Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who are these people that the government want to get back to work?

156 replies

MissHoneysHappyEnding · 15/03/2023 08:10

As in, the workers who they hope will come back because of free childcare.
I don't know many mums that don't go back to work straight away.
The few I have met feel strongly about being at home and I don't think free hours would change that.
The ones (two) I have met who left jobs and would like to return but can't afford childcare are in healthcare and hospitality where regular shifts don't fit in with nursery opening times anyway.
Tbh and only in my opinion, a lot of the 'we can't afford childcare so I had to give up my job' crew are often told that by controlling DH/ DPs or don't really want to go back to work anyway. Happy to be proved wrong!

OP posts:
Yuja · 15/03/2023 11:46

It would have helped me after my 2nd. We couldn't afford 2 in nursery so I didn't work for a couple of years. Back in the workforce now but I would have gone back earlier if this had happened then.

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 15/03/2023 11:41

@MissHoneysHappyEnding

NE Scotland. It got to the point where I seriously started to believe there had to be an issue with me that i just wasn't seeing.

With retail I even had recent experience as I'd volunteered in a charity shop whilst a sahm.

Gave up and went on the bank in a related role to what I used to do. Currently work around 20 hours a month but would have been just as happy doing way more in a different sector.

lazycats · 15/03/2023 11:41

I know lots of people who will financially benefit from this... but they're already in work.

Another problem is that it doesn't increase nursery capacity, so if there is big rise in demand a lot of people will be shit out of luck in oversubscribed areas.

Bucketheadbucketbum · 15/03/2023 11:40

Twizbe · 15/03/2023 08:42

I left a high paying professional job after having my second baby.

Childcare for 2 at that point would have cost us just under £2000 a month. We could afford it, but with commuting costs (which for my role could be really high and relied on timely claiming and paying of expenses) it wouldn't have been adding much to our family pot.

Add to that, my going back to work would have put our family earnings over the threshold for tax free childcare and the 30 hours.

I didn't love my job enough for my family to be only a couple of hundred quid a month better off.

If I had loved my job I could have gone back to work.

Then covid hit about 2 months after I was due back to work. Both of us working from home in big jobs with a 3 and 1 year old and no childcare ... I think that would have broken both of us. It broke several of my friends and all of them were failing at home and at work. They all had to reduce working hours and reduce pay. Many of us were also still paying some kind of retainer fee for our nursery place.

Because I don't work we only get 15 hours for our youngest. When she's in full time school in September I'm going back to uni to retrain in a career that I can do around school hours.

I won't be earning the mega bucks I was BUT I will be adding about the same to the family pot once you discount the childcare costs.

If we'd been able to get 30 hours for our youngest sooner, I likely would have gone back to work sooner.

Snap. Once you hit multiples of children childcare is prohibitive expensive to justify going back for nearly all jobs. I had more take home pay working 2 days a week vs 5 because I saved on 3 days of nursery. 30 free hours and I could have been full time

the80sweregreat · 15/03/2023 11:38

The wraparound care at my local primary school is reliable , but it's not cheap and only operates during term times. The after school club closes at six , so not that ideal for so many people who work shifts etc.
They don't cater for the holidays there at all , not even outside clubs some bigger schools might use. They let them use their facilities , but it's not cheap or even accessible for many either.
I feel that the government should have done a bit more ' homework ' over these matters really
They think that a child being at school equals the childcare sorted. It's not for so many people in jobs that are not in education anyway.

xK1991x · 15/03/2023 11:26

Mums like me! 18 month old twins and had a well paid job before having them. Nursery quotes are £3,400 a month so I cant afford to go back to work. Im following the news with interest

MyMachineAndMe · 15/03/2023 11:23

For us, with 2 dc, nursery cost us a fortune but it was easy; early drop-offs and late pick-ups that covered both our hours.

When they went to school, childcare was even more expensive and much more difficult because school didn't have an organised before or after-school club and there aren't any in our town. We had to use childminders; one retired after the first year and the next had to stop due to health issues. No other childminders would take on new children after 8 years old so we had no choice but for dh to take redundancy after the 1st lockdown.

