Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that "Rehabilitation" is a joke, because you can't change who someone is sexually attracted to!

188 replies

BeachBlondey · 16/03/2023 10:27

Inspired by the Gary Glitter latest story.

Why as a society, can't we accept, that you cannot fundamentally change who someone is sexually attracted to?

For example - no amount of "rehabilitation" will stop paedophiles being attracted to children.

We know that conversion therapy does not work (barbaric!)

Furthermore, you can't read people mind's, and of course they will say that they feel rehabilitated, because they know that this is their key to being released.

Further still, what happens when you ban someone from indulging in their sexual fantasies for years on end? Surely, the amount of sexual frustration and desire will build and build and build.

If a rapist has not had sex with a woman for 10 years, when he is released from prison, isn't he far more likely to be sexually frustrated and thus more likely to attack quite quickly?

If a paedophile hasn't been around children for 10 years, surely the first time he is around children, his sexual urges will go in to overdrive, probably to far more dangerous levels than ever before, because he will have an appetite that has not been sated for decades.

I am a female heterosexual woman, and no amount of "rehabilitation" forced upon me, would make me stop wanting sex with men. Nor would it magically make me fancy women. But, if I was in prison for having sex with a man, of course, I would tell the parole board that I was cured. And I'm sure that having been celibate for 10 years, the first thing I would want to do upon release would be to have sex with a man.

I'm so sick of sex offenders being released, who very quickly go on to reoffend, resulting in some poor innocent person being attacked or killed. We are constantly risking the safety of the public, under the guise of people having been rehabilitated, despite us seeing evidence to the contrary all the time.

When released prisoners reoffend, I would like to see the members of that Parole board penalised, either with being fired from their jobs, or being given monetary fines.

I realise that a big issue is space in prison. We either build more prisons, or consider medical castration maybe? We cannot keep placing the public at risk.

OP posts:
furryfrontbottom · 16/03/2023 11:05

GarfieldAteTheLasagne · 16/03/2023 10:33

You should have put a trigger warning on this.

God forbid that anyone browsing Mumsnet should have to spend ten seconds being aware of the existence of something nasty.

AdamRyan · 16/03/2023 11:04

BeachBlondey · 16/03/2023 10:44

Yes, very much my opinion.

Okay, about the power and control urge - do people really think that can be rehabilitated out of someone? I don't. It's an urge like anything else.

Power and control is at the root of a lot of sex based crimes, mainly committed by men:
Domestic abuse
Murder
Rape
Child abuse
Sexual assaults
Watching extreme degrading porn
Using prostitutes and other sex workers

I think it is very hard to change, I don't think paedophiles should be treated differently to any other "power and control" offenders.

Not sure what the answer is but the narrative that these (mainly) men "can't help it" definitely doesn't contribute positively.

LittleLegsKeepGoing · 16/03/2023 11:02

I agree that some criminals cannot be rehabilitated. Specifically those who have committed sexual assault against children (or been complicit in that). There's something terribly wrong with the wiring in someone's head if they commit these crimes and they should never be released into the general public to live private lives.

I'd be in favour of them always being remanded in some sort of supervised custody or chemically castrated. I know the latter is barbaric, but so are the crimes these people mostly men commit. Statistics prove they are highly likely to reoffend, so make it impossible for them to reoffend through whatever means necessary.

BeachBlondey · 16/03/2023 11:00

midgemadgemodge · 16/03/2023 10:58

People can control their sexual urges
We know this

Just look at how varied the rates of sexual assault are around the world

How do they compare? And is it related to the strength of punishment?

OP posts:
CoffeeCakeAndALattePlease · 16/03/2023 10:59

Some people can and do control their sexual urges. Whether offenders want to and are willing and able to work at this is on a case by case basis. Rehab works for some but not for all.

midgemadgemodge · 16/03/2023 10:58

People can control their sexual urges
We know this

Just look at how varied the rates of sexual assault are around the world

BeachBlondey · 16/03/2023 10:57

Punishing the Parole Board members is ridiculous

I disagree. How many parole board members would release a multiple rapist or child attacker, if they knew he would be housed next door? And yet they release very dangerous people, all the time, who they know will be walking amongst us, and we are none the wiser. It's an enormous gamble with the public's safety and they get t wrong so often.

OP posts:
StressedToTheMaxxx · 16/03/2023 10:53

Bunce1 · 16/03/2023 10:29

Medical castration is barbaric IMO.

So is being a victim of rape or childhood sexual abuse.

BeachBlondey · 16/03/2023 10:52

CoffeeCakeAndALattePlease · 16/03/2023 10:32

i thought that the point was not to stop the attraction but rather to stop the person acting on it. Understanding that it is wrong and harmful and therefore having the ability to control the urge. Developing strategies to stop themselves perpetrating.

But people can't control their sexual urges. We know this.

OP posts:
Snowontheblow · 16/03/2023 10:51

What's the alternative OP, whole life sentences for rape? It's hard enough getting a conviction as it is. And they "may as well" murder the victim if the sentence is the same.

GarfieldAteTheLasagne · 16/03/2023 10:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

A trump card? Don't put your assumed agenda onto me. I was simply explaining why I hadn't a full idea of the graphic nature of the thread. I'm not thread policing anyone. I found the content very triggering and upsetting having suffered child abuse and rape.

The pile on (insisting I should know the content of the thread) has just made me feel even worse, and now I'm crying so thanks for that.

You're the one not being nice. But you do you hun. Living up to the viper reputation. Don't bother replying.

