Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think truly chaotic messy people don't/can't change?

135 replies

houseofchaosandclothes · 16/03/2023 14:51

I have two small children, a demanding full-time job, a partner with a demanding full-time job and a parent with stage 4 cancer. (I also probably have ADHD but I'm stuck on a waiting list and not sure what difference a diagnosis would make. )

Yet the biggest source of stress in my life is my house. There are clothes everywhere - in laundry baskets waiting to be sorted and washed, in different shaped laundry baskets waiting to be sorted and put away. The toys are out of control. We can spend an hour cleaning the kitchen for one meal time to leave it destroyed.

I have read every thread about housekeeping and organising approaches in the world, and nothing seems to translate. It seems to take me twice as long as all these guides say it should to do something. TOMM is insane: fifteen minutes to do exactly what with a load of laundry? I can throw one in the washing machine in that time but sorting and putting it away will take me 45. We have a cleaner, and I would say spend 3/4 hours a week trying to scoop up the chaos enough she can clean around it. I try to declutter but every inch we reclaim seems to take a day and a half, and my limited annual leave and spare time is better spent with my parents or children. My husband does about 75% of the housework as he is much more efficient but we're still in chaos.

And I have spent YEARS of my life convinced I can change it. I grew up in a somewhat similar house. I'm 40. I have made half-hearted stabs at everything from flylady to a slob comes clean to Marie Kondo and nothing has changed and I'm starting to think that actually all the people who use these methods are not, in fact, the truly chaotic and messy. Or if they are, they don't have jobs/kids/sick parents/all of the above.

So I guess this is my question: has anyone truly messy and chaotic and terrible at housework reformed themselves? Have they done it when they have other things going on? Or are all these approaches just ways for ultimately organised people to get back on track and have nothing to say to the truly messy among us?

OP posts:
binnybonny · 16/03/2023 19:32

@CandlelightGlow do you work? I was my most tidiest pre dc and when dc were little I didn't work so found it much easier to defo ate more time to being tidy. Now I'm back working plus family stuff to get done I find it impossible.

Parsley1234 · 16/03/2023 19:28

I have a declutter business and from working with clients I always say before I start they need an infrastructure to carry on the work I’ve done. It’s unrealistic to think they will be able to carry on what I’ve done but if the right infrastructure is put in it’s possible

CandlelightGlow · 16/03/2023 19:28

I voted YABU but in a kind way. I'm horribly disorganised and went straight from living at home as a very young woman never having to think about washing or cleaning because my mum did it all (or cooking as my dad did it all), to being 21 and having a household and baby (then 3 DC) to look after.

It has been a LONG learning curve for me, my partner likes to tidy but like you has ADHD so it's difficult between both of us and the house is far from perfect. But keep working on it.

You have to learn to be kind of ruthless. Especially with the kitchen. Your life has to become focused (at least for a while, maybe forever?) on your priority of a clean home. My DC are now aged 3 - 7 and I'm finding it easier and easier to stay on top of their mess. Books can actually be put on the child level bookshelf and don't end up pulled down within 5 minutes.

I digress. Decluttering is super important, not only decluttering things you don't need, but also taking a minimalist approach to things you do need. If toys are everywhere all the time, you either need to have less, or you need to put a good chunk away in storage and rotate them. I agree with Marie Kondo about decluttering, but not her stance on storage. Have plenty of storage and have it assigned for purposes. We have plenty of clothes storage, it's not always organised but it's full of clean clothes. We limit crockery and pots and pans in the kitchen, that means if you've cooked something in a pot and want to cook something else, you need to get washing up.

Adequate storage is really good I reckon for people with this type of mindset, because if you're anything like me, you struggle to do day to day things frequently, but then get sudden bursts of hyper focused nestiness. So as long as day to day I can chuck things into appropriate storage, I know I will at some point be overcome with an urge to pair every misplaced sock, bag up all clothes no longer needed and take them for donation, sort each toy box so every single block of lego is in the right box, etc etc.

It's a struggle OP but don't give up. Again like you, while keeping house is a constant struggle, the different it makes to our mind set and quality of life is huge and unequalled.

CoedenNadoligLanOHyd · 16/03/2023 19:23

Solidarity. I'm the same. I can clean, and declutter. Follow any and all systems.

My house is a shit hole. There's no clean dishes. No clean pants. And stuff everywhere.

Also have ADHD.

Getting the teens to help is impossible. How can I teach them to do something I can't do myself.

Mabelface · 16/03/2023 19:15

This is how I do it

To think truly chaotic messy people don't/can't change?
Hochjochhospiz · 16/03/2023 19:07

I agree with others saying donate don't sell. I mean obviously it's great if you can sell some stuff and get extra cash BUT it's often associated with a right carry-on with people not picking up the items or whatever, or having to go and post them.
If you're drowning under clutter it could take forever to get rid of stuff. This happened to me recently when I wanted to sell some old furniture to make space for new. What a nightmare that was - so in the end, I'm afraid the furniture had to go to the tip.
Same with clothes and other smaller items. If you are really trying to de-clutter, just get rid of it - donate or recycle. Otherwise it will just sit in bags for months on end and become part of the problem.

Precipice · 16/03/2023 18:11

in different shaped laundry baskets waiting to be sorted and put away.

In this particular instance, it's sort of you making more work for yourself. If you separated out the stuff as you took it down from the drying rack, it would already be sorted by this point. By not sorting it at that stage, you're essentially making one job (laundry from drying rack to wardrobe/drawers) into two separate jobs (take from the drying rack into laundry baskets, take it out from laundry basket and sort). There may be other things you're making similar work for yourself with.

binnybonny · 16/03/2023 18:03

I can't seem to change my ways. So I bought a big house and have spare rooms I shove everything in when someone comes round to pretend I'm not as messy as I am. I have whole plans devised around what goes where when I have visitors. I hate it but I can't seem to get on top of it,
I also have a spare living room that is untouched outside of guests which is pretty shameful but works.

I started to make waves when I met my rather orderly and tidy dh but since having dc I found myself back in a mess again. I have been mocked and shamed in the past by various people about it and wish I didn't have to be this way but I have no idea how to change and oh have I tried!
Big house appears to be the way forward 😅

efeslight · 16/03/2023 17:50

Another recommendation for the podcast a slob comes clean.
Start at the beginning of the podcasts and listen to them as you clean. She talks about establishing good habits, making small steps to making your house better and more under control and not expecting perfection.
The later podcasts I didn't really like, she talks to other people about their household and habits etc, but these might appeal to you.
Sounds like you just have too much stuff- also love the Stacey Solomon programme, so maybe try that but on a mini scale. Donate stuff, don't sell it, it's too much work.
Take photos of any progress made and try to put things away in groups, so you can keep track of what you have.

BertieBotts · 16/03/2023 17:42

Sorry I have come back to your posts OP - You say you want Stacey Solomon to put all your stuff in a warehouse.

What's helped me with this is identifying nearby places that I can get rid of things quickly and easily. So I have completely stopped bothering with ebay/vinted to get rid of old clothing - it takes too long. I had a backlog of loads of kid's stuff, and I happened to see an advert for a baby/children's-specific jumble sale so I booked a table there and I'm taking all the clothes and the outgrown baby stuff and I went through all the toys and put all the outgrown/duplicate/unwanted ones in boxes. I'm going to do that this weekend and I've asked DH as soon as it's finished to drive me straight to the nearest charity shop and I will donate everything that is left over. It is NOT coming back into the house!

For other stuff - we have a clothing bank at the end of the road, a book box around the corner. I offer stuff on the local buy nothing page but if it's not taken within a week I take it to these places. Then there is a general secondhand shop which takes everything, even soft toys. I have a bag-for-life on the go at all times and tidy things into it as and when I realise they are to go. When it gets full I put it on the buggy and the next weekday we go to the shop and drop it off. There is another, larger branch of this shop just outside of town and when I have a huge amount of stuff I fill up a box or two and get DH to drive me there to drop it off.

This approach has helped SO much because before I would hang onto things for ages trying to dispose of it in the "best" way or procrastinating about taking it anywhere and it just was all still in my house taking up space and breeding carpet beetles and moths.

vincettenoir · 16/03/2023 17:15

I have improved my messiness / chaos / timekeeping over the years. One thing that helped me was observing my own behaviour a bit more. I would notice that I was doing 4 things in the kitchen at once and becoming overwhelmed so now when I notice that I make sure I complete a task score moving on.

It’s a relatively new thing that couples have both been working full time with children and a household to run. There are improvements in technology (washing machines / dishwashers etc). But a lot more is expected from parents in society now. It wasn’t that long ago that parents would send their kids out to play all the time and they just fed them before dinner and packed them off again the next day. Be forgiving of yourself for finding it hard. It is hard.

BertieBotts · 16/03/2023 17:15

A Slob Comes Clean is the only one which has worked for me. I've always been shit at this stuff. My childhood/teenage bedroom was a sea of clothes and paper about 3 feet deep and nothing magically changed when I grew up.

BUT:-

It doesn't work 100%. My house is still chaotic (as in, people would be shocked/alarmed) about 50% of the time or more. However it is much better than it used to be. It would not take days/weeks to get it presentable now, it would probably take an hour or two even on the worst days.

It is probably DH doing at least as much as me, often significantly more than me. I could probably not sustain it without him. If I didn't have at least one competent adult in the house it would probably all descend into overwhelming very quickly.

It has only worked on any level because I bought the book and basically got obsessive over it and went through the "28 day challenge" (which took me at least 3 months if you can even claim that I finished it, which arguably I never did). And I listen to basically every episode of the podcast, skipping them occasionally, most days. Always when I'm cleaning/tidying/decluttering in order to kind of cement everything together in my head. The repetition seems to be key in order to get the key concepts to embed themselves in my head as things that are cemented as true facts.

For example: I now understand the difference between what she calls "daily tasks" (or four habits) and "actual cleaning". It is, generally, the daily tasks not being done that make a house seem chaotic. If you can just manage those, even if everything else is insane, it helps. Conversely, you can spend hours on whatever plan or routine or anything but if you've neglected the daily tasks (because most cleaning routines don't bother to add them because apparently this is obvious to normal people) then it will look and feel chaotic. And you'll be exhausted and defeated and not understand why you worked so hard and it didn't help.

I also have ADHD, which I think is behind the general messiness/slobbiness. Understanding and putting strategies in place for ADHD has meant that other strategies (like this book, probably others might help too) are able to work effectively. If cleaning is something you struggle with to the point that no book ever helps, ADHD is something worth looking into.

I have to actually DO IT. There is a line in the book which made me laugh out loud because I felt so seen. She said something like: Stop searching for the magical secret that means your house will stay clean without you having to clean it. You can read this bool 100 times and your house will not get cleaner. You actually have to clean your house. Sorry. But this helps because I think on some subconscious level I was always looking for that secret, and because actually even just doing the first of the daily tasks (Dishes) makes such a hugenormous, instant difference and does not actually take that long it means that I can do that most days and if I have missed a few days I just have to get caught up on that and the rest can wait (and I don't need to reinvent the wheel or beat myself up - just start again and the starting task being easy helps hugely with this).

I had to get rid of a LOT of stuff. I am still in the process of this actually. I use Dana's method again. I am learning about why my previous efforts to declutter did not particularly seem to make any effect and this was because I did not get stuff out of the house quickly enough, meaning that it ended up reassimilating into our general stuff and/or gathering dust and taking up space. And I made frequent use of what Dana calls "Procrastination Stations" (keep pile/keep box).

I have heard KC Davis (domesticblisters on social media) is good for getting past a lot of the mental blocks and guilt spirals around cleaning which can be extremely unhelpful. Her book is "How to keep house while drowning".

Bloomingcancer · 16/03/2023 17:08

A while ago, and probably on here, I read about doing five things, so my five things every day for a while was to chuck a minimum of five things away every day, when I say chucking one bag was also things for charity the shop. I also had a box under my bed I threw bits and bobs in when busy and then before I went to bed I tasked myself to deal with one or more items, so something may have needed to be binned, something might have needed filing, something else might need repairing. It got a bit full on and I had bags of filing, etc. but then another night I took that bag and did that one thing.

neverendinglauaundry · 16/03/2023 16:58

I feel you. No advice really. It's easier with less stuff but my family love stuff.

nobodysdaughter · 16/03/2023 16:56

I disagree- but you are in the eye of the storm with little kids, go easy on yourself.
BUT you will always be chronically messy if you believe you will always be so. I used to be RIDICULOUSLY messy, now I keep on top of it - how? (And I've probably got undiagnosed ADHD)
I believe people can change, learn new habits, I tell myself "I'm a calm, organised, clean and tidy person" when I get overwhelmed. I repeat it over and over in my head. I NEVER call myself messy/untidy either in my head or to anyone else.
I'm well into my fifth year of decluttering, and it is only now that I can look around and see any big improvements. Please don't give up! It's not an over night thing. I haven't given up getting rid of a bin liner off old shite regularly. Get a bag sling a load of stuff in it, put it in the car - eventually it will get taken to the tip the it's gone FOREVER! You feel lighter!

