Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that "Rehabilitation" is a joke, because you can't change who someone is sexually attracted to!

188 replies

BeachBlondey · 16/03/2023 10:27

Inspired by the Gary Glitter latest story.

Why as a society, can't we accept, that you cannot fundamentally change who someone is sexually attracted to?

For example - no amount of "rehabilitation" will stop paedophiles being attracted to children.

We know that conversion therapy does not work (barbaric!)

Furthermore, you can't read people mind's, and of course they will say that they feel rehabilitated, because they know that this is their key to being released.

Further still, what happens when you ban someone from indulging in their sexual fantasies for years on end? Surely, the amount of sexual frustration and desire will build and build and build.

If a rapist has not had sex with a woman for 10 years, when he is released from prison, isn't he far more likely to be sexually frustrated and thus more likely to attack quite quickly?

If a paedophile hasn't been around children for 10 years, surely the first time he is around children, his sexual urges will go in to overdrive, probably to far more dangerous levels than ever before, because he will have an appetite that has not been sated for decades.

I am a female heterosexual woman, and no amount of "rehabilitation" forced upon me, would make me stop wanting sex with men. Nor would it magically make me fancy women. But, if I was in prison for having sex with a man, of course, I would tell the parole board that I was cured. And I'm sure that having been celibate for 10 years, the first thing I would want to do upon release would be to have sex with a man.

I'm so sick of sex offenders being released, who very quickly go on to reoffend, resulting in some poor innocent person being attacked or killed. We are constantly risking the safety of the public, under the guise of people having been rehabilitated, despite us seeing evidence to the contrary all the time.

When released prisoners reoffend, I would like to see the members of that Parole board penalised, either with being fired from their jobs, or being given monetary fines.

I realise that a big issue is space in prison. We either build more prisons, or consider medical castration maybe? We cannot keep placing the public at risk.

OP posts:
Annoyingwurringnoise · 16/03/2023 12:00

AdamRyan · 16/03/2023 11:28

Personally I think Glitter being recalled to prison shows the system works. I don't think we actually know what he did to be recalled. It could be a breach of very stringent licence conditions and nothing to do with children. (ie being out past a 6pm curfew, entirely fictional example)

It shows nothing of the sort. People know who Gary Glitter is, and people were furious that he’d been let out of prison. It was inevitable he’d be watched like a hawk and be sent back to prison in very short order.

I think all this shows, actually, is that paedophiles are overwhelmingly recidivist, in fact, I’d suggest that all will reoffend at some point in some way. If Gary Glitter couldn’t put a lid on it for as long as it took for the publicity to die down then all that tells me is there is pretty much nothing to be done with these people. They won’t stop. Imagine how quickly someone who didn’t have people watching would be back at it.

BeachBlondey · 16/03/2023 11:52

Gary Glitter is 78.

Often older men are released assuming they are so old, they no longer pose a real risk to society. Clearly not true!

OP posts:
FOJN · 16/03/2023 11:48

Bunce1 · 16/03/2023 10:29

Medical castration is barbaric IMO.

I'm genuinely interested in why you think this.

The drugs used for chemical castration are the same ones given to men with prostate cancer, women with endometriosis, women donating eggs and to suppress puberty in children.

There are unpleasant side effects but not incarcerating sex offenders or suppressing their sex drive arguable has far worse effects on the rest of society.

OrlandointheWilderness · 16/03/2023 11:35

AdamRyan · 16/03/2023 11:28

Personally I think Glitter being recalled to prison shows the system works. I don't think we actually know what he did to be recalled. It could be a breach of very stringent licence conditions and nothing to do with children. (ie being out past a 6pm curfew, entirely fictional example)

He tried to access the dark web.

ladykale · 16/03/2023 11:33

Feelinadequate23 · 16/03/2023 10:35

YANBU. A sexual offender will never be rehabilitated in my opinion and I also don’t think it’s worth the risk, even if some can be. The rights of innocent people should be placed above the rights of violent attackers.

They should have to:

  1. wear an electronic tag for life with GPS
  2. be unable to change their name
  3. have to report to a sex offenders board weekly try ensure their location is regularly monitored
  4. be subject to random and ad hoc inspections of their hard drives and mobile at home or mandatorily have to grant access at any time to IT team of a newly developed IT police body
  5. there should be a publicly searchable register identifying all sex offenders so they don't inadvertently get close up their neighbour's children without them realising
  6. Automatic life sentence for any related re-offending (including things like flashing etc)
  7. Have to get consent to travel & Gps Location could track to ensure the sick perverts weren't heading to places like Thailand to abuse children
  8. Their relatives should be put on notice of their crimes
  9. Longer sentences in the first place. Any form
of sexual abuse against children should get a minimum sentence of 30 years. My preference would be life without parole though.
JarByTheDoor · 16/03/2023 11:30

BeachBlondey · 16/03/2023 11:15

So on this basis, people who have committed barbaric crimes should never be released. Then all risk is mitigated.

