Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there should be a higher minimum age for face tattoos

213 replies

salutsandy · 15/03/2023 13:19

I think a face tattoo is such a huge decision that there should be a higher minimum age, say 25 or 30, for this. AIBU?

OP posts:
malificent7 · 16/03/2023 08:27

They should not be illegal....whatever next? Face piercings made illegal too? Just because YOU don't see a benefit...for others it's about self expression. I think society needs to get over this but the individual also needs to be mature enough to realise that people will judge so yes...the age limit should be raised.

I don't like them myself but if others want one...crack on. I'm more likely to judge by personality.

Northernsouloldies · 16/03/2023 08:17

DemonSpawn · 15/03/2023 14:15

Face and hand tattoos used to be so rare because it was very hard to get a tattooist that would do them - there used to be an etiquette and unwritten rules.

In the 70s/80s the only face or hand tattoos you would see would be home-made prison tattoos.

Usually one had to have most of the rest of their body tattooed before a professional tattooist would consider it.

Since the explosion in popularity of tattoos there’s been an explosion in tattooists (not surprising given the prices they can charge) and no regard for the historical etiquette and unwritten rules.

Similarly there also used to be an etiquette where your tattooist would re-colour your tattoos for no cost when they faded - bet that no longer exists.

All of the is so true, that made me think of some of the skinheads in the 70s early 80s faired with having a swastika inked on their forehead, cos at surely got to be a regret.

Brefugee · 16/03/2023 07:44

I suspect that is caused by the current fashion for infantilizing young people rather than anything physiological.

you can suspect all you like. There are several (dozen) papers and studies and very very experienced not to say highly qualified people who have independently, and together come to this conclusion. They didn't pull it out of their backsides. Your apparent self-belief that you know better than the (neuro)scientific community makes me wonder if you're 25 yet... (not really, that was goady, but you are infuriating)

JarByTheDoor · 15/03/2023 23:10

WigglyWigglyWiggly · 15/03/2023 19:13

Pragmatically, having excessively large breasts crushes your entire body and causes untold pain and medical issues. Pragmatically, breast reduction should be a higher priority than tattoo removal because it’s not self-inflicted, isn’t solely cosmetic and can’t be covered up by makeup. But I guess men are the ones with tattoos on their faces more often than women and women are the ones with unbearable pain caused by large breasts (whilst men get their breasts reduced with no medical need whatsoever) so I guess that’s why, pragmatically, breast reduction doesn’t get funding.

I think maybe I didn't make it clear to you what I meant by "pragmatically". I didn't use that word accidentally — I deliberately chose to discuss what might be pragmatic rather than what might be compassionate or medically needed or deserved, because you're right that when it comes to compassion or medical need or deserving, there are many things which might feel more pressing but which aren't provided.

I was referring to what might be considered practical and cost-efficient by those running the country and deciding what gets funded. Assuming that availability of NHS facial tattoo removal wouldn't incentivise extra people to get tattoos, then it's likely that offering a limited facial tattoo removal service would result in a net gain for the country, possibly via reduced mental healthcare costs and more likely via reduced benefits payouts and increased tax revenue from the now more-employable patient. So funding facial tattoo removal could well be a pragmatic policy, though you might not consider it to be as principled or as compassionate a policy as providing breast reductions.

It's also possible that offering breast reductions would be a pragmatic policy, of course, as well as being principled and compassionate. Regardless, it's pretty much beside the point whether breast reductions are more necessary, more compassionate, or more pragmatic — my post was just about whether, on a purely practical national moneysaving/moneyraising economic basis, it could be a good idea to offer NHS facial tattoo removal in certain circumstances.

BTW my tits are massive and hurt my back, and I don't have a facial tattoo, so I'm not making any of these points for any personal reason.

housemaus · 15/03/2023 22:47

I don't have a face tattoo and don't particularly like the look of them but I don't know why they're see as somehow worse than other tattoos. Is it because they can't be hidden easily? Because then that's just back to thinking tattoos are bad and should be hidden, which... seems a bit nonsensical and outdated.

Unless the tattoo itself reveals something negative about someone (Nazi symbol, misspelling, 10 ex girlfriends' names crossed out, etc) then I really don't see the issue.

FWIW I work in a reasonably stuffy industry and all four directors of our business have tattoos that are visible to some extent day to day (none on the face though, altough one has tattooed hands and neck). It's never been the slightest issue.

Florenz · 15/03/2023 22:46

You can't have an age of majority, when you become an adult, and then say you're too young, but still an adult, to do certain things. Maybe the age of majority should be raised to 21.

Liorae · 15/03/2023 22:44

Brefugee · 15/03/2023 15:55

I don't swallow that "brain doesn’t mature until 25" stuff. My peers and i were all working full-time and living away from our parents at 18.

that's up to you. Psychologists and people who study brains for a living agree that a brain isn't fully mature, and firing on all cylinders until it is between around 23 and 25 years of age.

I suspect that is caused by the current fashion for infantilizing young people rather than anything physiological.

housemaus · 15/03/2023 22:42

Blossomtoes · 15/03/2023 14:15

Took the words out of my mouth. They should be illegal. I can’t see any benefit from any tattoo.

Can you see the benefit of music? Or paintings? What about hair dye or makeup? What about wallpaper?

Whether or not you personally like the look of them, tattoos are a form of art, they're a form of making your body look a certain way because it makes you happy, and they're a form of decoration.

All the things above are also 'pointless' in that they don't serve a purpose other than to make us happy or make something more beautiful (in the eye of the beholder, of course - art that one person thinks is gorgeous might be of no interest to someone else).

We could live in houses with bare plaster and no art on the walls. We could never have music or films or paintings. We could insist everyone has to keep their natural hair colour and never use makeup... but we don't, because we get about 80 years if we're lucky to try and enjoy ourselves and get a bit of joy and we may as well feel good about how we look and what we look at.

CrosswordConundrum · 15/03/2023 22:37

People mature at different ages. I’d personally be concerned about most late teens having a face tattoo as it’s so obvious/permanent and I know how much I’ve changed since that time, however I’m on the fence about increasing age limit.

I might be harsh and don’t know how common this is (suspect not) but I’m not comfortable with NHS tattoo removal. If you’re old enough to decide and pay for it, you are old enough to pay for private removal. Self-inflicted cosmetics.

JarByTheDoor · 15/03/2023 22:30

Hey thanks — I apologise for suggesting you have a persecution complex. I didn't intend to suggest that wanting a tattoo automatically means your mental state is suspect. I was playing with ideas that would potentially provide some of the protections people seem to want, without the age discrimination, but at the cost of some loss of spontaneity, a little less absolute autonomy, and of course the monetary cost of paying a nurse/doctor/whoever for a cert of some kind. It seems from what people say that a lot of the current protections around what tattoos are offered on what body part depend entirely on the discretion of the tattooist involved, as they're not dentists or nurses with the requisite healthcare-related responsibilities and shouldn't be expected to be, and I also don't think it's at all reasonable to ask them to assess medical things like whether their client is capacitous and capable of informed consent, on top of the standards they might or might not hold themselves to. Whatever you do, there'll be unethical practitioners who are willing to illegally tattoo people, though, whether it's an age limit, a medical certificate, a different age limit for different types of tattoos, or whatever.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 15/03/2023 21:56

I'm grousing about the fact that because some people don't approve of facial tattoos they are looking for ways to limit them when there is already an age restriction and the industry is aware of their impact, and are using the mental health faux concern to bolster their own prejudices.

Apologies for snapping by the way.

It's just that after a decade of being adjacent to this industry, and hearing a lot about how those who don't like tattoos and piercings make negative assumptions about said practises, and have actively made life difficult for people doing a job to high standards, I am a bit defensive.

And it's been a long day.

But anyway, my apologies.

JarByTheDoor · 15/03/2023 21:41

MistressoftheDarkSide · 15/03/2023 20:55

@JarByTheDoor

Those mechanisms already exist and are practised by professional tattooists.

Fuck off with your persecution complex comment though.

Theorising about how much extra protection the vulnerable need in the context of body art is rather indulgent when mental health and vulnerability is ignored and underfunded in the general population without tattoos.

You miss the bit where I mentioned I'm a manic-depressive? 😅 Trust me, I'm familiar with the pitiful and parlous state of mental health services in this country.

If theorising on a discussion board when not everything is already perfect is indulgent, then there's an awful lot of us indulging ourselves.

If those mechanisms already exist, though, what are you grousing about?

XenoBitch · 15/03/2023 21:05

Hilarious that someone suggests actual prison time for someone who tattoos their own face.
'Your body, your choice' extends to more than women's reproductive health.

I know someone who has face tattoos. She is a goth, and they all go beautifully with her aesthetic. They are not swastikas and random words.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 15/03/2023 20:55

@JarByTheDoor

Those mechanisms already exist and are practised by professional tattooists.

Fuck off with your persecution complex comment though.

Theorising about how much extra protection the vulnerable need in the context of body art is rather indulgent when mental health and vulnerability is ignored and underfunded in the general population without tattoos.

JarByTheDoor · 15/03/2023 20:49

@MistressoftheDarkSide — this entire thread is about whether (facial) tattoos are something that should be restricted in availability to those who are (presumed to be) more able to think through the consequences of getting them. It's all about informed consent and capacity, which happens to be something we already have mechanisms for within healthcare.

Discussing theoretical mechanisms by which we as a society could, if we wanted to, restrict the availability of facial tattoos to those who can understand the consequences and have the capacity to choose them has absolutely nothing to do with your imagined implications about people who have tattoos. I personally don't have much of an opinion about tattoos per se, but I am interested in what responsibility, if any, society has towards its more vulnerable members and what we allow others to do to/for them if they ask.

All I did was hypothesise a potential mechanism via which getting tattoos could be subject to the same capacity/informed consent standards as body modifications carried out by medical personnel, without requiring all tattooists to train as nurses or something. It's far less authoritarian than banning everyone under 25 from having facial tattoos, and I didn't even advocate for it because I don't want to advocate for it — I don't have a solid position on body modification.

I just think it's an interesting area, where longlasting or permanent physical procedures are carried out on people under a different framework to most other procedures. I didn't say everyone with tats is a loony or mentally defective or whatever it is your persecution complex is telling you, any more than everyone getting a smear test is a mentally defective loony because the nurse is trained to make sure they understand and can consent to the procedure. And you're the one choosing the loaded language of "psych evaluations" to refer to a perfectly normal, commonplace part of getting any kind of physical procedures if it's from a healthcare professional.

TheLadyofShalott1 · 15/03/2023 20:42

MistressoftheDarkSide · 15/03/2023 14:05

Face tattoos can be covered by make up.

I honestly don't understand the still visceral response to body art in general. It's seen as an indicator of so many negative stereotypes still, yet given the number of people in responsible careers - medicine and law included, who sport them, it's clear it doesn't necessarily indicate any moral failing or incapacity on the part of the person with the tattoo.

Stereotyping and othering is an absolute no no for most people, yet the heavily tattooed are considered fair game.

It's ink on the skin. It hurts no-one, nor do piercings, Botox, fake tans and hair extensions.

And honestly, considering some things that people being encouraged to do for self affirmation these days, a facial tattoo is the least thing to be concerned about, IMHO.

I have friends and some family members who have 2 or 3 body and limb tattoos, and I think that all of theirs look very pretty. But when I think back to my dear babies clear and beautiful skin, and now look at my delicious Grandbabies clear and beautiful skin, I wouldn't want anything marking their skin other than what nature intended.

Having said that, if they were to only have 2 or three colourful tattoos in quite indistinct places, and if they weren't huge, then I don't think that that would upset me. But the people who absolutely cover their skins with dark squiggles (that is all that they look like to me when they are squashed together, with maybe a smudge of dark red - once a rose or a heart? - or some other indistinguishable colour) look to me like they have just finished work down the coal mine, and are in need of a good soapy shower... People covered in tattoos also make me feel sorry for them, as I imagine that they are actually trying to hide from something, whether it is themselves, society, or even life in general.

