Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think truly chaotic messy people don't/can't change?

135 replies

houseofchaosandclothes · 16/03/2023 14:51

I have two small children, a demanding full-time job, a partner with a demanding full-time job and a parent with stage 4 cancer. (I also probably have ADHD but I'm stuck on a waiting list and not sure what difference a diagnosis would make. )

Yet the biggest source of stress in my life is my house. There are clothes everywhere - in laundry baskets waiting to be sorted and washed, in different shaped laundry baskets waiting to be sorted and put away. The toys are out of control. We can spend an hour cleaning the kitchen for one meal time to leave it destroyed.

I have read every thread about housekeeping and organising approaches in the world, and nothing seems to translate. It seems to take me twice as long as all these guides say it should to do something. TOMM is insane: fifteen minutes to do exactly what with a load of laundry? I can throw one in the washing machine in that time but sorting and putting it away will take me 45. We have a cleaner, and I would say spend 3/4 hours a week trying to scoop up the chaos enough she can clean around it. I try to declutter but every inch we reclaim seems to take a day and a half, and my limited annual leave and spare time is better spent with my parents or children. My husband does about 75% of the housework as he is much more efficient but we're still in chaos.

And I have spent YEARS of my life convinced I can change it. I grew up in a somewhat similar house. I'm 40. I have made half-hearted stabs at everything from flylady to a slob comes clean to Marie Kondo and nothing has changed and I'm starting to think that actually all the people who use these methods are not, in fact, the truly chaotic and messy. Or if they are, they don't have jobs/kids/sick parents/all of the above.

So I guess this is my question: has anyone truly messy and chaotic and terrible at housework reformed themselves? Have they done it when they have other things going on? Or are all these approaches just ways for ultimately organised people to get back on track and have nothing to say to the truly messy among us?

OP posts:
AllotmentTime · 16/03/2023 15:26

Without knowing you and your house intimately I don’t think anyone can say. I would say I’m similar in that my house has been low-level messy for years despite resolutions to change it. The things I do that work are when I’ve really taken the time to stop and analyse what makes a specific area go from tidy to messy.

We tend to think of it as “mess needs to be tidied” without breaking that down. Is it that the post gets put on the side until it’s a mountain? Why does it get put there/where would be better/how can you make the “better” thing easier than the “messy” thing?
Is it that the DC get every toy out at once? What’s happening in the house at that moment? What happens next? Etc until you’ve gradually & eventually been through every aspect of what “messy” means.

the book Atomic Habits helped me. And thinking about how to make the desirable habit/behaviour easy, and then easier still, until you’re practically forced to do it.

SpookyBlackCat · 16/03/2023 15:24

Have you tried A Slob Comes Clean? I read her books and watch her YouTube videos. My house was really bad but it’s so much better now. I don’t know what it is about her system that clicked for me when none of the others did, but I think she’s great especially for those of us with ADHD.

usernother · 16/03/2023 15:20

I'm a very messy and untidy person. But I have changed to the extent I have strategies in place that make me tidy up and keep on top of things. I feel much calmer when I do these things. So, in answer to your question I think it is possible to change. Lurking below the surface I'm still chaotic and left to my own devices my home would look like there had been a burglary.

TeenDivided · 16/03/2023 15:20

Fewer clothes each? Then you will have to sort / put away as otherwise people will run out of clothes. Wear non underwear things more before you wash them to save laundry time.

Fewer toys / only let them get new ones out once others are put away?

Snowpaw · 16/03/2023 15:17

The biggest thing I have found makes a difference is doing a "power half hour" we call it in my house. Like last night. The kitchen was a state, there were toys out and clothes on the floor in various rooms. It was 8.30pm and me and my DP were knackered after having both been at work and we just wanted to chill in front of TV. But I said "Right, lets see what we can get done in 30 minutes, and then we meet back here on sofa at 9pm for an hour of TV before bed".

He tackled the kitchen (and in that time was able to unload and reload dishwasher, and do the rest of the washing up), clear the sides and empty the bin.

I put toys away, books back on shelves, and put clothes away. In 30 minutes we met back in the living room with the house in a much better state than it was (not immaculate by any means but enough for us to feel a bit more relaxed and like we'd achieved something) and we enjoyed the rest of our evening.

There will never be a state of perfect cleanliness in a family home with working parents, but instead of thinking "There is too much to do, its too overwhelming" you just have to try and do what you can in a set amount of time. Its surprising how much you can get done in 30 mins. I refuse to spend all my spare time cleaning and tidying.

Adhdsucks · 16/03/2023 15:14

OP how do you find having the cleaner? For so long I’ve toyed with it but I’d need someone very open minded and flexible.

Is the stress the night before worth it?

silverycurtains · 16/03/2023 15:11

Maybe you need to get a professional declutter person in to help you? Perhaps if you had a blank slate and an organised system, you'd be able to keep it that way? It may just be that you can't fight your way out of the pickle you're in and need someone to help you get started?

Adhdsucks · 16/03/2023 15:09

Yep I absolutely agree! I have stopped thinking that one day I will wake up a new, tidy, organised person because I am setting myself up for failure.

Dotjones · 16/03/2023 15:08

The word that jumps out is "declutter" - if you have more stuff than you have room to tidy it away in, keeping a place clean and tidy is impossible. A family of four living in a smallish flat needs as much stuff as a family of four in a spacious house but doesn't have the room to store it properly.

The way to keep somewhere clean is pack everything away that doesn't need to be on display. Then it's just a case of wiping down surfaces quickly and regularly. Problems occur when you're like me and there simply isn't room to move things away to.

Take a look at your kitchen. What's on display? It should only be sink/fridge/cooker/microwave/kettle, work surfaces should be clear. Plates, cooking utensils, food mixers, toasters and anything else need to be packed away when not in use. If you can't pack it away, and can't throw it away, it'll never be possible to keep the place clean and tidy.

ShippingNews · 16/03/2023 15:05

I agree , some people will always be messy . Maybe you are in that category. Your story reminds me of my sil, who bought her house 20 years ago. From the first time I saw it, to today, nothing has changed. Mess everywhere. In those 20 years she has gone from " two incomes, no kids" to " one income, two grown kids" . And the house remains in a mess . I've had the same family situations as she has, but my place has never been messy. I don't have any suggestions - if you can't change, there's not much you can do .

Swipe left for the next trending thread