Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ukraine refugee too reliant on me?

83 replies

Southerngirl99 · 15/03/2023 00:34

I’ve hosted a female in her 50’s from Ukraine for almost a year, she doesn’t speak English and hasn’t made much effort to learn, she relies on me to do everything for her, almost like a PA.

We’ve given her notice to leave soon and helped her onto local housing list etc etc.

the local council want her to attend a meeting and because they know I’m exhausted with it all after 10 months they’ve liaised directly with her for the first time to arrange meeting for tomorrow, they’ve told me not to attend and to get her to make her own way there, as when she lives independently from me she will have to do this anyway.

she’s very stressed about going to a new area of town on her own (she catches the bus everyday to work and back) and says she doesn’t know what to say and can I tell her what to say in the meeting.

so my dilemma

am I being unreasonable letting her manage for herself? Or should I be giving her a lift and waiting outside the venue so she feels less stressed?

OP posts:
ChaoticCrumble · 16/03/2023 15:55

How did it go @Southerngirl99

KvotheTheBloodless · 15/03/2023 16:25

She's very lucky to have you. I know firsthand how hard hosting can be, we've been hosting a family of 5 for the past 11 months. They're lovely, but we're struggling with the lack of privacy/space (as are they, I'm sure) and their moving on expectations aren't in line with the reality of the UK housing market. They've point-blank refused private rental (too expensive) and want social housing, but the number of 3-bed properties is really tiny in our wider area.

We've been clear from the start that 1 year is our max for hosting (we have close friends coming from NZ in May to stay with us) but I can't see how they'll be out by then unless they go into temporary housing (which the council have told us will be a B&B).

The UK housing situation is completely different to that of Ukraine pre-war, and the complexity is a lot to grasp all in one go - your guest talking through options with the council might be really helpful (and they can tell her what priority banding she's on re: the social housing list - if it's below a B she's got basically no chance of social housing and needs to get a private rental). You may be asked to write a letter confirming you will be evicting her from x date, as that will move her up the priority list (although realistically as a single adult with no dependents she's incredibly unlikely to ever get social housing - most likely a house share is her best bet).

Definitely focus on the end goal - getting her her own place - and decide what you'll do if the only option on eviction day is a B&B or hostel.

Mistletoewench · 15/03/2023 15:26

Toddlerteaplease · 15/03/2023 15:05

I'd maybe drop her off. But then leave to find her own way home.

😂

Toddlerteaplease · 15/03/2023 15:05

I'd maybe drop her off. But then leave to find her own way home.

KTheGrey · 15/03/2023 15:00

It isn't easy being a migrant. However, that cannot mean you have to share your home forever with somebody who points at Google translate rather than doing it herself. When have you given her notice to move out? I hope it's a specific date, it'll give her a focus and less time to brood is probably good.

Annaissleeping · 15/03/2023 14:57

I can well imagine she's traumatised and depressed and in freeze mode but you don't have much in the way of options here. Either you continue to look after her, in which case this could go on for ages (she might well manipulate you out of making her go and stay elsewhere) or you get tough. It's tough love, really. She's in an extremely shit position but she has little choice.

Now is the time to get moving with creating a different life for herself. I agree she should go to this appointment alone. Don't be tempted to help her, it's not actually helpful, it's enabling her to not move forward which might well feel safest for her but it's a slippery slope down to her mental health getting really bad. Be sympathetic but firm. She will cope and she will feel proud she managed if she does this alone. It's all very well refusing to meet with people and refusing houses, but she has to. She will feel low if she doesn't mix with others, that's totally normal. She needs her own place to take pride in and make her own home, even if she moves back to Ukraine eventually. We are going into spring, it's a nice time to move and settle somewhere and start getting herself out. It will be extremely hard for her and I feel so much for everyone in this position but that's life isn't it? No one can change the fact her country is being attacked. She has already had months of your amazing support, I'm sure in time she'll look back and be so grateful.

I'm sorry you are in this position but please don't allow your sympathy for her to act in a way that in the long run holds her back.

CaroleSinger · 15/03/2023 14:43

Southerngirl99 · 15/03/2023 01:04

Hi yes we’ve gone through the bus route, shown her on google maps etc.

im expecting the LA to give her a little pep talk about being independent and also to emphasise how lucky she is to be on housing register, (she has rejected several possible homes as they are not exactly what she wants in the location she wants, even said that she didn’t think one of the flats was built correctly as the foundations weren’t like they have in Ukraine).

she can use the translation app when she has to but normally she points at me to use mine.

See this would make my blood boil because it's everything we are usually told isn't the case with refugees. And here we have a prime example of why people who can't even get on the housing register are so upset. When I think how many years it takes for British citizens to get on the local authority housing list and how long they have to wait for a home this really does seem utterly ungrateful.

Onegingerhead · 15/03/2023 14:42

She is 50+. I agree she shouldn't be relying for the OP to be at her back and call but I don't think she will ever be able to acquire sufficient language skills to navigate (more or less) successfully and independently in life. Or get a good well paid job.
Younger Ukrainian refugees (20s or early 30s) yes sure, but the old you get the more impossible it becomes to learn a language. I see it all the time...
I'm not a native speaker and grasped the language pretty quickly when I came to the UK. After 6 months of being here I was able to communicate my needs pretty efficiently. My grammar sucked (still does sometimes) but I was able to get around without relying on anyone's help. But I was 23.
I really don't know what will happen to all these middle aged Ukrainian refugees and I feel for them.

Konfetka · 15/03/2023 14:25

I'm afraid you hosts are being taken for mugs. To survive the Soviet Union you had to be tough - and after the USSR things only got harder. Sounds like she's got you (and your husband) wrapped around her little finger, OP.

