Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Toddler sharing

39 replies

QWERTTY · 15/03/2023 15:45

So I know toddlers can’t share till they’re older because their brains haven’t developed, but what do you actually do in the scenario when they ‘need’ to but aren’t willing?

Playgroup first thing this morning. My child (just turned 3) had a toy fire engine for a while, another child wanted it so I got my child to give them the toy because she had had it for a period of time and it ended in absolute chaos with my daughter having a huge tantrum on the floor and in the end we had to leave because she just couldn’t reconcile herself. Everyone was staring at me, no one said a kind word and not even any friendly ‘we know how you feel’ smiles. I felt like I had wronged my daughter by making her give up the toy in a way but I feel like if I hadn’t then the other child wouldn’t have gotten an go with the fire engine and that wouldn’t be right either. The other child’s mother didn’t say anything whilst it all happened so they clearly felt their child should have the toy, which is fine.

so what do you actually do in these scenarios? I feel like a terrible parent who has failed either way and that’s what everyone else was thinking.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NotCopingWell1 · 20/03/2023 08:55

It's hard I can totally relate as I would do something like this feeling societal pressure in the room and then regret it afterwards.

I think if your child is playing with a toy and no one else is interested just let them crack on. If someone comes over interested say 'oh I think so and so wants a turn, let's have two more minutes and then let them have a go' and then do the reminders. Easy to think oh gosh must share must share when someone wanders over but what feels like a long time to you making them wait probably isn't actually that long. I am often delighted when DD chooses the toys which the other children clearly think are boring. Means I don't have to deal with this usually!

QWERTTY · 20/03/2023 08:47

Thank you every for your responses - will be having a proper read through. But from a quick skin so far it seems as though I was being utterly unreasonable and will be taking your advice into account, teaching about taking turns, giving warnings and sometimes saying you don’t have to share.

thank you to all of your for your kind and thoughtful responses. Xx

OP posts:
Grasshopper30 · 19/03/2023 08:36

When my son was little I went with the Montessori approach. I didn't make him share, if another child wanted what he was playing with I (and our group of friends did the same) just said "Billie (not his name) hasn't finished playing with it yet, as soon as he does, you can have a go." And we waited until the chid had finished. I remember reading about the philosophy and it said "imagine you are in the middle of doing something on a computer and someone just walks up and deletes it, how would you feel?!" It really resonated and from then on I didn't force him. As he got older and started to share I praised him when he did. He's 7 now, and despite being an only child is a lovely sharer.

Roselilly36 · 18/03/2023 18:46

Don’t be hard on yourself OP, or your toddler, how would she now how to share if they haven’t had experience of sharing? All part of learning. Definitely nothing to worry about.

Welshmonster · 18/03/2023 18:27

The other kid needed to learn to wait that they can’t have what they want straight away. Kids want to play with whatever other kids are playing with rather than all the other cool toys laying on the floor. The other kids mom should have entertained their own kid with a different toy.

thewrongcolourcup · 18/03/2023 09:42

Nursery teacher here 👋🏼

this is so common and I’m supporting lots of families with this. Post covid our support networks need building up to help nurture parents and little ones.
I agree with a pre warning, otherwise chaos will happen.
also teaching your child to say ‘I’m not finished playing with it yet’ and ‘can I have it when you are finished?’ Really does empower them to navigate conflicts over toys.
hang on in there, most adults were probably relieved it wasn’t their child having a tantrum.

LucyLeave · 17/03/2023 22:31

I wouldn't have made her share it.

Rootingforcatherinecawood · 17/03/2023 22:29

Stuff everyone else, this stuff is hard and it's hard for you and you dd. It's not that important in the greater scheme of things, it will happen to all the dcs and all the dm and dds, I would try to not think about it - it's a normal stage in development, anyone who has an issue with what happened to you is lucky it hasn't happened to them yet or doesn't give a whatsit so please try not to over think it. I'd say good try at dealing with a tricky situation, well done both of you, whatever to everyone else! Xxx

NeverMindTryAgain · 17/03/2023 22:11

The thing is. There is no right way to do it. If you force your child to share, the gentle parents will come for you and tell you all about Montessori and the trust and attachment and the cortisol and the stress!

If you don't force your child to share the traditional parents will come for you and tell you about rods for your back and raising a brat and social norms!

Just do the best you can at the time, that can look wildly variable on a day to day basis. Do what works for you and your little one without adhering to anyone else's method. The other parents probably weren't saying anything because they were too busy worrying about keeping their own kids under control 😂

Noodles1234 · 17/03/2023 21:36

A warning would be a good idea, something like another 5 minutes (or 1/2/3), then we will let another child have a go while we look for the next fun toy.

Most parents don’t say much as I think they know what it’s like and last thing some parents want is other parents over fussing, we all know (or will know), what it’s like at some point.

BadNomad · 17/03/2023 21:32

I think you need to distinguish between "sharing" and "taking turns". You can only share things that belong to you. They are yours, and you are being kind when you let others temporarily have them. You have the right to be upset when other people take them without your permission.

Taking turns is different. It's about manners. You take turns with items which don't belong to you because you do not have more rights over them than anyone else.

I think it's important for children to learn the difference.

InWalksBarberalla · 17/03/2023 21:09

Corcomroe · 15/03/2023 16:54

OP, this is of no help but might amuse you. I’m tired and I genuinely read your title as being about ‘toddler-sharing’, along the lines of job-sharing, and found myself thinking about the advantages of sharing someone small, shouty and uncooperative with another family…

I read it the same way originally too! My DC are way past toddler age and was thinking I'd be up for some toddler sharing - they are so adorable and amusing in small doses.

Gincan · 17/03/2023 21:05

My just turned 3 year old would have done exactly the same thing. I wouldn't generally take a toy off her, I spend most of the time trying to stop her taking toys off other kids 😬don't worry about it, every kid in there will have thrown a tantrum at some stage

JudgeRudy · 17/03/2023 21:04

I have mixed views on sharing. Turn taking is a form of sharing and I feel we all need to learn to do this, initially from rule following (2 more goes) but later through empathy snd social conditioning.
I do think though some parents are out of order sometimes though especially with older children. For example cousins come round with your sister and you essentially give them free range to all your children's toys. I disagree with that. I also think if you have a bag or sweets you shouldn't be forced to share. No one would dream of doing that to an adult. Imagine if your friend called round with her husband and you lent him OH jumper or drill!
I think your main mistake here was you did not warn your child or offer any alternative. It's good though you're thinking about it for next time. I actually think many of the other parents DID feel for you, you were just too flustered to notice.

Crackingoldjob · 17/03/2023 20:35

I have to say I agree with your 3 year old 🤷🏻‍♀️ I don't agree with forcing children to share like this, had she have been the other child waiting for it, would you have told them to share or asked her to wait until they had finished playing with it and find something else. I think if you wouldn't go up to someone and say 'I want that right now' and expect to it to be handed over, you can't expect children to stop their playing/learning/exploring/processing instantaneously either. They have to be allowed to naturally end their play 🤷🏻‍♀️

DidyouNO · 17/03/2023 16:10

Going against the grain here. I'm not a great fan of sharing in this instance.
This smacks of the other child being taught to 'politely take a toy from another child' She was playing with it, maybe a story in her head, her hands exploring it and then because another child decides they want it she has to stop. But she would have put it down eventually and there were plenty of other toys there for the other child, who had not yet connected with the girls toy. Who's saying the other child would have got such enjoyment? Of course we need to teach them taking turns. But that's for a game of snakes and ladders. We also need to teach them to wait their turn too!
The way I see it;

  1. An adult borrows a magazine at the doctors. Another adult stands over you until you have to give the magazine up?? No. No way but we teach our kids this is ok?
  2. you're queuing at a museum and everyone want to see a special painting. The line allows you to view for 2 minutes before moving on. Then yes, in this special scenario, time frames, move, share, take turns etc. but no. I wouldn't have stepped in there.
Wavescrashingonthebeach · 17/03/2023 15:45

Ahhhh don't worry about it, and I honestly don't care if people think I'm a soft parent. I won't have a go at my son for age appropriate behaviour, unless hes taking the P and he knows it. But there's things I care about that other parents don't seem to, like putting our wrappers etc in the bin instead of just leaving them on the table for staff to collect. Yes I know that's their job but I think getting toddlers in the habit of putting rubbish in the bin will pay dividends in the future.
But we all lose our rag sometimes we're all only human, apologies for any typos in my msgs if I don't type really fast MN inserts a million paragraphs into my reply drives me mad!

VeryLowTum · 15/03/2023 18:47

Or if you took a book out of the library which was a new release and in demand, but you decided to keep it at home for six months as you wanted to reread it a few times.

VeryLowTum · 15/03/2023 18:46

RiverRock22 · 15/03/2023 18:14

I read somewhere that we expect toddlers to abide by social requirements that we wouldn't be happy with yourself. E.g. if you were using your phone and someone said you've been using that for a while, let Tom have it for a while. We wouldn't be happy as we have no say in the interaction and something is just taken off us as it's perceived we have finished playing with it.

But they're not at home with their own toys, they've gone somewhere with communal stuff to be shared. So it's not like being asked to share your mobile. It's more like if you went to a theme park and just wanted to stay on a rollercoaster for hours without getting off when others were waiting for their turn.

RiverRock22 · 15/03/2023 18:14

I read somewhere that we expect toddlers to abide by social requirements that we wouldn't be happy with yourself. E.g. if you were using your phone and someone said you've been using that for a while, let Tom have it for a while. We wouldn't be happy as we have no say in the interaction and something is just taken off us as it's perceived we have finished playing with it.

Outwiththenorm · 15/03/2023 18:10

Our DS has only really ‘got’ the sharing thing now he’s 4.5 and even then when he’s almost good and ready to give something up. At 3 I say let her hog the toy but then praise her hugely when she’s had enough and another kid gets a go. She’ll get the idea.

Be reassured that every one of those other parents have been in this position at some point and I guarantee their main thought was ‘thank god that’s not me this week’.

VeryLowTum · 15/03/2023 18:05

Don't feel bad, the only way anyone on this thread knows useful strategies is because we've all spent time getting it very wrong! You sound like a lovely parent.

I have two toddlers I'd be happy to share out especially between about 4-6pm every day.

MelchiorsMistress · 15/03/2023 17:00

You could take a little 2 minute egg timer along to use as a visual cue that her turn is nearly finished along with the verbal cues if this keeps being a problem Get it out when another child says they want they toy and make sure your dd sees that someone else is waiting. There’s nothing wrong with making another child wait for your child to finish their turn.

Corcomroe · 15/03/2023 16:54

OP, this is of no help but might amuse you. I’m tired and I genuinely read your title as being about ‘toddler-sharing’, along the lines of job-sharing, and found myself thinking about the advantages of sharing someone small, shouty and uncooperative with another family…

QWERTTY · 15/03/2023 16:51

Thank you all for being so lovely. X

OP posts: