Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Expansion of free childcare

246 replies

Firefly2023 · 14/03/2023 22:21

I am too old to benefit from this but I do wonder if we are heading in the wrong direction. The expansion of free childcare to one and two year olds is obviously to encourage more people back to work. Is this really such a good thing for the children?

I know that women want to continue their careers and staying at home is detrimental to that. Also in current economic climate, two wages are necessary to survive in most households now, but I am concerned. I think it is a shame that children are all bundled into childcare at a young age and feel sorry for parents being pushed into work when they may prefer to stay home.

I always felt that I missed so much by going back to work very early and I regret not taking more time off in those early years. I wonder if there is a better way. Maybe parents should be encouraged to look after their own children if they want to rather than handing over their babies to childcare. Maybe spend some of the money on incentivising employers to give more paid leave/shorter working hours to support SAH parents. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Onnabugeisha · 16/03/2023 17:24

BlueRadiator · 15/03/2023 14:02

If a child gets dla and you’re their carer you don’t have to work or have any work related activity at all ?

The criteria for DLA have nothing to do with whether a child prefers home vs childcare.

Eatentoomanyroses · 16/03/2023 13:08

@Marghe87 I didn’t say that there weren’t good reasons for putting children in childcare. I just think there are some parents who put their children in childcare full time from very young ages in order to fund things that are not really necessary. Those parents could choose to work more part time and still have all the things you mention. I am not a sahm. I work but I’ve found a way to do it which means my youngest isn’t in a nursery and my oldest is never in wrap around care.

Motheranddaughter · 16/03/2023 13:03

I would never have given up my career
Nobody expected my DH to
Yes for about a year when I had 2 at nursery before the funding kicked in my net salary was only about 1k (part time work)
But we looked on nursery costs as a joint expense

Movingonupi · 16/03/2023 12:04

@Eatentoomanyroses i wish I could afford foreign holidays! Which by the way, benefit the children as well, but I can’t, until DD turns 3 as all the money I would have spent is going on childcare. Roll on when she’s 3 and we’ll be able to take the kids abroad again 😊

Capitalismwantsyou · 16/03/2023 10:58

Agree with you, time with loved ones is invaluable. People should be helped to be with their families and take care of each other. Capitalism doesnt give a crap.

Marghe87 · 16/03/2023 10:18

FWIW I think that letting DC cry until they fall asleep (as it's common here on MN) makes much more damage than sending them to a good, reliable nursery from young age. There is much more literature about that infact.

Marghe87 · 16/03/2023 10:14

Movingonupi · 15/03/2023 17:38

@pbdr i sent both my children to full time nursery from age 1ish not quite full time but for 4 days a week )a small nursery don’t know if that makes a difference), I clicked on the articles and it does make for very uncomfortable reading! However, this is just anecdotal among my small network of friends and acquaintances but the ‘known’ children who have the most serious behavioural issues, act up in school, at parties etc are without exception the ones who DIDNT go to nursery from a young age, or at all, and stayed at home. Obviously there might be issues I don’t know about. My 5 year old so far is thriving at school and excels in social skills and friendships. So I wonder, is this for All children, like it is a given they will become aggressive after going to nursery or are there other factors at play? Panicking a bit now I’ve stored up issues for when they are older!

Please do not let this b.....it bring you down - your DD is clearly a lovely, well balanced child and you have nothing to worry about. Growing up in a loving, caring household with parents that are present when together (even if not 12 hours a day) is what makes a child happy and secure. Do not read this stuff.

Marghe87 · 16/03/2023 10:10

Eatentoomanyroses · 15/03/2023 16:45

oops posted too soon. I was going to say that there are lots of parents that value lifestyle over time at home with small children. They’re not using childcare because they’re children would want for food and a roof over their head if they didn’t, they’re doing it to fund foreign holidays, cars and larger houses. Other people do make the decision to have less comfortable lifestyles because they don’t want to use childcare. It’s not black and white

It's not as simple as that. There are many reasons why it is wiser to continue working as it's especially women who get hit by being sahm in the long term. On top of the need to pay for a house and other essential stuff, here is some:

  • Anything can happen in life, people get ill, can die, couples can split up and relying on only one income is never a wise decision. This is an issue that brings lots of women to live into poverty unfortunately as they quit their jobs to be at home with DC and then maybe lose their husband or break up and have no way of supporting themselves
  • you continue to pay towards your pension, which will hopefully mean you will be able to live your late years with decent standards (no I don't mean luxury holidays around the world but simply the ability to pay your bills and do house repairs and get extra medical support if needed). I have relatives (women) who haven't worked and now live off a very small pension that is not even enough to cover the basics and their DC have to continously support them as they basically live in poverty
  • Working doesn't just bring monetary benefits to an individual: it challenges you, makes you meet more people, gives you a purpose outside of the domestic walls, stimulates you... all things that being a 24/7 stay at home mum cannot give you
  • you set an example for your DC, especially DD: what is the point of studying and working hard if we then feel we have to quit our jobs and become full time mothers once the kids arrive? I wouldn't want my DD to think that's the only way to have a family

I could list many more but I don't want this post to become too long.
It's not all black and white.

