Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not start taking HRT?

196 replies

OldSkoolLikeHappyShopper · 15/03/2023 21:40

My doctor has mentioned that HRT would be an option for me. She said patches because of a family history of breast cancer. I’m 42, no not flushes or night sweats. But my symptoms are:

low mood/irritability
loss of sex drive
find it hard to orgasm when I do have sex (never been a problem before)
bad skin
forgetfulness/brain fog
achy all over
crazy menstrual cycle (anywhere between 18-38 days)

I guess I’m a bit scared because of my family breast cancer risk, and also because I’ve never got on with any kind of hormonal contraception, I always had hideous side effects with it. I know HRT isn’t contraception, but would it have a similar effect in terms of not agreeing with me?

Really don’t know what to do…I wouldn’t say my symptoms are unmanageable or massively affecting my life (the sex drive/orgasms one is probably the most annoying), and I don’t know whether to go for the HRT or play or by ear and see if things get worse.

Others experiences and opinions would be appreciated, I feel completely clueless, this whole peri menopause thing has crept up on me and I feel woefully unprepared!

OP posts:
KnittingNeedles · 16/03/2023 15:28

but my mum was at her GP for hrt on Monday and they told her to try herbal first. I've never seen her so depressed and down in my life she's on constant pain too.

Your poor mum. It makes me so cross that women have to get really stropped and practically demand HRT. In my case it took two prescriptions for anti-depressants which didn't work and about 5 lots of antibiotics for UTIs caused by vaginal dryness/atrophy for me to join the dots. If I'd left it to the GP I'd still have no HRT.

Moredarkchocolateplease · 16/03/2023 15:23

I'm in my third month of HRT and I have just turned 45.

I was hesitant to try it also bad experiences with hormonal contraception.

But...

My breast feel perky again instead of saggy and without any sensation.
I can go a lot longer before I need a wee.
I stay asleep a bit longer than I used to (never had any trouble falling asleep)
Still no libido, but I've never had much of one anyway

And...

I might be helping my heart, improving bone health and possibly reducing dementia risk.

I did however spend the first two months in tears until i increased the strength of my patch! Def feeling better now.

Gel not for me, I can't be bothered moisturising so had no interest in rubbing a gel into me. Too much high maintenance.

@salutsandy I will take it as long as it makes me feel better. So how long is a piece of string?

salutsandy · 16/03/2023 15:05

Thanks Breadandwine2 I think it was kind of you to post and enjoyed reading the article.

People who are on HRT - how long are you planning on taking it? the risks increase the longer you're on it. What about stopping- do the symptoms come back? I don't think these facts are made clear enough. Also where's the evidence that it stops osteoporosis - and is that just when you're on it? I still think there's a lot of confusion. I know when I researched it myself it said higher risk of heart attacks and strokes during the first year of taking it.

Cece92 · 16/03/2023 15:02

I personally have no experience but my mum was at her GP for hrt on Monday and they told her to try herbal first. I've never seen her so depressed and down in my life she's on constant pain too. She's ordered menofriend and some cbd gummies to try for a bit. My friend has started taking the gel and said it's been a life saver if she hadn't she would be divorced or dead she said xxx

KnittingNeedles · 16/03/2023 14:59

It definitely makes sense, @borntobequiet. I am sure that I have read that women who suffered post natal depression are more likely to suffer with the anxiety/depression side of menopause. Not sure about the hot flushes and rest of it.

I think what the medics are keen to stress though is that it's not a foregone conclusion that if you've had PND, that you're going to be depressed in menopause. And although I am certainly not on board with the visiting vegan, other things like taking vitamin D and getting regular exercise definitely helps.

borntobequiet · 16/03/2023 14:53

One of my lottery win plans is to fund research to see if my Dad’s theory was correct, and that a history of PMS and postnatal illness makes it more probable that a woman might have a difficult menopause. Of course, some women will have such a history and an easy menopause, and others might not have such a history and a difficult menopause, but it might be a useful indicator.

Abra1t · 16/03/2023 14:50

borntobequiet · 16/03/2023 14:44

I also didn't get PMS or anything like that. Not sure if they're linked.

I had dreadful PMS/PMDD all my life, also two episodes of postpartum psychosis. My father - a psychiatrist- told me that I should be aware of what the menopause might hold for me. It was unusual for him to have that sort of conversation with family, so he clearly felt strongly about it.
Many of the repeat admissions in the large mental hospital he ran were women affected by their menstrual cycle, childbirth and the menopause. It was a distinct pattern, he said.

Many of the repeat admissions in the large mental hospital he ran were women affected by their menstrual cycle, childbirth and the menopause. It was a distinct pattern, he said.

That is so depressing. It was good he is/was keeping an eye on you, though. Bloody hormones.

KnittingNeedles · 16/03/2023 14:46

And on the flip side, I never suffered with PMT or post-natal depression, and the menopause hit me like a ton of bricks.

Everyone's different, it's all about recognising that your symptoms are particular to you, if you can cope or not having symptoms then fine. If you're struggling, there is something which might help.

borntobequiet · 16/03/2023 14:44

I also didn't get PMS or anything like that. Not sure if they're linked.

I had dreadful PMS/PMDD all my life, also two episodes of postpartum psychosis. My father - a psychiatrist- told me that I should be aware of what the menopause might hold for me. It was unusual for him to have that sort of conversation with family, so he clearly felt strongly about it.
Many of the repeat admissions in the large mental hospital he ran were women affected by their menstrual cycle, childbirth and the menopause. It was a distinct pattern, he said.

Breadandwine2 · 16/03/2023 14:18

highfidelity · 16/03/2023 10:37

While I appreciate you're trying to be helpful, this isn't really your place to offer help, more so given you're consulting google 🙄

Sorry, you misunderstood - I meant the search engine of Dr Greger's website. No google involved. All Dr Greger's work is science-based, peer-reviewed with full references. As for it not being my place to offer help, as a vegan my concern is not only for non- human animals, it also extends to my fellow human beings.
So here's another link you might like to check out:
nutritionfacts.org/video/dietary-approach-to-naturally-treating-menopause-symptoms/
And a book that the female members of my family recommend that all women should read is 'Your Body in Balance' by Dr Neal Barnard.

Willyoujustbequiet · 16/03/2023 14:14

VoluptuaSneezelips · 16/03/2023 10:39

I would say to weigh up the pro's and con's carefully especially if you have any medical conditions that run in your family that may be an issue.

I have very high level of DVT down my maternal line, some of the women in my family have had blood clots at young ages (in their early 20's) and while treatable we have sadly also lost loved ones too. This includes my own mum who died suddenly from a pulmonary embolism at age 57, both DVT and HRT Treatment were also listed as causes on her death certificate. Having to go through a sudden loss and inquest is something I wouldn't wish on anyone. My mum was actually advised against HRT but she decided that the benefits outweighed the risk because of her menopause symptoms. So while im not trying to scare anyone or create fear mongering (it was a very rare set of circumstances that led to the loss of my mum) I just want to remind people to take the risks seriously.
If any of you ladies on HRT have any symptoms that may indicate a blood clot go straight to A&E, PLEASE do not ignore it in hope it will go away like my mum did.

I'm sorry to hear about your mum.

Mine died of a stroke and so I don't want HRT. It worries me some posters appear to say everyone should be on it. That is absolutely not the case. Sometimes the risk outweighs the benefits

Barelyable · 16/03/2023 13:25

@dolorsit my GP said exactly the same...she said every woman over 45 should really be on it unless there is a medical reason for not being. She specialised in Menopause care.

dolorsit · 16/03/2023 13:14

@Lastnamedidntstick

My doctor definitely seemed to give the impression that she thought most women aged 40-50 would benefit regardless of menopausal symptoms.

I'm not sure but I think guidelines may have changed recently and that HRT should be prescribed if a woman in that age bracket requests it. (Assuming no specific medical issues which would advise against it)

LaviniasBigBloomers · 16/03/2023 13:07

Lastnamedidntstick · 16/03/2023 13:04

does anyone know if HRT is advised if you aren’t having menopause symptoms?

posters are saying about the benefits- bone, heart health, dementia risk etc.

so should I take it for those things purely because at 50 I’m probably at least approaching menopause.

or do I wait until I show symptoms? What if I don’t? Am I risking the above if I don’t take HRT?

pp said about lack of research, and this is the one question I can’t find the answer to.

That is a really great question actually.

Lastnamedidntstick · 16/03/2023 13:04

does anyone know if HRT is advised if you aren’t having menopause symptoms?

posters are saying about the benefits- bone, heart health, dementia risk etc.

so should I take it for those things purely because at 50 I’m probably at least approaching menopause.

or do I wait until I show symptoms? What if I don’t? Am I risking the above if I don’t take HRT?

pp said about lack of research, and this is the one question I can’t find the answer to.

UnderwaterSymphonyofHumpbackWhales · 16/03/2023 11:51

I completely agree @dolorsit - with hindsight my symptoms started in my late thirties (when i suddenly started getting spots for the first time in years, and my anxiety shot up). I am 47 now and just started HRT. I still have periods and have not really had hot flushes - but the other symptoms have gradually added- brain fog, fatigue, joint pain, irritability, huge mood fluctuations, rage...

All technically 'manageable' but I got tired of managing them. I basically weighed the risks. I luckily don't have any breast cancer history. I do have spinal issues though - so the Osteoporosis benefits of HRT were also on my mind.

I am personally glad I started taking it but agree it is an intensely personal decision.

GettingStuffed · 16/03/2023 11:48

I've never been on HRT as I was advised not to by my Mum's oncologist. TBH I didn't need it I had very few symptoms, the odd bit flush and regular heavy periods, from irregular light ones. Then my periods stopped, since then I haven't had a hot flush either.

I also didn't get PMS or anything like that. Not sure if they're linked.

dolorsit · 16/03/2023 11:37

I also wish I had recognised my peri menopausal symptoms at 42 for what they were. In my opinion women are socialised to minimise their medical symptoms.

It took a friend raising her eyebrows at me saying "oh it's not too bad apart from the brain fog, fatigue, aching bones, hives, insomnia and hot/cold flushes" that made me consider HRT. Suddenly getting the RAGE at family for no reason tipped me over.

dolorsit · 16/03/2023 11:29

I've recently started HRT. My doctor explained the risks as follows 40-50 no particular risk, 50-60 some risk but outweighed by the benefits, 60+ risks may start to outweigh the benefits.

The increase in breast cancer was that out of 1000 women taking HRT 6 more would develop it compared to a comparable group not taking HRT.

However, HRT doesn't cause cancer but speeds up the biological changes that cause cancer. Essentially you may develop cancer at 65 rather than 75 if you hadn't taken HRT.

This is a simplification of the discussion and I don't have a family or personal history of breast cancer so I don't have the same risk factors as you.

The different types of HRT have different risk profiles and different ways to mitigate the risk.

I'd listen to your doctor and trial it for a few months to see if it makes a difference. I don't think taking it for a few months would increase your risk unless you are like another poster who is contraindicted for hormone therapy.

maranella · 16/03/2023 11:27

It's your body, your choice OP. I'm pro-HRT, because the benefits for bone health are clear and there appear to be other benefits too related to heart health and possibly dementia, but at 42 you're likely at the start of peri-menopause and if you feel your symptoms are currently manageable/things you can live with and you have a family history of breast cancer, then hold off for now. Just because you make a decision at 42 not to take it doesn't mean you can't change your mind at a later date if you want to.

UnderwaterSymphonyofHumpbackWhales · 16/03/2023 11:20

Your symptoms sound very similar to mine. I had the same concerns - mainly that I never tolerated birth control pills. I started on oestrogen gel and two weekly progesterone pills two months ago (the natural based progesterone). It has helped me enormously. I was most concerned about the progesterone but it is the progesterone that has actually helped the most. My anxiety/brain fog is gone - I feel much calmer/even tempered. So much less rage!

So far no real side effects. I have always had hormonal headaches - and during the oestrogen only phase I still have those to some degree (but not as frequent or severe). I just generally feel better, back to my old self - more optimistic. Less like I am in slow state of decline.

Just to share my experience. Wishing you all the best.

SmartHome · 16/03/2023 11:19

I think that's true for women in their early to mid forties - you need to rule out other things. But if your 49/50/51 and having trouble sleeping, hot flushes, sudden anxiety, aches and pains, itchy skin, vaginal problems then it's pretty much going to be the menopause. I hesitated starting on it at 49 as, in hindsight, I didn't really need it to have a functional life.

At 51, the situation was very different. And I'd question the narrative that many women, our mothers etc all got through without it because we're in a different context, in many cases. Did that still have school age children? Did they have full time high pressure jobs? My mother didn't (and went through a horrendous menopause that turned her into an abusive narcissist) but I do. So I also came to the same conclusion as a PP. If it takes a year off my life, perhaps or gives me a small increase of breast cancer maybe then I'd rather that to have a pleasant, functional life and see my children into adulthood, rather than go through what my mother went through with the long term damage it did to her mental health and relationship with her children.

What I did do before I started was establish a baseline (scientific training). So I waiting until just after I'd managed to arrange my NHS mammogram, booked a smear test, had a scan of ovaries and uterus and had weight, blood pressure recorded and a full blood test checkup done and blood sugar levels checked (possibly not easy to arrange on NHS but my mother is T2 diabetic so they would do it). All on the NHS post COVID which wasn't easy, as getting face to face appointments is hard enough, but I spent the year or so when I was considering it getting those baselines established. So when physical symptoms hit me (like a rock) at 51, I was ready to go and have to regrets so far.

LaviniasBigBloomers · 16/03/2023 11:16

@bruffin I think we're actually agreeing.

Greensleevevssnotnose · 16/03/2023 11:13

Having being misdiagnosed for years and attempted suicide, ended two marriages and lost countless jobs due to my rage I finally was offered HRT privately only 3 months ago, aged 53: - )I am still peri but as I have waited so long I can only take it till December as they don't recommend it after 54 currently. I have to go private as my lha do not prescribe what I am on. From December I will move on to post menopausal hrt. Which I can take for life. Yesterday I was offered to trial testosterone to deal with libido but I don't suffer in that area so I declined. I found Davina's book revelationary and used that as a basis to talk to the private GP about it. Before I had been on antidepressants for about a decade which did not help at all.

bruffin · 16/03/2023 11:01

LaviniasBigBloomers · 16/03/2023 10:50

@bruffin I'm sorry your diabetes symptoms were mis-diagnosed as menopause. That must have been very frustrating for you. However, in no way does that mean HRT is bad/unsafe/or ineffectual. It means you were misdiagnosed and given the wrong medicine for your condition.

If I was given HRT for a broken ankle I'd still have a broken ankle, but it wouldn't prove anything other than HRT doesn't treat broken bones.

No they weren't misdiagnosed.
I had mild symptoms I put down to menopause, but they weren't , the were diabetes. The same with others on this thread with thyroid. It's dangerous to assume it's all down to menopause when it may not be.

Swipe left for the next trending thread