Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think truly chaotic messy people don't/can't change?

135 replies

houseofchaosandclothes · 16/03/2023 14:51

I have two small children, a demanding full-time job, a partner with a demanding full-time job and a parent with stage 4 cancer. (I also probably have ADHD but I'm stuck on a waiting list and not sure what difference a diagnosis would make. )

Yet the biggest source of stress in my life is my house. There are clothes everywhere - in laundry baskets waiting to be sorted and washed, in different shaped laundry baskets waiting to be sorted and put away. The toys are out of control. We can spend an hour cleaning the kitchen for one meal time to leave it destroyed.

I have read every thread about housekeeping and organising approaches in the world, and nothing seems to translate. It seems to take me twice as long as all these guides say it should to do something. TOMM is insane: fifteen minutes to do exactly what with a load of laundry? I can throw one in the washing machine in that time but sorting and putting it away will take me 45. We have a cleaner, and I would say spend 3/4 hours a week trying to scoop up the chaos enough she can clean around it. I try to declutter but every inch we reclaim seems to take a day and a half, and my limited annual leave and spare time is better spent with my parents or children. My husband does about 75% of the housework as he is much more efficient but we're still in chaos.

And I have spent YEARS of my life convinced I can change it. I grew up in a somewhat similar house. I'm 40. I have made half-hearted stabs at everything from flylady to a slob comes clean to Marie Kondo and nothing has changed and I'm starting to think that actually all the people who use these methods are not, in fact, the truly chaotic and messy. Or if they are, they don't have jobs/kids/sick parents/all of the above.

So I guess this is my question: has anyone truly messy and chaotic and terrible at housework reformed themselves? Have they done it when they have other things going on? Or are all these approaches just ways for ultimately organised people to get back on track and have nothing to say to the truly messy among us?

OP posts:
Nevermind31 · 17/03/2023 00:24

There are probably a number of things at work here, but only you’ll know if they resonate

  • any household with small children is going to be messy, because parents don’t have time, the washing is endless (meaning done is always drying and some is always waiting to be put away), and the toys are numerous
  • children will cause chaos
  • your house may be too small for the amount of stuff you have/ you don’t have sufficient storage
  • you may have more stuff than you need
  • apparently there is a strong link between adhd and messiness

some things you can obviously do something about, others you can’t.
but I find it amazingly calming to take things to recycling or the charity shop

RandomMess · 16/03/2023 23:29

When the kids were young they had very few clothes. They got to wear their favourite stuff lots regardless of whether it was a party dress or jeans.

The best thing was washing most days, hanging it up on hangers to dry and going straight in the wardrobe or being worn again.

They had 10 pairs of identical socks each, 10 pairs of knickers etc no piles of washing say around.

UrgentScurryfunge · 16/03/2023 23:14

It's hard to change your underlying character/ traits, but you can learn systems and methods that are more effective for you.

Good youtubers:
Clutterbug: she has ADHD. She identifies 4 methods of organising style.
When my sandwich toaster's been put away in the cupboard, I can go many months forgetting it's there and going toasted-sandwich-less. I need to see things as prompts. I need spaces to put clutter, and short term/ regular action items, so use "clutter baskets" to contain it to restricted zones, and when they're overflowing, it's time for action. Some people can hide things and remember they exist for use. People vary in how much detail to sort by.

Dana K White/ A slob comes clean: more ADHD. The container concept. The no mess method. "Just put it away" normally results in wandering the house in a confused haze of half-done jobs, and missing the point, but if I'm on a 30 minute targeted declutter/ tidy, it does work at avoiding being left with overwhelming piles when the time's up. 30 minutes better.

TOMM: works well at an even spread of managing the key living zones of the house across the week. The concept of doing it by time works well. I grew up with "tidy your room" which was a vast, overwhelming near impossible mission when faced with clutter and a lack of storage. Tidying was always a negative, often rage inducing task of facing inadequacy, and if it didn't fail was so bloody exhausting that it required a few days off and you've blinked and found it all a shit tip again.

TOMM has launched www.rockthehousework.co.uk/ of podcasts that talk you through cleans/ tasks. It's basically an ADHD strategy of mirroring and takes a lot of the exhausting thinking out of the process.

