Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for worrying about the removal of WCA for benefits?

71 replies

XenoBitch · 15/03/2023 22:19

According the Budget today, the Work Capability Assessments are being scrapped.
Initially, it sounds good. When you read into it, the only people who will be found unfit for work are also those who are disabled. To claim the 'health element' of UC (which would be the current LCW/LCWRA groups), you will need to also be in receipt of PIP.
Anyone who has tried to apply for PIP knows what a gruelling and undignified process it is. Many try, and give up. Many don't bother at all.
The weird thing here is that you can claim PIP, but also work. So how can PIP be the gateway benefit to claiming out of work benefits? It makes zero sense.
I am wondering what the various disability/mental health charities will make of this in the coming days.

For those of us who are in the ESA support group, or UC LCWRA, and not on PIP, this is a worrying time. With Hunt also saying there will be tougher sanctions on benefit claimants, the new measures will be causing a huge amount of stress.

OP posts:
RubyGrape · 16/03/2023 14:42

I used to get DLA years ago and when I was awarded it, it meant my Income Support increased significantly as I got several disability premiums on top. This system sounds a bit similar. For those who do get PIP (apparently 74% of UC LCWRA or support group ESA get PIP as well) it will be easier as they'll get the health element automatically and not have to worry about the WCA as well. My autistic DS is in this category (actually it's me that will find it easier, as his appointee as I have to deal with the forms)

I get PIP for myself and also deal with my DS's forms so I know how hard it can be to get it, but the chances of getting it are good if you use an advice agency and have a decent amount of evidence, and go ahead to appeal if not awarded initially.

PerkingFaintly · 16/03/2023 13:36

Nospringchix · 16/03/2023 10:39

Me too. Feel suicidal at the thought of this.

I know.

We're not dead yet – but the life we do have is spent in fear.

All because of these repeated, stupid, political-footballing "initiatives".

Eightiesgirl · 16/03/2023 12:27

@Darthwazette How annoying about the GP. Can you get anyone else who knows you to write a letter in support of your application? A carer, friend or family member who sees what your day to day struggles are? You probably know all this anyway. I, too, have heard the tribunal panel are more sympathetic. Again, these white paper changes hopefully won't be coming in for a few years, so it gives you time to get a successful PIP award. Good luck.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 16/03/2023 12:08

Darthwazette · 16/03/2023 11:21

Thank you for replying. When I looked it up the government seemed to be saying they wanted to change things asap. I don’t process things very well when anxious.

I am appealing the PIP. They didn’t give me a face to face assessment because they deemed it too risky because of my difficulties but then my Gp sent them a very basic report with little evidence so they said they didn’t have enough evidence to grant the PIP.

It’s always much better with appeal because the panel will ask questions.

My DDs appeal was done not-in-person because she wasn’t fit and they still did it by phone and made sure they asked the questions needed.

Darthwazette · 16/03/2023 11:21

Thank you for replying. When I looked it up the government seemed to be saying they wanted to change things asap. I don’t process things very well when anxious.

I am appealing the PIP. They didn’t give me a face to face assessment because they deemed it too risky because of my difficulties but then my Gp sent them a very basic report with little evidence so they said they didn’t have enough evidence to grant the PIP.

Eightiesgirl · 16/03/2023 11:17

@Darthwazette Please try not to worry. Nothing will change for years yet, they are saying 2026/2027 for new claimants and 2029 for existing ones. Can you appeal the PIP decision?

Darthwazette · 16/03/2023 10:52

I don’t understand this. I’ve just had my PIP application denied but I’m on LCWRA on UC due to depression and anxiety and I’ve just been referred for an ASD assessment. I currently struggle to leave the house without panic attacks. I’m on various medications which keep me alive but barely functional. I have weekly counselling. I struggle to sleep at night and wake short of breath with my heart pounding at multiple times through the night. I can’t manage to work at the moment. I’m trying my best to get better but it’s not working right now. I’m so scared about how I will manage to live like this. I feel like I may as well give up now.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 16/03/2023 10:40

BertaHoon · 16/03/2023 10:21

This is terrifying me. I just feel like dying now.