MumOf2workOptions · 16/03/2023 08:56

PleaseGoToSleeep · 15/03/2023 06:43

At our Pre school, where each of my four children started at 3, a three hour session cost £25. Funding they receive for FEET funding or 3YO funding is £4:50 p/h. Just over half of the cost. It’s not sustainable.

Yes I agree
I think that's what people just don't see.
Nurseries and childcare settings like domestic households also have higher gas and electricity prices too and so they'll be feeling the pinch aswell and they can't have it cold for young children.
Also nurseries round here are ALWAYS advertising - the pay is really poor it's minimum wage then only another 20-30p an hour as a supervisor the government need to do more to encourage people to work in that sector.

Ndhdiwntbsivnwg · 15/03/2023 18:25

As a working mum, who lover her job, I feel supported by this proposed change. HOWEVER! Women should be offered a decent alternative as well to stay at home, at least until the child is 2-3. It’s all about having to be able to make the choice. In my old country mothers are supported until the kid is 2 years old. Fairly compensated and all. And yes, sometimes that means that women don’t return to work until they had 2-3 kids and been at home for 6+ years. But I still think it should be a choice.

pbdr · 15/03/2023 17:47

@Movingonupi
The effects on average are fairly modest on an individual basis (although as the Quebec example shows can be more significant at a population level) and as the author points out some children will be affected much more or much less than average.
It is absolutely nowhere near being a certainty that a child who went to nursery from a young age is going to be aggressive or have behavioural problems. Just a slightly higher risk, but huge numbers of kids come through early years childcare with no issues whatsoever. If your daughter is sociable and thriving at age 5 then I don't think you have a thing to worry about. She's obviously got off to a great start in life.

Movingonupi · 15/03/2023 17:38

@pbdr i sent both my children to full time nursery from age 1ish not quite full time but for 4 days a week )a small nursery don’t know if that makes a difference), I clicked on the articles and it does make for very uncomfortable reading! However, this is just anecdotal among my small network of friends and acquaintances but the ‘known’ children who have the most serious behavioural issues, act up in school, at parties etc are without exception the ones who DIDNT go to nursery from a young age, or at all, and stayed at home. Obviously there might be issues I don’t know about. My 5 year old so far is thriving at school and excels in social skills and friendships. So I wonder, is this for All children, like it is a given they will become aggressive after going to nursery or are there other factors at play? Panicking a bit now I’ve stored up issues for when they are older!

pbdr · 15/03/2023 17:29

@tirednewmumm criticalscience.medium.com/on-the-science-of-daycare-4d1ab4c2efb4
This is the best evidence summary I've come across

ImAGoodPerson · 15/03/2023 17:21

This could result in many providers closing due to a number of reasons. I think there are better things to spend government funding on rather than extending free childcare.

JenniferBarkley · 15/03/2023 16:57

Eatentoomanyroses · 15/03/2023 16:45

oops posted too soon. I was going to say that there are lots of parents that value lifestyle over time at home with small children. They’re not using childcare because they’re children would want for food and a roof over their head if they didn’t, they’re doing it to fund foreign holidays, cars and larger houses. Other people do make the decision to have less comfortable lifestyles because they don’t want to use childcare. It’s not black and white

I've never known anyone who works for a fancy car or nice holiday.

I do know families which could survive on one income but don't because neither parent wants to give up their career.

Perfect28 · 15/03/2023 16:49

Early use of nursery has been found to have some negative effects however they are relatively small and the studies never take into consideration the parental health and wellbeing which has a big impact on the child and can be increased with the use of good quality childcare.

Eatentoomanyroses · 15/03/2023 16:45

oops posted too soon. I was going to say that there are lots of parents that value lifestyle over time at home with small children. They’re not using childcare because they’re children would want for food and a roof over their head if they didn’t, they’re doing it to fund foreign holidays, cars and larger houses. Other people do make the decision to have less comfortable lifestyles because they don’t want to use childcare. It’s not black and white

Eatentoomanyroses · 15/03/2023 16:38

@Rosebel not everyone is in your situation. There are lots of parents that valu

Mistressofnone · 15/03/2023 16:18

@Lovelyring it was a fascinating read I agree.

I was unsure about the section claiming that the high levels of stress hormone cortisol, is the reason kids catch so many bugs at nursery, as it impedes their immune system. I thought they caught all the bugs because their immune system is a blank canvas at that age!

Lovelyring · 15/03/2023 16:09

pbdr · 15/03/2023 08:35

@JenniferBarkley This is a good summary of the evidence; criticalscience.medium.com/on-the-science-of-daycare-4d1ab4c2efb4

Warning: if you have no choice but to use nursery/daycare for your very young children then it would be better to give this one a miss. It won't make you feel good and if it's not something you have a free choice about then it's not worth it.

