Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fed up of DH acting like an only child?

66 replies

PolkaDotMankini · 15/03/2023 17:11

DH has an older brother who has a lovely fiancée, good job where he picks his own hours, no DC or pets. MIL is in her 70's, in good health and very easy-going. I like her.

BIL "doesn't do visiting" on either day, meaning MIL comes to stay with us or we go to see her every single Christmas and Mother's Day. I think this is bloody selfish and would like to alternate so we can take turns to have these occasions just us.

Last Christmas DH agreed to going away this year. WIBU to remind him of this and that he needs to tell BIL to step up, then keep going to alternating actually happens?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PolkaDotMankini · 16/03/2023 08:15

You're right; it would be logistically possible for us all to go to my grandma's if we threw money at getting a hotel. A bit late for this year but something to think about. I do go to see her on other weekends and usually take the train but strikes and engineering works this weekend mean that wouldn't have been possible. I sometimes get very sleepy for no obvious reason, so I avoid long drives on my own where I can.

MIL, BIL and Grandma live about as far away from eachother as you can get and still be in England. The distances aren't trivial. We're closest to MIL but it's still a 2-hour drive one way. I'm allergic to her cat so we don't often stay overnight. BIL and fiancée have been together longer than me and DH. They have a lovely home but there's no space for overnight visitors.

I don't mind DH doing odd jobs and us visiting every few weeks. I think it's a good thing and would think less of DH if he didn't

TBH, this thread has thrown up some ideas I hadn't thought of, e.g. DH doing Mothers Day with MIL on Saturday. It seems really obvious but it just hadn't occurred to me.

I was really upset a couple of years ago when the DC hadn't done so much as organised a card for MD. DH has got better at organising them since then but there's no question of something happening just for me.

OP posts:
RosesAndHellebores · 16/03/2023 08:00

On the other side of this, probably because I'm an only child @PolkaDotMankini, as a 62 year old who has cared for family for 32 years, I have actual fantasies about spending Christmas day alone with DH. Preferably in bed with a bottle of champagne and side of smoked salmon, binge watching Netflix.

You may find your MIL feels similarly.

Barbecuebeans · 16/03/2023 07:40

Skyeheather · 16/03/2023 07:37

Can your and your DC travel down to your family on public transport if you don't want to drive? You could go the day before and stay somewhere. You go and visit your family and leave your DH to visit his.

Or could you visit DH's DM on Saturday, day overnight then visit your family on the Sunday?

You don't need to visit MIL on actual Mother's Day - DP is taking his DM out for dinner and giving her his gift on Friday evening as we have other plans on Sunday. MIL will see SIL the following weekend as she works shifts and will be working this weekend.

This.

It's lovely to treat his mum but it really doesn't have to be on the actual day. I often don't celebrate my birthday on the day. I'd much rather have everyone together because that's the important bit than worry about exactly when.

blebbleb · 16/03/2023 07:39

I take it MIL isn't married or doesn't have a partner? As the pp said, can't you get the train to your grandma if you don't like the drive? I'm sure you could get close enough to even the more remote parts of the country via train

Skyeheather · 16/03/2023 07:37

Can your and your DC travel down to your family on public transport if you don't want to drive? You could go the day before and stay somewhere. You go and visit your family and leave your DH to visit his.

Or could you visit DH's DM on Saturday, day overnight then visit your family on the Sunday?

You don't need to visit MIL on actual Mother's Day - DP is taking his DM out for dinner and giving her his gift on Friday evening as we have other plans on Sunday. MIL will see SIL the following weekend as she works shifts and will be working this weekend.

RosesAndHellebores · 16/03/2023 07:36

My SILs went to live on another Continent more than 30 years ago. One has done a minimal amount for her mother; the other diddly squat.

We have been married for 32 years. After a Christmas with an over-excited two year old at my mother's we said "children need to be in their own beds in their own homes". You are very welcome - both sides together or alternating.

My step didn't do visiting at Christmas. ILs visited every single year and stayed for a week until FIL died and then MIL came alone. Now she is frail we rent a house near her for Christmas.

So for 32 years, my mother and step have come for Christmas Dinner in mid December and the ILs/MIL for a week at Christmas.

My SILs on the whole have behaved like spoilt brats for the last 30 years. They have not behaved like only children because only children are usually generous and kind.

How far away is your gran that you can't manage the drive alone. That strikes me as a bit precious unless it's more than three hours each way.

redskylight · 16/03/2023 07:35

CrayonCloverClose · 16/03/2023 04:59

My sister has a new trick of visiting my Mother before Christmas, meaning we host her as usual, for over 20 years, when we would really like a day to ourselves for once.
Other sibling never offers to have her, but they do more than their share of running around the rest of the year.

I particularly hate Christmas

So have a day to yourself.

Literally the only person putting this job upon yourself is you.

rookiemere · 16/03/2023 07:22

You can't make BIL visit his DM more, so you have to accept if you choose to go away at Christmas MIL may be on her own.

I'm not saying you shouldn't do it - MIL may make other arrangements if you let her know now you have other plans, or BIL may step in, but you can't force him to.

I'd say as she is getting older, this will get worse in the future, so take your breaks now when it's just a question of company and little jobs, rather than more onerous needs.

Hardbackwriter · 16/03/2023 07:10

I'm really surprised by all the comments calling BiL selfish, saying 'who could leave a relative alone on Christmas' etc. Every Christmas MN is absolutely full of threads where everyone agrees that it's not just fine but better to do Christmas 'just your little family'. Is it because BiL (seemingly) doesn't have kids that he isn't allowed this?

MultipleVeganPies · 16/03/2023 07:08

Does the brother never visit or just never on Mother's Day?

I never do much for Mother's Day, I think these "days" are baloney (like valentine s day), does not mean I did not have a good relationship with my mum though (or my kids)

OhwhyOY · 16/03/2023 07:02

PolkaDotMankini · 15/03/2023 20:23

This is a good approach, thanks.

None of us live locally - it's a long drive. DH goes regularly to do odd jobs for MIL and we all go down every few weeks to spend time with her at the weekend. I'm proud of him for wanting to take care of her but it always being on him does affect time that we have as a family and with my family. His brother and SIL visit twice a year. There's no bad history that I know of.

For an example of how it affects my family, my grandma is still alive but very old and frail. She also lives a long way away in a different direction. I'd love to go down on Sunday to have lunch with her and my mum. MIL would be welcome too, as she is at Christmas, but she lives too far away to join in for just the day. If DH went to see MIL and I went down to see my grandma with the DC then it's a heck of a drive for me on my own and I'd be knackered and worrying about the journey back instead of enjoying a nice lunch. So I miss out and my family misses out because I know DBro will be with my mum but if we didn't go to MIL then she'd be alone. I don't want to be "that" DIL who forces her DH to choose, but I also don't think that the same arrangement every year is fair when his brother just cba to make the effort.

Could you not do something for mothers day with your MIL on the Saturday and your grandmother/mum on the Sunday?

Feelinglow27 · 16/03/2023 06:59

Wow. Everything we do as mothers and the love we have for our children, and it seems we then are just seen as a burden when our kids become adults. I'd be devastated if my children secretly resented me being there on special days. Very sad.

Untitledsquatboulder · 16/03/2023 06:30

So he lives with you, Iives with your kids and now you want to stop him seeing his mother every few weeks? Because it interferes with your family life? Or is it Mother's Day and Christmas only that you are bothered about?

Justforlaffs · 16/03/2023 05:58

IhearyouClemFandango · 15/03/2023 21:14

That doesn’t mean you can’t, you just don’t want to because it is a long drive. Big difference, and that one’s on you.

Yes, sorry - I don't understand why visiting your MIL every few weekends is stopping you from seeing your gran? Why don't you see your gran on the weekends you don't see your MIL?

I agree with others that you do t get to dictate what your BIL and SIL do - that's on them. Your dh should do what makes him happy and you shouldn't pressurise him not to see his MIl.

I would make my plans for Mother's Day with your own dm and then invite MIl along so she has the offer - up to her whether she comes or not.

CrayonCloverClose · 16/03/2023 04:59

My sister has a new trick of visiting my Mother before Christmas, meaning we host her as usual, for over 20 years, when we would really like a day to ourselves for once.
Other sibling never offers to have her, but they do more than their share of running around the rest of the year.

I particularly hate Christmas

NotWastingAnymoreTime · 16/03/2023 04:54

PolkaDotMankini · 15/03/2023 20:23

This is a good approach, thanks.

None of us live locally - it's a long drive. DH goes regularly to do odd jobs for MIL and we all go down every few weeks to spend time with her at the weekend. I'm proud of him for wanting to take care of her but it always being on him does affect time that we have as a family and with my family. His brother and SIL visit twice a year. There's no bad history that I know of.

For an example of how it affects my family, my grandma is still alive but very old and frail. She also lives a long way away in a different direction. I'd love to go down on Sunday to have lunch with her and my mum. MIL would be welcome too, as she is at Christmas, but she lives too far away to join in for just the day. If DH went to see MIL and I went down to see my grandma with the DC then it's a heck of a drive for me on my own and I'd be knackered and worrying about the journey back instead of enjoying a nice lunch. So I miss out and my family misses out because I know DBro will be with my mum but if we didn't go to MIL then she'd be alone. I don't want to be "that" DIL who forces her DH to choose, but I also don't think that the same arrangement every year is fair when his brother just cba to make the effort.

I'm shocked that people are comfortable with leaving an elderly parent (who is nice) on their own at Christmas time, but I've heard this so many times I think this is maybe this is a cultural thing. So yes I would tell my DB to step up but I wouldn't try and force him.

Op, if current arrangements mean you miss out on seeing your own side of the family then you need to put a solution in place, even if that involves overnight stays somewhere. Ultimately you are making a choice about your family which you cannot blame on your BILs behaviour. A 'heck of a drive' and even an absent husband wouldn't stop me from seeing an elderly relative if I wanted to, I'd book a B&B half way to break up the journey. It's only once a year and your suggestion would mean not visiting every year anyway.

Also quite telling that you negotiated with DH not to see your family this year but to go away.

Finally, I cannot believe that if your children aren't old enough to arrange Mother's Day treats by themselves, that your DH doesn't think he should step up and assist as they aren't biologically his. Are you a family or not? If it's important to you just tell him for goodness sake.

MiamiMyAmy · 16/03/2023 04:25

Your BIL can do what he likes, no one is obligated to see anyone on any day. Go on holiday at Xmas if you want to, as planned. As for you thinking your husband can just tell BIL to step up. Seriously? I’d tell you both to stop interfering. Work out what you’re prepared to do and leave others to do the same.

And your MIL is an adult, if I was MIL and thought my kids and partners were discussing ‘who does/doesn’t get me this time’, I’d be really annoyed.

Ponderingwindow · 16/03/2023 03:48

a decision by yourself and your husband to spend alternate holidays with his mother is completely independent of any choices the brother may make. You can’t control the brother’s plans, you can only make decisions for yourselves.

snitzelvoncrumb · 16/03/2023 03:10

You can’t have your life revolve around one person. If you can’t see her on a special day, explain that you will be away, and get MIL to ask BIL to visit. If he says no he will look like an arse. And that’s on him not you.

RobinRobinMouse · 16/03/2023 03:08

Could she not visit him if she chose? Either way you can only control what you do, not what anyone else does.

Doingmybest12 · 16/03/2023 03:02

CantAskAnyoneElse · 15/03/2023 17:52

YABU, Very U.

He doesn’t have to see her if he doesnmt want to.
That doesn’t make him selfish.
He’s done nothing wrong.
You are being odd though.

This is a bit of a sad post. No he doesn't have to see her but unless there is some awful back story I think most would hope he would and surely most siblings would hope to share the load. I can see why you are fed up OP but can also see where husband is coming from too. I would hope he will do cooking etc on Sunday for his mum.

Ivymom · 16/03/2023 02:49

OP, I think you need to focus on making plans with your husband and let MIL and BIL sort their own plans out. If you wish to include them, communicate that to them. If not, just let them know in advance that you guys have other plans for the holiday and won’t be available for a visit. If what you really want for Mother’s Day is for your DH to take you and your DC to visit your grandma, tell him. Ask him if he can take MIL out the day before.

BIL may be selfish or he may have a good reason for not visiting. We will never know for sure. We never do visits to anyone on the actual holidays. For the relatives we have good relationships with, we make arrangements to celebrate on another day. We focus our celebrations on our nuclear family and have developed our own traditions for what we do on those days. We have a lot of relatives that people think are absolutely lovely and they can’t understand why we don’t want to spend our holidays with them. The thing is, these relatives have treated us terribly, so we have chosen not to waste our holidays on them.

StoppinBy · 16/03/2023 02:34

PolkaDotMankini · 15/03/2023 17:39

Interesting that the comments think IANBU whereas the votes are 56% IABU. I'm taking my own mum out for Mother's Day on Friday. No one will do anything for me for Mother's Day (the DC aren't DH's). I would like to prioritise my own family (or even myself!) sometimes.

That is pretty shit of your husband,

Your children might not be his but you are his partner and he should be celebrating you as a mother.

I personally think both children should be doing something for his Mum for Mother's day, doesn't have to be on Mother's day but how hard is it to buy a card and some flowers for her?

Christmas, yes you should be able to take turns without feeling guilty and yes of course his brother should be doing something with his Mother for Christmas to take the pressure of you but if he doesn't that is unfortunately his choice and there's not much you can do to change it.

Partyandbullshit · 16/03/2023 02:06

So you want your DH to not visit his mum on Mother’s Day, so that he can drive you to/from, so that you can have a nice relaxed Mother’s Day lunch with your mum and grandmother and dc? Is that what you’re saying?

user1492757084 · 16/03/2023 01:53

Ideas:
Stop hosting special days yourself every year.
Brain storm with brother's fiancee about Christmas.
Have husband do the same with BIL.
Book a park rotunda for BYO picnics.
Book a restaurant near MIL or BIL house.
Ask BIL to call in and deliver flowers to MIL for Mothers Day for you as you will be away.
Get a caterer in to MIL place.
Shout MIL a high tea with three friends but no family in attandance every now and again.
Call in with MIL to BIL house for an occasional cup of tea.
Fiancee might bring with her some changes, hopefully.
Discussion needs to be had about MIL needs,wants, care as she gets older etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread