Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To pay DD's rent?

57 replies

Mastmw7g · 16/03/2023 02:58

First of all, I'm in the Bay Area of the States. DD is graduating university and was expecting to come home. We've talked about moving for a long time, but now it's actually happening. I did make the offer for her to move with us, but she wants to stay.

I want to cosign a lease for her to rent a room and give her the rent money for that for a year. Does that sound reasonable? She won't have use of the family car anymore and she has some student loans to pay on. I worry that I'm not doing enough, and setting her up for failure.

OP posts:
ArdeteiMasazxu · 16/03/2023 06:06

I don't know how you can downgrade from renting a room.

there's always a smaller room, in a nastier and more dangerous part of town, with less pleasant sharers and worse communal facilities. but who knows - a lot of this is going to depend on expected career progression for new practitioners of her chosen career. in some careers you expect to earn at very low levels for the first 3-5 years and then there's a good chance of getting promotions that release much higher earning potential. In other careers, progression can take a big leap after a relatively short period for initial experience, but may then stagnate for a while. does your DD have specific expectations for what her employment progression is likely to be?

if you had stayed put and she was living with you after graduation, do you think she would have been ready to move out after only a year? Living with parents for 3-5 years isn't at all uncommon.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 16/03/2023 06:00

Offer assistance for a year, with a view to having a discussion whether she needs further assistance or not. That way she knows she has your help for a year, and if she's stuck for longer she can have a discussion with you about her finances and what further assistance she needs.

If at that point she doesn't want to share details of her finances then she will have to stand on her own two feet.

Mastmw7g · 16/03/2023 05:48

SofiaAmes · 16/03/2023 05:38

Has she been living in the dorms all this time. If so, she will definitely need some advice/help on finding a room without being scammed. Happy to help. We should put our dd's in touch. If she is in SF then she won't need (or want) a car. Where is the job?

Yes, she's been in the dorms. That's a good tip about scams. I'm on the parent FB page for Santa Cruz and have read some horror stories. The job is in Mountainview, but it's remote, so she doesn't need to live near Mountainview. DH keeps talking about how he thinks she should stay in Santa Cruz and live with friends instead of renting from strangers.

OP posts:
SofiaAmes · 16/03/2023 05:38

Has she been living in the dorms all this time. If so, she will definitely need some advice/help on finding a room without being scammed. Happy to help. We should put our dd's in touch. If she is in SF then she won't need (or want) a car. Where is the job?

Mastmw7g · 16/03/2023 05:37

@ArdeteiMasazxu I'll think about that. I hadn't thought about her needing help past a year before making this post. I don't know how you can downgrade from renting a room. I'd hate to see what that looks like.

OP posts:
Frenchfancy · 16/03/2023 05:34

I think paying her rent is a generous thing to do, but remember that she is an adult. You provide her with the safety net but she needs to learn to fly on her own.

I would transfer the money to her and let her pay the rent. That way she is in control. She is not a child.

Mastmw7g · 16/03/2023 05:25

@isthisallnormal Oh, thank you! I felt so nervous telling her yesterday that she can't come home in three months, but she took it really well. She's a good person.

OP posts:
Mastmw7g · 16/03/2023 05:19

Coffeecoffeeinmytummy · 16/03/2023 04:59

If anything you’re being too generous. She’s an adult, she needs to live in the real world where things cost money and you have to work for what you have. It’s kind of you to offer to pay rent for a year but not necessary. She already has options, she can either stay in the Bay Area and sort herself out with a job/apartment etc or she can move back to live with you. Also why are you arranging an internship for her? Your post makes her sound about 15 whereas she must actually be 22+? Let her stand on her own two feet and don’t organise everything for her. It won’t help her in the long run.

I know. It's hard not to do everything I can to help. I even was looking up listings for rooms and dh told me to stop and let her do that.

OP posts:
ArdeteiMasazxu · 16/03/2023 05:15

my parents moved, during my university years, far away from where we had all previously been living. it was never really practical for me to live with them during the early years of my career when I was earning peanuts. My parents didn't tie their contribution to a specific thing like rent but they gave me a modest allowance which was enough to make ends meet while I needed it, and after a few years when I was well-paid enough to manage my outgoings solo I told them I was ok now and the allowance could stop.

My advice would be that ir would be better to offer a lower level of support over a longer term. paying the full rent is lovely but what happens after a year? what's the real probability that only a year after graduation she'll have employment that is well-paid enough for total independence? If you offer to pay 60% of her rent in year 1, 40% in year 2 and 20% in years 3&4 that gives her a more realistic chance of targeting her earning progression.

otherwise, if you subsidise more generously over a shorter time, she will probably have to significantly downgrade where she lives after the year is up, in order to rent what she can afford, and that will be miserable.

Mastmw7g · 16/03/2023 05:12

@Mummyoflittledragon His was a unique situation because his parents were in Germany. I guess this a unique situation, too. Who says three months before graduation "I know you were planning on moving home, but you can't stay here"?