I know you want to change, and I believe you can't

Wombatbum · 16/03/2023 16:44

This sounds like me, also pretty sure I have ADHD 😩

CornedBeef451 · 16/03/2023 16:43

Once you've got rid of enough stuff it's much easier to organise. So the kitchen won't be as messy because you have clear surfaces and only as much crockery etc as you actually need. You have space to put things away easily without having to move anything else.

Surfaces in living areas are clear and easy to wipe. Toys can be tidied away in 5 mins.

If you only have exactly what clothes you need then laundry is easier to keep on top of and put away as you won't have brought stuff to leave in piles.

It has revolutionised my life!

My house was never tidy enough to just have people over and now I can tidy the whole house in 30 mins (apart from teen DD's room) and another 30 mins to do any cleaning and visitors could go in ANY room, even my bedroom as there are no longer piles of stuff waiting to be moved somewhere else.

SootspriteSearcher · 16/03/2023 16:41

I really have to force myself to be somewhat tidy it doesn't come naturally to me, but I find mess stressful and hard to relax in. Dh and dds are all incredibly messy. After reading alot I believe DD2 has ADHD and I think I may do aswell as alot of the behaviors resonate with me and my childhood.

So it's been a massive struggle to get tidier and more organised.

For me things things that work day to day:

  • weekend/day off list literally broken down into tiny tasks. I feel a sense of achievement ticking of each task and can see what else I need to do.
  • tidying the kitchen while the kettle boils (put away washing up, empty bin or load dishwasher)
  • try and do a wash load every day and get it put away the same day not left in a pile of doom precariously balanced. (Still working on this, it's my worst area!)
  • a handheld hoover, I can literally whizz it around the house in under 10 mins. It's been a lifesaver and my favourite purchase.

What has made the most difference:

  • decreasing the amount of stuff, and what you don't have space for get rid of. There are charities that collect from your home so you could collect it all up and organise one.
  • decent, workable storage. A wardrobe when you wear mostly jeans and tshirts is pointless, use the space on a tall chest of drawers. Shoe racks that you can close make hallways look much tidier. A place to put keys/purse near the front door. We use a kallax unit as a TV stand so all the cables are hidden in boxes. We threw away all the dvd cases and just use a giant wallet - saves space as 2 wallets that hold over 1000 dvds fits in one kallax cube.
  • buy less food/toiletries, these take up alot of room and headspace when cooking. Eg I had loads of impulse buys I bought on offer now im now trying to use in this months meal plan.
  • find/buy specific storage for all those random things you need but don't actually have a specific home - tape measure, allen key, cellotape etc. I have a shelf in my storage cupboard with labelled boxes. This reduces the need to buy more stuff, eg when i need superglue I can check my sticky box. I also have a birthday box in the loft with candles, birthday cards, wrapping paper, banners. This also saves money in the long run.

I understand all these things take time to implement but I did them over a the period of a few months on my days off. I still have many problem areas but I take it slow. I look at it that it didn't become cluttered overnight, it's going to take time to declutter.

CornedBeef451 · 16/03/2023 16:37

I always recommend the podcast a slob comes clean.

She used to have a very chaotic home and might have ADHD.

She takes you through how to declutter without making a mess and just helps you get stuff out of the house.

She also has very, very simple routines for cleaning and tidying, much simpler that TOMM or anything like that.

Optionally · 16/03/2023 16:36

Would finances allow you to have the cleaner twice a week? If so, would she be up for:

  • changing bedclothes, washing, drying and putting away clean bedclothes
  • emptying the dishwasher and draining board (and sink, if necessary!)
  • picking up the post and putting it in to piles (you, DH, junk)
  • emptying all the bins / recycling
  • putting away an supermarket grocery delivery (and tidying / cleaning fridge as necessary before doing so)
  • putting away any clean laundry (you may need to agree to put it in the right rooms so she knows what belongs to which person)
If you get all that, plus cleaning, it should make a noticeable difference. But you will probably need to pay well above the going rate if you want someone who will stay long enough to really get to know you, where you keep things, what you really need doing.
Hochjochhospiz · 16/03/2023 16:30

Having less stuff really does help.
If the toys are a problem, go through them and get rid of half of them.
Same with the clothes. Socks used to drive me mad until I got rid of them all and just got black ones, so no need for matching pairs etc.
I used to be quite messy, but I wouldn't say I was too bad, and I've improved things by decluttering and then being really strict about what comes into the house. My mother and siblings were brought up in poverty and basically hoarded everything - so houses full of old yoghurt pots, flattened cereal boxes, every damn thing kept in case it could be reused. My generation - so me and my cousins - struggle not to be the same.
I've forced myself to not keep stuff - cardboard, plastic beakers, whatever, go straight into the recycling. Broken electrical items are taken straight to the tip and replaced. At one time I would have kept them hanging around in case I could use them for something!!
Junk mail doesn't even enter the house - I have a letter box outside, I empty it and any junk is chucked in the paper recycling bin. When I lived in the UK, I had a bin by the front door for junk mail. It all went straight in there.
I don't buy stuff unless I am replacing something else - eg. clothes, I don't buy a new jumper until an old jumper really is on its last legs.
That's how I keep things under control.

I've really noticed that with less stuff there is absolutely definitely less mess.

Coxspurplepippin · 16/03/2023 16:19

pompomdaisy · 16/03/2023 15:30

Basically people who stress about mess are mostly empty heads or anxious nuts. Do what you can. If someone judges you. Kick them out of your life.

There's plenty of research showing living in a cluttered messy environment can adversely affect some people's mental health.

CoffeeChocolateWine · 16/03/2023 16:19

Another messy person here. Was always messy as a child, then teen, then young adult. I've definitely improved since then and part of me thinks I may be able to keep things tidy if it was just me, but now I have three messy DC too so I just can't keep on to of it! My middle one especially is so untidy and spreads her crap throughout the whole house. It drives me mad. DH likes to think he's tidy but in reality he just shoves things in and on top of cupboards and puts mess in piles!

I have a cleaner who comes for 3 hours each week and she is a god send. I do get stressed the day before running around putting things away and clearing surfaces but I know having the discipline is a good thing otherwise if wouldn't get done at all.

Wish I could find something that works for me. I do like the idea of seeing every job as two jobs. But I'm the queen of half-doing things...lots of half finished jobs in our house. I just run out of time or something else comes up or the kids want something and it just doesn't get competed 🙄

DevonSunsets · 16/03/2023 16:07

I lived in low grade filth. Floordrobe. nasty bathroom, what was a vaccum? Threw out crockery rather than cleaning it (because it had gone nasty in the sink water slime) I had a super busy life and just didn't have the mental space, time or inclination. Added to that I was naturally messy anyway.

I just woke up one day and decided enough was enough. I grew very disheartened super quick though because, as you said, you are running just to stand still. All I can say is that it is a long game and if you peck away at it slowly it does start to move the mountain back down to a molehill.

The biggest one change i made was 'dont put it down, put it away' followed by you cant do it all so do some 'progress, not perfection'. I also did a version of the power half hour. While dinner is on me and OH will do a raft of chores while we are up and about.

It does work and i can prove it! because we had unexpected guests (a thing i would never ever accept - i used to hide behind the sofa and pretend i wasn't in!) with barely any warning and it didn't cause a meltdown or a screaming dervish of cleaning.

WonderingWanda · 16/03/2023 16:03

Be kind to yourself op. You have a lot going on and it's hard work just managing day to day life let alone managing the stuff which arrives in your house with young children. My biggest tip is try and make getting stuff out your house a habit. Know where your nearest clothing bins / charity shops are.

Get some big bin bags, go through each child's wardrobe and be ruthless with anything they have outgrown. Do the same with the toys and the books.

Have a day each where you can go and drop of at a charity shop / take stuff to the tip / put it in recycling bins. I take it straight out of the house and put it in the boot of my car then once a week get rid of it all.

Get rid of half done craft and colouring books if that sort of stuff is out of control too. Bin anything broken.

Get everyone their own laundry bin. That way you just wash one person's stuff at a time so no sorting. If you tumble it most of it can get put away without ironing anyway. So bung it in the wash in the morning, tumble or drying rack when you get home and then back into the bin and upstairs after tea (or next day of drying rack /line and put away.