Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neurodiverse and learning to Drive

64 replies

dottypotter · 16/03/2023 11:03

Can I have your opinions/experience please?
Is it harder/impossible for ND people to learn to drive?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Babdoc · 17/03/2023 11:33

ScruffyGiraffes, I’m autistic and go back to the days long before satnavs. I just looked up the route the day before in my road atlas and noted down the main points in large writing on a piece of paper, which sat beside me in the car.
Road signs are mostly clear and helpful in the UK, so I rarely got lost. Occasionally I would stop in a layby and just check the atlas again before a particularly complicated set of junctions.
I still find a satnav a bit of a distracting nuisance, especially when I know a better shortcut and satnav woman keeps whining at me to do a u turn!

kingsleysbootlicker · 16/03/2023 20:46

I'm Autistic and couldn't ever think of even trying to learn to drive. I have sensory overload and am overwhelmed even as a passenger. But my autistic DD learnt to drive easily and is great at it. It just depends on how each person's ND affects them

WorkingWhileStressed · 16/03/2023 20:42

I am going to disagree with the jump straight to an automatic advice. I think ND people should at least try a manual first and only switch to automatic if gears turn out to be a particular problem for them, as it can be limiting if you're restricted to automatic cars.

I am dyslexic and dyspraxic, and gears were not the issue that I needed to sort out, it was my road position (I was always slightly too close to the left or right, until after many, many, hours it suddenly clicked and I was getting the road position correct without thinking about it).

An automatic wouldn't have made any difference to me. I stuck at it because everything online about dyspraxia and driving said that it shouldn't preclude driving but it will likely take you far longer to master it.

FatCatt · 16/03/2023 20:36

Oh and I’m not sure if it’s related but I don’t like parking on the road going forwards. Like just pulling up to the kerb I find parallel or reverse parking MUCH easier to get nice and close without scratching my alloys

FatCatt · 16/03/2023 20:31

I think it makes anxiety worse.
I’m autistic and have ADHD. I’m a perfectionist and find driving very stressful. But I’ve been driving since 17 (now 24) and haven’t even bumped a wing mirror or anything. Whereas I know lots of others that have been in crashes. Motorway driving is my favourite driving. I can easily do 4/5 hours on the motorway. Town driving takes a LOT of concentration for me. Probably 25 mins town driving is there same as 2 hours of motorway.

I might try an automatic for my next car

Chillbrains · 16/03/2023 20:19

gettingoldisshit · 16/03/2023 12:29

Absolutely not more difficult! Both my ND DS passed extremely quickly.

Thanks, that made me feel so much better for my DS obviously more disabling disability in this area.

stayingaliveisawayoflife · 16/03/2023 20:11

Oh and I am dyspraxic.

stayingaliveisawayoflife · 16/03/2023 20:10

Bit nervous here because a poster from a while ago piled in saying there is no excuse for not learning to drive unless you are not intelligent enough. It all went a bit crazy.

I can't drive. I tried but I was so bad I was dangerous. Now I have a chauffeur (my husband) or public transport and I don't feel the need to try. I am doing my bit to keep public transport going!

dizzydizzydizzy · 16/03/2023 17:10

Autistic. Needed lots and lots of lessons. Driving instructor kept on delaying my test. I did past first time but was never happy driving. Don't drive at all now. Too scared.

WeightoftheWorld · 16/03/2023 17:08

I am ND. I had well over 100hrs of lessons but covid meant my learning was v stop start and I think that really made a big difference as I'd keep needing to relearn over again and rebuild my confidence etc. I have very high levels of anxiety about driving. I wanted to learn automatic but couldn't find an instructor so initial learned manual and still always struggled with gears. Eventually we bought an automatic car and I switched to that, it went much better. I failed 3 tests, my last one was the best of the 3 and was going well, I didn't really understand why I failed and it did feel unfair. After another break because there were 3 month waits for tests my anxiety got too bad and I cancelled my 4th test for a break. My theory was about to expire after it anyway. One of the problems for me was not being able to practice outside of lessons. I think if I could have gone out every single day for short stretches this would have made the difference for me but I couldn't. As initially we didn't have a car and then once we did, we had two kids, so no time as there was nobody who would sit in our house so DH could come driving with me, and on the weekends I felt sooo anxious to drive with the kids with us. Spent ££££££ on lessons that could have gone in to the house with nothing to show for it. Feel so sad about it all and like a total failure.

ScruffyGiraffes · 16/03/2023 16:49

One thing that would make life so much better is if people would use indicators. Or follow lane rules. I'm not sure the theory test is doing its job given there are so many drivers on the road that don't do that, or understand right of way etc. So that can be very frustrating and baffling, when they apparently have licences, and the rules aren't exactly complicated! 🤣 I'm convinced that 70% of the people on the road shouldn't have a driving licence. I think that's much more of a challenge - dealing with other people behaving in a bizarre manner - once you get over the basics of manouveringy a car. Although as said, that part will be harder for other people. We are all different.

NotTerfNorCis · 16/03/2023 16:32

In my area there is an instructor who specialises in neurodiverse people. Automatic cars only.

ScruffyGiraffes · 16/03/2023 16:31

Also would never have survived in the time before Sat Nav and would still be lost in an industrial estate somewhere from my first job. 🤣 How did even NT people manage with just maps and one driver in the car? I don't understand that at all. Thankfully not an issue these days.

ScruffyGiraffes · 16/03/2023 16:28

But definitely if capable of learning in a manual that is better. So try that first. And if it's not working move to automatic.

