them in that my condition could have been treated with medication without surgery had they listened to me the entire year I was begging for help with my symptoms. I just can’t.

I’m not a silly person and I am concerned that two surgeons have said no. They both recommended I get other opinions which is why I have spoken to four but I don’t want to make the wrong decision and end up with complications or even death.

So I’m just looking for advice on if you were in my position what you would do. I know it’s ultimately my decision but any input would be much appreciated as my mind is mixed.

thank you.

OP posts:
WhereIsMyRefund · 16/03/2023 19:38

You have ‘only’ been overweight for three years. There is a chance you could reverse most of this without surgery, given specialist advice and support.

I would spend the money on nutritionists and psychologists who can work together with you to address the underlying issues. With the tablets others have mentioned if needed. Good luck.

itsgettingweird · 16/03/2023 19:35

I'd see on side of caution.

If you have sleep apnea then you most likely aren't getting proper sleep which will also affect your weight. I'd look to get that sorted and give it a year of decent diet and exercise and reevaluate.

It also gives your current survey sites longer to heal. There's nothing stopping you doing it in the future should things change.

weightlosssurgeryprobs · 16/03/2023 19:34

I don’t have a pouch I had a straight rejoin small intestine - rectum. I am looking into ozempic now - anyone got any experience they could share with me??

OP posts:
pompei8309 · 16/03/2023 19:34

Dymaxion · 16/03/2023 19:33

With your history, I personally wouldn't risk it. The surgery might be a success as in you don't die on the table or within a certain timescale, but there are plenty of things that could happen that would make your life harder than it is now.

Speak to your GP about the sleep apnea and the possibility of trying Ozempic.

Saxenda and Ozempic are not sustainable, the weight comes back on as soon as you stop them

Dymaxion · 16/03/2023 19:33

With your history, I personally wouldn't risk it. The surgery might be a success as in you don't die on the table or within a certain timescale, but there are plenty of things that could happen that would make your life harder than it is now.

Speak to your GP about the sleep apnea and the possibility of trying Ozempic.

pompei8309 · 16/03/2023 19:32

weightlosssurgeryprobs · 16/03/2023 17:23

In a bit of a dilemma and would appreciate some anonymous, impartial advice if possible.

I’m 28, and up until I gave birth to my son in 2020 I have always been a size 10 - 12. I developed really horrendous postnatal depression and stopped exercising and looked to food as a comfort.

I am finally better but in three years I have gained almost 10 stone. I am now 20 stone with a BMI of 44 and I feel awful. Not just because of how I look but I get out of breath walking up the stairs, my back hurts standing too long, I snore incredibly badly and likely have sleep apnea.

I am eating healthily and trying to move more currently because I am determined to get back to my healthy weight. I have never felt so awful and I want to be healthy for my son as I am terrified of the consequences (I know I only have myself to blame).

I am looking into a gastric sleeve currently because I feel I really need help. However I am high risk as in 2015 I had my appendix and my colon removed in a sub total colectomy, a stoma bag for a year in open surgery & then another open surgery for a reversal and to close the stoma hole.

i have no issues since then; and in July 2022 had my gallbladder removed with no issues other than more pain due to the scarring.

I have consulted four surgeons so far - two have refused saying I am too complicated for the private sector and too high risk, however two surgeons have said yes, are skilled in operating on patients with experiences like mine and are confident it would be fine.

I don’t want to do it on the NHS as I have had a multiple failing by them in that my condition could have been treated with medication without surgery had they listened to me the entire year I was begging for help with my symptoms. I just can’t.

I’m not a silly person and I am concerned that two surgeons have said no. They both recommended I get other opinions which is why I have spoken to four but I don’t want to make the wrong decision and end up with complications or even death.

So I’m just looking for advice on if you were in my position what you would do. I know it’s ultimately my decision but any input would be much appreciated as my mind is mixed.

thank you.

Why don’t you try a gastric ballon first , they last 5-6 months and it’s nothing so drastic or as expensive as the sleeve

Brotherlove · 16/03/2023 19:30

If you had that much abdo surgery I'd not risk it unless necessary - ie you need more surgery for bowel blockage in the future.
Keep further surgery for those reasons only ...you will always be at risk of adhesions & having a bowel blockage.
Don't risk it.

Loose weight another way.

caringcarer · 16/03/2023 19:29

Would your GP let you have the new drug for weight loss Wegovy? I think if you BMI is over 35 and you have another medical issue eg sleep apnoea you will qualify on NHS. You can only get it for 2 years but during that time most people lose between 10 and 20 percent of body weight. During that time you would get a lot of energy and self confidence back. You could do more without getting breathless, so could exercise. You could also really try to limit carb intake and up vegetables and fruit intake. If Wegovy does not work, go for the sleeve but I would really try to make the Wegovy injections work first.

Singularity82 · 16/03/2023 19:29

weightlosssurgeryprobs · 16/03/2023 18:07

Thank you everyone. I do see the red flags and you’re right I do feel desperate. Yes they are U.K. based surgeons and are all highly reputable and recognised surgeons in the medical world. I’ve only contacted those I have in-depthless researched. It terrifies me that two have said no and I do have a bad feeling. This thread only furthers this feeling so I’m glad I wrote it. I
guess it’s time to look into other avenues…

I’m glad you’re taking the advice on board.
Good luck op, I wish you all the best, whatever you decide x

GreatBigBeautifulTommorow · 16/03/2023 19:27

As an obese person with GI issues I’d say no don’t risk it. I decided against as is a risk could worsen existing GI issues.

do you have Tier 3 weight loss services where you live?
you would be eligible for a tier 3 ref where I live. Involves an MDT…endocrinologist, dietician, psychologist etc and support to look into causes/ contributing factors to try and resolve long term issues.
possible to progress to tier 4 for bariatric surgery but I appreciate you don’t want under the NHS. Ours are a mine of information and support.

