Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think teacher is trying to put DC off

81 replies

Boogiewoogieanddance · 15/03/2023 09:27

Not sure if we ABU as parents that don't want to see DD isn't excelling but this just doesn't sit right with me.

Kids are preparing for the transfer test. We aren't pushy but ours showed an interest in doing it. At parent teacher meeting teacher advised DD doesn't do it as she thinks it would be bad for her confidence as she is toward bottom of the class and to take the choice off her. We had this conversation with her and she got upset and really wanted to give it a go. That's fine, we'll support her and help where we can, if she wants to stop prepping at any time she can.

My issue is with the practice papers and how the teacher writes the score. She puts the child percentage and then beside it the class average and where the child placed in class. Eg 45% CA75% 27TH/27.

Surely this could be information sent to the parents to review rather than writing on the child's paper for them to take home? I just think if her main concern is DDs confidence plaster over the paper she is bottom of the class isn't great. She is our eldest though so not sure if this is the norm.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Exasperatednow · 15/05/2023 22:32

I find the whole thing quite depressing. When I was in the equivalent of year 6 we would have a test on Friday and that would determine where you sat on Monday. I thought the early might have moved on.

In addition, I had one high academic flyer all the way through (now at Uni) and one who grew slowly (very average and slightly below in some area) and didn't fully flourish until half way year 10. Exceeded teacher expectations in gcse and is flying at A levels. I wish we wouldn't box children in so early.

Burgoo · 18/03/2023 18:45

For me it would be terribly demoralising. I was crap at school without being told I am last in the group!

Adarajames · 18/03/2023 18:41

I think the teacher is totally being VUR! What a cruel thing to do, tell the parents if they insist, but no need to write it for anyone to see, awful way to treat your class 😡

PollyPut · 17/03/2023 12:26

@Boogiewoogieanddance if your child is motivated to do this test and do well then surely knowing how she is actually doing will help her be motivated to work hard and improve? I'd be grateful that the teacher is being so honest - often it's very hard to get accurate information.

I'd praise your daughter's ambition and help her all you can.

Countmeout · 17/03/2023 09:01

Well @Boogiewoogieanddance its very early days and you can see how things go. Your daughter may change her mind about doing it once things get going which is obviously absolutely fine.
To go back to your original point about writing the scores on the papers in that format I think if you speak to the teacher she /he could either reflect on it and change or say she’s always done it that way and that is how it goes. Maybe she is trying to give you some idea how things sit for your daughter and hoping you reflect on your decision as she’s already had a number of discussions with you about it.
To put early scores on tests in some sort of context the high flying children were scoring 100% in the first wee tests last year (about 1/5 of the class ) . Not my class but I was aware of what was going on through having someone close doing it. Sorry that’s a bit vague but you get the gist.

Boogiewoogieanddance · 16/03/2023 14:17

@Countmeout not particularly, I would say it's pretty middle of the road and has children from lots of different backgrounds. Its a great school from what we have seen and very dedicated and well structured. We did ask and had a couple of meetings about it and gave it all alot of thought. She kept saying about her confidence but honestly I think it would be worse to not even give her a chance if she is so keen to try and prepare for it. I mentioned before that she can be so compliant and go along with things easily so for her to turn around and argue her point with us is very positive, so I think so then deny her the opportunity would be worse for her confidence.

OP posts:
MisogynyNonConforming · 16/03/2023 00:24

@Boogiewoogieanddance I agree that seems rather unnecessary.

Like a few other posters, I'm not clear on what a 'transfer test' is, but throughout my school life, the only time children were told by the teacher where they ranked was if they had come first / got 100%.

Unless the results for each child are going to be standardised according to the scores of all of the children in the class, then the placement is not of any relevance (the child could be in a class of unusually high scorers or unusually low scorers, which would skew the data).

There are some truly wonderful teachers out there, but unfortunately you do sometimes get bully types.

Countmeout · 15/03/2023 23:01

Is this a school in a very naice area or a prep @Boogiewoogieanddance ? If so some parents may want to see where their child sits in relation to others and the teacher may historically have accommodated that. However I think many of us agree we would not put it on a paper sent home.
Agree with @jujitsugrant it is very early days but am interested @jujitsugrant the standardised scores below which you would have advised parents against transfer or what you used to make that judgement.
I think I would have asked the teacher at the parent teacher meeting how she had reached her judgment that the child should not sit transfer.

Boogiewoogieanddance · 15/03/2023 22:13

@WigglyWigglyWiggly the ranking as a whole matters in relation to everyone who is sitting the test. From the small amount of research I have done over the last few days I think the schools class average is extremely high so I don't think just because she is towards the bottom of that small class means she has no hope. There is still 8 months to the actual test so lots of time for improvement aswell.

@jujitsugrant you sound lovely and have voiced how I think it should be approached.

OP posts:
WigglyWigglyWiggly · 15/03/2023 21:46

WigglyWigglyWiggly · 15/03/2023 21:45

The ranking is the only part that matters though. If she got 99% but everyone else got 100% then she’d fail. If she got 1% but everyone else got 2% then she’d pass. What’s the point in telling you the percentage she got when it’s a comparative pass threshold?

I meant if she got 1% but everyone else got 0%

WigglyWigglyWiggly · 15/03/2023 21:45

The ranking is the only part that matters though. If she got 99% but everyone else got 100% then she’d fail. If she got 1% but everyone else got 2% then she’d pass. What’s the point in telling you the percentage she got when it’s a comparative pass threshold?

Eyerollcentral · 15/03/2023 21:44

Tbf so can achieving a low mark in a test you don’t have to do

jujitsugrant · 15/03/2023 21:42

Youdoyoubabe · 15/03/2023 21:37

I think class rankings is not an unheard of way of comparing academic ability. I remember it at school and it is a helpful way to gauge where you sit within the class.

we were definitely ranked when I did professional qualifications. So I think it is pretty normal.

It has its place for sure, but these children are 9 and 10. I've seen children devastated by getting the lowest score in a spelling test. In this instance at this stage it serves no purpose academically but could cause terrible upset in a 9 year old.

Youdoyoubabe · 15/03/2023 21:37

I think class rankings is not an unheard of way of comparing academic ability. I remember it at school and it is a helpful way to gauge where you sit within the class.

we were definitely ranked when I did professional qualifications. So I think it is pretty normal.

jujitsugrant · 15/03/2023 21:34

Also 45% for only the third ever test paper? That is not bad at all. They are still getting used to the papers and test format etc.

jujitsugrant · 15/03/2023 21:28

I'm sorry I accidently voted that you are being unreasonable.

I taught P6/P7 for 6 years and so have done ALOT of transfer test prep and dealt with alot of related issues that arose.

I would never ever have placed a ranking on a paper or even shared it with parents unless specifically asked. No child needs to see that! Is this school policy? It's awful.

I used to mark the papers and put on the score, then percentage and leave it at that. I always made it very clear to each child that it was their choice if they wanted to share their scores with others in the class and noone was allowed to ask in case others felt pressure to share a score they weren't happy with.

I was an excellent tutor and teacher when it came to transfer test and the children in my class did very well. (One of the reasons I was stuck in the P6/P7 cycle for 6 years and wasn't moved). But I hated the system and it was a deciding factor in returning home (to Donegal) as I didn't want my children experiencing it. I know this sounds overly dramatic but such was the distress some of the students in my class were in during the process! In saying that I always advised parents if I thought their child wasn't capable or coping well, but ultimately the decision is between the parents and the child and aside from that conversation I wouldn't put a child off.

Anyway I've gone on a rant about the transfer now but I agree the teacher, should not have put the ranking on the test paper.

Countmeout · 15/03/2023 20:21

It’s 25% in NI @TwoPointFourCatsAndDogs .
Further complicated by an AQE score of 95-99 might get you into a grammar in some areas but in others you’d need 110 plus.

TwoPointFourCatsAndDogs · 15/03/2023 20:15

I cannot see the point in being ranked in class. Surely it’s detrimental for some children.
In my area here in the UK approximately the top 3rd get into Grammar, so it would have been useful to know what that top 3rd score was. Here all kids in the county are automatically entered and have to be withdrawn if they don’t want to sit it. I agree with PP that not prepping could leave your DD behind, assuming NI also includes Math & English elements. 11+ Tutoring is big business here, it was the worst year of our lives tutoring my DS. Good luck!

Eyerollcentral · 15/03/2023 20:11

Boogiewoogieanddance · 15/03/2023 20:07

@icanneverthinkofnc yes, she does some activities outside of school which we encourage.

@Lovewineandchocs unfortunately we missed them this year due to circumstances but we have been having a look at their websites, especially highschools rather than grammars.

@Eyerollcentral this is the problem with typing conversations isn't it, its easy to pick things up the wrong way and make an assumption of people's goals that aren't necessarily correct. Maybe a phonecall would be a better way to have a discussion with the teacher so nothing is taken the wrong way. I appreciate your input.

The teacher will already have marked you out as one of those parents who pushes their ambitions on to their child. They’ve seen it all before.

icanneverthinkofnc · 15/03/2023 20:10

Posted too quickly, if you find her particular talent, it will boost her confidence and may lead to a link with school.
My friends daughters were musical, music increased mathematics scores in turn a DD turned more to science.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 15/03/2023 20:10

Her place in the class shouldn't be recorded for all to see. Class average is useful though as it gives her something to aim for. That said you have to be realistic and think she may be able to work her way up to class average but if there are 100 places at the hoped for school, and 200 children hit the required percentage then only the top 100 will go through so she needs to be aiming higher,

Boogiewoogieanddance · 15/03/2023 20:07

@icanneverthinkofnc yes, she does some activities outside of school which we encourage.

@Lovewineandchocs unfortunately we missed them this year due to circumstances but we have been having a look at their websites, especially highschools rather than grammars.

@Eyerollcentral this is the problem with typing conversations isn't it, its easy to pick things up the wrong way and make an assumption of people's goals that aren't necessarily correct. Maybe a phonecall would be a better way to have a discussion with the teacher so nothing is taken the wrong way. I appreciate your input.

OP posts:
Lovewineandchocs · 15/03/2023 19:57

School open days/nights are also really good, you could go to them in P6 a few years ago, can you still? Good to view a mix of grammars and secondaries, both for encouragement and also reassurance that there are some amazing schools here that you don’t need the transfer test for.

Eyerollcentral · 15/03/2023 19:55

Boogiewoogieanddance · 15/03/2023 19:51

@Eyerollcentral but I believe we are guiding her? We haven't refused the professional opinion, we have listened and conversed with DD. Looked up schools with her that you don't need the transfer test for and been really excited about them. Despite this she has voiced she wants to atleast prepare. Surely that's guiding her? She knows at any time she decide she doesn't want to do it she can pull out and there is literally no shame in it. Our other option is to force the current opinion of the teacher on her which as you have rightly said is not always correct.

Thing is you sound much more invested in her succeeding in the test. You did say in the thread well actually I think she could do better than she does at class because she is shy. You’ve just said well the teacher might not be right. Experienced teachers can assess ability even with shy or quiet children. They are used to doing so. I don’t think you are guiding her, I think you are glad she has said she wants to do it because YOU want her to pass it.

icanneverthinkofnc · 15/03/2023 19:53

Boogiewoogieanddance · 15/03/2023 19:37

@icanneverthinkofnc honestly I think she is much more capable that what she has shown in school and her shyness holds her back as she wouldnt ask for help easily or give answers incases shes wrong. At home she will so if we put extra effort in I don't think it's beyond the realms if possibility that she gets a decent grade which will in turn boosts her confidence within school.

I would look at ways of boosting confidence. What does she like out of school? Is she interested in something in particular that she can shine in.

Swipe left for the next trending thread