Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Expansion of free childcare

246 replies

Firefly2023 · 14/03/2023 22:21

I am too old to benefit from this but I do wonder if we are heading in the wrong direction. The expansion of free childcare to one and two year olds is obviously to encourage more people back to work. Is this really such a good thing for the children?

I know that women want to continue their careers and staying at home is detrimental to that. Also in current economic climate, two wages are necessary to survive in most households now, but I am concerned. I think it is a shame that children are all bundled into childcare at a young age and feel sorry for parents being pushed into work when they may prefer to stay home.

I always felt that I missed so much by going back to work very early and I regret not taking more time off in those early years. I wonder if there is a better way. Maybe parents should be encouraged to look after their own children if they want to rather than handing over their babies to childcare. Maybe spend some of the money on incentivising employers to give more paid leave/shorter working hours to support SAH parents. AIBU?

OP posts:
Onnabugeisha · 15/03/2023 11:29

Corah5 · 15/03/2023 11:26

Honestly I think it would be better to support employers in creating part time flexible jobs for people with small children. So it’s not “full time work and childcare” vs “stay at home”. It should be possible for parents to keep their hand in with their career on a part time basis and still be able to raise their own children. It shouldn’t be an either/or choice. At the moment part time jobs are mostly shitty and low paid while high level career jobs are full time, and it’s wrong and unhelpful.

Yes, I agree. This would be better for the human beings involved. It goes to show that the government isn’t doing what is best for humans, but for the economy.

Onnabugeisha · 15/03/2023 11:27

LauraIAm · 15/03/2023 11:10

@Onnabugeisha Everyone has the choice to stay at home, they just have to fund it themselves. The choice to stay and home AND HAVE SOMEONE ELSE PAY FOR IT is being restricted. Given how awful you obviously think it is to be a FT working mum of a young child, you surely can’t expect women who do that to pay additional tax so you can stay at home? I do however agree with you that there should be an exemption for people with disabled children.

I don’t think it is awful to be a FT mum of a young child or children. I did that myself. I didn’t have a choice not to work though. Which is true of many women. There isnt always a choice to stay at home. I did have the privilege though of my DH being able to be a SAHD & PT Uni student. And with most of my DC having special needs/ND it actually was the best choice for their well being and development to only be in childcare PT. How many autistic toddlers do you know that can handle a 45hr week in childcare? I’d wager very few could.

This policy while great for many families, also comes with other policies that take away choice from many many more parents to stay at home or work PT.

All the policies are centred around “getting people back to work” to boost the economy. There has been no consideration of what is best for child development as not all children, especially ND children, benefit from FT childcare from a very young age (under 3).

The policies also widen the gap between low income and high income parents. High income parents will always have the choice for one parent to be a SAHP as they can afford it (as were my DH and I). Lower income parents previously could choose between living more frugally and topping up with UC while one partner was a SAHP or both working and perhaps having only a tiny bit extra income as a result. This choice won’t be permitted if the full suite of changes go through. There won’t be topping up with UC unless both partners are in work and both meet a new, higher minimum threshold to exempt them from actively looking for better paying work or doing overtime/extra hours.

So the privilege of choice will become yet more restricted to the privileged and well off. I don’t think this is morally right. Children born into low income families already face numerous disadvantages that have been shown to be mitigated by parents that can swing a work/life balance that means hands on involvment and sufficient time with preschool age children. If both parents are working dawn to dusk and then exhausted the rest of the time, their care for their child or children will suffer.

I don’t mind paying additional tax so that more parents who find that staying home or working PT is truly what is best for their child have access to that choice. The policies take away choice from many more parents, they don’t just encourage parents who want to work to be able to keep more of what they earn. There’s nothing wrong with supporting one policy like better funded childcare, while also being concerned at overall impact of ALL the policies being proposed.

Corah5 · 15/03/2023 11:26

Honestly I think it would be better to support employers in creating part time flexible jobs for people with small children. So it’s not “full time work and childcare” vs “stay at home”. It should be possible for parents to keep their hand in with their career on a part time basis and still be able to raise their own children. It shouldn’t be an either/or choice. At the moment part time jobs are mostly shitty and low paid while high level career jobs are full time, and it’s wrong and unhelpful.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 15/03/2023 11:25

smellyflowers · 15/03/2023 11:21

And even younger. Some people go back much much sooner than 1 year

Absolutely, especially as the last 14 weeks of maternity leave aren’t paid.

smellyflowers · 15/03/2023 11:21

IAmTheWalrus85 · 15/03/2023 11:19

How old are you and have you ever worked? Women can take 52 weeks’ maternity leave and have done for around 15 years now, so there are loads of one year olds in nursery.