I'm finding that there are two types of people, those who realise that this is life-changing genius, and those who are baffled by the concept of being told how to clean/ tidy. But that's the thing, it's a skill to learn. We accept for just about everything else that we have to learn for instance driving lessons, but somehow we're supposed to crack on with knowing how to be clean and tidy out of nowhere! When we sort out a room, we could be dealing with hundreds of items and that's all decisions about where to put it. If you do it in an ineffective order, you can end up wasting time and making more mess. It's draining and frustrating. According to conventional logic you'd do the floor last because of gravity, but doing it that way meant that I always lost focus way before then, and the bits on the floor would annoy me, and I never got round to it, but traditionally, starting by cleaning the bare bits of floor was a result and focused me. Doing it by time not by a mega job has helped because it's more of a little and often approach and it's better, not a failiure. Having a podcast tell me that I'm going to spend 3 minutes clearing the surfaces then 2 minutes wiping them is just genius!

I never didn't care. I was just always overwhelmed, frustrated and lacking in strategy. It was like giving a non-driver a set of car keys and telling them to drive to somewhere they'd barely heard of. The house is far from immaculate, but I do now know that it's managable to get it back in control and presentable within an hour or two.

Hochjochhospiz · 16/03/2023 22:58

When I re-modelled my lounge, I initially wanted to do that because I needed more storage, but once I started looking at furniture and the style I wanted to have I soon came to the realization that I didn't want a whole pile of Kallax units from Ikea which I could fill with crap and that the solution was actually to have less storage, even though that's counter-intuitive, and get rid of the crap.

One problem area was two large coffee tables with shelves underneath, one of which had two drawers which were crap magnets. The shelves were constantly full of stuff - just a dumping ground - and it absolutely did my head in. I couldn't concentrate on anything because my eyes were being constantly drawn to all this crap. So I took a risk and bought coffee tables with no storage at all and bought open shelving. I bought some nice storage boxes to go on the shelves along with the usual books etc, Those boxes are for current projects. Instead of having crap lying around on tables and spare surfaces, each project has it's own box and the stuff goes in there. It's so much easier. I constantly have several projects on the go at once, rather than concentrating on one then moving on to the next.... but this has really helped.

I've felt much better since I did all of that and amazingly it's now been over 2 months and the lounge has remained tidy the whole time.

Maybe analyze exactly what is contributing to the mess - and that could be easily available surfaces and random drawers of doom which attract crap.
Buying more storage units isn't always the right solution because it's not tackling the problem of there being too much stuff.

DCxx · 16/03/2023 22:03

feeling so motivated after I’ve read all these comments. I have all my toddler’s baby clothes sitting in bags, tomorrow I’m going to go through them and put a few bundles and a few of the nice outfits/jackets on vinted. Whatever hasn’t sold by next weekend il donate. That gets rid of three big bags of stuff.

I’m pregnant and can’t wear half the stuff in my wardrobe so I’m going to go through and take out anything I can’t wear right now. The rest can go in a vacuum bag in the cupboard, only if I will definitely wear it again soon!

then I’m tackling, my makeup box, the hall cupboard and utility room. I will have a mountain of stuff to get rid of but can’t wait to just be able to see so much more empty space in my house

KeeperSweeper · 16/03/2023 21:59

Yes, I am a reformed messy person. I have sorted it by:

Thinking through every task very carefully, figuring out what was making it hard, and coming up with a step by way of doing it which works so I don't get 'stuck'.

Not starting new bad habits, e.g. leaving clothes out to wear again tomorrow. NO! Everything goes in wash basket of dirty, or back in drawer if clean.

Regular clearouts. Easier to manage stuff with less stuff. Easier to managing washing with fewer clothes!

Sweenytoddler · 16/03/2023 21:51

I feel your pain! As pp have said - firstly be kind to yourself, 2 parents working FT with young children is a ridiculous ask by itself imho.

I'm in a similar situation. 40, 2 young DC ( infant school) and pretty sure I have adhd. I also think DH has adhd ( and hoarding tendencies) and also eldest child also very very like me, v likely adhd. So already, you can imagine the chaos.

I've found I've got better over the years as I've had to with kids and it's got easier with old kids.

Things that help:

Having a weekly cleaner. I do the mad run around before, but it sort of resets the place each week.

'Be your future friend' do jobs to make future you'd life easier, e.g. get everything ready the night before- e.g. clothes, bag packed, lunch made. So much easier!! More likely to be on time and remember everything. Although it slips and this week I was scrabbling round in the dark trying not to wake dh @ 5.30am for some pants and cursing myself for not getting stuff ready.