Southwest12 · 16/03/2023 19:17

I know a bariatric surgeon based in Edinburgh, he also does complex abdominal wall surgery. If you really want to consider surgery then I'd recommend speaking to him, if he says it's too risky then it really is

Have you got an internal pouch now? I'd honestly be surprised if the two that have said yes understand pouch surgery as its specialised and most surgeons have never even done one.

NannyGythaOgg · 16/03/2023 19:16

I had a gastric bypass in 2000, one of the very early ones and in most cases I would say, trust the surgeon, especially if they also do work for the NHS rather than solely private.

BUT having read your story I would be very very wary. It's a big op and maintaining nutrition afterwards, even with no secondary issues isn't easy.

If you are continuing to gain, despite your best efforts then maybe, just maybe - as life risks are high. If you are managing to lose weight, even slowly then stick with it - at least for a while. Maybe re-evaluate in a year by which time you will have hopefully lost 5 to 10% of your excess which, while it won't negate it, will make the risk substantially more manageable.

Dibbydoos · 16/03/2023 19:10

Are these surgeons in UK?

what did the 2 who said it was risky say as an outcome?

Did you tell tgectwo who said it'll be ok what the others said?

I personally would go with a surgeon eith experience of your conditions and the op. Be very clear, if it starts to look dodgy, put me right and don't do it. Be clear you want tge surgeon to err on the side of caution.

Good luck x

Emma228228 · 16/03/2023 19:04

Ive had a mini gastric bypass 8 yrs ago failed so i had a revision 5 yrs ago to a full bypass i still have issues ive lost 17 stone but left with a lot of health issues i also have a bad eating disorder x in the last 8 yrs ive had 7 major surgeries to my stomach too
its quite good they do all these weight loss surgeries but they dont tell you the long term problems u have afterward I would take advice if they say its to risky then take notice they are saying it for a reason. Good luck with what u decide

Fifi0000 · 16/03/2023 18:56

How many years experience do the two surgeons have and how many operations have they performed on someone with similar problem? In your situation I would only stay close to home and ensure the hospital you choose has a critical care/icu. I had the operation and it's been an amazing success I was BMI 41 and I'm now 21 for quite a long time zero dieting needed for me. Ozempic I would have piled it back on long term when I stopped the drug. I'd need it forever and private it's £150 a month. It's been totally worth it but I had no previous abdominal surgeries before.

QuietlyConfident · 16/03/2023 18:55

I'm not an expert, but to me the fact that you put the weight on over a short period under very specific circumstances suggests that your odds of reversing it by conventional means should be better than average, so you should give that your best possible shot before taking the riskier option.

But do try to get the sleep apnea treated first: it's very tough to lose a lot of weight but it's all but impossible if you're exhausted.

purpledalmation · 16/03/2023 18:50

To me it sounds risky. With a child to care for I wouldnt do this, but it would spur me to lose weight in a conventional way. not easy I know, but what are the alternatives.

mynewusername2023 · 16/03/2023 18:49

There are private hospitals with ICUs. I had a sleeve 3 years ago and due to my start weight I had to go to a different hospital to my local one so that there was an ICU. As it turned out I sailed through the surgery and only had to stay in one night instead of the expected two. It changed my life, I'm not at my goal but I couldn't be happier with my 14 stone loss.

I would be very cautious due to your history and maybe look at a band or balloon instead of surgery as this is a lot less invasive and could give you great results with much less risk.

JemimaPyjamas · 16/03/2023 18:49

Hi Op, I have not read all the post so I am sorry if this has already been said.

Firstly, massive hug to you for feeling like you do. I understand the feeling completely of being overwhelmed. I have many different issues that make losing weight more complicated and fiddly for me, and very much an uphill struggle, but one thing I have started doing which has made a LOT of difference both mentally and (hopefully) physically over the last three weeks is a personal trainer. I cried when I did my measurements and photo's and I could really be stricter with the calorie counting but it still feels like I am making a positive difference.

If you could find the money for some sessions a week, would that be worth looking into before exploring the surgery or other options?

SunshineGeorgie · 16/03/2023 18:48

Another vote for saxenda or ozempic!!

I. The time it's taking to research doctors you could have easily lost a stone!

whynotwhatknot · 16/03/2023 18:40

what is ozempic how does it work

Viviennemary · 16/03/2023 18:38

Reading through all these posts maybe you should think again, it does sound risky.

t

bubbles2023 · 16/03/2023 18:37

Another recommendation for ozempic. Not risk free and some potential side effects (I had very little), but if you were willing to consider surgery then I'd go for this.

Inkblue · 16/03/2023 18:37

I know someone who died after bariatric surgery. He was very unlucky but it has changed my view on it.

titchy · 16/03/2023 18:36

Given that you put on weight due to ppd, having had a healthy lifestyle up to that point, I'd have thought you could lose through diet alone. You don't have an entire lifetime of poor eating meaning you need a lifetime of correction, which surgery obvious would be.

Not worth the risk imo, esp as your eating is now back to normal and the weight should now start to drop off.