And even younger. Some people go back much much sooner than 1 year

smellyflowers · 15/03/2023 11:21

CandlelightGlow · 15/03/2023 10:46

I also was surprised to see provision extended to one year olds. I know some people especially in better paid jobs do send their DC to nursery really young though, so I guess it's a good thing. Not a decision I'd make myself, but I also imagine the uptake won't be too huge and therefore shouldn't be too costly, relatively?

Mat leave ends at 1 year - if you're lucky you can add accrued holiday on to that. They have to take you back in a similar role. If you don't go back then then good luck finding somewhere with a gap on your cv.

Mistressofnone · 15/03/2023 11:20

I think it's a great incentive. Although my timing is impeccable as always. My youngest is two so we will miss out and we are just about able to pay for one day a week at nursery. Which people also argue is more damaging to her than attending 2-3 days. DH & I manage the rest between us but again the kids get just one day a fortnight with both parents around together all day.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 15/03/2023 11:19

CandlelightGlow · 15/03/2023 10:46

I also was surprised to see provision extended to one year olds. I know some people especially in better paid jobs do send their DC to nursery really young though, so I guess it's a good thing. Not a decision I'd make myself, but I also imagine the uptake won't be too huge and therefore shouldn't be too costly, relatively?

How old are you and have you ever worked? Women can take 52 weeks’ maternity leave and have done for around 15 years now, so there are loads of one year olds in nursery.

QueefQueen80s · 15/03/2023 11:17

It's not going to work in reality, childcare already buckling.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 15/03/2023 11:15

You’ve used some choice words, OP. ‘Bundled’ and ‘pushed’ are my two favourites. Why did you choose those? You could have chosen ‘attend’ or even just ‘go’.

Skateboardsurprise · 15/03/2023 11:13

IAmTheWalrus85 · 15/03/2023 07:15

It does. Hopefully they’ll also fund the existing scheme properly because otherwise the entire sector will collapse and nurseries will go out of business left, right and centre.

And even though loads go out of business and there won’t be enough spaces for all of the children, as people have said they will change UC so people don’t really have a choice but to use the free house and so the parents who are on UC will be penalised for not going back to work.

Overthebloodymoon · 15/03/2023 11:12

@WeWereInParis - not a generalization. I’m in and out of nurseries across half the country every day. Personally, you may have found utopia with the provider you used. On a national scale, provision is absolutely dire and quality settings are few and far between. Even a good Ofsted rating covers a multitude of sins. There is so much concentrated in the top 5-10 nursery chains, which will ultimately be the only providers to survive as the small independents crash out of the market. All formulaic. baby factories with little to distinguish them from the next nursery down the road. Of course there will be outliers but would I send my own DC to the nurseries I visit on a regular basis? No.

LauraIAm · 15/03/2023 11:10

Onnabugeisha · 15/03/2023 10:26

@WigglyWigglyWiggly
How on earth is funding something that parents are currently having to pay for supposedly forcing those who don’t want to use it to use it?! Just because something is free doesn’t mean you have to use it.

I’ll tell you how this budget is taking away choice. The Spring Budget has the theme of get people back to work. The more money for subsidised childcare is the carrot. It’s going to benefit those who have either already chosen to go back to work or are working because they cannot afford not to. This isn’t a bad thing if it were by itself.

But it isn’t. You have to look at the full picture

But most have missed the sticks said so far in the Spring Budget pre-release. These are new requirements such as the partners of working partners now being required to actively seek work even if they have children aged under 3. The minimum income to not have to keep looking for work or better paying work is also going to be raised, such that the days of a parent doing PT work with preschool children at home, will be eliminated. These parents will have to seek FT work or a much much higher paying PT job (which exist for only a few elites), even if they have a child at home under age 3. If they don’t do this, they are sanctioned. And to add to this stick, DWP is being given the authority to auto-sanction anyone which may or may not involve AI doing sanctions, then the families appealing as the inevitable computer errors mount up.

All of the above is going to force yet more low income parents into FT work. They won’t have the choice to stay home, and they will be punished via sanctions if they aren’t getting a high enough paying job regardless of whether or not such a job actually exists for them after accounting for qualifications and any disabilities they may have.

There also doesn’t seem to be any allowance or exemption said so far for having a child with special needs- you will still be forced to find FT work.

@Onnabugeisha Everyone has the choice to stay at home, they just have to fund it themselves. The choice to stay and home AND HAVE SOMEONE ELSE PAY FOR IT is being restricted. Given how awful you obviously think it is to be a FT working mum of a young child, you surely can’t expect women who do that to pay additional tax so you can stay at home? I do however agree with you that there should be an exemption for people with disabled children.

Butteryflakycrust83 · 15/03/2023 11:06

This is such bullshit.

I cannot afford NOT to work.

I WANT to work.

I would have LOVED to have gone part time.

If this had been implemented two years ago, I would have saved £850 a month. That is £850 a month I could have used to put towards a deposit for a house. That is £850 a month I would have spent back into the economy. I could have dropped down to part time. I could have had a second child.

This will give women CHOICE.

LauraIAm · 15/03/2023 11:02

The issue is that women who stop work for long periods or go very part time / take jobs for which they are overqualified etc never recover their earning power. This is bad for kids as they are more likely to end up in a low income household. It also requires long term subsidy by other tax payers eg top up benefits for low earning women, benefits if a couple later split up and the woman can’t afford to run an independent household, pension top ups because women don’t end up saving enough. It’s a massive burden and it’s not reasonable to expect people who do work including mums who work (who also deeply love their children and want the best for them despite the undertone of the original post) to take this burden on. You chose to have kids and in most cases (not eg children with severe disability) you should financially provide for yourself and your children without subsidy. In most families this involves the mum working. Strongly support the new funded childcare. There is loads of data out there to support these facts but here’s an example: www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-56315730.amp.

JenniferBarkley · 15/03/2023 11:00

I just don't get it.

All through school - study so you can get onto a good degree.
In college, study hard so you can get a good postgrad.
At PG level, study hard so you can get a good job.
Get the job, and work hard for the promotions and the professional qualification (which took a further 9 years for me)

Then you're 34 and getting the judgy head tilt "Oh you're going back full-time?".

Meanwhile, DH is back at work after a fortnight, yes fulltime and not a head tilt directed his way. But he takes four weeks SPL and knows how to change a nappy, so let's all bow before his magnificence and tell his wife how lucky she is that she only does half the childcare, half the housework and earns half the money.

Ridiculous. So far to go for women.

getgetgetruby · 15/03/2023 10:59

@Shinyandnew1 not sure why you're comment is so condescending. I appreciate there isn't enough childcare provision. We know first hand as we found it hard to get a place. Eventually went for a CM over a nursery which has been a blessing in disguise as I've realised the benefits of a smaller homely setting. But in general the current system and not getting the hours until 3 is complete bollocks. The cost of our childcare for one child at its highest was the same as our mortgage (over 1000 pm) we had no financial wiggle room or ability to save for emergencies. Side note it was hard enough getting a mortgage in the first place but yet again there's no stability in renting so we felt we had to do that before having a baby. Seemed the sensible going to do. Ultimately I don't trust the Tories with a policy like this and hope to see the back of them at the next election. They have presided over a huge increase in equality in this country. Things have got worse and worse for families. We have a falling birth rate and yet it feels like there is so much resentment towards supporting families in this country. So expanding the hours to 1-2 year olds is the right way to go imo. Hoping the Tories crash and burn at the next election and Labour focus greater attention on affordable childcare.

Blughbablugh · 15/03/2023 10:55

JenniferBarkley · 15/03/2023 10:50

One year old isn't really young for nursery - maternity cover ends at one year, so of course children go to childcare from that age. I can think of one woman in my circle who didn't work in some capacity when her DC were one, and even she went back to work after DC1 so it was only DCs 2&3 she was home with.

The judgement dripping from some of these posts.

Yes this! Are people really that out of touch with how maternity works? The pay drops considerably over time down to nothing and then if you want to keep your job you have to go back to work. But let's not let that stand in the way of a bit of snearing!

Hello12345678910 · 15/03/2023 10:53

I'd love to stay at home with my (nearly) one year old - I simply cannot afford too.
After childcare I'll be taking home about £45 a week - but we cannot afford to be without it..

Though, I do feel "free" childcare for 1 year olds is also the wrong way to go, I dont mind paying - just not the excessive amount that is charged!!

JenniferBarkley · 15/03/2023 10:50

CandlelightGlow · 15/03/2023 10:46

I also was surprised to see provision extended to one year olds. I know some people especially in better paid jobs do send their DC to nursery really young though, so I guess it's a good thing. Not a decision I'd make myself, but I also imagine the uptake won't be too huge and therefore shouldn't be too costly, relatively?

