Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ukraine refugee too reliant on me?

83 replies

Southerngirl99 · 15/03/2023 00:34

I’ve hosted a female in her 50’s from Ukraine for almost a year, she doesn’t speak English and hasn’t made much effort to learn, she relies on me to do everything for her, almost like a PA.

We’ve given her notice to leave soon and helped her onto local housing list etc etc.

the local council want her to attend a meeting and because they know I’m exhausted with it all after 10 months they’ve liaised directly with her for the first time to arrange meeting for tomorrow, they’ve told me not to attend and to get her to make her own way there, as when she lives independently from me she will have to do this anyway.

she’s very stressed about going to a new area of town on her own (she catches the bus everyday to work and back) and says she doesn’t know what to say and can I tell her what to say in the meeting.

so my dilemma

am I being unreasonable letting her manage for herself? Or should I be giving her a lift and waiting outside the venue so she feels less stressed?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Spirallingdownwards · 02/03/2024 06:37

decionsdecisions62 · 01/03/2024 12:58

Was contemplating taking someone in last year. I didn't in the end. There seems to have been a few horror stories. Hopefully there were really positive stories too!

Yes have a fab guest who has gone on to university here but stays with us over the breaks and who managed to get themselves remote job in their field within 3 weeks of arriving here and still does it alongside their studies.

Very good work ethic, English has improved considerably since arriving. I suspect because they have had to to keep up with studies. Happy we haven't experienced some of the horror stories we have heard too.

user1474145159 · 01/03/2024 20:57

Do they still live with you so don't pay for rent while is on universal credit?

JKFan · 01/03/2024 20:55

decionsdecisions62 · 01/03/2024 12:58

Was contemplating taking someone in last year. I didn't in the end. There seems to have been a few horror stories. Hopefully there were really positive stories too!

I can give you a positive story. I have a Ukrainian refugee who has been with me about 15 months. I was nervous about having someone as I have not shared living accommodation since I was a student and I’m quite reserved and am now in my late 50s. Fortunately my local authority had a Zoom session of those thinking about it and those who already hosted and one of them spoke of it being like having a lodger. This made realise that we would both need space. We usually cook and eat independently, but occasionally one of us will invite the other to eat - she’s trying out food her mother used to make.
She spoke reasonable English when she came, but there were times I realised I thought we had a discussion and she had just bluffed her way through, not understanding what was being said. She has however put a massive effort into learning English with the various courses on offer.
It’s lucky that in some ways our interests coincide. She joined a choir I am in. In other ways our interests and personalities are quite different.
There are of course times when I feel exasperated- particularly when she pops up late at night and asks me to review the wording of an application for a course (she’s wanting to do another masters), but I’m glad I followed through on my initial impulse to offer a room.
Tomorrow we’re going with one of her friends to paint Ukrainian Easter eggs in Cambridge.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 01/03/2024 20:35

Spirallingdownwards · 01/03/2024 20:26

That's nonsense. The local authorities are providing English sessions specifically those here under the Homes for Ukraine Scheme.

I think you unfortunately will just have to give notice and send her on her way even if she had to present as homeless and go into b and b. She will soon sort somewhere then!

So thankful my guest has more gumption about them!

Councils are very variable in the English lessons they are providing. My former guests have plenty of gumption but nothing the council provided was any use- we found a free course taught by students learning to be EFL teachers at a local university and they have had online lessons from a teacher in Ukraine, but they had to pay for that.

STOTTYBUN · 01/03/2024 20:29

Interesting read. We hosted a mother and son for months. She worked every hour she could, paper round, cleaning morning and evening and lunchtime , still on Universal credit, as she earned under the limit that stops UC.. She went back to Ukraine in the summer then a month later, her husband arrived. She said he could come out of the army because he had a spinal injury. Since he came he has dome lqbouring jobs and doesn’t appear to have an injury. His wife has since given up all her jobs and they live on UC apart from what he can earn odd jobbing. She obviously went back to Ukraine to leave money she had saved to bribe medics so he can leave Ukraine. I know I would probably want my husband to be out of the war but she is not working now and seems happy to live on Universal Credit.

Spirallingdownwards · 01/03/2024 20:26

user1474145159 · 01/03/2024 01:11

She's working so presumably doesn't have much time, she's over 50 so it's much harder to learn a new language. Government is not very forthcoming in providing language courses like in Germany for example. She's set in her ways. Age is a huge factor

That's nonsense. The local authorities are providing English sessions specifically those here under the Homes for Ukraine Scheme.