I'm very much pro-choice when it comes to this. Fully support any parent who feels childcare is the right choice for their family, but plenty of parents who don't want to find themselves in the position of having no choice, and direct payments to families would help everyone.

Thanks for posting this, I found it fascinating.

Rosebel · 15/03/2023 16:04

Hence · 15/03/2023 06:47

I think this is great for families that want it. I would never use it personally as I cherished the years I spent with my four children when they were small. I was happy to not work until they were much older and I am so grateful I was able to - I work from home now so I have the best of both worlds now they are older. They are only young for such a little time and the early years are really important for their development and I wanted to be a big part of that. I understand that isn't a priority to everyone though. We are all different.

Did you actually mean to be so rude and horrible? I don't want to work. I would absolutely love to be a SAHM but I can't afford to give up work.
My first priority is to make sure my children have a roof over their head, food clothes. So I could give up work but then where are they supposed to live and what are they supposed to eat?
I love my children to bits and also love the time I spend with them. Such an ignorant comment.

BlueRadiator · 15/03/2023 14:02

Onnabugeisha · 15/03/2023 10:26

@WigglyWigglyWiggly
How on earth is funding something that parents are currently having to pay for supposedly forcing those who don’t want to use it to use it?! Just because something is free doesn’t mean you have to use it.

I’ll tell you how this budget is taking away choice. The Spring Budget has the theme of get people back to work. The more money for subsidised childcare is the carrot. It’s going to benefit those who have either already chosen to go back to work or are working because they cannot afford not to. This isn’t a bad thing if it were by itself.

But it isn’t. You have to look at the full picture

But most have missed the sticks said so far in the Spring Budget pre-release. These are new requirements such as the partners of working partners now being required to actively seek work even if they have children aged under 3. The minimum income to not have to keep looking for work or better paying work is also going to be raised, such that the days of a parent doing PT work with preschool children at home, will be eliminated. These parents will have to seek FT work or a much much higher paying PT job (which exist for only a few elites), even if they have a child at home under age 3. If they don’t do this, they are sanctioned. And to add to this stick, DWP is being given the authority to auto-sanction anyone which may or may not involve AI doing sanctions, then the families appealing as the inevitable computer errors mount up.

All of the above is going to force yet more low income parents into FT work. They won’t have the choice to stay home, and they will be punished via sanctions if they aren’t getting a high enough paying job regardless of whether or not such a job actually exists for them after accounting for qualifications and any disabilities they may have.

There also doesn’t seem to be any allowance or exemption said so far for having a child with special needs- you will still be forced to find FT work.

If a child gets dla and you’re their carer you don’t have to work or have any work related activity at all ?

wingingit1987 · 15/03/2023 13:44

maroonpie · 15/03/2023 06:54

I disagree nothing stops someone being a sahm. I would have loved to be a sahm when my dc was born. We couldn't work out a way to afford it with dh job being just above all the limits for even dc benefit and the cost of moving. I don't think it's a choice for many. Those who love working with dc always seem to pretend it's a choice. But a 'choice' they never really had to make and have no understanding of if they wanted to go back to work!

This. 100%. We don’t qualify for benefits as husband earns above the threshold. Instead, we had me reduce my hours but it’s still not ideal.

Janedoelondon · 15/03/2023 13:14

stripes416 · 15/03/2023 12:00

Saying children are being "dumped" in nursery is always going to sound bad. However a child attending a nursery with engaging, knowledgeable, passionate staff who have the resources and the time to provide learning opportunities and care for the children is not a negative thing.

Children will then have the opportunity to create new relationships and attachments with staff members, have more learning opportunities than they may at home, learn social skills, have more opportunity for outdoor play. The list could go on. I feel like by saying children should be at home with parents full time until they are 3, we are building up an image in our heads of how attachment will benefit both parents and children but it's not always a picture perfect experience unfortunately. Some parents may not benefit from being at home all day which then affects their mental health, affects their motivation, their identity, and then in turn affects the child

This. Thank you!

tirednewmumm · 15/03/2023 13:11

pbdr · 14/03/2023 23:18

It's a tricky one, because the evidence shows that until around age 2.5/3 centre based daycare/nursery is detrimental in terms of emotional/behavioural development and (for the youngest children) cognition in a way that is measurable years later. After 2.5/3 there are clear, measurable benefits.
It is not however realistic, nor for many parents desirable, for children to all be looked after at home until they are 3.
Providing direct payments to families rather than offering funded hours would help support those who wish to stay at home with their children, while funding childcare for those who wish to work. That doesn't solve the economic issues that are prompting the push to try to get parents of young children back into work, so it's not a fix-all either.

I'm not sure this is true! We did a lot of reading and looking into evidence and never found anything this concrete so please link if you have a source Smile

The evidence we found suggested that long days 7:30-6 for example 5 days a week from 9 months was detrimental for a lot of babies.

Evidence also suggested some did well especially those with a mix of family care and nursery type care who tended to outperform kids with a Sahp. This is at a population level though all kids are individuals and will have different reactions