Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most of us will work to death?

242 replies

Fifi0000 · 15/03/2023 15:51

I was thinking retirement age is rising again. I'm now 30 my grandparents are late 80s and retired before I was born. They aren't wealthy , They have only started really slowing down health wise. I was thinking about this and very few of us will get a 30 year retirement. If the retirement age rises to 68 I'm dreading what it will be when I reach that age and my daughter. I do have an ok pension pot but I think the expectation will be very short retirements in poor health basically work until you drop.

OP posts:
bibbybox · 15/03/2023 18:53

I worry about my dc & think they have it much harder.

It's really not that simple to just say one generation has it better than others.

but the boomers have had it good statistically...

freyamay74 · 15/03/2023 18:51

@bibbybox I don't think people are pretending anything. We're just recognising that every generation has its upsides and downsides.

My own adult dd will no doubt have to work more years than me. On the other hand, she's 6 months into her maternity leave which is 3 months longer than I had for her! And she's got the prospect of 3 more months on statutory maternity pay, plus another 3 months after that if she chooses. Her partner had 2 weeks paid paternity leave. 2 weeks more than my dh had when we had her.

It's really not that simple to just say one generation has it better than others. I think some people are just cherry picking the good bits and ignoring the downsides.

bibbybox · 15/03/2023 18:46

there is intergenerational inequality though, I'm not sure why people pretend it's not a thing & no it doesn't mean there aren't poor pensioners

pinkySilver · 15/03/2023 18:39

I don’t know a single pensioner who is worse off than us with two full time working adults in the household

There are millions of them - struggling on a small state pension with all sorts of health issues and no back-up. You're lucky that all your friends are rich.

And women had no choice about going out to work before. A few would have chosen it but many would have loved the chance to be a pilot or a lawyer or a bank manager. The fight was to be allowed to get a career. Most didn't choose that. And it left them completely dependent on a man. They couldn't leave. No pension, no money , no home.
There were just as many poor people then and they haven't suddenly got rich. But they took in laundry, or did cleaning if they did anything. And they didn't inherit anything.

The pressures were different. Some things were better, some worse - as you'd expect.

But as I said there's no point in pitting one generation against another - each had its challenges and I don't think many of us would want to go back. We'd be far better working together.

Fifi0000 · 15/03/2023 18:38

I didn't want to start a fight between different generations. There does seem to be a reluctance to admit that things are not progressing for future generations. I am worrying there will be no NHS , social care or pensions for my DD. How sad living standards are sliding backwards and not forwards.

OP posts:
RedHelenB · 15/03/2023 18:37

MsJD · 15/03/2023 18:16

When I was at school (late 70s), our economic teacher told us that by the time we reached his age, people would work for fun and the working week would be 3 days or less. He imagined that machines would do all the work and we would all be living lives full of leisure.

Exactly, and look how that turned out Capitalism will have us working in some capacity or other even if there is a huge increase in AI and robotics.

DuvetDownn · 15/03/2023 18:34

I think some people have definitely got their timelines muddled up the way they are talking about people in their mid to early fifties. Boomers! I’m 54, my DM is a boomer!!

CatsGinAndTwiglets · 15/03/2023 18:34

neilyoungismyhero · 15/03/2023 17:10

I can assure you I'm not lounging about on your dollar and I don't know anyone who is.

Entirely private savings then? Cos the state pension is paid for by the CURRENT tax payers. Tax from years ago was spent at the time!

CatsGinAndTwiglets · 15/03/2023 18:28

pinkySilver · 15/03/2023 17:03

Those people on the cruises didn't have any paid childcare, possibly no mat leave, very little sick pay, were much less likely to access health care when young and only went to the GP when really ill etc etc. That's not a prid pro quo but it's important to remember that not all older people have had a fun-filled easy time on someone else's dollar.

People live longer now - they rarely drop dead two years after retiring - which they used to do. It's good to work - we should all be contributing in whatever way we can. And we should be preparing for when we can't rather than expecting someone else to do it.

Setting up older people against younger people doesn't help us as a society though. And none of knows what's in store.

