Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there should be a higher minimum age for face tattoos

213 replies

salutsandy · 15/03/2023 13:19

I think a face tattoo is such a huge decision that there should be a higher minimum age, say 25 or 30, for this. AIBU?

OP posts:
MistressoftheDarkSide · 15/03/2023 19:23

I'm sorry, but I find that comparison in extremely poor taste.

There is a world of difference between the two things.

And I say that as someone who has supported several family members through cancer, with everything it implies.

Scoobydoobydoobydoo0987 · 15/03/2023 19:22

GoodChat · 15/03/2023 13:38

They should be illegal. I don't see a benefit of a face tattoo.

100% agree. There's just no reason for it. I have a tattoo on my wrist, which I got in my teen years, I deeply regret this and will soon be starting the process to remove it. I think if it was on my face, I would be severely depressed.

GoodChat · 15/03/2023 19:19

Am particularly gobsmacked by the idea of psych evaluations before having a facial tattoo and the subtle implication that there is something mentally aberrant about such a choice.

My DM had to have a psych evaluation before she was allowed a mastectomy when she had breast cancer. Does that give you a little bit of perspective?

WigglyWigglyWiggly · 15/03/2023 19:13

JarByTheDoor · 15/03/2023 14:19

Pragmatically, if removing a facial tattoo means that someone will be more socially successful and happier with themselves, leading to improved mental health and less need for NHS services on that front, and also more likely to be able to get and keep a job and pay taxes, then it makes sense financially for the state to pay for that removal.

I've met people with some… particularly ill -advised facial tattoos, obtained during periods of their lives when general public acceptability and employability were not at the top of their personal priority lists, but people change. If you can't get a job with a swastika tattooed on your forehead or (symbolic) teardrops tattooed on your cheeks, how are you going to pay to get it removed so you can get a job?

Pragmatically, having excessively large breasts crushes your entire body and causes untold pain and medical issues. Pragmatically, breast reduction should be a higher priority than tattoo removal because it’s not self-inflicted, isn’t solely cosmetic and can’t be covered up by makeup. But I guess men are the ones with tattoos on their faces more often than women and women are the ones with unbearable pain caused by large breasts (whilst men get their breasts reduced with no medical need whatsoever) so I guess that’s why, pragmatically, breast reduction doesn’t get funding.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 15/03/2023 19:11

From Google:

Imply means to suggest or to say something in an indirect way. Infer means to suppose or come to a conclusion especially based on an indirect suggestion.

So the inference here is that someone requesting a cosmetic procedure such as a facial tattoo needs psych evaluation with the conclusion they are less likely to be able to make that decision without lots of support and guidance?

Everything that carries a risk should indeed be discussed and explained by the person carrying out the procedure and the client, or patient if it's a medical procedure and all professions, including tattooists do this prior to said procedure.

There is a Tattoist and Piercing Union that campaigns for high industry standards. They liaise with councils around rules and regulations.

Did you know that the procedures around piercings for example, involve making sure ID is authentic, that parental consent is obtained on those wanting piercings who are not 18? That most reputable piercers won't pierce the ears of anyone under secondary school age? That a form has to be filled in with medical and allergen information? (Literally 20 questions if I recall). That every year a First Aid course is undertaken? Because without these things the public liability insurance could be null and void if something did go wrong?

My tattooist friends do similar. It is their livelihood and their art and they want to be safe, responsible and successful.

Extreme body modifications are already outlawed in the UK. As they should be I hear you cry, because tongue splitting and ear pointing is closer to medical procedure than adornment and carries greater risk. You can still go abroad for it though.

Professional tattooists usually have lengthy discussions with their clients about their art before going ahead. And they are within their rights to refuse a client if they are uncomfortable about anything, as are piercers.

I'm allowed to be gobsmacked that the old trope that tattoos / piercings indicate mental weakness is still being trotted out despite the fact that they have been mainstream since the 90s.

As for Botox (a poison) and fake tans from sun beds (cancer risk?) or anything else if that nature - your body, your choice, risks explained, professional indemnity in place, all hunkydory.