One year old isn't really young for nursery - maternity cover ends at one year, so of course children go to childcare from that age. I can think of one woman in my circle who didn't work in some capacity when her DC were one, and even she went back to work after DC1 so it was only DCs 2&3 she was home with.

The judgement dripping from some of these posts.

Onnabugeisha · 15/03/2023 10:48

@Chickenly
When you neutralise for income and social parameters, children in childcare have better outcomes.

I have only seen one outcome that is better across the board for all children and that is educational attainment. So not sure you can make such a generalisation by saying “outcomes”.

For example other studies have shown high # of hrs per week in childcare from a young age (below age 1) is linked to a higher risk of juvenile delinquency and poor mental health.

The outcomes also vary by age of the child when they start childcare and the average number of hours/week they spend in childcare. A commonality I have seen is that a better outcome is often associated with older children going fewer hours per week, and a worse outcome with younger children going for more hours per week.

CandlelightGlow · 15/03/2023 10:46

I also was surprised to see provision extended to one year olds. I know some people especially in better paid jobs do send their DC to nursery really young though, so I guess it's a good thing. Not a decision I'd make myself, but I also imagine the uptake won't be too huge and therefore shouldn't be too costly, relatively?

Marghe87 · 15/03/2023 10:41

Chickenly · 15/03/2023 10:32

I am too old to benefit from this… so I want to explain why I think something that

The expansion of free childcare to one and two year olds is obviously to encourage more people back to work.
Is it? Do you have any proof that funding childcare actually encourages returning to work rather than facilitating returning to work?

Is this really such a good thing for the children?
Even if we accept that it’s “encouraging” rather than “facilitating”, yes. Yes it is a good thing. There are many, many studies that show that. Each to their own and I won’t comment on other people’s parenting choices but, seeing as you started a shaming thread, we should probably look at this factually. When you neutralise for income and social parameters, children in childcare have better outcomes.

I know that women want to continue their careers and staying at home is detrimental to that. Also in current economic climate, two wages are necessary to survive in most households now, but I am concerned.
So, you understand why it’s necessary and you know why it’s beneficial but you’re concerned because it doesn’t impact you personally in any way at all?

I think it is a shame that children are all bundled into childcare at a young age and feel sorry for parents being pushed into work when they may prefer to stay home.
It’s not. The children are happy. The parents are happy. No one is being “bundled”, no one is being “pushed”. You’ve invented a narrative to disguise your judgment as concern. No one is stopping anyone from staying at home. No SAHP has any less because working parents have support.

I always felt that I missed so much by going back to work very early and I regret not taking more time off in those early years. I wonder if there is a better way.
Your personal issues are not how government policy should be decided. If you were supposedly forced back to work when there was no funding for childcare then how can you now claim that the funding is what’s forcing parents back to work? There’s no logic to this argument. Why didn’t you stay at home?

Maybe parents should be encouraged to look after their own children if they want to rather than handing over their babies to childcare. Maybe spend some of the money on incentivising employers to give more paid leave/shorter working hours to support SAH parents
Why? Your first suggestion benefits no one other than the parents who want to stay at home and can already afford to. Your second suggestion benefits no one except SAHP and actively damages the economy, the job market, small businesses non-parents and working parents.

AIBU?
Yes. On every single thing you’ve said. It’s not really surprising that you’re bitter that childcare might be funded for other parents when it wasn’t for you but don’t try to pass your opinion off as “concern”.

You've said it all! 👏

Marghe87 · 15/03/2023 10:39

Blughbablugh · 15/03/2023 10:16

It's this kind of opinion which really let's women down! "Bundled in to childcare" Really? The fact is that he world has moved on and I will defend to the death the right for women to be able to work. You only have to look on mumsnet at how dangerous it can be for a lot of women in being financially reliant on a partner. Lets also not forget the cost of living has become a lot more expensive than it was when women could afford to stay at home. My little boy goes to nursery three days a week. I'm lucky that my work has been flexible enough to let me work part-time. The cost of my childcare for those three days is £860 per month! The nursery we chose with care and consideration and both of my kids have been very happy there and are very confident children. If I was to give up work when having my children then we would be in a much worse place financially for a long time whilst I built my career back up again.
I am also proud that my children see me working. It sets a good example for them, especially my daughter which I think is so important!
But hey let's just pile on to those women who either have little choice or actually make the choice to work with the usual bullshit of "You shouldn't have children if you don't want to look after them" it's so tiring and actually really does women such an injustice, especially when coming from other women!

THIS👏

Marghe87 · 15/03/2023 10:38

THIS👏