As a lone parent it's been so useful being able to hire vans to take stuff to the tip or get hire cars in places where automatic cars are not the norm and would cost a fortune. A manual licence is very useful and it's not that much harder to learn for most ND or NT people: in a short time it becomes automatic to do gear changes the same way you don't think about how you put one foot in front of the other and balance while you walk once you've mastered it. But it really does depend how the neurodiversity in question impacts the specific person so in a minority of cases only an automatic would be manageable: just try and then see.

ScruffyGiraffes · 16/03/2023 16:23

I'm autistic qnd have ADHD. I learned just fine in a normal manual car, but everyone's different. As a PP said my main issue on the road is keeping in mind at all times that other people do not behave in a logical way and don't bother to follow the rules. Infuriating and baffling at the same time. But once you build in caution to compensate for their incompetence and weird behaviour, it's fine. Like you have to with all other aspects of life in an NT world really. 🤣

I think it would be different for different people as the whole point of the spectrum is that we all have different skills and deficits. Weirdly my spatial awareness when walking about is terrible but in a car it is really good, perhaps because I know I am driving a machine, not just moving my body without thinking, so focus all of my attention on that. I used to drive hundreds of miles per week for work, have driven in so many different countries, left hand drive cars etc, no problem. The only time I have ever had a crash was when I was on the way to my ADHD assessment... 🤣🤣🤣 So stressed about it and distracted. The irony.

suzyscat · 16/03/2023 16:20

I know a lot dyspraxic (and dyspraxic and adhd drivers. It took them a lot longer to learn, longer for the post test muscle memory to kick in but they're all great drivers.

1 has never had an accident
1 had several just before / after passing their test but none for over a decade and often drives abroad
1 had a few bumps and grazes in the first few years but nothing major and nothing for many years

My autistic and autistic & adhd drivers are also good drivers.

I trust all of them to drive my kids around.

acrimoniousone · 16/03/2023 16:15

I failed three or four times due to chronic ASD overthinking. Had a row with the last examiner as I saw early on he'd already failed me and saw no point continuing the charade.

Jules912 · 16/03/2023 16:10

I have ASD and it was harder but not impossible. For a long time I refused to drive alone anywhere I didn't know as I have no sense of direction and couldn't focus on driving when worrying about getting lost, but sat-nav was a game changer there.
Regarding telling the DVLA I did check with my doctor and he basically said if you can pass the test it doesn't affect your driving. This may not be the case for other ND conditions though.

Conkersinautumn · 16/03/2023 16:04

I didn't know I was ND. I have a great spatial awareness (no idea if that's ND) and I KNOW so much of the highway code by heart. BUT it took me a bit longer to develop the muscle memory part of driving. I did pass first time at 17. It was fantastic to be able to control the car environment, radio, heat, speed etc. Before that I'd always hated cars.

gogohmm · 16/03/2023 16:00

Neurodiverse includes such a wide spectrum that it is not useful to use the term when asking for specific advice like this. All 4 of our kids come under this umbrella, 2 have driving licences, passed first time, one is refusing to try as too anxious, one has ld's so no capacity.

Generalising, if you are only diagnosed as a teen/adult then you probably are not as affected so learning to drive should be possible, it may take a little longer, it may not. As I say I'm generalising, everyone is different

camelCase · 16/03/2023 15:47

I'm autistic, learned to drive in my late 20's and like PP's I focus solely on driving, I drive a manual and passed both the theory and practical first time.

GoldenGorilla · 16/03/2023 15:29

I’m dyspraxic and spent years thinking I couldn’t/shouldn’t drive. Now I do drive in an automatic, which is easier and I just drive the routes that I know well. Still stressful - I don’t like to drive for more than 20 mins at a time as it’s so tiring, don’t drive anywhere I haven’t previously been, won’t go on motorways, won’t go to places with big roundabouts, don’t try to parallel park. So there’s a lot of planning involved and I always allow extra time to find easy parking spots etc.

basically I know my limitations so just drive routes I’m confident I can do safely.

im probably a pretty annoying driver (tend to go too slow) but can drive (in the limited way that I do) safely at least.

TuesdayJulyNever · 16/03/2023 15:11

My dps gave me lots of off road practice so that the pedals and gears had become automatic movements before I ever went out on the road.

I also needed to read about how to drive, and not just be told or shown. And I needed answers to my hundreds of questions.

So yes, probably a bit slower than average but I passed first time and I’ve never had an accident. I think I have a more realistic grasp of braking distances than most drivers.

Fromthefog · 16/03/2023 14:47

I'm autistic and passed first go after a month of lessons. I had no idea at the time that I was ASD. I also think I am not a bad driver as I completely focus on driving and ignore my passengers to an extent.

Corah5 · 16/03/2023 14:45

It is harder. I struggle to notice road signs, so it helps me to have a sat nav where the speed limit pops up on the screen. I only drive on familiar roads where I know the correct lane and where I’m going, because when it’s unfamiliar I can’t react fast enough to the road signs and environment. If I need to drive somewhere unfamiliar I preview the entire route on Google Maps and memorise where I’m going and which lane I need to be in etc. It took me many hours to get familiar enough with the local roads to be able to drive on them well enough to pass a test - many more hours than a NT person would need. I couldn’t have afforded that many hours with an instructor, I needed to go out driving with my mum in her car for hours and hours to memorise the roads.

Swipe left for the next trending thread