The question of what age someone should get a facial tattoo is down to them once they are 18, already enshrined in law, and they have to live with the consequences.

Just because other people don't like it doesn't mean it should be pathologised and considered the downfall of civilisation 🙄

ClassicLib · 15/03/2023 19:09

No, of course not. YABU.

18 is the age of majority in the U.K., and on that birthday you assume the rights and responsibilities of adulthood, including the rights to vote, marry, die for your country and to deface your own body should you so wish.

The current tendency to infantilise 18-21 year olds is ridiculous. If someone had tried to tell me not to get a tattoo, or whatever else, at that age they would have received a very blunt two word response.

Blossomtoes · 15/03/2023 19:06

I used to work for an NHS trust which had a uniform policy that forbade all visible tattoos. I bet they’ve had to can that now.

MrsTerryPratchett · 15/03/2023 19:05

Am particularly gobsmacked by the idea of psych evaluations before having a facial tattoo and the subtle implication that there is something mentally aberrant about such a choice. Would you suggest that for those who come from a cultural tradition of facial tattoos? Think very carefully about your biases if you would.

Well it's transgressive in some cultures and a status symbol and cultural identifier in others. In the first cultures it is correlated with personality disorders and psychopathy. In the second it's not.

This can't be a huge surprise.

Fluffygreenslippers · 15/03/2023 19:00

surely it depends on the tattoo? A huge bat across your forehead is a lot more striking then a small dot on your face or something. My sister has two face tattoos. She works full time in a school as a receptionist.

GoodChat · 15/03/2023 18:59

salutsandy · 15/03/2023 18:54

In many cultures tattoos are highly important part of life. They date back to ancient Egyptian age, hardly a new phenomenon.
Facial tattoos are really common and highly regarded in many countries - of course it should be illegal though cos Sandra from Milton Keynes “doesn’t see the benefit”

But nobody's saying it should be illegal - just whether an older age to make this decision would be more sensible. Also, we don't live in a culture where facial tattoos are highly regarded, that's the reality.

Some of us have said it should be illegal.

If it's cultural that's different, but British people of British heritage who get facial tattoos then complain it's affecting their job prospects are idiots.

Whatwouldscullydo · 15/03/2023 18:58

Sure, but each individual drink isn't having those effects

We don't really know this do we. We can't garuntee that there arent undiagnosed underlying conditions that mean drinking at all could cause harm. If your drink is spiked who knows what happens.

Snakebites were banned in pubs because of how sick.they could make.people..in those not used to alcohol it could take very little to give adverse effects many of which wed not know about until it caused an issue could he years down the line.

Cars are a huge cause of accidents but we let 17 year olds drive them but a 24 year old married man with 2 kids would be deemed unable to consent to a face tattoo? if he wasn't mowed down by a 17 year old on the way

IHaveaSetOfVeryParticularSkills · 15/03/2023 18:56

There was a strong presidential candidate in one eu country with full face tatoos. Iirc he was a well regarded super intelligent professor.

salutsandy · 15/03/2023 18:54

In many cultures tattoos are highly important part of life. They date back to ancient Egyptian age, hardly a new phenomenon.
Facial tattoos are really common and highly regarded in many countries - of course it should be illegal though cos Sandra from Milton Keynes “doesn’t see the benefit”

But nobody's saying it should be illegal - just whether an older age to make this decision would be more sensible. Also, we don't live in a culture where facial tattoos are highly regarded, that's the reality.

OP posts:
MargaritMargo · 15/03/2023 18:49

In many cultures tattoos are highly important part of life. They date back to ancient Egyptian age, hardly a new phenomenon.