OP posts:
isthisallnormal · 16/03/2023 05:09

was a little ashamed to admit we were helping her get her first professional job through a friend. Someone might say we're not letting her be an adult.

It's so tough out there starting out trying to earn enough to live. Please don't feel ashamed! Your helping your daughter get established, it is brilliant that you are able to help.

Mastmw7g · 16/03/2023 05:07

@SofiaAmes My DD is at UCSC, too! She's a AGPM major (Art and Design: Games & Playable Media).

We're on the peninsula in San Mateo. She would like to stay on the peninsula, but avoid Daly City, Half Moon Bay, and Pacifica.

She'll be covered by insurance!

OP posts:
SofiaAmes · 16/03/2023 05:05

My parents subsidized my New York City rent for several years after I graduated from undergraduate and was working full time. That didn't stop me from getting a full time job and my MBA full time at night at the same time. And going on to be completely financially independent after that. Only you know what best motivates your dd.

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/03/2023 05:02

Mastmw7g · 16/03/2023 04:53

@Mummyoflittledragon I wanted to put an end date on it because DH's parents paid his rent after he graduated and didn't put an end date on it and he took advantage and was pickier about getting a job than he would have been otherwise.

Yes, I get that the aim is for your dd to get a well paid job. It’s going to be more play it by ear I suppose. I’m imagining your dh could have gone back to his home town and stayed with his family until earning enough to move out. I’d say there’s a fundamental difference there to recognise.

SofiaAmes · 16/03/2023 05:01

Where in the Bay Area? My dd is at university at UCSC and my ds lives in Oakland and I'm paying rent/support for both. If you are paying rent (and covering health insurance), then your dd should totally be able to manage on a job paying $20 an hour and if she doesn't think it's enough (because she has expensive tastes), then she should get a second job. The car is the hard part...if she can manage without one, that would be better as cars are expensive to run and more importantly to insure. I would definitely plan on paying the rent directly if you are going to co-sign as if your dd messes it up, that goes on your credit record. Also don't forget about the cost of utilities and internet which can add several hundred dollars a month to the rent. Feel free to PM me if you need some more specific advice....

Mastmw7g · 16/03/2023 05:00

@therearesomenastypeoplearound That's a good tip.

OP posts:
Coffeecoffeeinmytummy · 16/03/2023 04:59

If anything you’re being too generous. She’s an adult, she needs to live in the real world where things cost money and you have to work for what you have. It’s kind of you to offer to pay rent for a year but not necessary. She already has options, she can either stay in the Bay Area and sort herself out with a job/apartment etc or she can move back to live with you. Also why are you arranging an internship for her? Your post makes her sound about 15 whereas she must actually be 22+? Let her stand on her own two feet and don’t organise everything for her. It won’t help her in the long run.

Mastmw7g · 16/03/2023 04:59

@NumberTheory Oh, you're so kind! I was a little ashamed to admit we were helping her get her first professional job through a friend. Someone might say we're not letting her be an adult.

She's definitely used to sharing housing! She lives with four other students right now. It will be a luxury to have her own room.

OP posts:
therearesomenastypeoplearound · 16/03/2023 04:54

Personally I'd set up a monthly automatic transfer to the person who is renting out the room.

Don't pay it all up front in case your DD is unhappy there and wants to leave.

christmascrazylady · 16/03/2023 04:54

I think it's more than enough and to be honest the only way you could set her up to fail is by continuing to payroll her in life. You are moving she wants to stay she gets a job and supports herself as most adults do

Mastmw7g · 16/03/2023 04:53

@Mummyoflittledragon I wanted to put an end date on it because DH's parents paid his rent after he graduated and didn't put an end date on it and he took advantage and was pickier about getting a job than he would have been otherwise.

OP posts:
chazabella · 16/03/2023 04:53

I would pay her rent directly so she can t be tempted to dip into it when a bill crops up (I know how tempting it is from experience) making her pay the rest of the bills is the best option as it will encourage her to work hard and also knows how much life costs. I wish I had a parent who did this for me at her age. Life is hard but every struggle iv had I don't regret because it's made me work harder.

NumberTheory · 16/03/2023 04:52

24/hr should be enough to get by if she's prepared to share with roommates. And that will be a starting salary so plenty of room for growth. If she gets the job I would encourage her to save as much of your "gift" rent as she can to help out in fallow times. It's not the same getting by without your family around but you're offering her a safety net just in case and so many people in the Bay Area come here in just that fashion and thrive.

Mastmw7g · 16/03/2023 04:48

@therearesomenastypeoplearound Do you think I should pay her rent directly to the person renting her a room, or give her the money so she gets used to paying the rental amount?

OP posts:
Mastmw7g · 16/03/2023 04:46

@Summer2424 Everyone is being so nice! I was feeling so guilty that she thought she had a home to go to where she wouldn't have to pay for groceries and utilities, and had use of a car.

OP posts: