Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that "Rehabilitation" is a joke, because you can't change who someone is sexually attracted to!

188 replies

BeachBlondey · 16/03/2023 10:27

Inspired by the Gary Glitter latest story.

Why as a society, can't we accept, that you cannot fundamentally change who someone is sexually attracted to?

For example - no amount of "rehabilitation" will stop paedophiles being attracted to children.

We know that conversion therapy does not work (barbaric!)

Furthermore, you can't read people mind's, and of course they will say that they feel rehabilitated, because they know that this is their key to being released.

Further still, what happens when you ban someone from indulging in their sexual fantasies for years on end? Surely, the amount of sexual frustration and desire will build and build and build.

If a rapist has not had sex with a woman for 10 years, when he is released from prison, isn't he far more likely to be sexually frustrated and thus more likely to attack quite quickly?

If a paedophile hasn't been around children for 10 years, surely the first time he is around children, his sexual urges will go in to overdrive, probably to far more dangerous levels than ever before, because he will have an appetite that has not been sated for decades.

I am a female heterosexual woman, and no amount of "rehabilitation" forced upon me, would make me stop wanting sex with men. Nor would it magically make me fancy women. But, if I was in prison for having sex with a man, of course, I would tell the parole board that I was cured. And I'm sure that having been celibate for 10 years, the first thing I would want to do upon release would be to have sex with a man.

I'm so sick of sex offenders being released, who very quickly go on to reoffend, resulting in some poor innocent person being attacked or killed. We are constantly risking the safety of the public, under the guise of people having been rehabilitated, despite us seeing evidence to the contrary all the time.

When released prisoners reoffend, I would like to see the members of that Parole board penalised, either with being fired from their jobs, or being given monetary fines.

I realise that a big issue is space in prison. We either build more prisons, or consider medical castration maybe? We cannot keep placing the public at risk.

OP posts:
Naunet · 16/03/2023 13:03

Bunce1 · 16/03/2023 13:00

Jesus.

What’s with MN these days?

Why do you think it’s a binary “top trumps” type thing??? How totally unthinking.

Because if you think medically castrating a child rapist is barbaric, then obviously there is a top trumps at play as you’re leaving him capable of raping another child. I was abused as a child by my father, so yes, this subject does upset me because it’s something you NEVER fully recover from.

Lockheart · 16/03/2023 13:03

Naunet · 16/03/2023 13:01

All excuses. Girls are sexually abused far more frequently and don’t go on to sexually abuse children in the numbers men do, and anyway, how do you know these men weren’t lying for sympathy? There is no excuse and I have zero sympathy for them.

So when women claim they were sexually abused, we must believe them. When men claim they were sexually abused, they are lying. Alright then..

Lockheart · 16/03/2023 13:02

Naunet · 16/03/2023 12:58

More so than raping a child?

We don't have the "eye-for-an-eye" style of justice in the UK. People do many barbaric and awful things, but our laws punish them humanely.

Naunet · 16/03/2023 13:01

newtb · 16/03/2023 12:53

There was a very interesting programme in prison in either the late 70s or early 80s. It was effective, but sadly discontinued due to lack of funds.
The men concerned were hard violent sex offenders. What was found in each case, was that each and every one of these men had been sexually abused as a child. The abuse they'd suffered had been suppressed, normalised and internalised and, ultimately, denied.
Only when it was brought to the surface over a long period was their suffering treated and they no longer posed any threat.

Fwiw, I was seriously sexually abused as a child, to the extent of being very painfully vaginally penetrated before I could talk. It was my late mother and her brother acting together. She also procured her sister who was sent by her mother to masturbate the manager of the football club over the road. She was so scared she was like her mother/sister she never had children. The thing that saved me was that I suppressed all memories of this very early abusé until I was 45, the rest I always remembered.

My late mil was a victim of incest by her brother, as a little boy my xh had cystitis and she rubbed his penis better. WTF! It's possible that he, in his turn, touched dd inappropriately.

I don't think castration would work. What would happen next? Cutting off hands? Tongues? Stopping leering ? It's a pernicious problem and, sadly, I can't see a solution, except perhaps the use of therapeutic programmes like the one discontinued over 40 years ago. We've had Childline since then, but sod all else has changed.

All excuses. Girls are sexually abused far more frequently and don’t go on to sexually abuse children in the numbers men do, and anyway, how do you know these men weren’t lying for sympathy? There is no excuse and I have zero sympathy for them.