As for facial tattoos, no, sorry, but they really should be banned. I have heard too many stories of people getting to hate their facial tattoos, some have apparently and tragically, even led to them killing themselves. Probably the best way to ban them would be a definite custodial sentence for whoever put the tattoo on the person's face, whether that was a qualified tattoo artist - they should also lose their licence - a friend, or the person themselves. If not a total ban, then I think that people wanting face tattoos should have to be at least 35 years of age, but preferably more like 50 or 60, before it would be allowed legally. Hopefully those at the later ages, might realise that their increasingly wrinkled skin is unlikely to enhance the look!

millymae · 15/03/2023 20:21

I don’t have any tattoos but really do like some of the ones I see on others and can appreciate them for what they are -very clever body art. That’s not to say though that there aren’t others I see and think ‘more money than sense’ and wonder about the mindset of the person who has it and what it will look like in future years when body shape has changed, skin wrinkled and colour faded (if it does)

Facial tattoos are on another level again. I have never seen one that doesn’t make me think unfavourably about the person and feel a little scared. My problem I know, and perhaps not helped by the fact that I can’t help wondering what those born with facial disfigurements must feel when they see people who have chosen to intentionally disfigure their face in this way.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 15/03/2023 20:11

@Whatwouldscullydo

Precisely. Well said.

TheLadyofShalott1 · 15/03/2023 19:59

GoodChat · 15/03/2023 13:38

They should be illegal. I don't see a benefit of a face tattoo.

This.

IHaveaSetOfVeryParticularSkills · 15/03/2023 19:57

Would these rules about evaluation pre act include sex and subsequent pregnancies?
Now, that would benefit many

Whatwouldscullydo · 15/03/2023 19:57

I don't have any tattoo, I just don't want the law to limit people's freedom when it isn't necessary to do so

Yes its all very well to say X Y Z shouldn't happen when its not something that would personally affect you but rights don't work like that. If you'd seen any civid threads and the number if people who thought there should be a legal mandate to have a vaccine was disturbing. Becyase the flip side is that if they can do it for one thing they can do it for some thing else and what if its something that does effect you next time.

The cost to having the rights to do what you want with your body. Have a tattoo or piercing or choose whether or not to take a medical treatment is, that someone else also has that right and may well choose something you disagree with. It doesn't just apply to things that randoms on the Internet agree with. It applies to everything. For every person who gets a stupid offensive tattoo on their face there will be many others who get something sensible/discreet or whatever. Its admirable to want to save everyone from themselves all the time
.God knows we have all needed it and may well do again. But we cant/shouldn't screw everyone else over in the process.

CableTidy · 15/03/2023 19:47

I have tattoos and I don't know any decent artist who will tattoo someone's face who isn't already heavily tattooed.

Face tattoos aren't my thing.

However people pierce babies ears and that is bloody horrific

MistressoftheDarkSide · 15/03/2023 19:40

Yes, morons as you so charmingly describe them can have their whole face coloured if they do choose - choice being the operative word here - and they pay for it both monetarily and through any consequences that might make them think twice down the line.

It's not remotely comparable to the turmoil of a cancer patient's situation where it's clear the impact is far greater and not reversible.

Tattoos can be covered by make-up or removed.

They are not life threatening nor traumatic. They affect no-one other than the person making the choice.

These comparisons are a world apart and not relevant to each other.

ZiriForEver · 15/03/2023 19:39

I am shocked by number of posts like "I don't see the value, so it should be illegal" or "there is no reason for it". Why should your personal opinion restrict someone else in their personal matters?

People have a right to decide about their bodies and I definitely see pregnancy & raising a child or joining an army as more life changing decisions. Tattoo is just an image on a skin, not a missing organ.

I don't have any tattoo, I just don't want the law to limit people's freedom when it isn't necessary to do so.

GoodChat · 15/03/2023 19:33

MistressoftheDarkSide · 15/03/2023 19:23

I'm sorry, but I find that comparison in extremely poor taste.

There is a world of difference between the two things.

And I say that as someone who has supported several family members through cancer, with everything it implies.

I assume you're talking to me?

I think it's good she had to have the evaluation, and I think anyone who's having anything done to their body that's going to affect them for the rest of their lives should have the same.

The difference is she was forced to have the evaluation for something that was going to save her life, yet morons can have their whole face coloured a different colour without any intervention.

If you think the comparison is in bad taste that's fine.

Swipe left for the next trending thread