I know everyone will say, there aren't enough prisons, but, if you stripped away parole boards, and didn't have to monitor offenders on the outside, didn't have any repeat offenders, and therefore no arrests and trials for these, how much money would that save? Enough to build a few more prisons, I would think. Also, Life meaning Life, might be more of a deterrent in the first place.

You could do that, but I guess it might cause other problems that would need solving (which I guess you might consider well worth the trouble, if it would keep the worst offenders locked away). As another poster pointed out, that doesn't leave those who have committed barbaric crimes much disincentive for committing even more barbaric crimes, especially when they think it might help them get away with it. And I don't know how much prison behaviour is affected by the prospect of potentially getting parole. I don't have enough knowledge of the area to argue either way about prison terms — I just wanted to comment on the reasons that I think it wouldn't help matters, and might cause difficulties, if we were to punish parole board members who made decisions that turned out to be bad.

Cleargreysky · 16/03/2023 11:30

DappledOliveGroves · 16/03/2023 11:06

I know the official line is that rape is about power and control, but whether this is the case for all rapists is questionable. I do think some men have an overwhelming obsession with sex and getting off, and will go to whatever ends to do so, and that it's about sex rather than power.

I do also believe that some men are sexually attracted only to children. I doubt people choose their sexual proclivities and fetishes - they seem somewhat innate. And I do not believe that any kind of rehabilitation will stop people from acting on their sexual desire - the reoffending rate shows this.

Consequently, what are the options? Arguably, mandatory chemical (or physical) castration. Nothing else seems to work. One question - assuming someone doesn't want to be sexually attracted to children - could they request chemical or physical castration? Can one consent to it? I have no idea....

I think I pretty much agree with this.

I’ve seen research, a long time ago now, with young sexual offenders ( teenage boys) which concluded it was about sex for them.

Also saying, ‘it’s about power not sex’ assumes these two things are separate whereas for some people sex and power/ control are linked. See pretty much all mainstream porn. You can have power and control over someone without having sex with them, after all. If you are exercising control through sex it’s because the two are linked to the offender ( or S&M fan, or porn fan) in a way they find sexually arousing.

We could try to combat this of course by seeking to create an actively anti-porn culture. In the same way people talk about being actively anti-racist.

I also think it’s likely to be true that some paedophiles have a genuine sexual attraction to children ( which is not to say it’s an orientation like being heterosexual/ homosexual as these adults form life long emotional relationships based on the personality of their partner as well as their sex, whereas paedophiles attraction is time limited to the age of the child). I also think some develop attractions due to abuse or porn.

I also think chemical castration is a legitimate means to an end.

ancientgran · 16/03/2023 11:29

BeachBlondey · 16/03/2023 10:52

But people can't control their sexual urges. We know this.

Surely people control their sexual urges all the time. Lots of people might lust after someone but they don't all go out raping them.

AdamRyan · 16/03/2023 11:28

Personally I think Glitter being recalled to prison shows the system works. I don't think we actually know what he did to be recalled. It could be a breach of very stringent licence conditions and nothing to do with children. (ie being out past a 6pm curfew, entirely fictional example)

Annoyingwurringnoise · 16/03/2023 11:27

I’d agree that paedophiles can’t be rehabilitated. They’ve acted on their deviance, and that for me has crossed a boundary that can’t then ever be relied upon again. Even if they don’t directly abuse again themselves, they’ll just watch somebody else doing it on the Internet.

YABU for thinking about it like a sexual orientation though. Being a paedophile is not a sexual orientation, it’s a paraphilia. I am sexually attracted to women, members of the female sex, but never child members of the female sex. Paedophiles have a sexual orientation, they will either be hetro, bi or homo sexual, but their paraphilia is for child members of the sex they are attracted to. Do not confuse the two things. The gay community have had enough of paedophiles trying to align themselves with us, and the general public treating us as deviant. They are not the same, and it does harm to us when people speak as if they are.

Dotjones · 16/03/2023 11:26

I fundamentally disagree that just because someone is attracted to a certain group (men/women/boys/girls/animals) they are automatically unable to control their urges. Think about it, if this were the case, every straight man would be raping women, every gay man raping men. That's not what happens in the real world - most people can control their urges because they understand that it would be outrageous to do otherwise.