That goes for household jobs. See the dishwasher needs emptying/ refilling? Bins need emptying, toilet needs cleaning? Just do it there and then. For some reason I used to put everything off and it all.piles up and becomes unmanageable. Little and often

Laundry - just stick one load on a day, hand one load out, folding and put away another. It's better than nothing!

Write everything on a family calender. I get overwhelmed with too much stuff in my head.

The problem I used to have is leaving everything to 'tomorrow' meaning you come to cook dinner but need to clean the kitchen first- takes ages and is exhausting compared to if you rest the kitch the night before. It's culmulative so you might drive home in your messy car, from a job where you might have made mistakes that day. Then you walk into a messy house and feel overwhelmed.

Decluttering - like pp say, I donate rather than sell. Selling is too messy for me. Do little bits like 5 mins through your babies drawers.

Lemonyfuckit · 16/03/2023 21:46

AllotmentTime · 16/03/2023 15:26

Without knowing you and your house intimately I don’t think anyone can say. I would say I’m similar in that my house has been low-level messy for years despite resolutions to change it. The things I do that work are when I’ve really taken the time to stop and analyse what makes a specific area go from tidy to messy.

We tend to think of it as “mess needs to be tidied” without breaking that down. Is it that the post gets put on the side until it’s a mountain? Why does it get put there/where would be better/how can you make the “better” thing easier than the “messy” thing?
Is it that the DC get every toy out at once? What’s happening in the house at that moment? What happens next? Etc until you’ve gradually & eventually been through every aspect of what “messy” means.

the book Atomic Habits helped me. And thinking about how to make the desirable habit/behaviour easy, and then easier still, until you’re practically forced to do it.

I think in a completely unconscious way this is what did it for me: messier (or rather the mad mad panic tidy when someone was coming round) had become harder than keeping on top of things.
Little and often until it becomes habit.

Lemonyfuckit · 16/03/2023 21:42

OP I don't have a magic solution as to how I reformed but I did. I was truly messy as a child/teenager/young adult and into my early 30s. As I always lived in a house share I was always tidy in communal areas but my bedroom was an absolute bombsite. You could never see the floor. This is what happened: whenever I was dating someone if they were coming back to mine I would have to frantically shove everything in the cupboard / under the bed in a mad panic. Sometimes I got caught out and was embarrassed. When I met my now DH, because he became a regular visitor as it were and spent so much time at mine it was just too much hard work trying to mad tidy up all the time so I started trying to keep it tidier. And then when we moved in together, well he is very very tidy and basically would hate it if our home was messy. We do little and often, tidy up as we go along so rarely have to do a big tidy, we just put stuff away as we go. It's genuinely become habit now, and I don't like mess.

Turnipworkharder · 16/03/2023 21:27

You need a sort of housekeeper... one that will wash,dry,put clothes away.
Tidy things for you.

Would your cleaner be able to incorporate that , maybe add an extra hour on her clean ?

My dil sounds very much like you (I'm her unpaid housekeeper)😁

confusedlots · 16/03/2023 21:26

This really resonates with me and I'm pretty sure I have ADHD too. We're living in a tiny space at the minute as we do major house renovations and that is making the situation a lot worse as we are living in a pile of clutter.

I try to pick one small thing and sort and tidy that, then I often find that the satisfaction that brings motivates me to do another thing. So I might pick the fridge, empty the contents onto the table, give it a clean, then go through the food as I put it back in, throwing out any out of date stuff.

Or I might pick one drawer, maybe the drawer that the kids pyjamas are in, take everything out, check what I have and remove the ones that don't fit anymore and put the rest back in nice and organised so it's clear to see what I have.

For me, doing things in manageable chunks really helps. I would get too overwhelmed if I told myself I had to sort and clean the whole kitchen or all of the kids clothes, and then I'd never do anything.

stayathomer · 16/03/2023 21:26

Am absolutely no help as, at 42, we are only marginally better than we were years ago even though I’d have thought this started improving with age. The only thing is, I’ve accepted we’re a slightly chaotic family and made peace with it. For two reasons:

  1. my brother and sister both have insanely clean houses and are organised even though brother has two boys sister has four children. I realised that this is because their hobbies are cleaning. Bro and sip iron on a Friday night, Saturday is cleaning and gardening and Sunday is getting ready for Monday. They are amazing but … well, it’s just not me
  2. My mum was organised and clutter free. If we didn’t physically store something we wanted it was recycled or binned. I have lost so many of my prized books, art work, magazines etc this way. I know there’s a happy medium and as I said I am getting better, but I don’t know that the grass is always greener in a total mess free home!!
TinaYouFatLard · 16/03/2023 21:24

If laundry is a main source of the problem PLEASE take my advice and wash loads by person rather than by type. In my house each person has a basket with their name on and when it’s full for a load it all goes in together. It is so much easier to fold and put away when there aren’t 4 or 5 people’s stuff there.