They didn’t need paid mat leave or childcare because the wife was at home or doing a couple of hours a week!! Plus they bought a nice size family house for three times one salary, got their uni education paid for and retired on nice pensions! I don’t know a single pensioner who is worse off than us with two full time working adults in the household.

GlassBunion · 15/03/2023 18:28

CatsGinAndTwiglets · 15/03/2023 15:57

The current retireds didn’t pay enough into the system so the rest of us will work til we drop after they’ve finished their long holidays and art classes.

Does light bend round you?

My husband worked for 42 years and, for a large part , payed higher taxes and NI.
I worked for 39 years albeit a brief period where I stayed at home... wrap around childcare wasn't available.

We have now got savings to live on. I'm not apologising for it.

Why should we go back to work? We don't need to ... we rely on our own money.

Clioma · 15/03/2023 18:23

Dotjones · 15/03/2023 15:58

YANBU they're trying to get back to the idea of work until you're about to die and maybe have a couple of years hanging around until you do.

The problem is that the boomer generation were able to acquire wealth to a degree that is not widely possible these days. A boomer colleague retired recently at 54 mainly because they had a final salary pension that the company bought them out of (millions) and because they'd bought a house at 21 so were mortgage free by the time they were 40. An impossible dream these days.

People love to quote 'Boomers' and previous generations as having it all. I'm in my late 50s and a bit too young to be a boomer. I bought my first house with my DH in my 20s. Within months interest rates had rocketed to nearly 15%. We literally had no money. We had to sell our car to pay bills and we never went out. I had to take a job in a pub in the evenings after working all day. Within 2 years we had to move for work reasons and ended up in negative equity because house prices had slumped. I couldn't sleep at night for worry. It was a terrible time and it took years to get back on our feet.

Life is easier now because I've worked hard and saved all my life. I'll still have to work to 67.

But people thinking it's all been a bed of roses for everyone in future generations are deluded and it's insulting.

Daleksatemyshed · 15/03/2023 18:22

Unfortunately Covid hit the economy very hard, and the Government has to get funds from the taxpayers, so they are going to want as many people working for as long as possible. It's a hard truth but everyone wants a free NHS, free schooling, free childcare and regardless of which party is in charge they still need to fund all these things. My council tax bill has just risen by 5% and a lot of what it pays for are things I don't use, and have never used, but that's irrelevant, someone has to pay for schools and social services

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 15/03/2023 18:22

I think it's unlikely that most of us will be working at all by the time we hit retirement age. I honestly think that the next 20 years are going to be revolutionary when it comes to work. The leaps forwards in the last 2 years in AI coupled with the last 10 years of robotics technology are going to mean that so much stuff is automated.

And I'm not just talking about the obvious candidates like manufacturing. I'm talking lorry drivers, nurses, artists, composers, web developers, farmers, doctors, lawyers, care workers, marketing departments, journalists, architects etc...

In 20 years I truly believe that there will not be a 10th of the jobs available that there are now. And once that happens one of two things has to happen. Either universal basic income, or the majority of us starve while the rest live like kings.

I'm really hoping it's option 1.

AllMouthButNoTrousers · 15/03/2023 18:22

My mum also died young

Just enjoy life while you can. Yes we're likely to have to keep on working if the job market will still have us!

Weedoormatnomore · 15/03/2023 18:16

Mammyloveswine · 15/03/2023 16:28

My mam died at 67 so I'll probs die before retirement tbh!

My mum thought that as so many direct female relations died before they got to 63. 65 this year🤞 has to wait another 18mths for her pension.

MsJD · 15/03/2023 18:16

When I was at school (late 70s), our economic teacher told us that by the time we reached his age, people would work for fun and the working week would be 3 days or less. He imagined that machines would do all the work and we would all be living lives full of leisure.

Aposterhasnoname · 15/03/2023 18:14

Dotjones · 15/03/2023 15:58

YANBU they're trying to get back to the idea of work until you're about to die and maybe have a couple of years hanging around until you do.

The problem is that the boomer generation were able to acquire wealth to a degree that is not widely possible these days. A boomer colleague retired recently at 54 mainly because they had a final salary pension that the company bought them out of (millions) and because they'd bought a house at 21 so were mortgage free by the time they were 40. An impossible dream these days.

You don’t know what a boomer is do you?

Zippedydoo123 · 15/03/2023 18:11

The snag with retiring too early when we are still fit is that it is very common to develop social anxiety. It can be deskilling and you can lose your confidence. This has happened to so many people I have met over the years since working from home.

I will still have to work when I am 67. I am 60 in November though do not feel it. I think working reduced hours keeps us young and healthy.

Fifi0000 · 15/03/2023 18:03

The person terms are much worse now my DF has a final salary scheme same as Grandparents they don't exist anymore for the younger generation. Let's not make out it hasn't changed for the worse.

OP posts:
Fifi0000 · 15/03/2023 18:02

I have money paid into pension but there's talk of you not being allowed to draw it until later definitely not 55 as is allowed now. I don't feel there's any benefits for my DD really I feel society is sliding backwards. Housing is less affordable we have managed to ensure she will have help with that and then the pension situation will probably be worse and with no NHS.

OP posts:
saltinesandcoffeecups · 15/03/2023 18:01

Kabalagala · 15/03/2023 17:04

But it's not just down to personal responsibility is it. Pension schemes have all been downgraded, housing is more expensive and mortgage terms are longer, theres less social housing etc etc. I don't begrudge anyone doing what's right for them but let's not pretend that a lot of it isn't luck. I can be as responsible as I like, my pension terms are still worse.

All of those can be true and at the same time someone can prioritize their savings for retirement and their circumstances to allow for it.

Will everyone be successful with an earlier retirement, of course not. Will some have it easier than other, yep.

It comes down to the same thing as those who better cars, bigger families, better jobs, salaries, houses, holidays, or early retirement .

My suggestion to the OP and anyone else in the same age range is to sit down and come up with a plan if they don’t want to wait until gov’t funded retirement age.

Mistletoewench · 15/03/2023 17:54

PriOn1 · 15/03/2023 16:26

My parents have also had a long retirement. I’m 54 and my health is already deteriorating, but I have sixteen years left to work. I think the generation above ours got lucky in terms of housing being more affordable and being able to survive with only one parent working. I think the post war period was a time when men who were fit to work were at a premium and people were seen as more valuable, hence the introduction of free healthcare, better pensions and so on.

My father also ended up retiring early at a time when age and experience rather suddenly stopped being considered valuable, and when younger people suddenly began to be promoted earlier. He was in teaching and suddenly headteachers were expected to be young and dynamic and not experienced and wise. He didn’t want to retire, but was told he had to reapply for his job and might get demoted in a job where pension depended upon your final wage.

Really it’s little wonder there is less money available now, if his generation were widely thrown out of employment ten years early and had to be paid for all that time. He would happily have been productive for another ten years.

Life feels a lot worse now than it was when my parents retired, but I suspect their generation was a blip, rather than the norm. My grandfathers both had much shorter retirements

That’s such a shame about your father. I’ve got such fond memories of wise, older headteachers from my school days. Sometimes change is definitely not for the better

Hellybelly84 · 15/03/2023 17:53

If you are healthy and we are living longer (I know thats by no means guaranteed and should never be taken for granted), I actually dont want to retire early. The thought of retiring in my 50’s just seems way too young these days (obviously each to their own).

Holidays/hobbies are great but theres only so much time/money you can spend on those. Also, I think the difference for those in our 30’s/40’s now is that all our friends around us will also be working too, so it wont feel unusual to still be working. I work with alot of people now in their 60’s who love working and have a family member still working into their 70’s.

Also…I have watched my retired neighbours clean out the car and cut the grass as a team for many years (me and my Hubby joke about this whenever we’re doing jobs together) and that has possibly it put me off retirement🤣

Acheyknees · 15/03/2023 17:53

I hope to continue working in some capacity until my late 60's. For me, I'm at my best mentally and physically if I'm working. I plan to do a job that has always interested me but is very low paid and seasonal. The thought of retiring in my 50s and cruising does not appeal at all.

Tittyfilarious81 · 15/03/2023 17:52

@Ringmaster27 that's not 40 years of contribution it's 40 years left to contribute the remaining years you need which is 35 so I'm guessing you are 28 so 40 years til you are 68 , if you look on your forecast it will tell you how many full years you already have