Facial tattoos are really common and highly regarded in many countries - of course it should be illegal though cos Sandra from Milton Keynes “doesn’t see the benefit”

JarByTheDoor · 15/03/2023 18:48

Whatwouldscullydo · 15/03/2023 18:28

They're not comparable activities, in terms of frequency, likely long-term consequences, or amount of forethought a typical person might think appropriate before embarking on them

See thats the thing. Alcohol causes all sorts of issues.many of which have the potential to be lifelong. Alcohol kills people. How many die from a tattoo? Im.sure the numbers would be far less. A Saturday night in a&e full of drunks who have been spiked, drunk too much, fallen over and hurt themselves etc thats vefire we get to deaths from alcohol poisoning , drunk driving which has the potential to take others down with you and hypothermia/exposure from passing out and spending the night outside in evening wear.

Vs the odd infection from a tattoo.

One may be more socially acceptable ( who bats an eyelid at a table full of friends having a laugh and a drink) but as far as harm temporarily or permanently and deaths alcohol is well up there isn't it?

Sure, but each individual drink isn't having those effects.

pointythings · 15/03/2023 18:40

@Blossomtoes nope, still disagree. People are free to make daft choices in all other walks of life. Tattoos should be no different, whether facial or otherwise.

Ludo19 · 15/03/2023 18:36

I love tattoos I have mainly opted for cats and recently had hieroglyphics covered by a beautiful cat. I personally wouldn't have my face done. The tattoo artist that I go to has one on her forehead and she looks amazing but it's definitely not my thing.

JarByTheDoor · 15/03/2023 18:33

Am particularly gobsmacked by the idea of psych evaluations before having a facial tattoo and the subtle implication that there is something mentally aberrant about such a choice.

I think that's an inference rather than an implication. Any time you get dentistry done, or a smear, or anything, the practitioner is ideally using their dental, medical or nursing training to make sure that you're able to understand what you're having done and the potential consequences. Obviously tattooists can't be expected to have the training to do that or to take on the professional liability, which means non-medical body modification like tattoos is being held to a lower standard than botox (which has to be prescribed by someone who can prescribe drugs, even if someone else actually injects it). If you wanted that type of body modification held to the same standard as botox, then you'd need prospective clients assessed by someone who's qualified to make that kind of judgement. Do you think anyone who gets botox (or dental work, or a smear) is mentally aberrant?

If you're gobsmacked by ideas just being discussed, not even advocated, then I don't know what to suggest… perhaps avoid discussion boards?

Whatwouldscullydo · 15/03/2023 18:28

They're not comparable activities, in terms of frequency, likely long-term consequences, or amount of forethought a typical person might think appropriate before embarking on them

See thats the thing. Alcohol causes all sorts of issues.many of which have the potential to be lifelong. Alcohol kills people. How many die from a tattoo? Im.sure the numbers would be far less. A Saturday night in a&e full of drunks who have been spiked, drunk too much, fallen over and hurt themselves etc thats vefire we get to deaths from alcohol poisoning , drunk driving which has the potential to take others down with you and hypothermia/exposure from passing out and spending the night outside in evening wear.

Vs the odd infection from a tattoo.

One may be more socially acceptable ( who bats an eyelid at a table full of friends having a laugh and a drink) but as far as harm temporarily or permanently and deaths alcohol is well up there isn't it?

Blossomtoes · 15/03/2023 18:06

pointythings · 15/03/2023 17:42

@Blossomtoes tattoos should be illegal? Sorry, but that's ridiculous. An insane infringement on people's freedoms. And no, I don't have any tattoos. My adult children do though, and they are all about emotionally significant events.

No, I didn’t say that. I think facial tattoos should be illegal. Obviously it would be beyond ridiculous to outlaw them completely, even I’m not that bonkers! Our adult kids are real outliers, there isn’t a single tattoo between the four of them.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 15/03/2023 18:06

Good Lord, is this still rumbling on?

It seems like a clear stalemate between the authoritarian and the libertarian.

Isn't it a case of live and let live at the end of the day?

Most professional tattooists and piercers have professional insurance and environmental health licenses. The age at which you can have a tattoo is 18, the same age at which you are allowed to vote and do myriad other things that come with the age of majority.

Am particularly gobsmacked by the idea of psych evaluations before having a facial tattoo and the subtle implication that there is something mentally aberrant about such a choice. Would you suggest that for those who come from a cultural tradition of facial tattoos? Think very carefully about your biases if you would.

I can hear the whataboutery and false equivalency arguments from here, so spare me the whole "but but FGM / widows on funeral pyres" or whatever you might want to chuck into the mix.

Body art and adornment chosen by an individual harms no-one.

Tattooists refuse those who are drunk or on drugs routinely as it is because alcohol thins the blood to start with, and yes, impairs decision making.

Tattooists and piercers are already heavily regulated and choose their specialties- some may do faces, some don't.

The way some people are commenting here suggests every second 18 year old is sporting facial tattoos and as a result the economy will collapse due to their un -employability.

Out of dozens of tattooed people I know, about three have facial tattoos and two of them are tattooists. All of them are older than 18 and none of them are criminals, unemployed or otherwise "undesirable".

JarByTheDoor · 15/03/2023 18:03

Whatwouldscullydo · 15/03/2023 16:19

How would you justify precious scarce appointments being taken up by currenty healthy people who want a tattoo?

Do you leave one half done because the second appointment Couldn't be squeezed in before the expiry date ?

A certificate valid fir a week is still no indication of capacity the day after it was issued.

If family haven't acted to protect that person, ( ive worked in a place where carer/cops or whatever have actually come in and told us not to serve this person) hows the responsibility now on the tattooist and his/her signed consent form?

There are things the family akd friends could do if concerned. Why don't they? Whys it ok to pass that responsibility onto a stranger and blame them.imstead.

I used the words "pay for" deliberately — despite NHS scarcity, there always seems to be a willing pool of professionals to do easy private work. If you think that some people have temporary or permanent barriers to being able to give free and fully informed consent to body modification and you think those people should be protected from having body modifications that may harm them or which they may regret, then this sort of thing could potentially be a reasonable use of resources. But should be paid for by the individual, not by the NHS.

The specifics you mention — yes, I suppose if you had a system like this and someone didn't plan things well, they'd have to leave their tattoo half-done until they could renew their certificate.

And the week-long certificate example was purely an aside based on my own flavour of crazy 🤣 — it's highly unlikely that I would happen to get that certificate in the precise 1–6 day period before I went crazy, and if I did, well, I'd have wanted a tattoo when I was sane anyway, so it probably wouldn't be that much of a disaster… I mostly added that idea because I thought that it was only fair, if I was thinking about a system that would restrict liberties, to think about how it might restrict mine more than most.

But again I think you're mistaking my list of possibilities for a list of things I'm advocating for. It's not. I don't have a dog in this race, or more pertinently, skin in this game. It was a list of things that would be technically possible to require people to do before getting a body modification, that would be less feasible to require people to do because they fancy nipping in the local for a swift half, because a poster was comparing getting a tattoo with ordering a drink. They're not comparable activities, in terms of frequency, likely long-term consequences, or amount of forethought a typical person might think appropriate before embarking on them.

I find this area of ethics and stuff interesting, but like a lot of ethics it's complex and doesn't always lend itself to neat, simple laws and regulation.

WindowGazers · 15/03/2023 17:58

unclebuck · 15/03/2023 17:13

I did a survey of all my customers and the comments re face/neck/hand tattoos and septum piercings surprised me - most over 40s and almost all under 15 hated and or found them scary.

I can't imagine being over 40 and being scared of a tattoo, unless I had lead a very sheltered life. Who are your customers out of curiosity?

Oblomov23 · 15/03/2023 17:50

Agreed. It's a massive decision and shouldn't be taken lightly. Most tattoos I see are poor, poor quality. Most footballers ones are awful. I like a good one.

MrsR87 · 15/03/2023 17:46

GoodChat · 15/03/2023 13:38

They should be illegal. I don't see a benefit of a face tattoo.

I’m glad I’m not the only one who thinks this. I can’t think of any benefits (that you can’t get from something else) of a face tattoo. They do have documented negative consequences like poor employment prospects.