I think you unfortunately will just have to give notice and send her on her way even if she had to present as homeless and go into b and b. She will soon sort somewhere then!

So thankful my guest has more gumption about them!

banananas1999 · 01/03/2024 20:20

Ukraine isnt Gaza 70percent of the country is safe and life and business goes on as usual. I have family members from EU who travel to Ukraine as part if their work.0

banananas1999 · 01/03/2024 20:17

Violaviolin · 15/03/2023 01:39

Would you feel confident doing this in Ukraine after 10 months? Would you be fluent in Ukraine/Russian in 10 months? I know I wouldn't.

I came to UK just before ny 18th birthday by myself, got myself NI numbers,found a GP etc

Lollygaggle · 01/03/2024 20:08

Southerngirl99 · 01/03/2024 12:50

Just seen a message added to day so thought I would give an update to close the story.

she moved out last April. I got her a flat (newly refurbished) in a charitable trust for ladies over a certain age! It’s beautiful. She says it’s too expensive! We met three times only since she left and first sentence contained the words universal credit which she thinks she she get even though she works!

only contacts us when something needs fixing.

had a flashback to how exhausted I was this time last year!

never again!

I hear you. Our family moved out to another host family and only contact us when they want something as new hosts are not as "helpful" as us.

language has not progressed as they are no longer taking the English lessons provided , and child is no longer attending the activities we set up as we are no longer acting as taxi service and prompters.

Mum is still not working despite the fact we have said they cannot rent anywhere without extra income and despite putting them on council list they will , in all probability , not get a council house for years .

I am glad we did it and have many contacts with great Ukrainian families who have engaged and are independent and hard working. However it was so much hard work with this family , our full time work and their expectations and demands fuelled by social media .

mrsjoyfulprizeforraffiawork · 01/03/2024 13:24

Kokeshi123 · 15/03/2023 03:18

Nobody is expecting her to be "fluent," for goodness' sake.

I spent months travelling in remote parts of China in the early 2000s where I didn't speak the language very well and very few people spoke any English, and that was before all the translation apps and things they have nowadays. I went around with a point-and-say phrasebook, pencil and notebook; if I couldn't say what i wanted to say, I would use the phrasebook or draw pictures and diagrams on the notebook. I memorized the Chinese characters for stuff like things on menus and locations on bus stops and things I needed to be able to know or use. You get by. It's not easy, but this lady needs to try a bit harder to cope; it sounds like she has developed a bit of learned helplessness and has got into the habit of letting others do things for her.

@Kokeshi123 You have had a few critical responses to your comment but I get it. When I was a very immature, lacking in confidence 20-year-old I wanted to travel and decided to travel (alone, as I didn't know anyone to ask to come too) through Europe for about a month by train, bus, etc and staying in youth hostels, rooms etc I knew not where. I told everyone (work and home) but was quite apprehensive and downright scared as departure date got nearer. I had to go as I had told everyone. I was incredibly green but managed the trip, survived a few hairy moments, met some lovely people and found out how to communicate with mime with people whose language I couldn't speak and realised at the end that I had now got enough confidence in myself to get through life like other people. It changed my life, doing something I doubted I could. Later I travelled a lot in Asia and also round Australia, across Canada etc). Unfortunately, the OP's guest, though much older than I was back then, seems to be afraid of making herself have a shot at being independent. I assume she can speak reasonable English, as she goes to work in this country and can communicate with her hosts.

decionsdecisions62 · 01/03/2024 12:58

Was contemplating taking someone in last year. I didn't in the end. There seems to have been a few horror stories. Hopefully there were really positive stories too!

Southerngirl99 · 01/03/2024 12:50

Just seen a message added to day so thought I would give an update to close the story.

she moved out last April. I got her a flat (newly refurbished) in a charitable trust for ladies over a certain age! It’s beautiful. She says it’s too expensive! We met three times only since she left and first sentence contained the words universal credit which she thinks she she get even though she works!

only contacts us when something needs fixing.

had a flashback to how exhausted I was this time last year!

never again!

OP posts:
STOTTYBUN · 01/03/2024 09:06

I am afraid you have to make her homeless. That is the only way you can move her on. It sounds harsh but my friend did this so her guest coukd get a council flat. They are still friends and my friend still helps with hospital appointments or Job seekers visits but the Ukrainian refugee in her 50s is now working and proud of her home.

BabyWorker · 01/03/2024 04:07

user1474145159 · 01/03/2024 01:11

She's working so presumably doesn't have much time, she's over 50 so it's much harder to learn a new language. Government is not very forthcoming in providing language courses like in Germany for example. She's set in her ways. Age is a huge factor

It's been a year now...:-S

user1474145159 · 01/03/2024 01:11

She's working so presumably doesn't have much time, she's over 50 so it's much harder to learn a new language. Government is not very forthcoming in providing language courses like in Germany for example. She's set in her ways. Age is a huge factor

STOTTYBUN · 30/04/2023 13:57

My friend had a very difficult lady, traumatized as she had come from a war zone and her husband had recently died. She was thrown out of English classes because she wouldn’t try. The council found her a flat near my friend’s mother so she can visit once a week . Her guest has done amazingly well living by herself and now manages her own money. My friend did everything for her but now she, despite not knowing any English, is coping well.

Miloticc · 16/03/2023 23:25

The fact that she won’t change hosts makes me think she specifically likes you and your house. She doesn’t want anything else (except maybe properties she’ll never be eligible for).

I think the council need to be more blunt with her instead of putting the responsibility of explaining onto you. The UKs housing and council house lists must be really difficult for anyone to grasp, it’s going to take being stern even though it will feel awful. But you shouldn’t have to do it, the council should.

Berlinlover · 16/03/2023 22:11

Violaviolin · 15/03/2023 01:39

Would you feel confident doing this in Ukraine after 10 months? Would you be fluent in Ukraine/Russian in 10 months? I know I wouldn't.

I visited Ukraine alone in 2019 and was perfectly well able to use public transport, what an odd post.

Ohby · 16/03/2023 22:07

OP says she gave a lift, it's only 5posts up.

Cascais · 16/03/2023 21:58

Give her a lift

latetothefisting · 16/03/2023 21:44

Maybe give her a lift there so you know she'll turn up (because basically you want her out and this sounds like it's the quickest way to achieve it!) but she can make her own way home.

Tell her you can't tell her what to say because you don't know what questions they are going to ask her.
Again unless you want her moved ASAP and know a few things for her to say that will facilitate it (I.e. tell her to tell them she doesn't get on with you!).

Basically if it furthers your own aims help her out, if not don't feel obliged!

Southerngirl99 · 16/03/2023 20:38

Brunts12 · 16/03/2023 16:53

I agree with @Konfetka

OP, how come she arrived alone, while her family (mother, daughter and granddaughter) is still there?

I think we will never know the whole truth. She recently announce her partner of 10 years was dying of cancer but she didn’t see him when she visited family in January because he is with his wife!!

daughter is in 30s and been married 14 years and tbh I don’t think they have much of a relationship normally. Mum is mid 80s and living in a church due to bombing. Think mum didn’t approve of married partner so they have also been estranged.

I think when war broke out he went back to wife and family and that’s why she was homeless this could also explain why she’s helpless as he must of done everything for her.

OP posts:
Brunts12 · 16/03/2023 16:53

Konfetka · 15/03/2023 14:25

I'm afraid you hosts are being taken for mugs. To survive the Soviet Union you had to be tough - and after the USSR things only got harder. Sounds like she's got you (and your husband) wrapped around her little finger, OP.

I agree with @Konfetka

OP, how come she arrived alone, while her family (mother, daughter and granddaughter) is still there?

Southerngirl99 · 16/03/2023 16:33

So I took her to the meeting and waited outside then dropped her to work, she said it all went fine.

There is a very good possiblilty of a rematch with new host that lives near her work but she wont consider that at all - grrr, been advised by local council to show her who actually got the flats she bidon so she can see that the points she holds are nowhere near enough to be succesful in bidding - reallity check once again. Local council have been very supportive to me on the phone.

Unsurpisingly all the tears and feelings of loneliness and longing are long forgotten.

She told my husband shes not eaten for two days - why?? either eat or dont but dont look for freaking sympathy - the cupboards and fridge is full of food as always - such a martyr !

I do feel like I have another teeenage child on my hands.

Thank you for all your comments they really resonate with me and I feel validated in my exasperation lol

OP posts:
whittingtonmum · 16/03/2023 16:32

Really tough situation. After 10 months in a different country I would expect people to be able to be independent - especially with a job and no caring responsibilities.

There might be mental health issues involved so good to encourage her to talk to her GP. Translation should be provided by GP practice.

In any case - regardless if it's mental health problems or a general reluctance to stand on her own two feet - you are unable to provide any further support and this includes accommodation. The Council will need to step in now and hopefully the lady manages to pull herself up on her bootstraps once she can't rely on you for support anymore.

Swipe left for the next trending thread