BrandyandGinger · 16/03/2023 21:11

Don't do too much washing, make sure that hoodies and jumpers etc get worn a few times. Hang up towels and use them a few times before washing.
Before bedtime every single day empty all the clean laundry onto your bed and put it all away. Help the kids put their clean clothes away, even if they are tiny they can help.
If you do this every single day you'll be on top of the washing and other tidying will be less overwhelming.

Wbeezer · 16/03/2023 20:58

I can be tidy if surrounded by tidy people, it rubs off on me and my efforts aren't immediately undermined which is motivating. Unfortunately I am usually surrounded by family members who are messier than me with bitty hobbies and creative messy jobs they do from home so I'm fighting a losing battle. When DH isn't working too hard he's good at doing tidying but when he's busy he just leaves a trail of stuff behind him!
I would love to declutter more but my family are collectors and we have a big house so I content myself with buying lots of shelving.
At some point well downsize and I will have a more modern easy to clean house with less people and stuff and a husband with time to help more and it will be acceptably tidy, I'm determined.

CatNamedEaster · 16/03/2023 20:57

I think that decluttering will still only work if you can change your natural approach to maintain it. If we go away for a weekend with one small bag each, the hotel room will have my stuff scattered around all four corners after the first night (probably earlier but I'm being generous to myself 😂).

NoSquirrels · 16/03/2023 20:55

And I agree that you have to make it a priority if you want it to change, at least till habits are established.

It absolutely sucks and it is boring as fuck but hey ho.

This is what jumped out at me from your OP:
Have they done it when they have other things going on?

And the answer is yes, but either it’s not quick and a dramatic change or yes, but they made it a priority.

CatNamedEaster · 16/03/2023 20:51

OP I empathise completely. A couple of weeks ago I broke down and cried that I have spent my life fighting against my chaos thinking it was something I could improve if I just tried harder or found the right technique. I'm fucking tired of beating myself up about it.
@StepHigh you have looked inside my brain! The revelation that every job is two jobs has blown my mind. I can see that every single job I do is half finished but I never understood why...and you have pinpointed exactly why. I do most of the laundry but once it's on the dryer that's me done then DH has to bring it in and put it all away; if I do some work in the garden, DH spends half an hour putting the tools away and filling the green bin because the prunings are dumped on the lawn; if I batch cook or make a cake, he ends up washing up most of the cutlery and baking equipment we own as I can't bear the mess that I've made.
@Shouldbeasleepbynow I've just reserved Struggle Care from the library, thanks for the recommendation.

NoSquirrels · 16/03/2023 20:51

I think if you return to A Slob Comes Clean and just listen to the podcasts, you might find you’re inspired to more than a half-hearted attempt.

In particular, if your problem is laundry, follow her ‘Laundry Day’ system and see if it makes a difference. And chuck out 30-50% of your clothes. Just bag them up and put them somewhere inaccessible for now.

bubbles2023 · 16/03/2023 20:49

I think that you can change. I often watch the sort your life out programme and get anxiety just watching how people live. Their lives and homes are so much lighter after. Decluttering can make a huge difference. We moved a few years ago after living in previous house for 15 years (we merged 2 houses). We cleared at least 30% of our house. New house feels so much more manageable- does need another clear out tbf as dc outgrown loads of toys.

Boriswentcamping · 16/03/2023 20:48

SpookyBlackCat · 16/03/2023 15:24

Have you tried A Slob Comes Clean? I read her books and watch her YouTube videos. My house was really bad but it’s so much better now. I don’t know what it is about her system that clicked for me when none of the others did, but I think she’s great especially for those of us with ADHD.

This! My house is so much better than it ever it has been. I am naturally messy and chaotic, her books were a game changer for me. Its all about changing your mindset - and decluttering!!

BertieBotts · 16/03/2023 20:47

Oh yes I agree also with the person who said make getting a clean house a top priority for a while.

One of my strategies to manage ADHD is allowing myself 3 spots for things I can think about and work towards. Before I did this I would have so many things that I was vaguely aiming to "work on" - I wanted to improve our diets and the house and my exercise and playing an instrument and cutting down my screen time and my sleep routine and socialise more and streamline my clothing and mindfulness and a child's homework and another child's chores and another child's sleep and my language proficiency and setting up a blog and getting a job or a better job and and and and... And I did none of it because it was all overwhelming and nobody can work on that many things at once. But then I'd feel simultaneously guilty because I wasn't making progress and vaguely think oh yes, I'm working on that, even though I wasn't.

Neurotypical people would probably prioritise without necessarily having a list somewhere, but what I need to do for me is have three distinct areas where I'm focusing on and I know that anything productive I'm doing needs to be towards those. So at the moment it's DS2 behaviour, improve the house, and then I have a blank slot because the thing that was in my third slot doesn't need so much of my attention any more.

This has really helped. So because for example diet and exercise are not on the list I give myself full permission not to do any exercise except for walking and eat whatever convenience food is easy. I do not feel guilty about it. I am not letting it take up brain space. It is on my list to possibly move into a top spot when one becomes available but I haven't decided what to put in that slot yet. Probably socialising.

Because improving the house is in my top spot that's what made me do things like seek out podcasts or books, I'm binge watching all of the sort your life out etc. I'm allocating money in the budget to buying paint or organising solutions or anything like that.

It won't need to be a priority for ever. I've found that items just stop needing to be in that top category because I stop thinking about them. For example, one of ours at one point was money. So I researched loads and set us up with a budget. I got a job. I applied for things that we weren't receiving. I cancelled subscriptions that we weren't using. None of that big one off stuff needs doing again and the budget is working well by itself so it's not a priority any more but the effects of me prioritising it previously have stuck.

I prioritised language at one point. I tried to speak the language I'm learning every day. My skills improved and it doesn't need to be a current focus, although might come back in future.

It's been one of the most helpful things I've done.

bussteward · 16/03/2023 20:45

I’m reading this thread as a naturally neat person who has a messy house largely as DP has ADHD; I do think if that’s the case it’s very hard to change. And time works differently if you have ADHD, so putting a wash on can really take 45 mins!

Less stuff definitely definitely helps, and creating a place for everything in storage areas and making that place easily accessible: it’s no good if XYZ lives in the cupboard if stuff falls out as you open the cupboard and you have to jostle and move things to put it away. One thing DP does is constantly buy things to buy a solution to his mess, like if he just has the right box/container/system/shelves he won’t be messy. But then the container arrives in a cardboard box, which itself gets put on the counter instead of straight in the recycling, then he finds the container needs assembling and a special type of screwdriver, which he has but can’t find (because he actually has 10 crammed in the cupboard but they’re hidden by all the other stuff), so he orders another one, discards that packaging too, but by then his brain has moved on to another idea so the container and the screwdriver just sit there, cluttering.

I periodically go on decluttering rampages, which helps.

It’s funny though: I just left the bedroom where I was with the baby, and swapped wit DP so I could eat. On my way out I grabbed a sicky babygro to throw in the wash basket, a book that belongs elsewhere, and some other items to put away: it’s automatic. Stepped outside onto the landing to find DD’s clothes in a heap from bathroom (which DP supervised), bath still full, wet flannel on the floor, light on. He’s walked right past it all and genuinely doesn’t see it.

Not sure where I’m going with this but I do think: less stuff will help. Systems help but only if they’re intuitive to what you actually DO. I can implement a bowl for keys and pocket detritus all I like, but it has to be in the place that DP naturally pauses and dumps that stuff out, even if I don’t really want a bowl there. A ban on stuff incoming to the house: cancel things like amazing prime if you have it. Don’t multitask if it’s not your strength: watching DP empty the dishwasher of clean stuff while making breakfast and watching something on his iPad is painful to behold. Always “close the task”: making dinner isn’t just cooking, it’s clearing up, loading the dishwasher, wiping surfaces and “resetting” the kitchen back to baseline zero.

But be kind to yourself; you have a lot going on.

Croissantsandpistachio · 16/03/2023 20:37

Yes @hausmaus has great advice! And thinking about it, that's sort of how DH operates naturally.

Undethetree · 16/03/2023 20:33

@housemaus Great post, I love this advice!