Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fed up of DH acting like an only child?

66 replies

PolkaDotMankini · 15/03/2023 17:11

DH has an older brother who has a lovely fiancée, good job where he picks his own hours, no DC or pets. MIL is in her 70's, in good health and very easy-going. I like her.

BIL "doesn't do visiting" on either day, meaning MIL comes to stay with us or we go to see her every single Christmas and Mother's Day. I think this is bloody selfish and would like to alternate so we can take turns to have these occasions just us.

Last Christmas DH agreed to going away this year. WIBU to remind him of this and that he needs to tell BIL to step up, then keep going to alternating actually happens?

OP posts:
JudgeRudy · 16/03/2023 01:10

Freshstarts22 · 15/03/2023 17:33

I’m really shocked at people saying neither has to see her. Imagine leaving your Mother alone at Xmas for no good reason 😥

@Freshstarts22 but it is a good reason. Its his Xmas day too.. Having another person their will completely change the dynamics, thats assuming theyre even at home. I bet she'd want picking up too.

JudgeRudy · 16/03/2023 01:04

I think its unreasonable for your brother to insist that it's his 'turn' this Xmas. I think it's even more unreasonable for you to get involved. You cannot put social or moral obligations on me.
I have never had any guest for Xmas Dinner. I don't do Xmas. I'm regularly invited to others' homes and sometimes I do join in but mostly I enjoy doing nothing on my own. It riles me that people think I should eg spend Xmas with an elderly relative. Why do their needs trump mine.
Likewise your BIL prefers to do his own thing at Xmas. Why should your MILs wants trump his? It's not 'wrong' to not have a strong bond. It is wrong to think he should feel like you do. I doubt he's uncomfortable with his decision. Mention you'll be away this year but don't start telling him what he should do. I feel you are mistaken if you think that if you step back he'll be forced to step up. I doubt he'll feel that way.
I am curious about one thing though. How do you maintain a relationship with him if he never 'does visiting'? Do you always go to his? Again, if you do don't think if you stop going they'll somehow come to you. They won't. At least not anytime soon.
Accept that people are different.

XanaduKira · 16/03/2023 00:41

CantAskAnyoneElse · 15/03/2023 17:52

YABU, Very U.

He doesn’t have to see her if he doesnmt want to.
That doesn’t make him selfish.
He’s done nothing wrong.
You are being odd though.

I agree with this.

Enko · 16/03/2023 00:26

Yabu

Not because you want to go away
Not because you want to do alternative years.

Because you feel you can tell bil how to live his life. You can't. Work out what you want to do. Do it and let bil work out if he wants to visit then. Mil will cope.

Freshstarts22 · 16/03/2023 00:19

redskylight · 15/03/2023 17:39

Firstly, there's no indication that she would be alone if neither family went to see her.
Secondly, if she doesn't live with anyone else, presumably there are lots of other days when she's alone. Why is Xmas Day different?
Thirdly, people should go and see other people because they like them and want to; not out of a sense of "duty".

My MIL spent last Christmas alone. We actually did invite her over but she said she was happier just spending the day as she wanted.

Which brings me to my fourth point, which is that maybe someone should ask MIL what she'd like? Maybe she's going to see OP and her DH because she feels bad about letting them down?

I think it’s obvious that to most people Christmas isn’t just like any other day though. I also disagree that you shouldn’t see somebody out of a sense of duty. Assuming there’s no big back story I think adult do have a duty to their parents when they get older. They generally sacrifice a lot for their children and don’t deserve to be repaid by being neglected.
If they want to be alone that’s obviously fine but otherwise I think it’s quite selfish.

In op’s situation though, I would let dh and bil sort it out between themselves and prioritise seeing my own family when possible.

OnaBegonia · 15/03/2023 21:48

How far a drive to your mum/gran? could you go in train or is the MN long drive or 1/2 hrs?

Soproudoflionesses · 15/03/2023 21:39

Freshstarts22 · 15/03/2023 17:33

I’m really shocked at people saying neither has to see her. Imagine leaving your Mother alone at Xmas for no good reason 😥

Me too!! Jeez l couldn't let anyone be in their own unless of course they wanted to be

LittleOwl153 · 15/03/2023 21:37

PolkaDotMankini · 15/03/2023 20:23

This is a good approach, thanks.