Rosula · 15/03/2023 14:19

Violaviolin · 15/03/2023 01:39

Would you feel confident doing this in Ukraine after 10 months? Would you be fluent in Ukraine/Russian in 10 months? I know I wouldn't.

I don't imagine I'd be fluent, but after 10 months of living and working in another country I think I'd be pretty competent to get around and would be familiar enough with the language to be able to live independently. If you immerse yourself in another language for that length of time you can't help but pick up a lot of it.

Choconut · 15/03/2023 14:18

I think I would try to compromise - take her there to make sure she finds her way and gets there on time, but then leave her sort the meeting and get the bus home.

Alltheproductsnoidea · 15/03/2023 14:12

Can you ring / email the LA and tell them she is having issues attending? Maybe they can do a zoom call? Sounds very frustrating and you sound like you are at the end 🔚 of your tether!

jane1956 · 15/03/2023 14:04

I would be telling her that if no social housing is what she wants and not like the Ukraine, she knows where there are houses like the Ukraine ....in the Ukraine and they speak Ukraine there. happy days

uncomfortablydumb53 · 15/03/2023 14:00

You have been very generous to host her, but it seems she hasn't made efforts to be independent
I hope at the meeting, the LA will see how dependent she has been and show her what progress they expect
It could be that she has lost motivation and confidence due to depression, which in her situation is understandable.
Perhaps consider accompanying her to a GP appointment too

catsnore · 15/03/2023 13:56

This is really tough but you need to throw her in at the deep end. Otherwise the fear of doing it will keep holding her back. She needs to come up with coping/communication strategies that work for her. She needs to be 'forced' to speak in English in a variety of situations without you there to hold her hand, otherwise she will always rely on you to step in when there is a problem. Having lived abroad I know the fear feeling you get when you have to go stuff like this - but the only way through it is to take a big breath, put big girl pants on, and try to forget about making mistakes and just go for it!!!!

therearesomenastypeoplearound · 15/03/2023 13:43

Just tell her they've asked for her to go along on her own.

Lollygaggle · 15/03/2023 13:38

In retrospect when we started hosting we would have set more boundaries and tapered off support much quicker.
We did everything for them and , unfortunately , created a situation where they were very dependant and demanding of our time and resources , including childcare, doing homework with child etc. Everything was expected to be done by us immediately or at their convenience with no accomodation for us working full time and with other commitments.

Without doubt mum is depressed but is very selective over what help and support mechanisms she will use. Unfortunately the local Ukrainian support networks tend to reinforce the negative things going on and encourage dependency and demands .

These are adult people who have led their own lives independently . They have had much more help than other refugee groups by dint of having hosts. For your own sake and theirs you need to step back. It is difficult and you will feel guilty but doing it in a controlled way saves getting to a crisis and having a relationship break down in a catastrophic way . But they need to be an adult and make their own , good decisions . Almost certainly it will be more difficult than living in your home , at first , but part of their healing journey is taking up responsibilities once more and being captain of their own ship.

FourFour · 15/03/2023 13:37

She has had a year to help herself in small ways. She is too reliant on you. You need to take their advice and let her find her way.

Lucylock · 15/03/2023 13:34

@Untitledsquatboulder Perhaps because she actually is quite brave and resourceful?

Clearly not.

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/03/2023 13:31

viques · 15/03/2023 13:09

No, but I have often been in countries where I don’t speak the language and have been able to navigate my way on public transport.

But im guessing you aren't suffering from any significant mh problems

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/03/2023 13:29

Although I agree she could have done more to help herself. Think of all the trauma this poor woman has been through and what an impact it has had on her mh then add to that a language barrier no wonder she is struggling. Also nobody knows her history for all we know she could of suffered from agoraphobia or other mh issues in the past which makes dealing with something as simple as going to a meeting alone almost impossible

viques · 15/03/2023 13:09

Violaviolin · 15/03/2023 01:39

Would you feel confident doing this in Ukraine after 10 months? Would you be fluent in Ukraine/Russian in 10 months? I know I wouldn't.

No, but I have often been in countries where I don’t speak the language and have been able to navigate my way on public transport.

LaurelGrove · 15/03/2023 13:04

In the end, unless you want to support her indefinitely she needs to find a way to be independent.

It's not sustainable (or particularly sensible) for private individuals with no training to bear the burden of integrating refugees effectively. That is the huge failing of this scheme which was well intentioned but ultimately puts far too high a burden on hosts.

Your guest chose to come here, rather than another country and a year is enough time to acquire enough language to be confident getting around and start to build a life here. If she wants to stay for the remainder of her visa and you are not prepared to host for that period this - and other things - are going to be essential for her. It's hard and not a message that is easy to deliver, but it is necessary.

You've already done a lot. It's time for her to help herself. You can have all the compassion and empathy in the world for her situation but the kind thing to do is to encourage her to take these steps forward.

I speak as a host. I think only people who have been through this experience can really understand the mixture of guilt and frustration and obligation we all feel!

Tiani4 · 15/03/2023 13:00

Deep breaths OP

She'll be at the housing meeting and expected to bid herself in properties

If I were you, I'd stick to your notice date, housing team will find her temporary B&B accomodation if she doesn't sort herself out and bid on properties.

You've fallen into the role of being a mother / support worker to her and it's exhausting you. No one expected this level of support from you after nearly a year. First few months sure, but after then ... no

Keep reminding yourself that she isn't your responsibility, you've done your bit hosting her for as long as you have and it's up to her to get on with it now. She has support, housing will help her and staying in temporary accomodation May be her incentive to take the steps she needs to.

Trinity65 · 15/03/2023 12:54

Ah I posted before I saw an update

None the less, if she is not bidding then she won't get anywhere will she.