ChocSaltyBalls · 16/03/2023 10:50

Bunce1 · 16/03/2023 10:29

Medical castration is barbaric IMO.

So is the sexual abuse of children. I know what I would prefer to happen in society out of the 2 options however.

AuntieMatter · 16/03/2023 10:49

Not all sexual offending is attraction based. It often isn't.

Sometimes rehabilitation is about people recognising their offending triggers and developing strategies to prevent them progressing to assaulting someone etc.

Some people are completely unable to be rehabilitated. Some people are. It is not an "all or nothing".

There are multiple factors involved in the success or not of the release of a serious offender. Punishing the Parole Board members is ridiculous.

Suzi888 · 16/03/2023 10:49

YANBU

There was one years ago, he admitted if he was released he would attack a child and rape them. It was an uncontrollable urge. Cary Jay Smith “I’ll do it again unless you cut off my penis and hands”.

Case closed. He’s one of many. Those that seek freedom will lie. Obviously.

ChocSaltyBalls · 16/03/2023 10:48

You can’t stop them having the attraction but surely they can be treated/educated so as not to act on it. They aren’t robots and are
human beings with agency in control of themselves and are choosing to act on the impulses they have. If this can’t be done then they should remain indefinitely in custody or be castrated, chemically or otherwise.

JarByTheDoor · 16/03/2023 10:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TheKeatingFive · 16/03/2023 10:46

Well, there clearly are individuals who are sexually attracted to children. I'm prepared to believe this is an innate thing, whether you want to call it an orientation or not.

So what should we do with those people if they cannot refrain from acting on those urges?

BeachBlondey · 16/03/2023 10:44

Feelinadequate23 · 16/03/2023 10:35

YANBU. A sexual offender will never be rehabilitated in my opinion and I also don’t think it’s worth the risk, even if some can be. The rights of innocent people should be placed above the rights of violent attackers.

Yes, very much my opinion.

Okay, about the power and control urge - do people really think that can be rehabilitated out of someone? I don't. It's an urge like anything else.

OP posts:
GarfieldAteTheLasagne · 16/03/2023 10:43

JarByTheDoor · 16/03/2023 10:40

Being autistic, it was obvious for me.

What is wrong with people. Ever heard of a spectrum? Now you're just being unnecessary.

Rosafiona · 16/03/2023 10:42

I think you've misunderstood what is meant by rehabilitation? It's to reframe how someone deals with feelings they can't help having. Putting behaviours, habits in place and learning how to deal with thoughts. I'm sure it won't work for everyone (even assuming they want it to) and potentially those it doesn't work for need to be restricted in some way for the rest of their lives to protect the public.

And to your point that everyone has to act out their sexual fantasies eventually because humans couldn't possibly be expected to have some self control, well that's not true at all. Plenty of people abstain for years, or even their whole lives, for a huge variety of reasons.

GarfieldAteTheLasagne · 16/03/2023 10:41

BaroldFromEastenders · 16/03/2023 10:39

It’s really clear from the thread title what this is about

Like I've already said I'm autistic so don't necessarily draw the same conclusions as most. But thanks again for making me feel stupid.

JarByTheDoor · 16/03/2023 10:40

GarfieldAteTheLasagne · 16/03/2023 10:37

Being autistic, no it wasn't obvious to me. But thanks for your input.

Being autistic, it was obvious for me.

Nimbostratus100 · 16/03/2023 10:39

BeachBlondey · 16/03/2023 10:27

Inspired by the Gary Glitter latest story.

Why as a society, can't we accept, that you cannot fundamentally change who someone is sexually attracted to?

For example - no amount of "rehabilitation" will stop paedophiles being attracted to children.

We know that conversion therapy does not work (barbaric!)

Furthermore, you can't read people mind's, and of course they will say that they feel rehabilitated, because they know that this is their key to being released.

Further still, what happens when you ban someone from indulging in their sexual fantasies for years on end? Surely, the amount of sexual frustration and desire will build and build and build.

If a rapist has not had sex with a woman for 10 years, when he is released from prison, isn't he far more likely to be sexually frustrated and thus more likely to attack quite quickly?

If a paedophile hasn't been around children for 10 years, surely the first time he is around children, his sexual urges will go in to overdrive, probably to far more dangerous levels than ever before, because he will have an appetite that has not been sated for decades.

I am a female heterosexual woman, and no amount of "rehabilitation" forced upon me, would make me stop wanting sex with men. Nor would it magically make me fancy women. But, if I was in prison for having sex with a man, of course, I would tell the parole board that I was cured. And I'm sure that having been celibate for 10 years, the first thing I would want to do upon release would be to have sex with a man.

I'm so sick of sex offenders being released, who very quickly go on to reoffend, resulting in some poor innocent person being attacked or killed. We are constantly risking the safety of the public, under the guise of people having been rehabilitated, despite us seeing evidence to the contrary all the time.

When released prisoners reoffend, I would like to see the members of that Parole board penalised, either with being fired from their jobs, or being given monetary fines.

I realise that a big issue is space in prison. We either build more prisons, or consider medical castration maybe? We cannot keep placing the public at risk.

fundemental misunderstanding of the motive behind rape, sexual attraction doesn't really come into it - it is a power thing

BaroldFromEastenders · 16/03/2023 10:39

GarfieldAteTheLasagne · 16/03/2023 10:33

You should have put a trigger warning on this.

It’s really clear from the thread title what this is about

Brieandme · 16/03/2023 10:38

I agree with @veganmayo Many of the offender's I've come across (through my work) - it's because of power, control and/or opportunity. Not because of some innate sexual attraction to children.