The potential argument that most men don't rape women because there are other legal ways to get sex (online dating, relationships, paying for an escort) doesn't wash. It's perfectly possible for a person not getting any sex of their preferred kind at all to go through life without resorting to criminal behaviour. Before homosexuality was legalised and accepted it wasn't uncommon for a gay man to suppress their urges and live out their life married to a woman and having children with her.

The same logic must apply to those attracted to children and animals too. The crime isn't being attracted to them, the crime is grooming/molesting/raping them or breaching the terms of release for a previous conviction. Therefore it doesn't automatically follow that a convicted paedophile can't be rehabilitated in the sense that they can't be brought to understand that they cannot act on their urges.

They can't be "converted" just as a homosexual cannot be converted to being straight. But they decide not to give in to their urges if they choose to do so.

Personally I'd just bring back public hanging for all criminals where a crime is deliberate and causes obvious permanent harm to the victim, but apparently that's not the woke thing to do these days.

ancientgran · 16/03/2023 11:26

CoffeeCakeAndALattePlease · 16/03/2023 10:32

i thought that the point was not to stop the attraction but rather to stop the person acting on it. Understanding that it is wrong and harmful and therefore having the ability to control the urge. Developing strategies to stop themselves perpetrating.

Yes I agree with you. There's lots of stuff we might feel like doing if we don't know it is wrong or haven't learned that we must control that urge.

AdamRyan · 16/03/2023 11:25

TheKeatingFive · 16/03/2023 11:08

I don't think paedophiles should be treated differently to any other "power and control" offenders.

What is an appropriate course of action in your eyes?

Im conscious of how difficult it is to convict rapists, for example.

Jail. Therapy. Probation with strict conditions. Lifelong risk management.

I'd like to see the type of management paedophiles currently recieve extended to other "power and control" offenders. But that's a long way off seeing as we currently only manage to convict a miniscule number of rapists.

Jonei · 16/03/2023 11:22

CoffeeCakeAndALattePlease · 16/03/2023 10:32

i thought that the point was not to stop the attraction but rather to stop the person acting on it. Understanding that it is wrong and harmful and therefore having the ability to control the urge. Developing strategies to stop themselves perpetrating.

I would think so certainly.

Bookworm20 · 16/03/2023 11:19

Snowontheblow · 16/03/2023 10:51

What's the alternative OP, whole life sentences for rape? It's hard enough getting a conviction as it is. And they "may as well" murder the victim if the sentence is the same.

Yeah. You realise alot of rape victims suffer immeasurably for years and a number go on to commit suicide? So yeah, lets make sure they leave their victoms alive and as a reward get 6 months community service and a slap on the wrist and leave the victim to feel so helpless they end their own life.

Personally, if anyone commits rape and their victim then takes their own life they should then be tried for murder.

BeachBlondey · 16/03/2023 11:17

Bookworm20 · 16/03/2023 11:13

Protecting children and not the offender?

Anyone who can hurt a child in that way, even once, is beyond rehabilitation. There is something fundamentally wrong with them that cannot be cured by a stint in jail. It wasn't an 'accidental mistake'. A thief, drug user for example does have hope of being rehabiliated. A person who would do that to a child? Never.

They ruined that childs life. So the alternative to 'rehabilitation'. Keep them locked up for life or better yet end their life. I have no sympathy for anyone who can do that to a child. Zero. Whatever their reason and however sorry they appear to be. What is the actual point of them?

My view may be very controversial, but even medical castration is not enough. if someone sexually abuses a child, they should be physically castrated and left to bleed to death. But we can't do that, so we 'rehabilitate them' and then let them out to do it again. And ruin another innocent childs life. Because 99% of them, do do it again.

Whatever the alternative, letting them out to reoffend is NOT a solution.

👏

OP posts:
BeachBlondey · 16/03/2023 11:15

JarByTheDoor · 16/03/2023 11:08

It's extremely difficult to predict an individual's behaviour, even for experts — you can see that in the real struggle psychiatry has had trying to determine who might be at risk of suicide. In this study: jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2788456 which looked at various techniques including machine learning on self report, the study authors said, "Clinicians’ assessment alone was little better than chance at predicting suicide attempts".

So you'd expect parole boards to unfortunately release people who go on to offend quite frequently, unless the authorities massively raised the threshold for when someone should be released. As far as I'm aware that's not up to parole board members to decide, so I suppose they just have to try and make these tough guesses as best they can according to the guidelines they have to work with. If you implemented punishment of parole board members for decisions that turned out badly, I would've thought you'd struggle to recruit for those roles, because a lot of these people are highly-paid professionals who could easily get other work.

So on this basis, people who have committed barbaric crimes should never be released. Then all risk is mitigated.

I know everyone will say, there aren't enough prisons, but, if you stripped away parole boards, and didn't have to monitor offenders on the outside, didn't have any repeat offenders, and therefore no arrests and trials for these, how much money would that save? Enough to build a few more prisons, I would think. Also, Life meaning Life, might be more of a deterrent in the first place.

OP posts:
Bookworm20 · 16/03/2023 11:13

Bunce1 · 16/03/2023 10:28

What’s the alternative?

Protecting children and not the offender?

Anyone who can hurt a child in that way, even once, is beyond rehabilitation. There is something fundamentally wrong with them that cannot be cured by a stint in jail. It wasn't an 'accidental mistake'. A thief, drug user for example does have hope of being rehabiliated. A person who would do that to a child? Never.

They ruined that childs life. So the alternative to 'rehabilitation'. Keep them locked up for life or better yet end their life. I have no sympathy for anyone who can do that to a child. Zero. Whatever their reason and however sorry they appear to be. What is the actual point of them?

My view may be very controversial, but even medical castration is not enough. if someone sexually abuses a child, they should be physically castrated and left to bleed to death. But we can't do that, so we 'rehabilitate them' and then let them out to do it again. And ruin another innocent childs life. Because 99% of them, do do it again.

Whatever the alternative, letting them out to reoffend is NOT a solution.

ItsShiela · 16/03/2023 11:12

@GarfieldAteTheLasagne FlowersCake So sorry for what happened to you.

GandhiDeclaredWarOnYou · 16/03/2023 11:11

BeachBlondey · 16/03/2023 10:52

But people can't control their sexual urges. We know this.

Absolute nonsense. Rehabilitation is about changing their behaviours, not who they are attracted to.

ItsShiela · 16/03/2023 11:11

furryfrontbottom · 16/03/2023 11:05

God forbid that anyone browsing Mumsnet should have to spend ten seconds being aware of the existence of something nasty.

That poster said they were autistic and a victim of child abuse, @furryfrontbottom .

Can people on here stop bullying Garfield? It's enough now already.

JarByTheDoor · 16/03/2023 11:08

BeachBlondey · 16/03/2023 10:57

Punishing the Parole Board members is ridiculous

I disagree. How many parole board members would release a multiple rapist or child attacker, if they knew he would be housed next door? And yet they release very dangerous people, all the time, who they know will be walking amongst us, and we are none the wiser. It's an enormous gamble with the public's safety and they get t wrong so often.

It's extremely difficult to predict an individual's behaviour, even for experts — you can see that in the real struggle psychiatry has had trying to determine who might be at risk of suicide. In this study: jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2788456 which looked at various techniques including machine learning on self report, the study authors said, "Clinicians’ assessment alone was little better than chance at predicting suicide attempts".

So you'd expect parole boards to unfortunately release people who go on to offend quite frequently, unless the authorities massively raised the threshold for when someone should be released. As far as I'm aware that's not up to parole board members to decide, so I suppose they just have to try and make these tough guesses as best they can according to the guidelines they have to work with. If you implemented punishment of parole board members for decisions that turned out badly, I would've thought you'd struggle to recruit for those roles, because a lot of these people are highly-paid professionals who could easily get other work.

YukoandHiro · 16/03/2023 11:08

"But people can't control their sexual urges. We know this."

Erm, yes they can - otherwise every straight man would be a rapist.

Back to the until question: what's the answer? Other than punishment and prevention (including teaching children very early about red flag behaviour and how to report it to trusted adults), what alternative is there?

What do you do about people brought up in a cycle of intergenerational abuse? Not even try to rehabilitate despite the fact that they are damaged child victim as well as adult perpetrator?

TheKeatingFive · 16/03/2023 11:08

I don't think paedophiles should be treated differently to any other "power and control" offenders.

What is an appropriate course of action in your eyes?

Im conscious of how difficult it is to convict rapists, for example.

DappledOliveGroves · 16/03/2023 11:06

I know the official line is that rape is about power and control, but whether this is the case for all rapists is questionable. I do think some men have an overwhelming obsession with sex and getting off, and will go to whatever ends to do so, and that it's about sex rather than power.

I do also believe that some men are sexually attracted only to children. I doubt people choose their sexual proclivities and fetishes - they seem somewhat innate. And I do not believe that any kind of rehabilitation will stop people from acting on their sexual desire - the reoffending rate shows this.

Consequently, what are the options? Arguably, mandatory chemical (or physical) castration. Nothing else seems to work. One question - assuming someone doesn't want to be sexually attracted to children - could they request chemical or physical castration? Can one consent to it? I have no idea....