None of us live locally - it's a long drive. DH goes regularly to do odd jobs for MIL and we all go down every few weeks to spend time with her at the weekend. I'm proud of him for wanting to take care of her but it always being on him does affect time that we have as a family and with my family. His brother and SIL visit twice a year. There's no bad history that I know of.

For an example of how it affects my family, my grandma is still alive but very old and frail. She also lives a long way away in a different direction. I'd love to go down on Sunday to have lunch with her and my mum. MIL would be welcome too, as she is at Christmas, but she lives too far away to join in for just the day. If DH went to see MIL and I went down to see my grandma with the DC then it's a heck of a drive for me on my own and I'd be knackered and worrying about the journey back instead of enjoying a nice lunch. So I miss out and my family misses out because I know DBro will be with my mum but if we didn't go to MIL then she'd be alone. I don't want to be "that" DIL who forces her DH to choose, but I also don't think that the same arrangement every year is fair when his brother just cba to make the effort.

I'd also be making plans for next years mothers day then... I'd work out what you could achieve logistically and accomodation wise and making the plan. I'd probably make it work without DH - can your mother drive ? Could you hire a car / changeninsurance to make that work? Then I'd plan to go maybe Friday night or early Saturday, stay over come back Sunday. Yes you are driving late but its only 1 weekend.

I'd assume DH would come with you but I wouldn't force him. I'd say we'll I didn't see Grandma over Christmas/ last x number of mothers days and it's something I'd like to do. He will face a difficult choice no doubt - but he can't centre everything your whole family does around his mother. Making some different choices will opennup the conversation at least.

Whats happening for Easter? Could you make a long weekend of grandma visiting then as everyone is off school etc?

I know where you are coming from OP. I used to play this game with my family / inlaws...

Lampzade · 15/03/2023 21:17

Couldyounot · 15/03/2023 17:29

"doesn't do visiting"

Bet he "does" inheriting though 🙄

YANBU

Exactly

Floralnomad · 15/03/2023 21:15

YABU, the fact that your husband feels obliged to entertain his mum has nothing to do with his brother who is entitled to make his own decision , nobody is forcing your husband to visit her .

IhearyouClemFandango · 15/03/2023 21:14

That doesn’t mean you can’t, you just don’t want to because it is a long drive. Big difference, and that one’s on you.

Xant · 15/03/2023 21:11

I do see your point. But if BIL is an arsehole, then the options are you see MIL every year or she is alone for xmas sometimes for no good reason.

Growing up I saw both sets of grandparents every year, they all came to stay at same time, and it was so lovely. Yes we kids had to sleep in idd places while grandparents borrowed our rooms butnit was fun.

Demanding you go away for Christmas or spend it alone is missing the point of the holiday. It’s about getting family together and making family memories for your children. Just do what everyone else does: stick MIL in the corner with a bottle of sherry and a box of quality street and get on with your day.

bellac11 · 15/03/2023 20:29

PolkaDotMankini · 15/03/2023 20:23

This is a good approach, thanks.

None of us live locally - it's a long drive. DH goes regularly to do odd jobs for MIL and we all go down every few weeks to spend time with her at the weekend. I'm proud of him for wanting to take care of her but it always being on him does affect time that we have as a family and with my family. His brother and SIL visit twice a year. There's no bad history that I know of.

For an example of how it affects my family, my grandma is still alive but very old and frail. She also lives a long way away in a different direction. I'd love to go down on Sunday to have lunch with her and my mum. MIL would be welcome too, as she is at Christmas, but she lives too far away to join in for just the day. If DH went to see MIL and I went down to see my grandma with the DC then it's a heck of a drive for me on my own and I'd be knackered and worrying about the journey back instead of enjoying a nice lunch. So I miss out and my family misses out because I know DBro will be with my mum but if we didn't go to MIL then she'd be alone. I don't want to be "that" DIL who forces her DH to choose, but I also don't think that the same arrangement every year is fair when his brother just cba to make the effort.

This is simple logistics, no one has to miss out. Your mother in law can come the day before, stay over at yours or even get train/cab to a bnb near your nan and meet you there?

PolkaDotMankini · 15/03/2023 20:23

LittleOwl153 · 15/03/2023 17:16

I'd give it a couple of weeks to clear mothers day - I'm assuming you already have plans with her this weekend? Then I'd raise booking the Christmas trip - show him some places you've looked into and see what his reaction is. I'd be looking to get something booked and then sharing with BIL/MIL.