The gov't should look at setting up and properly funding wraparound childcare for older children.

My sibling has an older, now adult, child with autism and for many years had to avoid working certain jobs because there is no childcare for older children, of high-school age, with disabilities.

Keha · 15/03/2023 11:23

My DH is part time and would work more hours if/when DS gets funded hours. Up until then his awkward shift patterns and pay rate means he'd be working to perhaps have £20 at end of shift once childcare deducted. Doesn't feel that's worth it so opted to do most of childcare himself. He's an NHS worker.

the80sweregreat · 15/03/2023 11:21

On lbc radio earlier on ( Nick Ferrari ) people were tweeting that parents who leave under 1s in nursery or with child minders are not committed to their child
I had this said to me in the early 90s when I left my 9 month old in full time care(nursery) so nothing much changes really does it ?
People have to do what is right at that time for their own circumstances and I didn't have any help at all and we needed money for the bills.
Wasn't ideal, but life never is! Seems some attitudes haven't altered much either

MissHoneysHappyEnding · 15/03/2023 11:20

@Dinosauratemydaffodils I'm not doubting your experience but I've worked in retail and catering and we would pretty much hire anyone who seemed to have a good work ethic. Showing up to the interview pretty much guaranteed you the job. I don't think many can afford to be picky. Where in the country are you?

OP posts:
Dinosauratemydaffodils · 15/03/2023 11:12

These aren't the sort of people there is a huge requirement for though - businesses aren't struggling to recruit in highly paid roles, they're struggling to recruit in minimum wage/zero hour contract roles. The 100K systems analyst isn't going to take a minimum wage job cleaning office toilets or fruit-picking.

And even if they did want to, I doubt they'd get the job. I applied for many minimum wage type jobs last year having been at home for 7 years. At first I was honest on my cv, listed my University degrees, roles before dc and all the voluntary roles I currently do. After feedback I dialled all that back and outright omitted all higher qualifications and the more professional volunteering. Got more interviews but didn't get a job, just lots of well meaning suggestions to look for work in similar fields to the ones I worked in previously.

CheersForThatEh · 15/03/2023 11:09

CascaChan · 15/03/2023 09:47

I actually used the excuse of not being able to afford childcare (it is true, partner was going to stay at home and I was going back to work as I earned more),I am very convinced that children are best at home with their mother until the age of three.
I had to say that it was a cost thing because I felt that people would judge me for wanting to be a full time mother.

I also knew that other women would take offence because they felt differently, I didn’t want to make others feel bad.

Motherhood is the only thing that has ever made me truly happy and fulfilled. I should be able to carry out my biological role without criticism and being made to feel guilty.

The government can back off because I did everything I was told a woman should do to be happy, worked my entire adult life and became a mother late, and all I have to show for it is my beautiful child.

My husband has two jobs and we are still struggling due to the way the country has been destroyed by government over an extended period.

I will not sell my child to the corporate machine. I have paid my dues when I was working and will take a few years out of work, thanks!

Written by a man.

Architectahoy · 15/03/2023 10:49

I've just received the usual "due to unforeseen circumstances - after school clubs will be cancelled today. Please pick up your children as usual"

If I was at work my options would be

  1. leave early and get the kids despite having deadlines and having had Part Time / Flexi time refused and inevitably get a warning

(Which is exactly what happened!! So I had to jump before I was pushed!)

Botw1 · 15/03/2023 10:45

@CascaChan

No.

I absolutely don't know that mothers are better.

I mean, both of mine sit crying in their rooms most nights because I worked when they were under 3 but it's totally worth it

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 15/03/2023 10:40

MissHoneysHappyEnding · 15/03/2023 08:10

As in, the workers who they hope will come back because of free childcare.
I don't know many mums that don't go back to work straight away.
The few I have met feel strongly about being at home and I don't think free hours would change that.
The ones (two) I have met who left jobs and would like to return but can't afford childcare are in healthcare and hospitality where regular shifts don't fit in with nursery opening times anyway.
Tbh and only in my opinion, a lot of the 'we can't afford childcare so I had to give up my job' crew are often told that by controlling DH/ DPs or don't really want to go back to work anyway. Happy to be proved wrong!

I don’t think there are separate ‘crews’ like that, I think it’s a whole bundle of factors for everyone.
When I gave up my job I was very torn about it but the fact that with three kids in childcare it was costing me a lot of money to go to work was a huge factor. It’s going to be something that gets weighed in the balance whether you would rather be at home or at work.

Bluenigellas · 15/03/2023 10:36

Me! I’m a teacher and didn’t go back as my school would not consider part time and the nursery fees (south east) were astronomical. It would have cost me to go back to work and I have 10 years experience teaching. We have no family nearby to help with the odd day either and I know lots of people in a similar boat to me.

LadyWithLapdog · 15/03/2023 10:35

Free childcare would have helped me, not to go back to work as I did that anyway, but to have more money to spend or save. I could have worked FT rather than PT and had a better pension when the time comes.

Coffeecoffeeinmytummy · 15/03/2023 10:30

Someone may have already pointed this out but the new funding could actually help with staff retention because nursery workers are the exact sort of people who are probably not going back to work after maternity leave. The pay in early years is very poor and there are currently no funded hours for under 3s if you’re working (unless it’s very part time/low wage) so there’s no incentive to go back as by the time they’ve paid for a nursery place they’re barely breaking even. Having some funding towards childcare would hopefully make it financially viable for women who work in early years to go back to work after maternity leave.

PMAmostofthetime · 15/03/2023 10:30

Honestly the price of child care increases recently if there wasn't a subsidised childcare then parents would be priced out of returning even if they wanted too.

In my line of work I see parents working for less than they would get on benefits due to child care costs they are the people around 70% of working parents ( statistics on flying start website)

Kazzyhoward · 15/03/2023 10:29

LadyWindermeresOnlyFans · 15/03/2023 10:13

@Architectahoy Rishi and Jezza don't really "get it" - do they? Cos they have their nannies

I've often thought that part of the empathy gap that government has must be down to things like this. They don't get it and they don't care about getting it. Completely oblivious to how other people live.

It's always been the same, right from "Let them eat cake" from the 18th century!

whattodo1975 · 15/03/2023 10:28

Realistically its not about those who have retired coming back to work, its about those who are coming up to retirement or planning to retire early putting off retirement for a few extra years.

Teatime55 · 15/03/2023 10:27

LadyWindermeresOnlyFans · 15/03/2023 10:13

@Architectahoy Rishi and Jezza don't really "get it" - do they? Cos they have their nannies

I've often thought that part of the empathy gap that government has must be down to things like this. They don't get it and they don't care about getting it. Completely oblivious to how other people live.

I’ve also had this as well though. I was struggling for childcare and was told I just needed to get a nanny or an au pair.
Im nearly 50, worked in many professional environments, literally never met or heard of anyone having these.
The major difference I’ve seen is people who have parents who do all the school runs/make meals/go to school shows, cover holidays etc. they can work long hours and it benefits their careers enormously.

Working in school is actually one of the worst places when you have children. Staff expected in by 7.30am (students can come for breakfast from 8am) when most childcare only just opening or not open until 8am. There’s no joined up thinking.

Kazzyhoward · 15/03/2023 10:26

I don't think it will have much impact. I've often thought the "I can't afford childcare" is used mostly as an excuse to justify being a SAHM by a lot of parents. Likewise, I think the pension "tax" on the higher earners such as doctors is also an excuse to justify them retiring early.

The biggest and best improvement to get people working again would be longer hours provided by childcare providers, such as much longer days, evenings, and weekends, especially to help those who work unsocial hours and shifts which is where we seem to have the biggest worker shortage, i.e. hospitals, hospitality, etc.

Grapefrui · 15/03/2023 10:22

If anything, childcare gets harder once your children are on school. Many children who have been to nursery their whole lives don’t enjoy after school club and holiday club. They’re often quite unstructured and can be pretty boring, especially if your child has no friends attending.

KnottyKnitting · 15/03/2023 10:18

DH and I retired early last year ( late 50s) We are fortunate to be financially self sufficient .

No bloody way would I be persuaded to go back into teaching, especially with the shit show that the education system is now!

Swipe left for the next trending thread