Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neurodiverse and learning to Drive

64 replies

dottypotter · 16/03/2023 11:03

Can I have your opinions/experience please?
Is it harder/impossible for ND people to learn to drive?

OP posts:
Babdoc · 16/03/2023 14:35

I’m autistic and find it actually makes me a better driver! The single minded focus on the road means I am aware of other drivers’ behaviour and intentions much earlier, I am continuously reading the traffic flow ahead of and behind me, I am not distracted by things that interest neurotypical drivers like conversation or music.
It took me a while to learn, as I was very anxious, and needed a lot of practice to coordinate gear changes and foot pedals etc, but once I had the movements memorised I could absolutely “get into the zone” and become one with the car.
As a young doctor I used to have to drive on emergency calls at over 100mph, covering two hospitals from home, and I’m proud of my over forty years no claims bonus.

ChopSuey2 · 16/03/2023 14:34

I likely have ADHD (I score high on inattentive subtype on validated measures) but I have never been assessed. Everyone I've asked has said it's a terrible idea because I get very easily distracted. I agree. I also struggle with spatial awareness, directions, and knowing my left and right. I doubt I'd be safe on the road. I have to get pushed out of the corner on bumper cars 😂

stbrandonsboat · 16/03/2023 14:25

I'm ND and never had any problems learning to drive. Passed first time as well. Ds', on the other hand, hates driving and is really struggling. He's going to have to do it though as I can't keep on giving him lifts and public transport is too expensive and unreliable.

alloalloallo · 16/03/2023 14:23

Willyoujustbequiet · 16/03/2023 13:54

You don't need to declare the diagnosis itself.

Only if it affects your driving.

Yes.

My daughter has Tourette’s, ASD and dyslexia.

None of them would stop her driving and she didn’t have to declare it DVLA unless she felt they affected her driving - they didn’t.

It was seizures that put the kibosh on her driving in the end

HostessTrolley · 16/03/2023 14:06

My DS just passed this week - he's 24 and has high functioning ASD (was diagnosed Aspergers but I understand this is no longer a 'thing'). He learned in an automatic. His issues were never with operating a car, more in anticipating the actions of other road users where they are illogical or don't follow the rules. He didn't try when he was younger due to uni and covid.

It took him 4 attempts to pass but he finally did it! He's been driving my car in the long gaps between his tests (because it's still a nightmare to get test bookings) with learner insurance - I've just been sitting in the car on my phone, his driving is fine, he's just struggled on test days. He drove himself to his sports training last night, and commented that it wasn't as weird as he thought to drive on his own. I said 'this is why I've sat quietly on my phone in the car, so you're not used to having someone chatting a lot'.

Willyoujustbequiet · 16/03/2023 13:59

It depends on the individual. Dyspraxics may struggle but the autistics I know found it easier than neurotypicals.

Willyoujustbequiet · 16/03/2023 13:54

DollyPartonsBeard · 16/03/2023 12:27

You may well know this already, OP, but depending on the nature of the neurodiversiry, your DC may be required to declare it at the application stage, and undergo additional screening before a licence is issued. The list includes ASD and ADHD.

www.gov.uk/health-conditions-and-driving/find-condition-a-to-z

You don't need to declare the diagnosis itself.

Only if it affects your driving.

Anonymous48 · 16/03/2023 13:50

I'm not sure what the AIBIU question is, so didn't know how to vote. But as many other people have said it completely depends on the individual person and the nature of their neurodiversity. My young adult child has dyspraxia and ADHD, which manifests as poor spatial awareness and motor planning, impulsivity and slow processing. All of which would be barriers to learning to drive and/or being a safe driver.

BanditsGravyStain · 16/03/2023 13:47

I have ADHD which means, for me, I aced the theory but can’t stick with lessons long enough to learn to actually drive Blush

RelationshipOrNot · 16/03/2023 13:46

I'm autistic and have come to accept that I can't always trust my own judgement. This means I've decided not to learn to drive, as I cannot trust that I would make safe decisions.

VikingLady · 16/03/2023 12:31

Oh, and your type of neurodiversity affects how you learn. He reckoned my autism/paranoia about other drivers made me exceptionally safe as a driver. ADHD tends to mean less fear. It's actually a bonus in some ways.

Tapenade · 16/03/2023 12:30

DollyPartonsBeard · 16/03/2023 12:27

You may well know this already, OP, but depending on the nature of the neurodiversiry, your DC may be required to declare it at the application stage, and undergo additional screening before a licence is issued. The list includes ASD and ADHD.

www.gov.uk/health-conditions-and-driving/find-condition-a-to-z

Although that’s only if it affects your ability to drive safely - so not everyone with those conditions needs to declare.

gettingoldisshit · 16/03/2023 12:29

Absolutely not more difficult! Both my ND DS passed extremely quickly.

VikingLady · 16/03/2023 12:29

I'm autistic and I passed my test in a manual last month, in my40s.

I chose a very calm driving instructor and warned him I had extreme social anxiety and would probably be very, very nervous. So he took it slowly and NEVER got wound up at me.

We started in the quiet end of a supermarket car park, on the quietest part of the week, just going up and down to get used to the idea and to concentrate on getting the hang of coordinating feet/hands etc. We didn't hit an actual road for a month. He regularly took over doing the indicators if I needed to concentrate more. Crucially, he stayed calm!

I found two hour lessons with a toilet/coffee break in the middle was best. You spend the first bit calming down (we always started on the same easy route to get into it again), then the second half doing harder stuff once you're calm.

Honestly, it was fine. Way better than I'd expected. I passed first time despite having shit coordination!

If you're in the NE I can recommend him

Tapenade · 16/03/2023 12:28

I passed first time in a manual but it took me a long time to be ready for the test.

I’m a much better driver now I’ve switched to an automatic with parking sensors though.

DollyPartonsBeard · 16/03/2023 12:27

You may well know this already, OP, but depending on the nature of the neurodiversiry, your DC may be required to declare it at the application stage, and undergo additional screening before a licence is issued. The list includes ASD and ADHD.

www.gov.uk/health-conditions-and-driving/find-condition-a-to-z

QuintanaRoo · 16/03/2023 12:26

Dd had to switch from manual to automatic, really struggled with manual lessons and took to automatic like a duck to water and passed first time. I think all new electric cars are automatic?

BoardLikeAMirror · 16/03/2023 12:26

It was impossible for me, sadly.

Ohby · 16/03/2023 12:23

Depends completely on the person really, I don't think I will ever manage it, passed the theory test several times but the stress of the practical test is too much and I get flustered too easilt. But I know other autistic people that have passed it no problem.

bigbluebus · 16/03/2023 12:23

My DS (ASD diagnosis) learned to drive at 17. Passed his test 2nd time. Don't think he found it difficult tbh. He did have 2 young driver type lessons on private land when he was 16 (with a driving instructor) so he'd mastered the clutch/gears before he hit the road at 17.

Ladybowes · 16/03/2023 12:21

Dyslexic here - as others have said totally depends on the individual. I passed my driving test first time but I was in my 20s. I wasn't ready at 17 and did not have the spare cash... be sure to shop around for a good driving instructor who has helped us neurodiverse people. Good luck any learning.

SnacksToTheMax · 16/03/2023 12:20

I should also say, I’ve had an issue with left and right my whole life! No instinct for it - I have to manually think it through every. Single. Time.

When I sat my test, I asked the examiner to point in the direction he wanted me to turn as well as saying. He obliged, and I’m still very grateful to him. No way I would have passed otherwise.

Chillbrains · 16/03/2023 12:19

my DS18 (ASD dx) has just pulled out of his test. He’s completely technically competent when he’s concentrating but as soon as he’s not he’s an utter liability. It Probably wouldn’t show up in a test, but could have catastrophic consequences in real life - he just focuses intensely on whatever is going on in his head and not in the road or what he’s doing in the car - it’s terrifying!!

We’ll try again in a few years but it’s still shit for him.

SnacksToTheMax · 16/03/2023 12:17

Depends on your issues really. I’m autistic - visual stimulus can be very overwhelming, and I’m slow to process and react to it.

I learned at 18 (before I knew I was autistic) and found the whole experience awful. Went through three different instructors (I sacked one because he couldn’t teach me, one sacked me because he couldn’t teach me and the third was extremely patient). 40+ hours of lessons, cancelled my first test because I wasn’t ready… but then passed first time in the end. It was extremely stressful for everyone involved and I’ve literally not driven since because it’s just too scary.

People kept telling me the various processes would click eventually, become automatic and instinctive, but they never did - I felt like I was having to manually think through every tiny step of driving whilst processing too much information that was coming at me all the time in a way that constantly startled and stressed me. I would flinch constantly. I couldn’t judge gaps or relative speeds. Eurgh.

I need to re-learn now at 40 and I’m terrified, but I’m looking for an autism-informed instructor this time around. I feel like I need to build the skills up way more gradually than most people, so I can automate each part of the process before I move onto the next one. Trying to learn it all simultaneously was just waaaaay too much for my particular brain.

Tomnooktoldmeto · 16/03/2023 12:02

Harder possibly but impossible no, do your research on instructor before you start is in my opinion the key factor

DH DD and DS are all ND. DD and DS have spent the last 18 months learning with a very patient instructor (who we all feel is also ND) DS passed a couple of months ago at his third attempt, DD has her test in a couple of months

I did take DS out quite a bit once he had reasonable skills but I also spent the 2 years before he started driving on journeys to school getting him to assess the traffic and situations to increase his awareness of how to approach traffic and situations

just be ready for the expense, at one point we were paying out £650 a month on lessons for the two of them