The change hasn’t been made yet and it’s going to take whole new legislation so if they do make it then there’s time between now and then for governments to change.

Try not to worry.

as it stands people absolutely can claim conts based new style ESA anywhere in the UK.

Nospringchix · 16/03/2023 10:39

BertaHoon · 16/03/2023 10:21

This is terrifying me. I just feel like dying now.

Me too. Feel suicidal at the thought of this.

BertaHoon · 16/03/2023 10:21

XenoBitch · 15/03/2023 23:32

That is the case anyway... you can't claim UC if your partner earns too much.

This new rule will mean a single person living alone wont be able to claim the 'health element' of UC unless they are also claiming PIP

They will have to live off less than £400 a month and be expected to look for work with threat of sanctions otherwise.

This is terrifying me. I just feel like dying now.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 16/03/2023 10:14

Eightiesgirl · 16/03/2023 10:05

@Zebedee55 Everything you say is correct, that's why the government knows exactly what they are doing. There will be no choice but to drag yourself to work, in any job you can get, even if you aren't well, physically or mentally, unless you have been awarded the notoriously very hard to get PIP.

And if they do completely scrap ESA then you’d own NI contributions will mean zilch if you have a partner or savings as that will mean no UC award.

Eightiesgirl · 16/03/2023 10:05

@Zebedee55 Everything you say is correct, that's why the government knows exactly what they are doing. There will be no choice but to drag yourself to work, in any job you can get, even if you aren't well, physically or mentally, unless you have been awarded the notoriously very hard to get PIP.

Zebedee55 · 16/03/2023 07:19

But DLA/PIP and ESA are completely different benefits given for different reasons.

Many on DLA/PIP work and always have. It's for the extra help that long term sick/disabled people might need - whether with care or mobility. The criteria to receive it are very specific.

To receive you need to have suffered x/had additional needs for a specified time, and it is considered that you will continue to suffer from whatever/have additional needs for an x amount of time.

www.gov.uk/pip

ESA, however it's paid, is for those considered unable to work for whatever length of time. They may not be entitled to PIP, but that still wouldn't automatically mean they could reliably work.

That's why the current two assessments are completely different.

ESA is contribution or income based (means tested). UC is means tested. PIP is universal and non means tested.

www.gov.uk/employment-support-allowance

I can't see that you can mix and match them both - PIP can take many months for an award, especially with appeal. This reform will fall apart very quickly.🙄

AutumnColours9 · 16/03/2023 00:33

They basically say in the report that they want to 'help people' (ie force) get into work. The same thing for forcing people who work part time due to being carers or health issues. Their own research showed people usually had good reasons to work less hours or not at all but they didn't use the research and instead just want to force everyone into any kind of work in the guise of it being the best for everyone all the time.

They don't want to place people in a group which removes them from looking for work. In their eyes there is always some work for everyone.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 16/03/2023 00:26

XenoBitch · 15/03/2023 23:59

Didn't speak to anyone, it was all automated. No ESA where I live, only UC.

There is nowhere in the UK where you cannot claim new style ESA if you have the NI contributions.

If you were able to claim the right amount of UC it’s fine.

I only highlighted it because of the potential that someone could have been missing out on £100ish a week that they were entitled to.

Babyroobs · 16/03/2023 00:14

XenoBitch · 15/03/2023 23:47

I am not sure what you want me to prove. I rang the line to claim ESA.. and after telling them my postcode was told I could not claim it.. it was UC only.
My area has been full UC for years. No new style ESA, no ESA at all.. only UC.
I was pointed to the UC claim website.

You can claim New style ESA wherever you live as others have correctly pointed out. It sounds like you tried to claim income related ESA which has been replaced by UC.

Chonk · 16/03/2023 00:12

@YetMoreNewBeginnings is correct, where you live has no impact on whether you can claim New Style ESA. Maybe you rang the enquiry line for income-based ESA not New Style ESA.

XenoBitch · 15/03/2023 23:59

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 15/03/2023 23:53

I’m not asking you to prove anything.

I’m telling you - and the link in my post will confirm it - that the person who told you there was no new style ESA in your area was wrong.