Laptopneeded · 16/03/2023 13:01

Castration is offered in the USA in some states

Bunce1 · 16/03/2023 13:00

Naunet · 16/03/2023 12:58

More so than raping a child?

Jesus.

What’s with MN these days?

Why do you think it’s a binary “top trumps” type thing??? How totally unthinking.

latetothefisting · 16/03/2023 13:00

CoffeeCakeAndALattePlease · 16/03/2023 10:32

i thought that the point was not to stop the attraction but rather to stop the person acting on it. Understanding that it is wrong and harmful and therefore having the ability to control the urge. Developing strategies to stop themselves perpetrating.

Exactly this! I think you've missed something key somewhere OP.

Nobody releases rapists with the expectation that they will never have sex ever again, but with the hope that given their rehabilitation they will only have consensual sex in the future.

Pedophiles are slightly different in that obviously they are released with the expectation that they will never have sex with under age children (or consume or make CSA porn).

Some might be helped with therapy to the extent that it is just one part of their sexuality and they can ignore it and get fulfilment (sexual or otherwise) elsewhere. Others might very well continue to be attracted to underage children for the rest of their lives but (as grim as it is to think about) if they confine this solely to masturbatory fantasies or role play with adult consenting women, it's not a crime and they could be safe to be within the community.

If you never released anyone from prison because you couldn't be sure they wouldn't reoffend, you'd never release anyone from prison, ever, because you can never be 100% sure.

It's not as if they just ask the prisoners politely and take their answers at face value, it's an in depth assessment with the input of trained professionals!

safetyfreak · 16/03/2023 13:00

I believe there are peaodphiles who do not act on their attraction to children...however, the ones that do should be chemically castrated. I am surprised we dont do this?

Naunet · 16/03/2023 12:58

Bunce1 · 16/03/2023 10:29

Medical castration is barbaric IMO.

More so than raping a child?

Nimbostratus100 · 16/03/2023 12:57

Annoyingwurringnoise · 16/03/2023 12:49

The ones who don’t offend, or more likely just don’t get caught, will never come to the authorities notice. The ones who do get caught have done it once, ant least, and are overwhelmingly likely to do it again, and the safety of children comes before being nice to paedophiles.

there’s a really easy way to avoid the consequences of being caught messing with kids or watching others mess with kids, and that’s not to fucking do it. Those who get caught doing it should get no better than they deserve.

why is it more likely that the ones without records have not been caught, rather than have never offended? I think you are being very judgemental

we are not in control of our sexual feelings, only of our behaviour

many paedophiles never offend

newtb · 16/03/2023 12:53

There was a very interesting programme in prison in either the late 70s or early 80s. It was effective, but sadly discontinued due to lack of funds.
The men concerned were hard violent sex offenders. What was found in each case, was that each and every one of these men had been sexually abused as a child. The abuse they'd suffered had been suppressed, normalised and internalised and, ultimately, denied.
Only when it was brought to the surface over a long period was their suffering treated and they no longer posed any threat.

Fwiw, I was seriously sexually abused as a child, to the extent of being very painfully vaginally penetrated before I could talk. It was my late mother and her brother acting together. She also procured her sister who was sent by her mother to masturbate the manager of the football club over the road. She was so scared she was like her mother/sister she never had children. The thing that saved me was that I suppressed all memories of this very early abusé until I was 45, the rest I always remembered.

My late mil was a victim of incest by her brother, as a little boy my xh had cystitis and she rubbed his penis better. WTF! It's possible that he, in his turn, touched dd inappropriately.

I don't think castration would work. What would happen next? Cutting off hands? Tongues? Stopping leering ? It's a pernicious problem and, sadly, I can't see a solution, except perhaps the use of therapeutic programmes like the one discontinued over 40 years ago. We've had Childline since then, but sod all else has changed.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 16/03/2023 12:52

You might not be able to change it, but you can choose not to act on it, being a human and in control of your actions and your choices.

Lockheart · 16/03/2023 12:49

TheKeatingFive · 16/03/2023 12:21

We don't have the faintest notion how many are out there with pedophilic attraction they've never acted on.

No we don't. It's been suggested that the between 1% and 5% of men may at least have tendencies towards it, if not a full-blown disorder.

5% would be incredibly high if true. That's 1 in 20.

I suspect there are quite large numbers of boys and men out there with the paraphilia who have never acted on it. It's impossible to know for sure however.

Annoyingwurringnoise · 16/03/2023 12:49

Nimbostratus100 · 16/03/2023 12:19

It isn't true that all paedophiles will reoffend

It isn't even true that all paedophiles will offend in the first place

The ones who don’t offend, or more likely just don’t get caught, will never come to the authorities notice. The ones who do get caught have done it once, ant least, and are overwhelmingly likely to do it again, and the safety of children comes before being nice to paedophiles.

there’s a really easy way to avoid the consequences of being caught messing with kids or watching others mess with kids, and that’s not to fucking do it. Those who get caught doing it should get no better than they deserve.

Bunce1 · 16/03/2023 12:48

Greenfairydust · 16/03/2023 12:33

@Bunce1

''Medical castration is barbaric IMO.''

Because you think someone having a functioning dick/libido is more important than the welfare of kids and their right not be abused by perverts?

There is no rehabilitation possible for paedophiles. They will always be a threat to children.

I think you need to have a serious look at your values...

Yep- ok because if I say medical castration is barbaric then it follows that I support CSA.

Ridiculous and flawed thinking. But critical thinking skills seem to be lacking, so a nuanced discussion seems wasted.

In the USA there is a program where women were offered sterilisation instead of a jail sentence for drug offences and where their children were taken into care. So jail or loose your ability to have a baby. It is a blunt and brutal instrument to “solve” a complex problem. Crime reduction was negligible. Women’s rehabilitation- nope juts trauma from having been sterilised and having done so under the guise of a choice at a time of extreme vulnerability.

User678945 · 16/03/2023 12:47

YABVU for saying that being a paedophile/rapist is comparable to being born gay.

YANBU for thinking that rehabilitation might not be possible for sex offenders, and worrying about them being released back into society again.

Lockheart · 16/03/2023 12:42

BeachBlondey · 16/03/2023 12:20

Given that they don't come with an identifying tattoo on their forehead, as to which category they will end up in, why should the public be put at risk?

For the same reason we don't lock everyone up who has anger issues, or paranoid schizophrenia, or one of many mental illnesses, on the basis that they might assault or kill someone in future.

The law deals with what you've done. Not thought crimes or potential future crimes.

Paedophilia often starts manifesting at puberty (it's hard to know what the root cause is or whether this is true for everyone, since it's complex and not well studied). Do you really think parents will be offering up their 10, 11, 12 year old boys to be imprisoned because they might be a risk one day?

Greenfairydust · 16/03/2023 12:33

@Bunce1

''Medical castration is barbaric IMO.''

Because you think someone having a functioning dick/libido is more important than the welfare of kids and their right not be abused by perverts?

There is no rehabilitation possible for paedophiles. They will always be a threat to children.

I think you need to have a serious look at your values...

Sunriseinwonderland · 16/03/2023 12:24

I worked with hardcore paedophiles for 7 years in the prison service. I personally do not believe that they can be rehabilitated.

TheKeatingFive · 16/03/2023 12:21

We don't have the faintest notion how many are out there with pedophilic attraction they've never acted on.

BeachBlondey · 16/03/2023 12:20

Nimbostratus100 · 16/03/2023 12:19

It isn't true that all paedophiles will reoffend

It isn't even true that all paedophiles will offend in the first place

Given that they don't come with an identifying tattoo on their forehead, as to which category they will end up in, why should the public be put at risk?

OP posts:
Nimbostratus100 · 16/03/2023 12:19

Annoyingwurringnoise · 16/03/2023 12:00

It shows nothing of the sort. People know who Gary Glitter is, and people were furious that he’d been let out of prison. It was inevitable he’d be watched like a hawk and be sent back to prison in very short order.

I think all this shows, actually, is that paedophiles are overwhelmingly recidivist, in fact, I’d suggest that all will reoffend at some point in some way. If Gary Glitter couldn’t put a lid on it for as long as it took for the publicity to die down then all that tells me is there is pretty much nothing to be done with these people. They won’t stop. Imagine how quickly someone who didn’t have people watching would be back at it.

It isn't true that all paedophiles will reoffend

It isn't even true that all paedophiles will offend in the first place

Nimbostratus100 · 16/03/2023 12:18

LakeTiticaca · 16/03/2023 12:02

Chemical castration.

which increases violence and risk...

Annoyingwurringnoise · 16/03/2023 12:10

I personally think physical castration, with a rusty bread knife and no anaesthetic, plus eyes put out and hands chopped off. If they don’t want that they can be put down..

LakeTiticaca · 16/03/2023 12:02

Chemical castration.