This is a good approach, thanks.

None of us live locally - it's a long drive. DH goes regularly to do odd jobs for MIL and we all go down every few weeks to spend time with her at the weekend. I'm proud of him for wanting to take care of her but it always being on him does affect time that we have as a family and with my family. His brother and SIL visit twice a year. There's no bad history that I know of.

For an example of how it affects my family, my grandma is still alive but very old and frail. She also lives a long way away in a different direction. I'd love to go down on Sunday to have lunch with her and my mum. MIL would be welcome too, as she is at Christmas, but she lives too far away to join in for just the day. If DH went to see MIL and I went down to see my grandma with the DC then it's a heck of a drive for me on my own and I'd be knackered and worrying about the journey back instead of enjoying a nice lunch. So I miss out and my family misses out because I know DBro will be with my mum but if we didn't go to MIL then she'd be alone. I don't want to be "that" DIL who forces her DH to choose, but I also don't think that the same arrangement every year is fair when his brother just cba to make the effort.

OP posts:
Yesthatismychildsigh · 15/03/2023 19:00

It’s not for him to tell his brother what to do. And he needs to grow up with the not visiting.

blumppump · 15/03/2023 18:51

I don't do visits to a family member.

I have good reasons for that.

They are no one else's business.

You'd not get very far trying to guilt trip me into going.

barbrahunter · 15/03/2023 18:26

I have been in the same situation as you, OP and trust me, even holding a gun to his head would not have made my DB into a decent person who wanted to visit the mother who adored him. You might as well accept that you and your DH are on your own with MIL. How often you want to invite her to your home is something in the short term to think about.

What may be more useful is to find out your MIL's wishes about what she wants to happen if her health/mental state starts to decline. Perhaps a LPOA, perhaps a discussion about nursing homes? I think you can expect jack shit support from BIL and You'll only see him take interest when the will is read, as someone upthread already said. Selfish arses will never change.

Stompythedinosaur · 15/03/2023 18:20

You don't get to dictate what bil does.

You are fine to decide to celebrate alone sometimes.

ShapesAndNumbers · 15/03/2023 18:06

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

bellac11 · 15/03/2023 18:03

I meant to add that you should be proud of your partner that he supports his mum.

CecilyP · 15/03/2023 18:02

Do you actually have genuine plans for going away at Christmas; is there something you really want to do? Or do you just want to to ensure BIL steps up? Regarding Mother’s Day, it’s just another Sunday really. Assuming you all live locally, if you see MIL this Sunday, there are plenty of other Sundays to do what you want.

phoenixrosehere · 15/03/2023 18:00

I’m curious on what the relationship/backstory is between BIL and his mother that he doesn’t want to see her.

Saying that, your DH cannot force his brother to see her if he doesn’t want to.

Bellaboo01 · 15/03/2023 17:58

Eyerollcentral · 15/03/2023 17:51

I’m assuming your children are too young to organise a present for you themselves, but why wouldn’t your husband help them? He still knows you are a mother and presumably lives with the children. I find that odd. Just remind your husband now about going away for Christmas and ask him to speak to his brother. I really don’t see the big deal having your mother in law with you for Mother’s Day, surely she can just join in with your family?

This

Bellaboo01 · 15/03/2023 17:56

PolkaDotMankini · 15/03/2023 17:11

DH has an older brother who has a lovely fiancée, good job where he picks his own hours, no DC or pets. MIL is in her 70's, in good health and very easy-going. I like her.

BIL "doesn't do visiting" on either day, meaning MIL comes to stay with us or we go to see her every single Christmas and Mother's Day. I think this is bloody selfish and would like to alternate so we can take turns to have these occasions just us.

Last Christmas DH agreed to going away this year. WIBU to remind him of this and that he needs to tell BIL to step up, then keep going to alternating actually happens?

When you say he doesnt do visiting do you mean all year round or just those two days of the year that you are bothered about?

If she is nice, what is the issue with including her in your plans. Or if you dont, she is young enough to arrange her own plans.

HanSB · 15/03/2023 17:56

You can't force someone to be a nice person and considerate to others. It sounds like your BIL is selfish by nature. Yes, it is unfair that it has fallen on your family to ensure MIL is not lonely. Perhaps a word to his 'lovely fiancee' who may be able to sway him to consider his own mother?