If you were entitled to income based UC there’s a chance it will have made no difference to you.

However, if you had a partner or savings or something then the person who told you that could have made an error that cost you money (if you’d have qualified for contributions based).

Im not remotely saying you did something wrong. I’m saying it sounds very much like you spoke to someone who misinformed you. As happens with them.

Didn't speak to anyone, it was all automated. No ESA where I live, only UC.

OP posts:
YetMoreNewBeginnings · 15/03/2023 23:53

XenoBitch · 15/03/2023 23:47

I am not sure what you want me to prove. I rang the line to claim ESA.. and after telling them my postcode was told I could not claim it.. it was UC only.
My area has been full UC for years. No new style ESA, no ESA at all.. only UC.
I was pointed to the UC claim website.

I’m not asking you to prove anything.

I’m telling you - and the link in my post will confirm it - that the person who told you there was no new style ESA in your area was wrong.

If you were entitled to income based UC there’s a chance it will have made no difference to you.

However, if you had a partner or savings or something then the person who told you that could have made an error that cost you money (if you’d have qualified for contributions based).

Im not remotely saying you did something wrong. I’m saying it sounds very much like you spoke to someone who misinformed you. As happens with them.

XenoBitch · 15/03/2023 23:47

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 15/03/2023 23:44

If you were entitled to contributions based ESA then you may have been misinformed.

There are no areas on the governments website listed as not being allowed to claim new style ESA.

I am not sure what you want me to prove. I rang the line to claim ESA.. and after telling them my postcode was told I could not claim it.. it was UC only.
My area has been full UC for years. No new style ESA, no ESA at all.. only UC.
I was pointed to the UC claim website.

OP posts:
YetMoreNewBeginnings · 15/03/2023 23:44

XenoBitch · 15/03/2023 23:34

Misinformed in 2017?

I rang the number to claim to ESA and after I said my postcode, was told it was UC only. Not a lot I can do about that.

If you were entitled to contributions based ESA then you may have been misinformed.

There are no areas on the governments website listed as not being allowed to claim new style ESA.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 15/03/2023 23:43

XenoBitch · 15/03/2023 23:32

That is the case anyway... you can't claim UC if your partner earns too much.

This new rule will mean a single person living alone wont be able to claim the 'health element' of UC unless they are also claiming PIP

They will have to live off less than £400 a month and be expected to look for work with threat of sanctions otherwise.

My point is that you can currently claim new style ESA if your NI contributions qualify you. It doesn’t matter how much your partner earns.

This is my entire point.

Many disabled and sick people claim ESA (new and old style still - old style is going but there has been no official announcement that new style is also being scraped) based on their NI conts in the last couple of years.

The can claim it regardless of saving or partner to replace their lost income.

XenoBitch · 15/03/2023 23:34

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 15/03/2023 23:30

Yes.

You should also look into if you were misinformed in 2017.

Misinformed in 2017?

I rang the number to claim to ESA and after I said my postcode, was told it was UC only. Not a lot I can do about that.

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 15/03/2023 23:32

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 15/03/2023 23:29

That’s what I’m thinking.

it’s PIP and UC only then anyone with a working partner or savings won’t qualify for any income replacement. It’ll be pip alone, if they qualify.

Which will be a massive impact on families where someone has to give up work suddenly. It’s already impact enough, and mostly far from completely replaced by the £400ish a month contribution based ESA, but that’s better than nothing.

I am concerned this plan is a back door removal of conts based benefits.

That is the case anyway... you can't claim UC if your partner earns too much.

This new rule will mean a single person living alone wont be able to claim the 'health element' of UC unless they are also claiming PIP

They will have to live off less than £400 a month and be expected to look for work with threat of sanctions otherwise.

OP posts:
YetMoreNewBeginnings · 15/03/2023 23:30

XenoBitch · 15/03/2023 23:24

Yes, you are right. My dad was on ESA and my mum worked, so I guess he was on the contribution based ESA?

This is going to be a whole fat mess when the new rules come in.

Yes.

You should also look into if you were misinformed in 2017.